5 ms·
> unless you want to throw your money away renting. You're not always throwing your money away when you're renting; I'm pretty sure that housing prices are ris
by pessimizer 4y ago
> unless you want to throw your money away renting.
You're not always throwing your money away when you're renting; I'm pretty sure that housing prices are rising faster than rents, due to a culture of housing speculation.
- pharmakom 4y agoWhy do people use this phrase? You are paying for a service (somewhere to live). Unless you can afford to buy outright then you’re either “throwing money away” renting or on interest payments.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoIn a lot of places, mortgage payments are around the same as rent, so if you can "buy" (qualify for a good mortgage) you'll be paying less AND your net worth will be growing Of course, the situation is more complicated in areas like the SF Bay and Seattle. Housing prices vs rent basically assume 5% year over year growth forever, so if you think housing prices will be flat, it's economically advantageous to rent There's a good calculator without a ton of BS here on this old page: https://michaelbluejay.com/house/rentvsbuy.html https://michaelbluejay.com/house/rentvsbuy.html
- gassiss 4y ago> In a lot of places, mortgage payments are around the same as rent, so if you can "buy" (qualify for a good mortgage) you'll be paying less AND your net worth will be growing sure you'll be paying less, but you'll also be buying a lot of risk. You don't own anything until it's fully paid, and if the interest rates skyrocket good luck with bankruptcy
- causi 4y agointerest rates skyrocket good luck with bankruptcy What kind of lunatic doesn't get a fixed-rate mortgage?
- pharmakom 4y agoThis is the norm outside of the US
- imtringued 4y agoWhat kind of lunatic offers a fixed rate mortgage for 30 years? If people knew anything about banking they would realize that this type of mortgage can only exist in the form of a government subsidy.
- lazide 4y agoFYI - that hasn’t been true for several years in most of the country.
- OscarCunningham 4y agoAnd if you buy outright you're throwing your money away on opportunity costs. That money could be in the stock market.
- scarface74 4y agoYou’re assuming that a mortgage is always more expensive than rent. Your rent is going to go up. My mortgage isn’t. To put things in perspective, my parents had a mortgage of $600/month in 1978. It wasn’t too much of stretch for them then. But it did sting. They were a teacher and a factory worker. By the time they paid the house off in 2008, $700 by then was laughably small.
- lumost 4y agoThis is a vastly underestimated component of why owning makes more sense than renting for the majority of the population. Practically, you are unlikely to make more than 2x your starting compensation from school. Rental costs are somewhat sticky at around ~25-50% of your income depending on your preferences. You can save money, and live frugally. But a good chunk of your future disposable cash flow is going to come from fixing your housing costs.
- scarface74 4y ago> Practically, you are unlikely to make more than 2x your starting compensation from school I wouldn’t go that far. I don’t know what my parents made in 1968 or for that matter 2008. But from the time period I mentioned 1978 - 2008, if their income just kept up with inflation, it would have gone up by 650% according to the official CPI calculator (https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=100&year1=196801&year2=200809 https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=100&year1=1968...). Well actually, they retired in 2002 at 55 and 57 respectively - from teaching and factory work - and have been retired since then. They’ve taken two 5 month long cross country trips and have only slowed down their shorter road trips in the last couple of years because they were worried about Covid
- 4y ago
- bombcar 4y agoIt’s like saying eating at a restaurant or using Uber eats is throwing money away because you could have bought a stove instead. Kinda true kinda not.
- scarface74 4y agoHousing prices may be going up faster than rent. But as a homeowner my housing prices aren’t going up. When we moved into an apartment in 2012, rent was $1200. By the time we left in 2016, rent was $1700. Our mortgage was $2200 including PMI, taxes and insurance for a house we had a built. By 2020, rent at the same apartment was $2400. Our house is three times the size. The rent you are paying now is the least you will ever pay where you live. Besides changes in property taxes, our mortgage is the most we will ever pay.
- hactually 4y agolot of opinions here - counter to that, we're paying less for renting the same location we moved into three years ago. Covid, WFH and location value... lots can happen to change prices.
- scarface74 4y agohttps://www.cnn.com/2022/08/24/homes/us-rents-record-july/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/08/24/homes/us-rents-record-july/in... > Still, rents rose by double-digit percentages in all size categories in July compared to a year ago, with monthly rents for studios up 14.3% to $1,555; one-bedrooms, up 12.2% to $1,745; and two-bedrooms, up 11.7% to $2,103. > The South and Northeast have seen the largest rent increases. Miami, where rents were up 26.2% from a year ago, saw the biggest increase among the 50 largest US cities for the 10th-straight month. Miami was followed by New York, Boston, Chicago, and Orlando. https://ipropertymanagement.com/research/average-rent-by-year https://ipropertymanagement.com/research/average-rent-by-yea...
- smileysteve 4y agoYou are throwing money away. If not in the principle building (mortgage payments are commonly less than rent and 20+% goes to principle year 1 - assuming 0 price increase over your term). But also in the US + state tax code and credits - first with "homestead exemptions" - but especially if you make over $100k (yes, roughly 2x median household income, but applies broadly to hacker news and it's a home worth the "average"city price as you get to deduct the property tax and the mortgage interest (so rough savings of 25% on the remaining 80% year 1). For icing on top, you also get credits on energy efficient upgrades.
- leetcrew 4y agosure, if you're going to live in a 3BR+ home either way, it doesn't take long to break even on a purchase in most markets. but I'm living in a 1BR apartment that comes with a garage parking spot, an ideal setup for me personally. a mortgage for an entry level home in the same neighborhood is comparable to my rent, but it would be a strict downgrade to my QOL, as I don't actually benefit from the extra sqft and would have to put in more work to maintain it. obviously a house with a garage would be much more expensive. I've looked at 1BR condos, but the condo fee generally means it takes much longer to break even vs renting a similar property.
- smileysteve 4y agoPricing is different in different markets. In Atlanta, I was renting in a 1br condo for 7 years; when rent went up 15% in one year, it was free (after principal subtraction) for me to buy/move to a 2br in the same building in 2017. (Even more advantageous as a friend moved in). By 2019 comparable rents for a 2br were 2x my total payments.
- lazide 4y agoMy current rent is half (literally) what I’d pay in mortgage and property taxes if I’d bought the same place at the same time. That was when rates were low. It’s even crazier now, with the interest rate spikes. Even at the maximum rate it’s allowed to go up, it would take 5 years for that to change. But that isn’t happening, because California prices dropped 30% yoy already, and it isn’t stopping there anytime soon. Conservatively, my landlord has been ‘paying’ me $4500/mo due to the difference. She inherited it, and refinanced with low rates, so she’s fine at least. A lot of folks I know are staring at bankruptcy right now. Landlords haven’t had positive cash flow on a property in California in at least 5 years (based on ‘purchase now’ numbers). What you are talking about is the ‘sane market’ behavior, but that hasn’t happened anywhere in the country (near as I can tell, from real estate investor friends) for years. Hold onto your butts.