9 ms·
Battle with bots prompts purge of Amazon, Apple employee accounts on LinkedIn
- jamghee 4y agoI can't wait until North Korea mimics my profile and finds out just how unemployable I am
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoI guess they haven't got them all yet, I mean, the consensus seems to be that Apple has ~155K employees[1] not 284K (and obviously not every Apple employee will have a LinkedIn account...) 1: https://www.statista.com/statistics/273439/number-of-employees-of-apple-since-2005/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/273439/number-of-employe...
- stormbrew 4y agoLikely a lot of people just never update their employer on linked in after they leave. Especially if they retire. That'd be a different kind of problem than bot accounts.
- dylan604 4y agoI haven't updated my LI profile for quite some time. I don't even care enough to login to see exactly what was the last update. I do know that a recruiter was emailing me about a company that I had already spent time working with and since moved on, but was after I quit updating the LI profile. Still haven't retired either.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoI have noticed multiple former colleagues where I work not bothering to update their profile when leaving.
- silisili 4y agoSame. LinkedIn even suggested I congratulate one on her 4th anniversary, despite having left a year prior.
- ipaddr 4y agoYou have double accounts and contractors who officially worked someone else claiming employment. Plus former employees who never updated
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 4y ago> LinkedIn claims that its security systems detect and block approximately 96 percent of fake accounts. In order for that number to mean anything, they'd have to know what the total is. It would be more accurate to say that 96% of those who are caught at all are caught by LinkedIn themselves (presumably the rest by third parties) but that says nothing about how many are still in the system ... and that still seems to be a lot.
- pfortuny 4y agoYou can do random sampling, though. It can give a good estimate. Not saying they are doing it, though. But you certainly can get a good assessment without knowing the total population.
- oersted 4y agoAs in any similar problem: you can sample a reasonably representative set of accounts, review them thoroughly by manual means, and see how these manual results compare to the automatic ones. They don't need to know what the total is, if they knew the problem would be solved. 96% represents the probability of a correct prediction, not a fraction of the total.
- tedunangst 4y agoNo, that would be much less accurate to say. They're not saying the other 4% are caught at all.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 4y ago> No, that would be much less accurate to say. You don't know that. If I was premature in making a guess, you were equally premature in contradicting it. What's your interpretation? That they meant 96% of the total? I might enjoy seeing you explain how that could be true while still leaving 600K Amazon/Apple profiles to be cleaned up in a special campaign responding to media exposure. Do you think it's 96% of what they could have caught by manually examining every profile? That's no more supportable than the theory you summarily rejected. Your own guesses or assumptions are no better than anyone else's.
- gnicholas 4y agoI have wondered about fake profiles on LinkedIn. Seems like people believe that someone is real and their credentials are real just because they have a profile. But it would be easy to set up an account with a fake photo, make up an educational and employment history, and current employer. None of this is verified, AFAICT. Then you just start following/connecting to recruiters and others who are Very Online on LinkedIn, to make the profile look legit.
- __derek__ 4y agoA particularly easy suggestion I first heard on the Risky Biz podcast after the reporting about fake CISOs: LinkedIn should prominently display profile creation dates.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoOnline dating apps do selfie verifications or identity proofing. LinkedIn could do the same as well. To verify someone's identity with a gov ID is about $1-$2 per proofing request. https://stripe.com/identity https://stripe.com/identity (only as an example, many vendors offering this service)
- wildrhythms 4y agoHow does the Gov ID verification work?
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://identity.stripedemos.com/ https://identity.stripedemos.com/
- metadat 4y agoThis will only create a market for old "used" accounts. LinkedIn allows you to change your name and profile content as often as you wish, and doesn't keep or publicly expose any of a profile's past info.
- ilamont 4y agoEven before the current LinkedIn purge, shouldn't duplicate profile images be a red flag? I got three invites from three different accounts with the same profile photo in the space of a week over the summer. This is also an ongoing issue for Facebook, except the fake accounts use the same profile photo and name as real people. It's a vector for fraud and causes untold headaches for millions. It's been going on for years.
- jrd259 4y agoSurely easily defeated by using fake images from thispersondoesnotexist.com?
- ben_w 4y agoIf the criminals are keeping up with tech. I have no reason to expect them to be any more in the loop than anyone else, and I still surprise tech people with Google Translate's augmented reality mode, which is nearly 12 year old tech now.
- duskwuff 4y agoUnfortunately, I can say from experience that social media spammers adopted AI-generated profile photos very quickly.
- latchkey 4y agoLinkedIn is a cesspool of shit. I spent a bunch of time and removed literally everything from my profile except for my current job, which only has minimal information. That had the effect of actually increasing the number of Amazon headhunters writing me weekly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- donretag 4y agoI explicitly have on my profile that I am not interested in Amazon, but their recruiters still contact me. Recruiters still not read profile, it's basically spray and pray. That said, it's been a couple of weeks since I have heard from Amazon. There truly must be a hiring freeze going on
- mabbo 4y agoEvery time an Amazon recruiter emails me, I reply back CC'ing every previous Amazon recruiter. I say "Thanks <new person name> but I'm not interested in working for Amazon. <Previous recruiters>: I previously asked to be taken off the mailing list- what happened?" I got to 4 people on my list before the emails stopped coming.
- metadat 4y agoAfter 14 years on LinkedIn, I recently closed my account. LinkedIn never did much of consequence for me, and I've been enjoying no longer receiving recruiter spam. A long time ago I did once find a job through LinkedIn ads, but beyond that it's been a complete waste of time and energy. At this point, social media, especially of the "professional" variety, seems like more trouble than it's worth.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have someone in UAE that is listed as an employee of one of my companies, as an administrative assistant. The company is in my home, in New York. I reported the fake profile, but it's still there, listed as an employee of mine. [UPDATE] Actually, belay that. They seem to finally be gone.
- makestuff 4y agoSlightly related but there is a fake profile of me on Facebook I have been trying to get taken down for months now. It copied my profile picture and added several of my mutual friends. Facebook just keeps saying the profile doesn't violate their guidelines even though my last name is very unique and the profile picture makes it blatantly obvious.
- Brybry 4y agoI wonder if you DMCA/copyright strike the fake profile for using your picture if that would be more effective.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoA young (attractive) man was murdered in my country with a case dragged out over a period of years, there was a fake but active profile using his highly published images under a different name. Facebook banned me for continuously reporting the profile, in every report I linked multiple articles containing the relevant images. I would suggest you encourage a large volume of contacts to report the profile. Funny that you have to game the system to achieve a perfectly legitimate result.
- derefr 4y agoI feel like the workflow that happens when you click "flag" in social networks has become ossified according to " Content Guidelines" in the same way that Level-1 CSR scripts are ossified. To actually get one-off (rather than rule-based) evaluation of a problem, you need your report to not come in from that direction, but from some other side-channel, e.g. a viral tweet complaining about the problem.
- pawelwentpawel 4y agoI've seen a number of accounts that had fake profile pictures straight out of https://thispersondoesnotexist.com https://thispersondoesnotexist.com, majority of them used for spam. Also, the content created by (seemingly) real people is sometimes worse than if it would be automatically generated. I run a couple jobs board groups on LinkedIn and the amount of sheer amount of low quality spam that people are trying to push in is incredible. Despite all that, I still find LinkedIn useful.
- cmeacham98 4y agoObviously this won't work for every company, but for Amazon, Apple, and similar it seems like the solution is obvious: LinkedIn users should be forced to verify an @amazon.com/@apple.com/etc email address to claim they are currently an employee of those companies.
- plandis 4y ago…and then get spammed on my work email? No thanks!
- pvarangot 4y agoIf your work email is a common combination of first name and last name or initials this already happens if you work for FAANG. A lot.
- tharkun__ 4y agoWorst idea ever. I have never and will never give LinkedIn (or similar platforms) my work email address. I strictly separate work from personal stuff. Work stuff gets my work email. Personal stuff gets my personal email. Traveling for work and need to book a hotel? Work email. Apple Id for work laptop? Work email. New account per employer. Gets disassociated and closed before I hand in my laptop. Electronic pay slips? Personal email. Health insurance account? Personal email. Apple Id for personal laptop? Personal email. There are things I need or want access to without being dependent on my employer. LinkedIn has nothing to do with my work. It's personal. It's about me. I list information about me. It's like a CV. No I should not have to update my CV through my work email account where my employer has access to information they shouldn't and where I can't update it if I no longer work there.
- derefr 4y ago> No I should not have to update my CV through my work email account That (changing your account to use your work email for sign-in) is not what they're suggesting; they're suggesting binding the email address as secondary information to your account (by sending it a magic-link email you have to click) — like a Keybase verification that you "own" a profile.
- raydiatian 4y agoLinkedIn is such an objective failure. I’m independent and even I deleted mine. You can rest assured they’re still handing out our information.
- bushbaba 4y agoEh disagree. It’s been invaluable for keeping up with former colleagues. And finding contacts to assist with business.
- unforeseen9991 4y agoYeah people's contact information changes over the years, especially these days. Some people I develop a close enough relationship with to exchange personal email accounts, the majority I don't. I'm independent as well and some of my biggest projects have been from former people i've worked with reaching out.
- raydiatian 4y agoIt always seems that the tech companies that make major OSS contribs turn into fiestas. 1. LinkedIn gave us Kafka 2. Netflix gave us Hystrix 3. Greatest of all, Facebook, who gave us everything: React, PyTorch, Jest
- Macha 4y agoApple with LLVM is arguably a bigger contribution than LinkedIn with Kafka, and Apple are notoriously stingy with open source. I'd have thought their contributions to FreeBSD would be Netflix's most notable contributions. No mention of Google with Angular, Dart, WebM, AOSP, Guava, Kubernetes, Bazel, Go. At this stage Microsoft is also arguably a larger open source contributor than LinkedIn or Netflix.
- raydiatian 4y agoThis is all fair. I genuinely didn’t know Apple developed LLVM, I knew they were heavily involved in early 00’s. Can’t believe I forgot Kubernetes & Angular. Anyways it’s a hot take, you’re totally right.
- Kon-Peki 4y agoApple didn’t develop LLVM. It was a research project at the University of Illinois. Apple hired one of the lead developers and started the Clang project. Which is still a great contribution ;)
- sylens 4y agoShouldn't there be an option to verify your employment at a company? If you list a company in your profile, you have to provide a company email and click a link to prove that you own that email address. You could tune this to prompt someone to "refresh" the proof once a year or something.
- laweijfmvo 4y agoeven Blind does this, and that’s top-tier trash. I imagine LinkedIn has no benefit from doing this. It would only serve to show how few real employees they have and devalue the platform to recruiters.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mh8h 4y agoI wanted to share the link of a job posting on our company website to LinkedIn. It asked if I want to add my work email to my profile, just for verification reasons, so that it shows the "Is Hiring" ring around my profile photo. I made sure it's displayed nowhere in my profile. I also unselected every single consent related to using that email address. Less than a week later I started receiving recruiter emails in my work address.
- dlahoda 4y agowhy not they ask to do kyc before kick?
- etchalon 4y agoIt's absolutely ridiculous that the administrator for a Company Page can't remove a person as an employee from that page. We have a dozen or more fake employees on our page, plus ex-employees who never updated their linkedin, and there's no way for me to say, as a person who owns the business, "This person does not work here." Ridiculous.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RyJones 4y agoAs an employee of an open source foundation of seven people, who sees hundreds of employees of said project, I guess I salute this move.
- paxys 4y agoI work at a large tech company and we are routinely made aware of phishing scams on LinkedIn using our name – either fake profiles pretending to be an employee or even impersonating one of our actual employees. People have: * Tried to sell our product to others, despite not being affiliated with us * Acted as recruiters for our company * Tried to get jobs at other companies pretending to have an employment history with us It's frustrating that we cannot do anything other than report it to LinkedIn, who may or may not take it down eventually. The next time you are answering a LinkedIn DM, remember that anyone is allowed to write anything on there. None of it is verified.
- stcredzero 4y agoIt used to be, in the pre-internet 20th century, that people would exploit mismatches between paper stores of information to forge fake identities and game the system. https://www.edenpress.com/productcart/pc/viewPrd.asp?idproduct=9 https://www.edenpress.com/productcart/pc/viewPrd.asp?idprodu... Now, in 2022, people are just using the mismatches between various Big Tech walled gardens to do the same. Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose
- iam-TJ 4y agoHas your organisation tried sending a letter from your General Counsel to the General Counsel of LinkedIn? There's a strong case for arguing the content negatively affects the brand value, etc., of your organisation and in some circumstances could be considered libel.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoHm. Boeing keeps wanting to hire me. Might be bots.
- cyanydeez 4y agoHad these random Asian ladies posting adverts to some charcoal industrial machines to geology forums. I reported them multiple times and each time got an email from linked in saying they were legit content. LinkedIn is purposefully ignorant in the hopes of driving fake engagement.
- stcredzero 4y ago> LinkedIn is purposefully ignorant in the hopes of driving fake engagement. From Upton Sinclair Quotes: It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.
- chaostheory 4y ago“Show me the incentive, I'll show you the outcome.” - Charlie Munger
- mizzao 4y agoYep, the young Asian ladies with glamour shots that have 10 connections and went to some well-known school with work histories that make no sense, all seem to be fake. I report them all as fake when they add me but they never get erased. (I'm also Asian so not discriminating.)
- lokar 4y agoThat's not really how discrimination works.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imwillofficial 4y agoI deleted my LinkedIn long ago after they pushed to become some “thought leadership” social media Frankenstein
- MattDemers 4y agoI had this problem when managing a company's page. No real tools exist to prune these people, and it just ends up a mess. I was working for a sports team, and we'd have fans list themselves as employees ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- kregasaurusrex 4y agoFake accounts on platforms raise internal metrics of usage & activity, which practically creates an anti-incentive for the parent company to remove them. One can imagine fictional scenarios that wouldn't pass a basic litmus test yet make an otherwise meaningless number go up that for some reason pleases the investors solely because it's higher than the previous quarter's number. I'd move my profile over to ShlinkedIn if given the choice. "Wow, according to LinkedIn, over 8 billion people work at FacAmAppNeGoog! That company must be doing very well to be able to pay all those employees; let me update my important financial model based on this non-audited number. Nevermind that only 100,000 worked there a few months ago, this is fastest growing company in history! Here are 5 ways to replicate their success from the comfort of your broom closet:"
- the_jeremy 4y agoAs someone currently trying to switch jobs, I will say LinkedIn is head and shoulders above its competitors that I know about. I switched to "Open to work" and get 2 dozen recruiters a day reaching out, and around 5% are recruiting for positions that pay competitively for me (5 YOE, targeting high 200s, which is L4 Google comp in my area). By contrast, I've had less than 5 companies reach out from Hired and Triplebyte (and none that were offering competitive pay), even though I got top 10% scores on the platform's stupid quizzes. If there's a new platform I should be using instead, please let me know, because having to respond pleasantly to 19/20 recruiters who are wasting my time is a bit draining. Unfortunately, I didn't major in CS and have only worked at two companies, neither of which normally pay well, so my network is pretty limited.
- MezzoDelCammin 4y agoOne thing left me baffled for a second: how exactly does one scrape a site the size of LinkedIn to notice a stat like this?
- FeepingCreature 4y ago"Battle with bots prompts purge of Amazon" Ah good, they're finally cutting down on Chinese vendors with random company names and fifty unrelated products, soon I'll be able to trust a company's reputation again "employee accounts on LinkedIn" Aw.