4 ms·
If so, that's quite stupid. That's more money that the richest person in the world has, and it's incommensurate with the impact of Jones's behavior. It serves
by dekhn 4y ago
If so, that's quite stupid. That's more money that the richest person in the world has, and it's incommensurate with the impact of Jones's behavior. It serves nobody- not even the families whose children were killed.
- sollewitt 4y agoRight: nobody, not even billionaires, can afford to do this ever again. Seems like a win condition to me.
- phantom_of_cato 4y ago
- gnu8 4y agoShould the amount of wealth someone can hoard be essentially unbounded, allowing them to become impervious to any civil consequences for their actions?
- phantom_of_cato 4y agoThat has nothing to do with the ridiculous argument made above.
- dang 4y agoAs you know, using HN primarily for ideological battle is not allowed here, regardless of what you're battling for. Since you're clearly doing this with this account, I've banned it. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- phantom_of_cato 4y ago[dead]
- cykros 4y agoExcept that's not what civil court is for. It's for obtaining redress for damages suffered. $10 million, or even $100 million, and I'd say these victims must have suffered a lot...but very well, maybe they did. $1 billion? This is an abuse of the court system, and is the sort of money large corporations get fined when they do something really bad. Facebook famously got hit for $5 billion over Cambridge Analytica in 2019. OJ Simpson, on the other hand, paid $70 million when a person actually died. Even with inflation, getting to $1 billion is stretching things well past the breaking point.
- lettergram 4y agoI mean… if anyone watched the trial this whole thing is a joke. He may have done something bad, but the trial was Soviet level. I followed the trial and this is the way the “trial” went: 1. Plaintiffs / Judge claimed he had evidence (marketing material on sandy hook - claimed he never had marketing material) 2. Jones said he didn’t 3. discovery didn’t prove the evidence ever existed 4. Judge then said “guilty by default, because he must have destroyed the evidence” 5. Jury trial commences for damages - judge tells Jones he can’t claim not to have evidence, can’t claim innocence, and a whole list of other stuff 6. Jury trial talks about a bunch of unrelated stuff that other people said. 7. A few times you see a clip where Jones mention “sandy hook is a psyop” or “this parent laughing before fake crying is a crisis actor” (paraphrasing obviously). But never mentions people by name, nor outside what is presented on the news (CNN for instance) If anyone knows about defamation. (1) defaulting never happens (2) you have to name the person and have to claim an explicit in the defamation that you know to be false, with the purpose of causing damage. It was real interesting to watch, but I imagine it’ll be overturned
- cykros 4y agoThis is the first of these takes I've heard; seems most of us are just taking third hand hearsay on this one. I've always found Jones entertaining, though more interesting back in the 9/11 Truth and Bilderberg group days than anything recently as he seems to have gone a bit loopier than ever. I wasn't even terribly opposed to a hefty fine for defamation if he did what he's accused to have done, though the idea of it being a billion dollars is a bit absurd (Facebook, for reference, got hit with a large fine of $5 billion a couple years back). I'll have to get to doing some digging, because if it's as you say, this is even more of a travesty than it seemed. As for this new total, well, this makes the Napster lawsuits against children of yore seem sane by comparison, and much of the same logic seems to have been used for how the figure was calculated. And the idea that we're actually talking about the events the trial is supposedly about rather than Jones' entire history of being a thorn in the side of some powerful people is clearly a lie. If anything, I have to wonder how anyone doesn't see this as suggesting that maybe he was onto a thing or two they'd previously written off that he's being publicly made an example of for exposing.
- 4y ago
- thomascgalvin 4y ago
- BuckRogers 4y ago
- polotics 4y agoI respectfully disagree. As a father I am amazed Alex Jones is still walking free, still walking, not still.
- dekhn 4y agoHim being jailed, and given an impossibly large fine, are two distinct things entirely.