5 ms·
Don’t let the great ESG self-deception infect climate tech investing
- vardump 4y agoYou know it's bad when some of the world's most environmentally damaging companies top the scores.
- AirStreamer27 4y agoESG is a trash index
- goatsneez 4y agoThis is excellent start of a debate, spot on on all points.
- thanatos519 4y ago"When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart's_law
- anonu 4y agoThe ESG push of the last 5+ years was rooted in good reasons. But the approach was wrong. In finance, ESG metrics are just factors like value, growth, momentum, etc... Those factors need to explain risk vs returns. The issue is they never did. There was never any explanatory power behind these things. Even the massive backing by asset managers like Blackrock was not sufficient enough to create demand because ESG factors were all over the place: 20 different providers with 20 different BS methodologies - mostly driven by NLP-style approach to parsing quarterly reports. Ultimately you throw in some nice words and greenwash the heck out of your report and your ESG metrics go up. The free and open market approach prevails. And if we want to see ESG impact the world around us, we should have the free market dictate how that happens rather than Larry Fink.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoI would like to see not the 'free market' dictate how it happens - I would like to see companies that harm their investors end with their ceo/cfos perp walked out and arrested. I want to see companies remember they have a fiduciary duty to their investors.
- mijamo 4y agoInvestors live on earth. Climate change will incurr extremely high costs on anyone living on earth. Therefore it is part of their fiduciary duty to fight it for any company in the world. In a more cynical way, ESG is a way to try to escape tougher legislations that would impact revenues in a larger way, and so is also part of the fiduciary duty in that sense. Note that fiduciary duty already does not force companies to outsource to China even if that would save some money and increase benefits.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoI am happy that, in the US at least, the current legal climate does not agree with you. In some countries, I have seen what you are saying becoming more and more pronounced. In Western Europe, specifically, you are seeing it. I imagine the upcoming cold winter in Germany and the scramble to secure supplies at any cost for their citizens will help fix this issue.
- Orothrim 4y agoGrow up, these climate changes will happen, the companies can make the appropriate changes now (early), or they can hold off and be forced to comply or die by governments.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoPlease follow hacker news guidelines or choose not to post. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Or, since your account is only 88 days ago, I guess create a new account. I don't bother replying to the "substance" of troll comments.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoThe point of companies are to make money. As a shareholder in a company, I want to see increased valuations, good free cash flow metrics, and an increasing dividend. The article is right in a way - ESG is infecting companies. I do not want a company I invest in to "weigh in" on political issues [1]. I do not want to see banks put in racial quotas in order to get preferred rates [1]. I do not want to see a 'restorative decolonial' approach to ESG in companies [2]. For gods sake, I do not want laws to change to remove a companies requirement of a fiduciary duty so they can adopt more esg goals [3]. When did saying "I invest in a company for profit related reasons" turn into such a big boogey man. [1] - https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/06/17/using-esg-tools-to-help-combat-systemic-racism-and-injustice/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/06/17/using-esg-tools-t... [2] - https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/anti-racism-esg-just-might-save-world-hr-rewired/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/anti-racism-esg-just-might-sa... [3] - https://www.esginvestor.net/reforms-needed-to-free-investors-to-consider-esg-factors/ https://www.esginvestor.net/reforms-needed-to-free-investors...
- gadders 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine "there is one and only one social responsibility of business—to use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays within the rules of the game, which is to say, engages in open and free competition without deception or fraud." In a way, you could call this the Corporate/Investing equivalent of effective altruism. Generate as much profit as possible and let employees/shareholders use that cash to support the causes they choose.
- Orothrim 4y agoIf the company kills people in the process of generating as much profit as possible, it should be stopped. You are saying it should be stopped by the 'rules' which clearly means that governments should be forcing rules that focus on the ESG objectives? That seems like a dangerous path to walk. Any intelligent business manager knows that it is better to act early and in ways you choose than to be forced down a road you don't want later.
- uri4 4y agoI wonder if clima folks are sponsored by Russia or China to ruin the West. So far it worked in EU.
- Raydovsky 4y agoTBH I wouldn't be surprised. The obsession with renewables has hurt Europe beyond measure.
- rvba 4y agoWhat hurt Europe was that nuclear power plants were closed after protests. Renewables help.
- tablespoon 4y ago> What hurt Europe was that nuclear power plants were closed after protests. IIRC, early European anti-nuclear protesters got some support from the Soviet Union.
- rvba 4y agoThat whole account looks like some sort of a propagandist. Hopefully this will get investigated by dang.
- yucky 4y agoChina most likely since they benefit the most. Russia doesn't really have much industry. Then again they both benefit with the destruction of the US capital markets by ESG/DEI initiatives so there is that.
- throw0101c 4y agoI think Cullen Roche is correct when it comes to ESG: > 2) The secondary market is a bad place to enact change. The intelligent defense of ESG is “by reducing the demand for a stock we can increase its cost of capital and impact its operating performance.” This is true to some degree, but I think this is dramatically overstated. For instance, the firms in the S&P 500 are all large established firms that have more than enough capital to finance their operations. They aren’t using the secondary equity markets to fund their operations. In fact, most firms have so much capital that they’ve been net buyers of stock in the last 50 years. So, this puts the cart before the horse. The better way to think of public companies is to think of them like horse betting. We can bet on the horses, but secondary market purchases are just private exchanges, not cash issuance to firms. As a result, betting on the horses doesn’t change the outcome of the race. Similarly, our secondary market purchases and sales have a far smaller impact on the firm’s operations than we might think.[1] > 3) ESG investing puts more money in the hands of bad actors. Point 1 is the most basic arithmetic of markets. A smart indexer decides to own all the firms in the market because we don’t know which firms will perform better or worse. So, when you reduce exposure to certain firms because they aren’t aligned with your moral views then you increase the odds that you’ll earn a lower return. This means that someone else is earning a higher return and potentially investing more of that money into the causes you don’t believe in. You are, in essence, choosing to earn a lower return thereby funding the very types of people you might disagree with. * https://www.pragcap.com/my-view-on-esg-investing/ https://www.pragcap.com/my-view-on-esg-investing/ There seems to be decent evidence for Point 3 that ESG generally gives lower returns: * https://www.pwlcapital.com/sustainable-investing-how-will-it-impact-your-returns/ https://www.pwlcapital.com/sustainable-investing-how-will-it... So if an oil tycoon can get extra returns, he can then 'invest' some of those returns in funding astroturfing campaigns and false studies to cause confusion about climate change, thus helping to keep climate initiatives at bay. People who ESG invest may have lower returns and so may have fewer resources to fight against the oil tycoon.
- Proven 4y ago