2 ms·
Keeping property vacant because you only care about appreciation and don’t want the hassle of being a landlord is a reasonable course of action, even if immoral
by seanmcdirmid 4y ago
Keeping property vacant because you only care about appreciation and don’t want the hassle of being a landlord is a reasonable course of action, even if immoral. Property tax acts as friction against this, but often isn’t good enough to force people to rent out their property.
- roenxi 4y agoSure, but in that instance the correct policy response there is to stop the policies that force house prices eternally upwards, meaning that this strategy doesn't work in the long term. It takes quite distorted incentives for the obvious course of action to be (1) build a house => (2) leave it empty. For that to make economic sense for more than maybe 12 months, the government has to have really come in swinging with crazy policies.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tomcam 4y agoIs it moral for a city to control how I price my products? Is it moral for that same city to give me nothing when renters stop paying rent and utterly destroy my property before they leave after many months or years of mandated delays? Is it moral for a city to keep prices so low I can’t possibly afford to maintain the place for tenants and also make my own mortgage payments?
- Eisenstein 4y agoWhy would it be immoral for society to do things in its best interests, instead of only yours? Whether these actions work or not, it is not immoral to attempt them. There is no 'human right to profit at the expense of others'.
- tomcam 4y agoWell that does nothing to address my questions, but at a minimum New York landlords are paying the highest taxes in the country. They are literally being forced to contribute to the public good with a little or no oversight as to the effectiveness of their involuntary contributions. Also you appear to have hallucinated things I didn’t say.
- parineum 4y agoAnd that only happrns because regulation of new housing keeps demand for the empty property high.
- imtringued 4y agoForcing people to rent out their property is immoral. Forcing people to conserve land which is a scarce resource in urban environments is not.
- vkou 4y agoAnd I'm of the mind that letting people hoard a scarce, necessary to life resource, when they aren't even using it is immoral. The discomfort you experience of having to let out your bought-for-the-purposes-of-renting properties, instead of letting them sit fallow is less important to me than the discomfort of the person you're evicting. Fortunately, vacancy taxes can solve this problem very easily. You want to be a landlord? Comply with tenant laws. If you don't like it, you won't be missed, it's not like you can leave and take that apartment with you.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoIf the tenant laws mean being a landlord isn’t profitable, then no one will bother doing it. Capital will flee from the market chasing better returns elsewhere, and then who is servicing rental demand? In China, rental returns are so paltry compared to purchase prices that many property speculators simply don’t rent out their properties (renovating a property reduces its value in that market, so leaving it unfinished is a winning strategy). That has nothing to do with regulation and everything to do with an out of control property bubble, but the same principle applies. Here in Seattle, being a landlord is an increasingly untenable position, especially for private individuals. They are instead in it just for the appreciation (property bubble again) and so it makes sense for them to just leave the house vacant and keep squatters away.