13 ms·
Europe now has so much natural gas that prices just dipped below zero
- the_optimist 4y agoRather, so few places to store natural gas for ordinary use. Don’t trust journalists to be not dumb.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoI had to pay 800 euros last month for home energy on my variable contract in Amsterdam. Insane.
- bpodgursky 4y agoWell, if you have a refrigerated pressure tank which can store a few tens of thousands of cubic yards of LNG, you are in luck.
- ralphmelish 4y agoWhat are the kWh prices in Amsterdam? I'm in London and would need to consume more than 1,700 kw to pay that much (£0.3866 per kWh, £0.3849 standing charge). Edit: I'm also on a variable contract
- iso1631 4y agoHow variable -- how many times a day does your price per kwh change?
- ralphmelish 4y agoIt doesn't change during they day, it only changes when the government approves price increases. I guess variable means a different thing in the UK. Do you have peak and off-peak prices?
- Okkef 4y agoThat's not how it works in the Netherlands
- ralphmelish 4y agoThat's why I asked. Thank you for your detailed explanation.
- iso1631 4y agoBefore the last 12 months, Octopus had an agile price where the price you pay the rate depending on different time of the day. Sometimes this would be high (25p+), sometimes it would only be a couple of pence. Sometimes it was negative. https://agileprices.co.uk/ https://agileprices.co.uk/ shows the price for a given region. For example back on October 1st you'd actually be paid to charge your battery -- Because of the government's meddling in the market it's no longer available for new customers, so if you have the resources or ability to smooth your load, it's meaningless, you can simply claim your massive subsidy from the government and recharge your 80kWh car battery at peak time for 35p // £28, with the taxpayer picking up the extra £52. But in a free market you'd charge at low demand times (say overnight when you could have been paying 10p/unit) and either use it, or possibly sell it back, at high peak times (that 80p/unit) (I'm not sure how feed in tarrifs worked with Octopus, but a system which would reduce the load on the grid has been scuppered by the government with the inexplicable energy policy)
- ralphmelish 4y agoThat's quite interesting. Prices seem quite cheap compared to what I'm paying right now. Too bad they are not taking new customers.
- Dma54rhs 4y agoI'm not from Holland but in EU and I pay hourly market rate of my regions electricity pool.
- ralphmelish 4y agoSo your prices are constantly changing? How much do you pay on average for a kW?
- Dma54rhs 4y agoYup, around 15c/kwh, spot prices are common over EU in some countries more than others.
- aspyct 4y agoSorry what? The price of gas has multiplied by 15 here...
- jefftk 4y agoNormally you run storage facilities neither all the way full nor all the way empty: you want to be able to smooth out fluctuations in supply and demand. Because of the war Europe is running gas storage near its upper limit, which means we should expect less flexibility and more price volatility: they won't want to draw them way down if we get a serious cold snap, and they have nowhere to put extra gas if it's warmer than usual. The latter happened, there's nowhere to put incoming gas, so spot prices fell below zero.
- visviva 4y agoGreat, succinct explanation - thanks.
- sorokod 4y ago>you want to be able to smooth out fluctuations in supply and demand. Can you say a bit more about the "you" mentioned? I can imagine "you"s who care only about having heating during wintertime.
- antasvara 4y agoFrom context, it seems that the "you" in question is "a company that runs a natural gas storage space." As a company with fiduciary responsibilities, they likely can't concern themselves too much with the problem you mention.
- proser 4y agoEuropean utilities are often public utilities that are nationalized in some way, not strictly corporate businesses.
- jhoechtl 4y agoFor good. Remember Texas electricity costs soaring?
- AlmostAnyone 4y ago
- goodpoint 4y agoAny link to the price charts?
- c7b 4y ago> Natural gas prices just dipped below zero. > Those ships [are] carrying about $2 billion worth of LNG. Really?
- sudhirj 4y agoThe local spot prices dropped below zero. The price of gold might be 1000 currency units an ounce, but if my house is about to collapse under the weight of all my gold I might pay you a little to take it off my hands - dropping the price below zero for the people in my immediate vicinity.
- laverya 4y agoDepends on where those ships can offload the LNG. If they were in Asia or the US Northeast, prices would not be negative. (But prices differ by significant multiples between those locations)
- FerociousTimes 4y agoThe $2 Bln quote could be historical but in real time live spot prices at the present, the rates cratered momentarily to zero or even negative territories.
- hef19898 4y agoLuckily, LNG ships can simply be parked at sea until prices rise again, same for oil tankers. Pipelines going into almost full storage don't have that luxury.
- jandrese 4y agoIt costs money every day to leave the ships parked and idle, but in some ways it is a good thing. Those ships are basically extra storage in the event of a long cold winter that stresses the natural gas supply harder than expected. They offer flexibility to deal with pipeline shortages.
- hef19898 4y ago
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThis is a better situation than the reverse. It’s fortunate the winter has been mild so far. Will be interesting if the LNG industry can keep pace and replace Russia for good.
- FerociousTimes 4y agoNot to nitpick and assuming you're living in the northern hemisphere, winter has not officially arrived; we're still in the fall/autumn season.
- ndlzk 4y agoIn fact It’s unseasonably hot currently. Nobody is using heaters at all I suspect.
- FerociousTimes 4y agoWhere do you live?
- ndlzk 4y agoThe south of Spain. Yeah, sorry.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoSame here, northern Germany, it has been unusual warm, we haven't started to heat this year yet because of it (though I might not be impacted as hard later also as the city is producing biogas and is using PtH).
- morgelgluff 4y agoStrikingly warm in Sweden as well. Geothermal heat pump does work a few hours per day, anyway. It drops far below 10 degrees celsius at night and my house is not modern enough to manage comfortable temperature with only waste energy as source.
- csours 4y agoYou have different markets essentially - there is a market for delivery, and a futures market. The market for delivery briefly went price negative. This is dominated by what is in the pipeline right now and what volume of gas is being pulled from the pipeline right now. The futures market is still positive. This market is served by LNG and gas that is still in the ground. The price here is dominated by risks. --- The above model is oversimplified and wrong. If you want to know how things work, it may take some dedicated study beyond internet comments.
- cj 4y ago> The above model is oversimplified and wrong. Can you share anything that would help us commoners reading internet comments understand why the analysis is wrong?
- csours 4y agoThere are more than 2 markets. The dominating factors change based on market conditions.
- Twisell 4y agoHowever it would be equally false to believe that the only useful data point come from future market. Every market that enable trade gambling is bound to be volatile and sometimes disconnected from reality. Gamblers that manage to to accurately estimate this delta are the winning one. PS: Actually that's how you end up with negative price, a gambler acquired a huge quantity of gaz in the future market hoping to sell it even higher on the daily market. Nice weather daily market drop. He end up selling negative because he's just a gambler living in NYC and he don't have any usage for the gaz he own in a ship ready to deliver in the European northern sea. So he is ready to pay to get away of this deal and soon enough he is ready for his next sad gamble...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chinchilla2020 4y ago
- atty 4y agoI am an American and not knowledgeable about how energy pricing works, so I am curious, how do we square this with the rates that Europeans have been paying for energy and natural gas lately? Are utilities making off like bandits? Or were they running very low over the last few months and suddenly got a huge influx?
- KingOfCoders 4y agoWell lately the price is <100EUR/MWh, peak this year was >350EUR/MWh
- guerrilla 4y agoYes, on the one hand there are some sticky prices and higher profit margins (which is talked about) but also increased volatility in general. Beyond that, I wish I understood it better.
- colechristensen 4y agoVery short term and local supply and demand issue where there was way more supply than demand. A market inefficiency issue with Europe finding new sources for natural gas supply and being paranoid about running out. They’re trying to cut off Russian supply and being threatened of being cut off. Russian supply is being replaced with American gas. But this is new, it was warm, there was too much gas in places. It happens. It’s good news really.
- Denvercoder9 4y ago> how do we square this with the rates that Europeans have been paying for energy and natural gas lately? Different markets. The price that went negative was for immediate delivery of gas (spot market), while utilities buy their energy way before it's actually delivered (futures market). The price on the spot market went briefly negative because it's unseasonably warm in Europe right now (so less gas usage for heating), and all the storage is nearly full. The price on the futures market is still high, because once it gets cold demand will pick way up and outpace supply. An interesting sidenote is that storage being full significantly increases volatility in the market: in the usual situation, a storage facility would buy up all the surplus gas on the spot market at a cheap but probably non-negative price, store it, and sell it on the futures market for a higher price. This stabilizes the market, and creates some constraints on market prices. Now that storage is full, they can't do that, and prices can fluctuate much more.
- dr_faustus 4y agoI really don't understand the doom and gloom wrt next year. What was obviously completely underestimated was the elasticity of consumer demand for gas. In Germany, consumers are using 25% less gas even if you account for the weather. So with increased supply from Netherlands and Norway, even a limited amount of LNG will probably be enough to fill the storage again and compensate the missing Russian gas (which accounted for about 40% of the German gas supply. We, too, have not switched on the gas based heating yet. Instead, we are using a mix of wood and infrared electrical heaters to keep the rooms at a bearable (albeit not overly comfortable) 19 degrees celsius.
- behringer 4y agoI imagine you'd be using gas if you were paid to use it. Sadly market prices in the consumers favor seems to rarely make it to actual consumers.
- Denvercoder9 4y agoAt least in the Netherlands you can get a energy contract with dynamic pricing, where you pay the actual market price (plus tax) at time of use. When energy prices go negative, you'll also get paid. However, this is a knife that cuts both ways: if the energy market prices rise sharply, you'll also immediately have to pay higher prices and don't benefit from the contracting ahead-of-time and averaging that regular energy companies do. I've spoken to people with such a contract whose energy bills went up by >100x this year, compared to last year.
- behringer 4y agoSeems incredibly risky to take without any storage tanks!
- aschearer 4y agoThe doom and gloom makes more sense when considering who benefits from pushing that narrative.
- landoftheice 4y ago
- qeomash 4y agothen why are we still paying so much for it?
- remus 4y agoI think the article is misleading. The spot price is about supply and demand over an extremely short time period and has dipped below zero because at the moment gas storage in europe is very full, so if you've got a load of natural gas to sell no one is buying because there's nowhere to put it. This is probably related to unseasonably warm temperatures in Europe at the moment, so people are using less gas than expected to heat their homes. The high prices you pay as a homeowner are to do with high expected demand over to winter relative to the available supply, because the supply has been seriously reduced due to the war in Ukraine.
- em500 4y agoBecause most Europeans do not need all that gas today or tomorrow, and storage costs money.
- qeomash 4y agoCan anyone ELI5 on to why are we paying so much for it then?
- remus 4y agoCopying my answer from another comment: The spot price is about supply and demand over an extremely short time period and has dipped below zero because at the moment gas storage in europe is very full, so if you've got a load of natural gas to sell no one is buying because there's nowhere to put it. This is probably related to unseasonably warm temperatures in Europe at the moment, so people are using less gas than expected to heat their homes. The high prices you pay as a homeowner are to do with high expected demand over to winter relative to the available supply, because the supply has been seriously reduced due to the war in Ukraine.
- hef19898 4y agoAlso, gas providers filled up storage and secured volumes at high prices. Even if they now buy for way less, customer prices will be an average (at least, depending on exactly how providers calculate costs and thus prices) of those two. So until the old inventory is consumed, consumer gas prices won't move a lot. Overall, this is good. As a consumer you want stable prices and not depend on spot and future markets fluctuations.
- jandrese 4y agoThis is a classic market shock panic buying. Something newsworthy happens that will reduce the availability of some commodity rising prices slightly, the reaction is that people start trying to stockpile the commodity which further stresses the market and drives prices even higher, fueling more fears about shortages, and so on. Then the storage fills up and it wasn't really that big of a shortage in the first place so the demand utterly collapses. It's the same thing that happened to toilet paper back in early 2020. I only hope this accelerates the transition to renewable energy sources in Europe.
- matai_kolila 4y ago
- anm89 4y agoDifferent countries have very different storage capacities. Some nations have most of their years demand in storage capacity whereas others like the UK have only a few days and require a constant flow. If you are one of the countries that can store a whole year this is great news. If you're Britain, you could still be out of gas and paying exorbitant prices a week from now
- msie 4y agoHeh, how's Brexit working out for them? BTW has Nigel Farage paid for his lies?
- lowercased 4y agoNot to dismiss this entirely, but I can't recall political leaders at that level ever 'paying' for lies or misinformation in any capacity commensurate with the negative impact of the lies. Has his reputation been dinged a bit in some quarters? Perhaps. That'll be the extent of it.
- anm89 4y agoThis really isn't a brexit story
- tuukkah 4y agoIt's the same with electricity markets: at times there's so much wind and nuclear power that the spot price goes below zero in Europe as well as in the US: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666792421000652 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S266679242... I still pay around 5 cents/kWh to the middlemen though so consumption hasn't been profitable to me so far.
- leobg 4y agoWhere are you based if you are paying five cents? Here in Germany, I pay 10 times that much.
- legulere 4y agoThe cost for the electricity net was around 7.5 cents in Germany last year: https://www.bmwk.de/Redaktion/DE/Artikel/Energie/strompreise-bestandteile.html https://www.bmwk.de/Redaktion/DE/Artikel/Energie/strompreise...
- loufe 4y agoI paid only slightly more than that in Québec, Canada. The province is blessed with a superabundance of hydroelectric potential and thankfully the infrastructure is in well-managed government hands.
- tuukkah 4y agoIn Helsinki, Finland, we pay 4 cents/kWh to the local grid company. Then on top of that, everyone has a contract with an electricity supplier of their choosing, and mine charges 0.9 ¢/kWh on top of the hourly spot price. (My previous supplier charged a fixed price and went bankrupt due to the current crisis.) The spot price in Finland is somewhat linked to the prices of the neighbouring Sweden, Norway and Estonia. Recently, it has varied with -0.1 and 93 ¢/kWh as the extremes and the average around 15 ¢/kWh (night-time lows included).
- leobg 4y agoSo can I run a line to your house, please?
- Ekaros 4y agoSpot prices are just that spot prices. Just like oil prices dropped below zero for short period during shutdown. Now this happened with gas. Doesn't necessarily tell too much for next months.
- Denvercoder9 4y agoThe oil prices that went negative were actually futures, not spot prices.
- ck2 4y agoThey need to perfect the capture and storage technology and force all the Bakken oil field flares to use it. Billion of cubic feet every DAY just burnt off into the atmosphere because the oil makes them more money. Over $100 Million per MONTH Our country/world is insane with waste while people freeze and starve.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoWhy can't things just be free? Free stuff for everyone everywhere! Yeah! I'd vote for anybody offering me free stuff, even if it came with strings that I wasn't aware of until it was too late. If only Hugo Chavez were alive today. He'd know what to do. Sadly, the only playbook all our leaders have to go on are his books.
- anthk 4y agoAlso, the climate helps. We have 25C in Bilbao. >30C expected at the weekend. We usually get UK weather on Fall, and it didn't rain in weeks... No chilly-windy Winters, but the "alternative" we are living on looks far worse.
- rybosworld 4y agoThis is not entirely related to the article: Rising temperatures should reduce demand for fossil fuels as a heating source (I think). Does anyone know if this is already factored into global warming predictions?
- guerrilla 4y agoI don't know but just so you know, it can also make it a lot worse by cutting off the gulf stream which is how we're not spending even more energy in (especially northern) Europe.
- bluGill 4y agoIt will also raise demand for whatever runs air conditioners. This is all factored in. What isn't factored in (guesses are, but we have no idea to know what guesses are right) is how much will we become more efficient, or how fast we will switch to renewables. This year heat pumps were very popular to install in Europe this summer, and they are more efficient, so all models need to be updated. Predictions that are more than a few years out are all being updated for expected growth in EVs, solar, and wind - all of which are growing (probably in expected range or your predictions so far, but all above the expected values)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imnotlost 4y agoThe headline should be that Europe as 0 storage capacity so people will pay to get rid of the natgas (someone else should store it). This is a temporary problem and does not mean the natgas issues are solved for the winter. There was a similar issue with oil storage in April 2020[1] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/20/business/oil-prices.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/20/business/oil-prices.html
- tenpies 4y agoExactly, we are witnessing supply destruction. It's worth considering that liquid natural gas is one of the most expensive (in both emissions and cost) to ship. It needs to be held in special LNG carrier ships that can keep it not only at the right pressure, but the right temperature (against vast fluctuations). The crew on this ship requires special training and the ships carry a different insurance profile. This is not like oil which is essentially held at room temperature in a water tight vessel. Therefore just having LNG in a ship takes a considerable number of resources even if it's just sitting there. Crew and insurance has to be paid, refrigeration and ship costs add up, as well as the opportunity cost. As you can imagine, getting the LNG that you very expensively purchased in the US, shipped, and then brought to Europe, is quite important. Every day delayed this becomes money that is not just being incinerated, but also not being maid. What we are witnessing now is supply destruction, and as much as the ignorant journalists at CNN may celebrate it, this is actually quite bad long-term for Europe. Coincidentally, the only other thing that is likely to be more expensive to ship is what Canada's Trudeau has promised Germany it will send: hydrogen. Thankfully that is likely to never happen as the promise was as limp-wristed as it gets.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoCrazy idea... Let them refill ships like these https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CMA_CGM_Jacques_Saad%C3%A9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CMA_CGM_Jacques_Saad%C3%A9 at sea! While https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow_steaming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow_steaming Like aerial refueling for military aircrafts, where the tankers are circling back and forth along the traffic patterns in the air!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- labrador 4y agoWhat's wrong with storing it on a ship? Anchor it and pay a skeleton crew to keep it operational.
- netrus 4y agoI cannot imagine a happier person right now than the owner of a LNG tanker. Sure, using it as a dumb storage is a good business, but it's sure a better business to move the ship around to do arbitrage between gas markets with crazily different prices.
- kgwgk 4y agoThat you cannot conjure a gas tanker ship -and the required infrastructure- out of thin air.
- labrador 4y agoThey arrived full of gas with nowhere to offload. Those ships are what I'm suggesting wait until offloading is possible.
- kgwgk 4y agoGas is also transported by other means. I imagine those ships are not selling their load at negative spot price. What is “wrong” with waiting is that you’re losing money instead of being making money.
- Denvercoder9 4y agoThose ships most likely sold their load of gas before they even set sail.
- balderdash 4y agoNothing wrong with that, except the day $100-200k/day you’re paying for charter…
- labrador 4y ago
- sebow 4y agoTextbook clickbait article, though I don't expect (nor want) the title to be changed or the link to be removed because it shows how desperate CNN is for coming back into the mainstream. The prices are not "zero" or "below zero". Maybe for the companies that buy gas in order to resell it to the average consumer, but the normal consumer does not get it for free or gets paid to burn gas randomly.This is what a layman understands when s/he reads the title, which is factually incorrect as per others have already explained in this thread. On another note, I'm even skeptical to believe the gas storage across Europe is full. Because if that was the case, the prices should have began to plateau sooner up until now, instead of staying the same/relatively decreasing.
- pvorb 4y agoCompletely unrelated, but I'm truly impressed that CNN offers a light version of their articles without any layout. This is really refreshing and a pleasure to read. I would like to see more websites do this and focus on the content.
- Vecr 4y agocnn.com pretty much went down during 9/11 and I assume they tried to put in countermeasures after that, but who knows how well it would work after over two decades.
- hulitu 4y ago> Europe now has so much natural gas that prices just dipped below zero Is canabis legal in US ?
- goatcode 4y agoI'd be interested in how storage capacity has changed over the past 5 or so years. Has it been reduced for some reason?
- lumberjack24 4y agowell, they haven’t turned my building’s heating on yet.
- exabrial 4y agoAre we buying 0 gas from Russia so we can stop funding their war machine? Imho a total ban of imports is needed.
- Gravityloss 4y agoThere have also been a lot of new interconnect pipes installed in the recent years. Basically all the way from Norway-Scotland-England-France-Poland-Lithuania-Latvia-Estonia-Finland it's part of the same network, although I'm sure there are bottlenecks. Here's a recent new pipeline part: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_Interconnection_Poland%E2%80%93Lithuania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_Interconnection_Poland%E2%... Sprinkle some LNG terminals which have and are coming also online, and it becomes much more resilient. There's a lot of this diligent infrastructure work going behind the scenes, away from the political drama.
- isitmadeofglass 4y agoNoone told my gas company which is still demanding about 10 times the normal price.