8 ms·
Population shifts mean an ever-shrinking minority of the population can block changes to the constitution. It’s barely even double digits at this point. Const
by hedora 4y ago
Population shifts mean an ever-shrinking minority of the population can block changes to the constitution. It’s barely even double digits at this point.
Constitutional amendments were supposed to be easier than right to rebellion. That’s not really the case any more. At the same time, the supreme court is just ignoring the law, over the objections of 66-75% of the population (depending on the ruling).
These are dark times for US democracy. There’s no evidence things are working as intended.
- kepler1 4y ago
- voltaireodactyl 4y agoIn my opinion the unacceptable, repetitive, fundamentalist-led attacks on the very institution of voting itself would take far more precedence than the social issues you listed, although I know social media leans hard on them. If you truly feel those are the most pressing issues in your mind/spheres, I would urge you to remember that social media is largely an echo chamber designed to distract from the actual issues, like the aforementioned sustained assault on the very basis of American society.
- kepler1 4y agoPlease say what about voting has been fundamentally attacked at its core that rises to the level of amending the Constitution? That voters are required to (gasp) verify their identification, once every 4 years, if certain conditions aren't met? That drop boxes for ballots were reduced in number? Gerrymandering? Just look at some of the district designs in New York. I might remind you that all the things that are criticized in Republican states for suppressing the vote, exist as rules in certain Democratic states as well. It's easy, I might point out to you as well, to live in an echo chamber where issues get inflated in perceived importance, only because they hurt your side. Yet those same issues happening where it doesn't hurt the side, somehow fall from being a problem. That's no way to come to what should be an amendment to our basic document.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> Gerrymandering? Just look at some of the district designs in New York. Nobody said that this was a republican-led-state problem only. That doesn't stop it from being a major threat to democracy, nor does it a priori mean that the Democrats do it as much or to the extent that Republicans do. > I might remind you that all the things that are criticized in Republican states for suppressing the vote, exist as rules in certain Democratic states as well. Do tell. No food or drink supplies allowed while standing outside in line for hours? Where's that in the Democratic states?
- voltaireodactyl 4y agoWhen one side repeatedly accuses the process of being rigged, that has the effect of lowering overall belief in the system. And when every objectively proven, convicted case is perpetrated by that SAME side, yet never condemned by said side, the only possible conclusion is that said side is operating in bad faith. When one entire half of the political equation is no longer operating in good faith, it has a cascading effect throughout society. Civilization exists because the majority believe in it, no more, no less. All of recorded history would seem to support this theory. And to put your mind at ease, I assure you I speak from my life experience rather than any internet talking points. For a simple example, take gerrymandering in my home state of NC. A complex issue, but if one does the work to understand what’s going on, everything I’m saying is clear. Research is required because the party in power would prefer it NOT be easy to comprehend the big picture — thus my patience with your high-handed-while-largely-misinformed statement of your understanding. I am curious: how do you explain away the most recent former president demanding votes from Georgia? To continue to treat/request support from such an individual is, to me, an absolute signifier that one does not consider the right to vote to be a fundamental issue, in my opinion. Not to mention the tomfoolery with ballots going missing, again in NC, due to the actions of an entrenched conservative “deep state” (for lack of a better term). Nevertheless, I support your right to your opinion! I do wish conservative leadership felt the same way. I hope this comment leaves you feeling more fully informed of the issues, so you don’t feel the need to bring up bathrooms in the context of rebellion again :).
- Dylan16807 4y ago> That voters are required to (gasp) verify their identification, once every 4 years, if certain conditions aren't met? Until we give everyone an ID card, yes that is voter suppression because it prevents many citizens from voting. > That drop boxes for ballots were reduced in number? Drop boxes and polling locations. It's hard enough that voting day isn't a paid holiday. If it takes hours and hours or goes outside of the range someone can easily travel, that's a big problem.
- TeeMassive 4y ago> In my opinion the unacceptable, repetitive, fundamentalist-led attacks on the very institution of voting itself would take far more precedence than the social issues you listed How are they attacked? From what I've seen, all the "voter suppression" stories coming from the US are all things we have in place in other modern democracies like in Canada. We have voter ID, we have to make sure we are registered, we can only ask for mail ballots for certain circumstances, voting machines are banned and we have move of the results before midnight.
- Nursie 4y agoVoter suppression in the US appears to take on other forms, reducing the number of polling places in urban centres such that it can take several hours to cast a vote, restricting their hours, making it illegal to provide water for those in the queue, that sort of thing. Multi-pronged attacks which try to ensure only 'your' people get to participate. As an Australian resident and a British citizen, it seems outrageous to me - I've never had to take more than about fifteen minutes out of my day to vote in the UK, and in Australia voting is fast, mandatory and always run on a weekend so that most people can get to it. They even usually have a charity barbecue outside the polling place! Other, indirect attacks on the system include Trump's big lie, the stated intention of the republican candidate for the secretary of state of Arizona to return the state to republican control because he thinks it's what the people really want regardless of the outcome of the actual vote (because clearly the vote is rigged!), the various "alternative electors" that republicans attempted to send to congress during the aftermath of the last presidential election etc etc. The US right is currently mounting an attack on US democracy itself in various ways, to try and work around the system and usurp democratic mandate.
- jliptzin 4y agoUpvoted and also amazed that you know so much about what’s going on in US politics!
- Nursie 4y agoThanks, it's fascinating and a little scary to watch! The US has a huge influence on the world, particularly on the other western, anglophone democracies, so it feels important. I also have family and friends in various states. My generation in the UK grew up with America being this shiny, free, wonderful, aspirational land over the sea, the land of Baywatch and Miami Vice and Disneyland and CocaCola all the other things. It really did appear to be the mythical shining light on the hill. I love visiting the US and have spent over a year there now, on and off. It is a varied land of contradictions and of very different values and lifestyles, a land of opulence, but also of left behind little places. But the politics ... it seems to have become pathological, and the population increasingly cynical about politicians, about the media and sources of information, to the extent that most trust seems gone and consensus reality seems to be frequently called into question (I'm not claiming this is unreasonable! Just observing). These tropes are definitely present in the two countries I've called home, but to a much lesser extent, the poison doesn't seem to have permeated quite so far. You do see stuff get thrown around on social media like "Make sure to take a pen to the voting booth so that they can't change your vote!" but it's fringe whackos. Even if the politicians themselves are disliked, the mechanics of democracy are usually pretty well trusted. IIRC in the last general election here one of the tiny right-wing parties tried some voter-fraud type rabble-rousing ahead of the poll, but they were largely ignored and pretty quickly contradicted by the Australian Election Commission.
- meowkit 4y agoConsensus Failure is the issue that underlies all your listed examples, and many more important ones. Gridlock, over an >extended< period of time, indicates there is a problem. Its like an engine seizing.
- kepler1 4y agoAnd consensus failure means that we should codify into the basic law what you believe is the consensus on that topic? Or change the rules to reflect the lack of consensus? How odd. A change to the Constitution isn't going to save you from people fundamentally disagreeing on things.
- nyokodo 4y ago> These are dark times for US democracy The US system has little d democratic aspects but it is not a democracy. It was intentionally setup to protect the minority from the majority in critical respects like constitutional amendments. Also, population shifts are ongoing and the coastal blue populations are the most rapidly aging in the country and the increasingly red US born Hispanic populations are the most rapidly growing. The future may contain some surprises.
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> population shifts are ongoing and the coastal blue populations are the most rapidly aging in the country But they also have longer lifespans by a couple of years. > increasingly red US born Hispanic populations are the most rapidly growing. A lot of those US born Hispanics are in California and very blue (thanks to Pete Wilson).
- tibbydudeza 4y agoAmazing how California shifted from reliable Red (Ronald Reagan era) to reliable blue. What was the factor in this seemingly quick shift - population shifts ???.
- Ligma123 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Reform_and_Control_Act_of_1986 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Reform_and_Control...
- tibbydudeza 4y agoPete Wilson and Proposition 187 - clearly the GOP still have not learned.
- pasquinelli 4y ago> It was intentionally setup to protect the minority... ...of the opulent, is the quote.
- CGamesPlay 4y agoThe Supreme Court is, in no sense of the word, ignoring the law. They are interpreting the laws in ways you disagree with and in ways which have historically not been how it was interpreted by the same court, but this is not what ignoring means. Further, the objections of the population have nothing to do with the judicial branch and everything to do with the legislative branch. The courts are not and have never been democratically elected entities.
- kepler1 4y agoI would add that if you are a fan of courts protecting minority rights not subject to the whims and abuses of majorities, you should be grateful that judges are not democratically elected.
- geraneum 4y agoThe worse case is majority rights being subject to the whims and abuses of a minority. Protecting minorities shouldn’t mean that this is ok! P.S. minorities here could mean anything i.e the mega rich, the “legal” cartels, etc.
- bilbo0s 4y agoHow is that "worse"? Abusing any population, is abusing a population. What you just argued is akin to walking into a room full of pregnant high school girls, and declaring one to be the "most" virgin. Besides, the point of the Constitution, is to make it difficult for such things to happen in one direction or another in the political dimension. Which it does pretty well. If you want it to provide protections in the dimension of private economic activity, you can do that, just make an amendment and build a consensus. If this new amendment which you draft to ostensibly protect this "majority", can't build the requisite consensus, then not only is it doubtful that it actually protects a majority, but it also shouldn't be an amendment. That's just democracy since the "majority" you claim to be serving doesn't seem to want the amendment.
- sosull 4y agoThere are twenty-three states where judges all the way up to the State Supreme Court are elected, rather than being appointed. These include partisan elections, nonpartisan elections, and legislative elections. https://ballotpedia.org/Judicial_selection_in_the_states https://ballotpedia.org/Judicial_selection_in_the_states
- akira2501 4y ago> Constitutional amendments were supposed to be easier than right to rebellion. I think they were more worried about entire _states_ going into rebellion and not factions of populations spread across them. > These are dark times for US democracy. I don't think that's warranted. I would say these are the growing pains of a country now fully entering the age of always available connectivity with a founding document created when horse travel was the only credible way to travel across it. > There’s no evidence things are working as intended. You could say this of many things. The highly monopolized state of our media in the face of this new era is definitely a baffling outcome, and I definitely spend a lot of time thinking about the connection between this and the previous statement.
- philjohn 4y agoIndependent State Legislature theory potentially being concurred with by SC and the ability of state houses obtained through gerrymandering to overturn any election they disagree with says that indeed it IS dark times for US democracy.
- jimbob45 4y agoAt the same time, the supreme court is just ignoring the law, over the objections of 66-75% of the population (depending on the ruling). SCOTUS can be overruled by the states themselves via amendments. They’re not ignoring law at all.
- Marazan 4y agoTell me how Shelby County vs Holder was not ignoring the law?
- refurb 4y agoSupreme Court rulings are not a popularity contest. It’s intended as an independent (as independent a nominated body can be) that interprets the laws the Congress passes within the confines of the Constitution. I for one would fear living in a country where the courts were swayed by public sentiment.
- pavlov 4y agoIt’s hardly an independent body when 67% of members are lifetime political appointees from a party that hasn’t represented a national majority in several decades.
- thenewthotness 4y agoThe entire structure of the US government is meant to guard against rule by a “national majority” amongst other things.
- refurb 4y agoIt's not "from a party", it's nominated "by the Senate". For example, Amy Barrett was confirmed by a vote of 55-43, including 3 Democrats. I'm not sure why you mention "a national majority". It was never a popularity contest. States elect senators, senators confirm Supreme Court justices.