23 ms·
Colleges that ditched admission tests find it harder to fairly choose students
- onos 4y agoUSA is rich in universities. I wish people would focus less on the rankings and looking good credential aspect of college, and more on using it as an opportunity to learn / actually getting good at something. If we did the latter, we’d realize that people could go to pretty much any university (or coursera!) and get a high quality education here.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoYou are absolutely missing one of the primary points of US universities, which is to maintain a social hierarchy. I mean, if you just want to learn stuff and get a good education, there are loads of resources where you can do that, often for free or near free. College is about much more than just learning new things, and if that's the only framework through which you value a college education, you'll be doomed to misunderstand the institution.
- onos 4y agoYeah you’re right, that is the aspect of uni that this article is about. Who gets to get the premo credential.
- Onanymous 4y agoNonsense. Education is not about taking a course or reading bunch of books. The big part of education is being able to directly ask a knowledgeable person once you're stuck. You can ask the community of course but the quality of community answers is more than often just trash.
- 2devnull 4y agoI think you’ve defined a tutor. Tutors cost less than college tuition. And top professors answer emails from non-students, sometimes they teach for free on MOOCs. Perhaps you’re on a very narrow field where knowledge is extremely scarce, but that’s atypical.
- bombcar 4y agoFor the cost of a college education at some places you could likely hire a knowledgeable professor of the skill set you’re interested in to live with you for four years. Nobody will loan you money to do that, howvevr.
- ALittleLight 4y agoPeople would probably loan you money for that if you have the income or collateral to support a loan.
- preommr 4y ago> The big part of education is being able to directly ask a knowledgeable person once you're stuck. Stuck on what? For an undergrad, those problems can easily be solved by going online or to a tutor for a fraction of the cost. And that's for STEM based problems, humanities is all about flattering whatever opinions the professor personally holds. The best piece of advice I got was from one of my english highschool teachers who told me a story about how when he was in university he was getting graded really poorly on essays until he basically regurgitated what he thought the the professor wanted to hear. It's been a while since I've been to university, but I think it probably still holds.
- bombcar 4y agoNow you know why businesses love university graduates! Being told what you want is a prime mover in business. Now back to my TPS reports.
- aeonik 4y agoAnother unique bonus of university education: in my undergrad one of the professors noticed that I cared about the subject material more than my classmates. Due to this he gave me opportunities to perform research in areas that I didn't even know existed. Had I not gone to a university I never would have been exposed to these areas of technology.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- necrotic_comp 4y ago"humanities is all about flattering whatever opinions the professor personally holds" - maybe at some universities, but not at a good liberal arts school.
- telotortium 4y agoGood liberal arts schools don't really exist in the US anymore, unless we're talking about something like St. John's College or maybe some Catholic universities. I believe the capture of university humanities departments by critical theory is pretty complete at this point, and the sciences are rapidly being colonized.
- bushbaba 4y agoYou get 1000 resumes for a job. How do you drop 95% of the applicants. One easy way is to look at the University and GPA as a quick snuff test. After running that cheap low-pass filter you now only have 50 Resumes. You now spend ~3mins on each of those resumes to determine the 10 people you plan to interview. That's why university matters, it helps you get past the first level of screening. It's also fair of employers to assume that the average Top 25 university graduate is better than the AVERAGE bottom 50% university graduate.
- catiopatio 4y agoThere are far more effective ways to stand out as an applicant than your GPA and university — in particular, by actually contributing notable work to the field, but also by making social connections and leveraging those into a job. I didn’t even graduate from high school, but I’ve never struggled to find employment with the companies I wanted to work for. The idea of a degree as a first-pass filter is oversold at best.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mjhay 4y agoThe highest quality education I received was at a community college. The undergraduate education I got after transferring to a well-regarded research shool was lower quality, with larger classes and professors who weren't incentivized to put effort into teaching.
- nO0b 4y agoMalcolm Gladwell explains why it's statistically FAR better to be among the smartest kids at a 2nd or 3rd tier school than struggling to get into some elite institution where you will be below average among your peers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3UEwbRWFZVc&t=220s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3UEwbRWFZVc&t=220s If you're borrowing money to pay for a degree, going to a school where you are not at the very top of the class is really taking a big risk.
- giardini 4y agoThank you for posting Gladwell's talk, which should be required viewing for any young, bright and hopeful high-school graduate. I wish all my nephews and nieces had watched it.
- WalterBright 4y agoI thoroughly enjoyed being around students a lot smarter than me in college. I also enjoy working with people smarter and better educated than me. It's just more fun, and it also puts me on my best game.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agothat's such a loser mindset, you should want to be challenged and pushed by peers stronger than you edit: I agree that the first part of this comment is too harsh, see child thread
- bushbaba 4y agoWhat! A 2nd tier school still has strong peers which you can surround yourself in. If you're at the top of a 2nd tier school you can push yourself to be near the PHD researchers and graduate students giving you similar academic peer rigor.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoI agree with you from an academic standpoint! Maybe my comment was too harsh, I think surrounding yourself with PHD researchers and graduate students counts as challenging and pushing yourself. But it's more fun when the people pushing you are your friends and peers. In contrast, how many PHD researchers with a spouse and kids want to study and get coffee with a 19 year old undergrad?
- RobotToaster 4y agoI find it hard to believe there's a shortage of people capable of teaching 1st year students, so this seems like a problem of artificial scarcity.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIt's all about margins. They want to squeeze teachers and get minimum-wage adjuncts to teach 1st years. At the same time, they want future rich people to be students, so they will donate back. Harvard, MIT, and Oxford have no problem finding future rich people. Random schools can't compete for smart people, so it makes sense for them to try to find prospects based on alternative criteria.
- efficax 4y agofar from a shortage, there’s a surplus of phds in almost every discipline. despite charging the highest tuition ever and sitting on massive endowments, the mbas in university administration don’t want to have to pay for them
- hattmall 4y agoWhy would they even need phds at all. Teaching first year student should be more of a side job thing.
- dgacmu 4y agoI think you're misunderstanding the challenge. Teaching first year students doesn't require Ph.D.-level knowledge, but it requires more teaching experience and skills than teaching later levels: The classes are larger; the students are less experienced at learning on their own; the students are new to the environment and less familiar with how to navigate it. Large classes of novices are particularly sensitive to logistical and teaching errors. You make a question on a homework or exam a bit confusing, you have 400 students utterly perplexed who may not have the domain expertise to know it's the question that's broken. At Carnegie Mellon, our teaching-track faculty generally own the large intro classes for this reason. They're the best we have at the process of teaching & education. It's the exact opposite of a side job. You want people who are deeply expert and passionate about teaching so that you don't completely botch the job, because the opportunities to botch it are huge.
- yasp 4y agoWas this not obvious from the outset? Do these people not consider the consequences of their actions beforehand?
- civilized 4y agoThey're not reversing the decision, are they? Going test-optional was a capitulation to social pressure, not a deliberate decision made for its benefits.
- CharlieDigital 4y agoAlternate headline: "Colleges that ditched admissions tests have to actually holistically evaluate applicants rather than reduce them to two numbers" No doubt that it's more subjective and more difficult; human beings are complex, multi-dimensional entities and I find it sad that in many of these selection processes, they are reduced to a few numbers for the sake of low effort filtering.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThere is plenty of evidence to doubt the whole "holistic evaluation" line of thought, which is often a tool for subtle discrimination. And pretty much all of these schools already did "holistically evaluate" students; test scores were just one part of that evaluation. Besides, at the end of the day everything boils down to a single number - applicants are ranked and those that make the cutoff get in, those that are below the cutoff don't.
- Spivak 4y agoHolistic evaluation in practice really means “present your best self in your application whatever that might be.” It allows for a range of impressive feats outside “was good at the arbitrary selection of school subjects and extracurriculars.”
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoIn practice it also often means, "This Asian isn't 'well rounded' enough and they're only into math and chess club." https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/15/us/harvard-asian-enrollment-applicants.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/15/us/harvard-asian-enrollme...
- Spivak 4y agoI don’t really know what you do to combat this kind of thing because what would you do as an admissions officer trying to create a student body with a wide range of skills and experiences but you have thousands of applicants who are “focused on having perfect grades to the detriment of everything else and participated in the ‘look how smart I am clubs’.” And I say this with full self-awareness that this was me. It’s probably the thing I regret most about my high school experience because of how unnecessary it was and how much it set me back on all the things that mattered. I consider myself extremely lucky that any university took a chance on me because my application was 100% “I have no real interests except playing the game of school and winning by min-maxing the point system” which looking back is so obviously the worst applicant. I for sure lost out on my dream school because of it.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoI’m looking at this and thinking: Did the colleges have no forsight, at all? Why did they think admission tests existed? Did they honestly think, “wow, the tests are flawed, so get rid of them, problem solved?”
- factsarelolz 4y agoNo it made it easier to discriminate and make more money money. Simple as.
- leeroyjenkins11 4y agoBecause people like taking down fences without knowing why they are there, because they are of course smarter than everyone who came before them.
- bombcar 4y ago
- TinkersW 4y agoRemoving SAT harms lower class people and benefits upper class people, so of course that removed it.
- compiler-guy 4y agoThe theory was that standardized tests harm lower class people and help upper class people. That is why they removed it [1]. This article demonstrates that the theory was wrong, but the intention was opposite of what you describe. 1. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/why-us-colleges-are-rethinking-standardized-tests/2022/03/14/81c7fd9a-a3a0-11ec-8628-3da4fa8f8714_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/why-us-colleges-are-...
- high_derivative 4y agoBut...that was exactly the purpose? To be able to more freely select amongst racial and gender lines as desired
- hbbwebw 4y agoI think it’s more complicated than that because the students expect to get jobs after completing the degree, if they even can complete the degree. For example, Im not great at art and don’t really have a passion for it. Should an art school accept me even though I’ll never have a career as an artist? Keep in mind I’d be taking a spot from someone who could. I have no doubt they’ll be able to improve my abilities but that’s not why many students apply.
- bombcar 4y agoI wonder what percentage of people work in the field their degree is in. I suspect it’s very high for some (law, pilot, doctor) and very low for others (history).
- WalterBright 4y agoI was trained in mechanical engineering, but write software. I still find my college education to be of great help.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWho could have seen that coming? The whole point of ditching quantitative tests is to empower the bureaucrats who want to make qualitative judgements based on their personal whims and biases. "Holistic" my ass.
- tsunamifury 4y agoIt’s really disappointing that many recent attempts of progressivism have just turned into new sexism and racism but defended as “the correct” versions of those. It erodes the intellectual validity of these institutions.
- nerdponx 4y agoFortunately I feel convinced that it's a passing fad. I just hope that the pendulum does not swing too far the other way.
- FredPret 4y agoMaybe I'm in a bubble, but every anecdote I read online in the past year or two is someone royally fed up with liberal politics. On Twitter, Reddit, and real life, the majority of people keep complaining about crime, drugs, homelessness. Sounds like a perfect environment for a generation of conservatives to get elected. Hopefully they stay close to the center for a long time.
- JadeNB 4y ago> Sounds like a perfect environment for a generation of conservatives to get elected. Hopefully they stay close to the center for a long time. The conservative groundswell is because generations of conservatives have already been getting elected, especially in less flashy positions that wield influence. Conservatives have really played the long game, at least since the New Deal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- joezydeco 4y agoThe "avalanche" of applications isn't just from the lack of standardized test scores, but the rise of the Common application platform. It's incredibly easy to fill it out once and then fire off a dozen applications in an afternoon.
- sbilstein 4y agocommon app is over 20 years old.
- whoooooo123 4y agoThis is why, in the UK system, you're only allowed to apply to five or fewer universities in the same academic cycle. (It's possible to enforce this because all applications go through the same centralised system.) You're also not allowed to apply to both Oxford and Cambridge in the same year - otherwise both universities would get twice as many applicants.
- notart666 4y agoHonestly it wouldn't be as big of a deal if colleges accepted more applicants than they have seats for. The UofMN does just that and has a 70% acceptance rate and is a top public school. They have yet to run into any problems by doing so. While this might not work for colleges in say California or Ivy Leagues, for competitive and selective schools it's definitely an option almost none of them do.
- WalterBright 4y agoColleges do overadmit, including elite colleges, because a predictable percentage decline the admission.
- compiler-guy 4y agoThe term for the percentage of accepted students who enroll is “yield”. Every college predicts its yield and admits enough extra to get a full class. It’s basic college admissions. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yield_(college_admissions) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yield_(college_admissions) https://www.thoughtco.com/what-is-yield-788445 https://www.thoughtco.com/what-is-yield-788445
- sokoloff 4y ago> “I think the students that do have the strong test scores still do have that advantage, especially when you have a student that has strong test scores versus a student who doesn’t have test scores and everything else on the academics is more or less the same,” an admissions officer Why would we expect this to not be the case? It’s literally additional evidence of scholastic aptitude and, if you want it to not have any effect on admissions, you have to prevent its inclusion* rather than making it optional, as optional means “those with strong scores submit those scores.” * Or, accept them in the application but prevent their inclusion in the admissions process and use them only for research/analytics and only after the fall semester starts.
- mynameishere 4y agoThey are very upfront in terms of rhetoric about wanting more black and Hispanic students, but their policies are a lot of shuck-n-jive, trying to get that result while pretending to be fair. Nothing has worked so far. The pretending-to-be-fair sure hasn't either. So, one thing that will work and keep it all simple: Just establish quotas. "We will admit the highest scoring black students until we hit x%." But I suppose that would make legal challenges easier.
- kenjackson 4y agoA better alternative is to fix the problem upstream. Push much more test taking prep for poor students. And reevaluate the SAT. It’s well known the stories of the SAT not including questions blacks score higher on and using questions that whites score higher on. Try to remove the bias from the test even if that gives surprising results. I’m not a fan of quotas, but I do think taking race into account up until a point is reasonable. It’s just a really tricky line.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoCite?
- kenjackson 4y agoCite what?
- bombcar 4y agoI assume the stories of black questions being dropped.
- kenjackson 4y agoAhh. See: https://digitalcommons.law.scu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1285&=&context=lawreview&=&sei-redir=1&referer=https%253A%252F%252Fwww.google.com%252Furl%253Fq%253Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fdigitalcommons.law.scu.edu%252Fcgi%252Fviewcontent.cgi%253Farticle%25253D1285%252526context%25253Dlawreview%2526sa%253DD%2526ust%253D1538140607175000%2526usg%253DAFQjCNE7hKd6k-dofEZjqSgp_DPh9JynxQ#search=%22https%3A%2F%2Fdigitalcommons.law.scu.edu%2Fcgi%2Fviewcontent.cgi%3Farticle%3D1285%26context%3Dlawreview%22 https://digitalcommons.law.scu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic... There are some good snippets, but I’m on my phone. The whole thing is worth a read though.
- 5mv2 4y agoIt reminds me of European universities switching from selecting on humanities to selecting on maths a century ago. The idea was to remove the social upbringing's impact on test scores, as candidates from higher socioeconomic status are heavily advantaged from using a larger vocabulary from birth. A PhD friend who studied this told me it had no measurable impact. Put aside raising math tutors salaries of course.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoI'm from a former socialist european country, and we use grades + standardized tests results to get into most colleges (art, music and acting colleges are an exception, due to obvious reasons). Everybody has to pass a standardized test at the end of highschool, 5 subjects, for most, the first three are slovene (our native language), english (second language) and math + two subjects chosen by the student (eg. physics and sociology, or chemisty and informatics, or whatever). The colleges just give out rules how to calculate "points" (usually 40% are the grades, 60% is the test score, but some (eg medicine back in my time) require you to choose chemistry or biology as one of your subjects and that is worth 20%, next to 40% for the other ones and 40% for the grades). Students know those rules, apply for a college they want, finish the year, do the standardized tests, get the results, colleges calculate them into points, and if there are 60 spots for that study course, top 60 students are accepted... you don't even have to wait to get your letter, colleges publish that the cuttoff was 82 points to get accepted, and if you're above that, you're in, if not, you compete in other colleges/programmes that still have open spots left over. No races, no letters, no subjective stuff, no problems with -isms.
- tester756 4y ago40% are grades?! taking grades into account seems weird as hell
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoGrades for each subject are calculated into end-of-year grades (for that subject), and a final "total" grade is calculated (some special formula, not a pure average). A mix of those is then calculated into those 40%... I can look up the formula, but yeah, the grades are used too.
- VLM 4y ago
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoIt should be easy to make the student body reflect the diversity of applicants: select them at random.
- whoooooo123 4y agoI actually think this would be a good way to run admissions at ultra-selective elite universities - places like Harvard or Oxford where getting in or not can make a huge impact on the entire rest of your life. Everyone knows the evaluation process is bullshit and highly dependent on luck, so why pretend otherwise? Just discard those applicants who don't meet some minimum objective standard (SAT scores or whatever) then pick the remaining names out of a hat. It's never going to happen, but still. If people don't like it then maybe the solution is to improve the quality of other universities so that getting rejected from Harvard isn't such a big blow in the first place.
- bombcar 4y agoIt’s often not the quality as it is the network. It’s well known that many state schools have excellent business programs (think MBA) but that you should only ever go to your local one, because the network you get will be limited to that locality. Whereas NYU Stern or whatever is a world-wide network.
- texaslonghorn5 4y ago> places like Harvard or Oxford where getting in or not can make a huge impact on the entire rest of your life. ??
- whoooooo123 4y agoWhat part don't you understand?
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoI disagree that getting into those two schools makes such a huge impact.
- petilon 4y agoA selection process based on academic achievement alone yields a graduate more highly valued by corporate America [1]. Private universities should be able to use whatever criteria they want (as long as there is no illegal discrimination) including "building communities" and "shaping the student body". (It's a free country after all!) But public universities must use objective criteria. Students need to be able to control their own destiny through hard work. That's a basic principle of fairness that should apply in this land of opportunity. No "shaping" of the student body by universities that receive funding from taxpayers, because that is unfair to students. Imagine being denied admission by the only good public university in your state, not because your grades or test scores are not good enough, but because you didn't fit in whatever "shape" the university decided is appropriate for that year! For more on this see [2]. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/college-selection-method-can-boost-graduates-value-11575058720 https://www.wsj.com/articles/college-selection-method-can-bo... [2] https://circles.page/5680a56b5c28af0998656e09/College-Admissions-in-the-US https://circles.page/5680a56b5c28af0998656e09/College-Admiss...
- cuteboy19 4y agoI very much agree on the shaping your own destiny part. How can anyone subject themselves to a committee of random bureaucrats deciding their future? Even if they were 100% fair and impartial, does it not take away your agency in choosing your own fate? And let's not pretend that they are 100% fair and impartial. We know for a fact that they are racially biased against different races depending on the time period. And maybe the one who rejected you didn't like how you name sounded. It's not as though the process is transparent, and they're only making it a 100 times more opaque as people catch on to them. This Holistic Admissions nonsense has always been a scam just like Holistic Medicine
- funstuff007 4y agoOne of the most bone-headed directives I've ever seen. I truly believe the progressive goals are true and noble, but they have the aim of a blind man.
- fny 4y agoIn time, maybe universities will collapse under the weight of their own idiocy. I went back to school to finish my degree for fun at 25 t a top school. To my dismay, many online courses were better taught. In retrospect, the only courses in I enjoyed were small seminar passion projects.
- MengerSponge 4y agoKind of a big assumption that admission was fair before. Having test scores to fall back on is more useful as a CYA exercise than anything meaningful. "Nobody ever got fired for hiring McKinsey” indeed.
- josephcsible 4y agoNobody thinks admission was completely fair before, but it was without a doubt more fair with objective test scores than without.
- MengerSponge 4y agoThe headline says it was easier to fairly choose students with the exams, and I'm calling bullshit on that assumption. It implicitly assumes that selecting for standardized test scores is more fair. College admission has been unfair for generations. TBH I'm not sure "fairness" is even a good metric. Is it fair that I didn't have to work after school to support my family? No. Is it fair that my parents have advanced degrees and read to me as a young child? No. Is it fair that I got to take the SAT twice, because I wanted a higher math score? No. None of that is fair, and all of it helped me get into highly selective colleges.
- ok123456 4y agoI thought that was the actual point of ditching admission testing. They wanted to return to the pre-SAT days when they could just admit any legacy, no matter how unacademically suited an alumn(us|a)'s progeny was.
- Noumenon72 4y agoMatt Parlmer on Twitter recently stated it this way: > The university is primarily for theological indoctrination and secondarily for rich kids to get the same credentials as smart kids so they can maintain their status > This has not changed one iota since Oxford was chartered, it's what the system is for, take the Caplanpill
- 2devnull 4y agoAdmissions tests are the best tool to fight racism, specifically institutionalized racism, that we have in our tool kit. When racism increases in the future the tests will be ushered back in with great urgency, but because institutionalized racism takes decades to slowly grind away at, I think we’ll be doomed to such cycles. On some level it’s hard not to see that process play out, notice that it benefits the elites by acting as a sort of moat around their comfy middle class lifestyle while hurting racially marginalized groups, and also hurting groups which are rapidly closing the gap like Asians, and not see it as at least potentially misguided.
- remote_phone 4y ago> One college purchased a data service that ranked high schools and factored those high school rankings into each application. Students from underserved high schools received a lower ranking, an admissions officer explained. It wasn’t a fair process. This is the crux of the affirmative action fascists. They picked what they thought was a “fair” set of criteria and it didn’t produce the outcome they wanted. They concluded it wasn’t “fair” because it didn’t produce they wanted. That’s garbage. Backing into an outcome simply based on skin color that they want is racist and truly unfair. If you want certain communities to do better in education, you don’t manipulate the outcome by changing the selection criteria, you produce better candidates. Invest in education and safety in lower income areas. No one does this. South side Chicago and St. Louis Missouri and Baltimore aren’t filled with stupid people. They are filled with people who have suffered generational poverty, living in some of the most violent areas of the world. If you dump money into schools, jobs, and police in those areas, you will produce a thriving middle class in a single generation and from there you can create hundreds of thousands and millions of educated “underrepresented” people that are COMPETITIVE.
- kelnos 4y ago> They picked what they thought was a “fair” set of criteria and it didn’t produce the outcome they wanted. They concluded it wasn’t “fair” because it didn’t produce they wanted. That’s garbage. No, that's science. If your goal is "more racially- and background-diverse admissions", and you set up a process to achieve that, and then find that your new process didn't work, then the process was wrong. So you come up with a new process. > If you want certain communities to do better in education, you don’t manipulate the outcome by changing the selection criteria, you produce better candidates. Invest in education and safety in lower income areas. The problem is that universities don't really have the ability to invest in education and safety in lower income areas. As rich as many top-tier private universities are, they don't have the resources to make a dent in this problem. So you have a chicken-and-egg problem: you can't fix the inequity that causes some kids to get a worse primary education, but you can't give them a better secondary education and allow that to flow back into their communities. You have to break the cycle somewhere, and it seems pretty obvious that US federal and local governments have been failing miserably at improving education and safety in underserved communities. So you decide that you're going to find kids that your regular admissions practices would have rejected out of hand, but have the potential to learn and be successful at your school, even if there are gaps in their education. No, it's not a perfect plan, but what had been going on before wasn't working either. And maybe this won't work. But I think it's a worth trying.
- kewrkewm53 4y agoIt seems like modern wokeism was designed to make it easier for rich elites to exploit their privilege. Stuff like this makes it easier for lazy kids with rich and connected parents to get into best colleges/universities. All the talk about race and gender also conveniently turns attention away form real solutions that could help the underprivileged, like progressive taxation, which the rich elites oppose. At least Marx was smart enough to understand that ultimately who has the money/assets is the key, unlike modern progressives and their obsession with other less relevant qualities. We should tax the rich and fund the poor regardless of their ethnicity or identity.
- thegrimmest 4y agoI think this implies a personal philosophy along the lines of negative utilitarianism. I'm not sure everyone shares that.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoOh, you mean the correct one? Well, we need to make them understand that some ethical systems are better than others. Negative util is truthtil.
- int_19h 4y agoIt wasn't designed for this, but you're correct in that, so long as existing structures of economic power remain as they are, the rest is mostly just virtue theater.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoThis is not surprising, because the whole point of ditching the admissions test was to make the process less fair, and more biased.
- uri4 4y agoMaybe the "minorities" are actually smarter than you think, do they actually want to study there? What were rejection rates for minorities? In many cases college is a scam, investment is simply not worth the money (future earnings). Diversity studies referenced in article were mostly performed on "liberal arts colleges". Maybe this type of study is good hobby for rich white kids. But most normal people will not throw away their future on such schools!
- gdss 4y agocolleges are worth it if you get into the top 10 ones. Also, if you get scholarship.
- thefaux 4y agoFor everyone who finds the removal of admission tests ridiculous, how do y'all feel about leetcode?
- bombcar 4y agoFrom what I’ve seen interviewees hate it (this is dumb busy work) but interviewers love it because of the absolute deluge of incredibly inappropriate candidates they receive.
- throwawayu64 4y agoI spend my time working on open source or other products instead of leetcode prep. This means I don't apply to FAANG roles.
- ApolloFortyNine 4y agoLeetcode easies are fine, and that's all most companies outside of FANG ask in my experience. I've done interviews myself, and atleast 30% of candidates fail a problem that simply required a for loop to solve (no trees, no algorithms, just simple loop through list and do x). And if companies dropped the degree requirement and only asked leetcode mediums, I'd consider that fine honestly. Most of what I learned through college was useless to my career, 6 years out of college and I think I'd struggle to name even 25% of the classes I took.
- grumple 4y agoI don't expect my employees to solve problems on the spot, why would I expect it of interviewees? I give them a short take-home challenge, and it has worked well so far - I have a great team.
- rayiner 4y agoWhat surprises me is how many Asians support these measures. Make no mistake: our ability to progress as we have in America has depended on the fact that objective metrics cannot easily be gamed. The cost of test prep is a minor barrier to entry compared to the cultural knowledge required to write an essay that moves a WASP admissions officer, or the social capital and connections required to get involved in charitable or social activities that stand out in an application.
- exhilaration 4y agoI'm not sure where you're getting this impression, just read the Wikipedia page for SFFA https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Students_for_Fair_Admissions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Students_for_Fair_Admissions Asians are a pretty big and diverse group but I would say there's pretty strong support the lawsuits that will soon dismantle affirmative action.
- notart666 4y agoRealistically everything you listed here all requires you to come from at least an upper middle class family to attempt. My family couldn't even afford for me to join a club in high school. There is in reality no real fair way of selecting candidates without knowing more personal information such as their families tax history, income level, demographics, citizenship, etc.
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm not aware of any clubs in my high school that charged its members. Not even the Boy Scouts. None of the colleges I applied to asked for my family's tax history or income level, except for on the separate financial aid application.
- metalforever 4y agoI can answer this because I was in this position. Parents couldnt afford the gas. They worked long hours to make ends meet and couldn’t take time to drive me to this stuff even if they had the gas money. Finally, there’s just not a lot of ECs available in a lot of poor areas , like the one I came from. I filled that space in the app talking about my hobbies instead because there was no money. Yeah.
- paulpauper 4y agoEven very high scorers sometimes find it impossible to get into top schools. Part of the problem is supply of slots has not kept up with population growth. It's not like Harvard's enrollment has kept up with population growth. Another problem is that the ceiling of standardized tests has been lowered, so top scores more more common.
- bombcar 4y agoUniversities like to limit themselves somewhat because they don’t want to endanger the brand, but it takes an insane amount of money and effort to get a new college or university off the ground. The state schools may be able to sidestep this a bit.
- kelnos 4y agoNot just an insane amount of money and effort, but likely decades to develop a reputation that could rival that of a Harvard or MIT. When you're starting from zero, you're not going to be able to attract top-notch faculty.
- wincy 4y agoI know a guy who got a perfect on his SAT at my lower middle class suburban high school back in 2004 or so. He got rejected from Harvard. Even the most prestigious school around the Kansas City Metropolitan area only gets 1 or 2 people going to Ivy League schools every year out of maybe 200. Which I think is funny because they definitely bill themselves as an “Ivy League Prep” type of school.
- wallscratch 4y agoYou mean Pembroke? Probably more like 5-10 kids a year. Even my public suburban kc high school had 7ish kids going to ivies my year.
- warbler73 4y agoAs Nelson in The Simpsons would say: "Ha ha!" In other words, this was a foreseeable consequence. > Without SAT and ACT scores, he explained, the job of admitting students had become more subjective and more time-consuming. It's amazing we are doing a nationwide experiment to find this out.
- ALittleLight 4y agoI am confused as to why this wasn't expected. "We removed our objective measures, but then the process became more subjective." Riiiiiiight.
- nova22033 4y ago1. Spend more money to give kids all the extra assistance they need 2. Remove/Reduce the testing criteria and lower standards Schools and colleges are overwhelmingly choosing option 2...to the detriment of ALL students.
- dougSF70 4y agoMIT admissions concluded that SAT scores were the least inequitable method for selecting students that would be successful at MIT.
- bushbaba 4y ago
- geraldyo 4y agoWhat's the sarcasm? You could argue the SAT is designed for testing skills that can only/primarily be learned within the current school system. And that System is designed to keep minorities out, so I could argue there's a correlation there
- tester756 4y ago>You could argue the SAT is designed for testing skills that can only/primarily be learned within the current school system go ahead then and argue using that point, I'd want to know what makes you think so I've prepared for SAT's equivalent in my country mostly from the youtube videos, so I'm curious what makes you think like that
- humanizersequel 4y ago"that System is designed to keep minorities out" That is an extraordinary claim to make with such poorly defined terms and lack of evidence.
- ratsmack 4y agoThis argument is parroted constantly regarding many things and not a shred of evidence is ever required.
- thelock85 4y agoThe evidence is literally in the federal and state legislation passed since late 1800s to support public education with extreme prejudice toward women and minorities. And the subsequent battle to make the system inclusive, culminating with the 1964 Elementary and Secondary Education Act (commonly grouped with “civil rights acts”). And even this law is continuously reauthorized by both sides on the aisle in the name of less discrimination (most recently “No Child Left Behind” and “Every Student Succeeds”). It is very true that “systemic discrimination” is an argument often parroted without evidence, especially in audiences that prefer rigorous scientific method to be persuaded. But it’s also true that counter arguments often lack evidence that systems are inclusive, and almost never take on anthropological context which take time and effort to build.
- raincom 4y agoJust take a look at kids of all Harvard faculty, top administrators. These kids get admitted to Harvard. I know of some MIT faculty, who jumped to Harvard, only to have his kids get admitted there. Sure, any testing, any measurement would have problems. Replace that with a better one. Instead, these people hide behind "well-rounded" admit pool. Since SCOTUS is going to put an end to affirmative action, Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford, etc will get rid of SAT/ACT requirement. Also admission committees will implement a secret system for admissions, where all comments about applicants are recorded and then get deleted after three months.
- crackercrews 4y agoI've heard that lots of professor kids get into the colleges where their parents teach. But is that surprising? They would presumably be much more well-qualified than the average applicant, based on both nature and nurture. Most administrators are not professors, but are former professors. The same rationale would apply to their kids.
- melony 4y agoUniversity staffs' (that are reasonably high up) kids are always given priority. That's just how it works. The reason is that you don't want the parent to leave or complain.
- crackercrews 4y agoWhat's your source for this? What makes you think this is the reason, as opposed to the nature and nurture rationales?
- melony 4y agoJust ask anyone in academia? It barely counts as an open secret. Most admission forms (for the Cali and other state schools/private schools) would ask you explicitly if you have any relatives working for the school and their specific title and role.
- c7b 4y ago> Admissions officers at selective colleges were also “overwhelmed” by the volume of applicants that test-optional policies had unleashed. Given that acceptance rates are used as a ranking metric, and given what we have learnt about the lengths that even elite colleges like Columbia will go to to game those rankings, how sure can we be that the increased volume of applications wasn't the actual reason why they adopted test-optional policies (plus the nice side effect of likely raising the average scores of those admitted students that did submit scores, another common ranking metric)?
- metalforever 4y agoI came from poverty and was able to go to a top CS school because of standardized testing . I didn’t score as well as my peers , but the admissions committee looked at district and county percentiles . I checked test prep books out of the library . I took the SAT test with low income fee waivers. I was saddened at the news regarding removing testing because my parents couldn’t afford extra curriculars and the tests were the only way I was able to level the playing field.
- tomohawk 4y agoIt's the illusion of control. It may be possible to select the obviously great candidates, but its foolish to think that this can be carried out for all of them. Set aside 15% of the slots for the highest ranked candidates. Set another threshold for "nope". Then all the candidates that do not get into the 15% but are better than nope go into a lottery.
- gumby 4y agoWhy even pretend that admission is in some sense "fair"? I don't mean this as a "anti-woke" or "pro-woke" harangue, or as a middle school cynical pose. Admission in the USA is a manual and largely arbitrary process. Just like judges' rulings, it's influenced by which person happened to read the application, what they had for breakfast and what time of day it is. Plus random factors like the orchestra's french horn player having just graduated. We recognize this for hiring, why not school applications? Acknowledging it will reduce a lot of heartache. (Another heartache reducer would be the elimination of the "common application")
- hawaiianbrah 4y agoWhy would removing the “common application” remove heartache? I’m not familiar with that idea.
- gumby 4y agoThe common application encourages people to apply for schools they aren't qualified for ("what the hell it's only another $30"), a phenomenon which has been exacerbated by the schools themselves. The USNWR ranking includes acceptance rate ("more selective" means a higher proportion of rejections), so schools send letters to kids who can't get in, encouraging them to apply. I saw these letters last year. In addition, the common app really restricts what you can say. For example two kids might have earned an Eagle Scout rank: one just did the minimum to get a check box; the other might have really used it to learn and develop. In the common app there isn't really room to differentiate unless you devote your essay to it. Back when each school had a unique application, the burden of applying makes you more judicious in your choices. However it also allowed you to adapt your application to what you wanted to emphasize to each school. For a quantifiable difference: back when I was applying to universities in the 1980s, MIT had quite a high acceptance rate compared to its peers, ~18% IIRC. Why? Turns out few people applied because they (probably correctly) assumed they wouldn't get in anyway.
- forinti 4y agoJust forget about trying to be fair: use some kind of test and pick out by lottery from the n best results.
- poorbutdebtfree 4y agoNo one would dare complain if the incoming student body went from 80% white/asian to 80% black/hispanic.
- geraldyo 4y agoPeople like you would
- hairofadog 4y agoNo? Nothing close to that has happened and many people are already complaining.
- hotpotamus 4y agoWhat if they eliminated racial consideration and it went to 0% black/hispanic? I wonder if anyone would celebrate?
- SantalBlush 4y agoRight now, you are complaining about how nobody would complain.
- absrd 4y ago> No one would dare complain It hasn't even happened and you're complaining about it!
- ordinaryperson 4y agoI'd encourage everyone to read Emily Shaw's research on this topic: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED563202.pdf https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED563202.pdf "Validity of the SAT for Predicting First-Year College Grade Point Average" TL;DR: High School GPA + SAT score produce correlation coefficient values between 0.44 and 0.62, depending on the population. How strong are those values? > A general rule of thumb for interpreting correlation coefficients is offered by Cohen (1988): a small correlation has an absolute value of approximately 0.1; a medium correlation has an absolute value of approximately 0.3; and a large correlation has an absolute value of approximately 0.5 or higher. From Dr. Shaw's paper on page 7, linked above. In other words it's very strong, the strongest correlation coefficient that has been found for any signal associated with first year GPA at college. This has been well understood in the academic community for decades, it's only outside of professional education circles that the validity of the SAT and ACT (when combined with high school GPA) as a predictor of future performance at college is even questioned.
- Madmallard 4y agoWater is wet.
- BobbyJo 4y agoThe greatest source of admissions inequity is childhood socioeconomic status. Dropping the SAT is so obviously not a fix for that I question the competency of the administrators who thought doing so was a good idea. The SAT is probably the most attainable piece of the application process for a poor kid to succeed at. You literally just need a guide book or two and enough time to study. One good smart friend helps if you're lucky enough to have one. Literally the lowest barrier to entry for a kid stuck in a shitty school with parents that aren't around and no money to your name. Is it still a hurdle for poor kids? Undoubtedly, but I can't think of anything that can show academic capacity that requires fewer resources.
- crazygringo 4y ago> You literally just need a guide book or two and enough time to study. I think it's important to realize just how extremely non-obvious this is, though, for many high school sophomores/juniors. I went to a decent high school and was in honors classes, and even I would have had zero idea test prep was even a thing, if a single science teacher hadn't randomly mentioned it in class once. I went to the school library and found the "Princeton Review" and practice exams and everything. I absolutely credit it with raising my score by probably a couple hundred points. But I never would have discovered it except for that single teacher's offhand comment. I just assumed it would be a test that was an accurate reflection of your knowledge/intelligence, so as long as you were going to school, you'd just take the test and get your grade. If someone had pressed me, I probably would have said that test prep would be something kids in rich schools wasted their money on that wouldn't make a difference anyways. I just had no idea. Yes, I absolutely agree that the SAT is the most attainable way for a poor kid to succeed at. I personally don't support the movements to remove standardized testing, not at all. But I also want to highlight how there's still an utterly gigantic step needed to reliably educate kids both about the importance of the SAT and how to prepare for it. Very often barriers aren't even primarily a question of money/time/effort -- they're simply a question of awareness that an option even exists or that it matters.
- MereInterest 4y agoEspecially because the entire purported schtick of the SAT is to measure aptitude (the "A" in the acronym). In principle, if the SAT is true to its name, getting a study book shouldn't help at all. But since study guides or repeated testing does improve the score, it can't be a true measurement of aptitude.
- slavboj 4y agoYes, that was the intention - to admit more "diverse" students without embarrassment, at the expense of kneecapping themselves with crappier heuristics for the general admissions pool.
- Yujf 4y agoIt is honestly fascinating to look at the US (and many other countries) college system as a Belgian. Except in few cases (becoming a medical doctor is the only one I can think of but there might be others) you can just study what you want, where you want. Obviously the US can not do that as some colleges would be overrun by students but it is so foreign to me.
- flashgordon 4y agoWell duh. SATs maybe useless and completely unrepresentative of real world application. But they are just that - standardized. You know 10 years in advance what you are prepping for as opposed to "oh well I am this background so doing this set of activities optimizes my college application because the application reviewer is so totally allowed to bring in their own biases".
- nickpinkston 4y agoI think it's not about doing away with all tests, but providing various kinds of tests / process to get in, so various types of students can get in. For instance, like some here, I never knew about SAT prep, etc., but I did run a business in high school and did a ton of hardware/science projects, which both in retrospect made me far better prepared for startup life than anything school taught me. However, this more makes me think we need a better way of matching students with schools, training, and other programs that fit their style. People think the "Learning Styles" approach has been discredited, with in specific they're right, but that doesn't mean that the current style of school is good for everyone either. I went to school in rural Western Pennsylvania with parents who went to community college, and I definitely didn't have anyone helping me think through any of this stuff. Big shame, because plenty of people have everything but the right environment / people around them to help them succeed. I was lucky to go to Pittsburgh and found the startup scene basically by random.
- harrisonjackson 4y ago> I think it's not about doing away with all tests, but providing various kinds of tests / process to get in, so various types of students can get in. This. Same goes for hiring. You don't want to eliminate a successful pool of candidates but rather unlock more pools and places to recruit from. Although I don't think education should be limited the way hiring is. There may only be 1 position that can be filled at a company but there are so many ways IMO we could expand class sizes at exclusive universities and/or improve online college options.
- TrinaryWorksToo 4y agoSat should be pass or fail. It's not precise enough to rank students
- HarveyBungus 4y ago1) The SAT is obviously a superior and more objective indicator of "will do well on schoolwork" than the other components of college applications. Essays on political topics, biggest weaknesses, and a time you had to overcome a challenge are obviously less standardized, more subject to whims of reviewer, and this is why they are being promoted. The idea that there are kids with terrible scores but great portfolios of work worthy of admission seems wrong to me. The people with portfolios of work were likely already getting in. 2) "If you can study for the SAT that defeats the point" is wrong. Nassim Taleb made a point of demonstrating that these tests are study-able. The idea that you can't really study for the SAT is loserthink promoted by the SAT. Nearly everyone I know who wanted to succeed in school studied multiple times, took the test multiple times, and greatly improved their scores. It might still be unfair insofar as the better-prepared<->better-supplied kids get a head start but if you grind out a 1600 from a bad school that is still impressive and demonstrates hard work. 3) The solution to inequities in SAT/admissions is to devalue education via school, a la Caplan/ScottAlexander.
- kleinsch 4y agoGrades you got on actual schoolwork are a much more obvious predictor. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-12-22/grades-vs-sat-scores-which-is-a-better-predictor-of-college-success https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-12-22/grades-v...
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoGrades from different schools are not equivalent. It's extremely difficult to compare grades from hundreds or thousands of different schools. You have to really know how rigorous each individual school's grade scale is.
- elgenie 4y agoGrades from different schools are not remotely equivalent in representing material learned. However, they are comparable with respect to the hoop-jumping conscientiousness of the students involved, and there's a decent argument that it's the latter is what matters for successful completion of college.
- yieldcrv 4y agoThis is not saying the SAT is good. It is saying they don't have something better. A lot of people are misinterpreting this. The zeal of reaction to the problems with the framework left everyone without any framework. A very common failure mode that exacerbate the division in "culture wars".
- LatteLazy 4y agoColleges should admit everyone then let those who pass pass and those who fail drop out. That is the fair way to run your admissions policy. Everything else is BS.
- yCombLinks 4y agoHarvard admits 4% of it's applicants. How is it going to allow 25X as many students?
- LatteLazy 4y agoMore accommodation. Most of them will fail first year. Or if they don't, Harvard needs to up it's internal standards.
- John23832 4y agoI hate that these article from obviously biased random websites are submitted to HackerNews just to be a lightning-rod submission for people to air their already inbuilt frustrations in the comments. The site's subtitle is "Covering Innovation & Inequality in Education" for god sakes. Look at all the articles and there is nothing positive. There is space to analyze affirmative action, or schooling in general, but this is literally just educational propaganda.
- bribri 4y agoSeems like the fairest option. GPA, essays, and extracurriculars are BS and even worse.
- qwertyuiop_ 4y ago
- throwaway22032 4y agoThe idea of "fairly" choosing students is insane on the face of it. We want the best and brightest to succeed. They should be showered in whatever is necessary in order for us to advance the state of the art.
- known 4y ago[dead]
- known 4y ago