11 ms·
The Rise of ‘Luxury Surveillance’
- john-doe 4y agohttps://archive.ph/OYgjc https://archive.ph/OYgjc
- adolph 4y agoI hope this doesn't get flagged, although I thought to flag it about a quarter of the way in. Essentially the thesis is that people opting into personal surveillance are changing norms, changes that will be misused by state and employer power against people who don't opt in. Hidden below all of this is the normalization of surveillance that consistently targets marginalized communities. The difference between a smartwatch and an ankle monitor is, in many ways, a matter of context: Who wears one for purported betterment, and who wears one because they are having state power enacted against them? Looking back to Detroit, surveillance cameras, facial recognition, and microphones are supposedly in place to help residents, although there is scant evidence that these technologies reduce crime. Meanwhile, the widespread adoption of surveillance technologies—even ones that offer supposed benefits—creates an environment where even more surveillance is deemed acceptable. After all, there are already cameras and microphones everywhere.
- pooper 4y agoI haven't read the article but I think the outrage is misplaced. There are people forced to wear a Islamic head dress. The solution is not to ban Islamic head dress. There are people forced into sex slavery and prostitution. The solution isn't to ban prostitution. There are people who are forced into an abortion. The solution is not to ban abortion. The solution to abuse cannot be curtailing of rights.
- FredPret 4y agoPooper, you should run for office
- tomcam 4y agoI too must hear more about the Pooper platform
- pooper 4y agoSorry to disappoint but I'll never win any election. Inconsistency annoys me so I'll try to make my thoughts consistent. One thing I learned from HN is housing cannot be both a universal human right and a reliable asset for people to retire out of so I must choose the former. This by itself means I cannot win any meaningful political office, or if I do, I cannot imagine not being swiftly nerfed so I won't be able to act on it. Now that I've alienated homeowners, next idea I have is elimination of all credits, deductions, and exclusions or anything like that when it comes to taxes. You can probably see how this is a very bad idea for national security. Next idea is eliminating income eligibility or similar ideas in government programs. Everyone from the richest people to the poorest should feel safe to take advantage of all our programs. At this point, I'm sure I've made enough enemies that I won't even get ballot access (:
- FredPret 4y agoI think to win, you have to find commonalities enough people share to get them to vote for you. You just have to find your tribe. We should all be more politically active - look at what happens when only the idiots do it.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoIt is shocking how much this extra level of discussion about values and policy is not addressed. Thanks for making it so succinctly.
- DennisP 4y agoWhat about my neighbor's Ring doorbell, pointed at my front door from across the street?
- Xylakant 4y agoRules in germany are that you can have video surveillance, but it must not cover public spaces. A ring doorbell monitoring your porch is fine, recoding the sidewalk not. Now, enforcement is another issue, but the rules make sense.
- unreal37 4y agoThat is illegal in some countries. For instance in Portugal, you can't film roads or other people's private property. So "car dashcams" are illegal. And any surveillance cameras you have on your property cannot be pointed at someone else's property. https://europe-cities.com/2022/09/12/the-use-of-%E2%80%B3dash-cams%E2%80%B3-in-portugal/ https://europe-cities.com/2022/09/12/the-use-of-%E2%80%B3das...
- sneak 4y agoI’m torn on this one; as a photographer and videographer I find the right to shoot or film anything I can see from a legal vantage point very near and dear to me. We should always be legally allowed to film public places. Europe’s legislative approach to this is wrong, I think, but I see the problem. Perhaps we need different societal norms.
- __d 4y agoI'm ok with it being legal to photograph, video, or record audio of public spaces without people. I'm pretty sure I'd prefer that photographing, filming, or audio recording me in an identifiable way was illegal without my explicit consent. I think public officials should be subject to recording while performing their duties. I think celebrities should not, unless they explicitly consent. Security cameras might need some sort of exemption: record, but don't look except under explicit circumstances (like, you've been robbed).
- 4y ago
- mechanical_bear 4y agoFirst of all, at least you are honest about commenting on something for which you have no basis to be commenting on, having not read the article. Second, the appropriate response may not be to ban all of those things outright, but comprehensive regulation is certainly within the best interests of society. Finally, the casual assertion of abortion as a right is noted and summarily rejected. I won’t engage further though on that point, in an effort to not drag us off topic.
- godelski 4y ago> as a right I just want to note that there are two types of "rights." There's positive and negative rights. Negative rights are the typical libertarian types of issues, namely that things cannot be taken away from you or rather that you do not have s specific duty. These are things like freedom of speech (no duty to regulate your speech), freedom of religion (no duty to have a specific religion), fair trial, life, the right to not be enslaved by another, etc. tldr: you have no duty to act (or not act) in a certain manner. Positive rights are typically left leaning and are entitlements. As an example, you have the right (you are entitled) to an attorney. Others include public education, national security, and a minimum wage. People are advocating for other things like the right to clean water, fair housing, higher education, health care, internet access, etc. tldr: you do have a duty to act (or not act) in a certain manner (often in the form of taxes). I bring this up because people often talk past one another because they just say "rights" and are using different definition. So I believe this causes a lot of fighting rather than productive conversation as people just embed the idea that "rights are rights." It is also a good example of where communication breaks down because what is obvious to one party is not obvious to another party and they are operating in completely different frameworks, refusing to recognize that the other party is operating in said framework. As for abortion (maybe I'm maybe sidetracking) it is often considered a negative right because one (the state) needs to take action to stop a specific action (abortion). Though it can also be framed as a positive right if either 1) the fetus is viewed as a human, and thus they are being deprived of their rights to life through the action of another or 2) one is forcing physicians to perform abortions.
- godelski 4y agoI agree and disagree. As I see it, the solution is to use privacy preserving techniques. Federated learning would be a nice start but isn't good enough. Homomorphic learning would be the acceptable solution here as we could then preserve privacy and get the benefits (corporations would still profit from the data too). I'm honestly surprised that there's no big push for this by companies like Meta, Google, or Apple. You want to say you actually care about privacy? Put your money where your mouth is. I do honestly expect the first ad style company that is fully homomorphic will upset the balance that we have now.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> I'm honestly surprised that there's no big push for this by companies like Meta, Google, or Apple. You want to say you actually care about privacy? Put your money where your mouth is. Apple HomeKit will stream, process, encrypt the data locally then upload the encrypted data to iCloud so I think we're seeing it? Lots of other companies (nest?) are offering on-device or on-lan processing of video feed. TBH this is probably so the company saves on bandwidth.
- josters 4y agoThis is definitely a point the author could have touched on more. How will environments without this purported widespread adoption of surveillance technologies react to an increase of these 'luxury surveillance' items? Will they also gradually accept more (government-imposed) surveillance into their lives? Maybe even demand it? Or is acceptance of surveillance culturally biased?
- adolph 4y agoI think the thesis is that positive consent of less-privacy leads to less-privacy for people who have less power of consent, possibly because the expectation of privacy is a social construct of the more powerful and influential. To respond to your thought-question about adoption of surv-tech in places where it isn't common: Taken outside a privacy context, in many small towns locking the doors to one's car or house is not a norm. I grew up that way. When I visited my big city cousins the emphasis on locking doors struck me as odd. If one lives in such fear then one has a larger problem than locking a door or not. Another privacy
- infogulch 4y ago> The difference between a smartwatch and an ankle monitor ... The real difference is who can access and control the generated data. An ankle monitor's purpose is explicitly to send your location history to the government. A smartwatch's purpose is ostensibly to help you record your activities so you can analyze and optimize your life, which on its own is not unreasonable, but in reality there is little separating the government from that data so it's practically the same as an ankle monitor. The solution here isn't more regulation, it's individual sovereignty over data you generate. Maybe that means software goes back to being software and the market for a 'data service provider' is squeezed out.
- sokoloff 4y agoI’m having a hard time drawing a conclusion of “practically the same” for a device you’re free to remove at any time without consequences versus one that gets you sent back to prison for a parole violation if you voluntarily remove it.
- nonameiguess 4y agoIt's not even close to practically the same. What is the actual rate at which the government subpoenas smartwatch location history and the probability it will happen to you? This is like saying the fact the government has the capability to imprison or shoot you at any time and you would not be able to stop them is exactly the same as actually being imprisoned or executed. But yes, clearly the best way forward is individual data sovereignty. The reason intelligent personal digital assistants that knew you intimately didn't seem dystopian when they were in Star Trek is because nobody then envisioned that the software and data would be running on corporate servers. We envisioned these things being more along the lines of trusted friends in their own right, with a clear data boundary at the physical limit of the sensing devices they used, not that they would be perpetually networked and owned by third parties like Amazon. They weren't supposed to share information with anyone but you.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> A smartwatch's purpose is ostensibly to help you record your activities so you can analyze and optimize your life It's an additional megacorp data collection tendril that they let you use a fraction of.
- ewzimm 4y agoIf there were an Amazon Prison option, I wonder how many people would choose it. Need to serve time? Skip the cell and stay home with a robust suite of real-time behavior analytics to ensure compliance. Conversations are processed locally and scanned for restricted subjects with advanced AI. A special Amazon Prison store offers a full suite of approved products with automatic payments, accessible with Alexa, and customized meal plans are optimized by biometrics. Need money? Work is available on Mechanical Turk at reduced rates for store credit only. Now available for undocumented immigrants awaiting processing!
- sokoloff 4y agoIf I had the choice to serve a sentence in real prison or Amazon Prison, I’m 100% on Team Jassy.
- yamtaddle 4y agoAlmost anything would be worth it to avoid prolonged contact with other prisoners and prison guards.
- Benobba 4y agoDisappointed that the author went straight to the cliche:this technology is bad because isn’t perfect and here and can be used in nefarious ways. His argument has been tackled extensively by academics, techies and journos. The author’s opening but could be classed as plagiarism in an academic setting for how familiar its beats are. There are many critiques of Amazon survelliance/tracking products and wish the authors would’ve engaged them. Hopefully the author gets feedback and grows from this
- philsnow 4y ago> this technology is bad because isn’t perfect and here and can be used in nefarious ways Did you click through to the wired article ([0]) about the tech disproportionately making false positive identifications of black people? The thesis is not, "surveillance can be misused by authorities / corporations", but rather "surveillance technology as it currently exists is killing and/or ruining the lives of, specifically, falsely-accused black people". > Hopefully the author gets feedback and grows from this [0] https://www.wired.com/story/wrongful-arrests-ai-derailed-3-mens-lives/ https://www.wired.com/story/wrongful-arrests-ai-derailed-3-m...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 4y agoslightly off topic, but: Growing up in Detroit under the specter of the police unit STRESS—an acronym for “Stop the Robberies, Enjoy Safe Streets” ...am I the only one heartily sick of propagandistic backronyms? The branding of public policy is a disturbing (and long-running) symptom of institutional capture. This example is particularly totalitarian, inflicting a reminder of STRESS on an entire community. Of course, the excuse is that 'it's just meant to create stress for the criminals.' We should be looking at outcomes, since intentions are unfalsifiable.
- Animats 4y agoThe Detroit PD STRESS unit was disbanded after, through miscommunication and trigger-happiness, they got into a shootout with Wayne County sheriff's deputies.[1] [1] https://www.robertankony.com/blog/the-rochester-street-massacre https://www.robertankony.com/blog/the-rochester-street-massa...
- anigbrowl 4y agoNormally some cop-on-cop mayhem is worth a grim chuckle, but that's quite a hair-raising account. Great find, thank you.
- sschueller 4y agoI am really starting to question if the movie robotcop isn't a documentary. /s
- nicbou 4y agoYep. Same with acts military operations. Patriot Act? Operation Iraqi Freedom? It suggests what you are if you oppose their contents.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago"What does it mean when one's life becomes completely legible to tech companies?" Does it mean something different than if one's life becomes completely legible to a government. If yes, then why.
- dnissley 4y agoMore fundamentally, does this tech actually make one's life completely legible to tech companies?
- krapp 4y agoYes, because governments can have you silenced, arrested, tortured or killed, whereas tech companies can at best only ban you from their platforms, or not target ads or content to you.
- LeonTheremin 4y ago
- code_duck 4y agoGovernments have many ways to get information about people from tech companies, though. Legal, illegal, quasi-legal, in aggregate or about individuals, direct from the company, or through interception. Sometimes the companies volunteer it, sometimes they are required to share it, sometimes a government just takes it. Not thinking of only the US here. I assume if Meta, for instance, has data about me, the US Government and maybe even local agencies have access to that data somehow.
- krapp 4y agoSure, when government and big tech cooperate, especially off the books, all bets are off. But if one is comparing what a tech company can do with your data versus a government obviously a tech company is less of a threat even in the specific case of it giving your data to a government. It's still the government that's going to send the goon squad after you.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pugworthy 4y agoReading that intro it really reminded me of the old Apple Knowledge Navigator video... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZ_ul1WK6bg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZ_ul1WK6bg
- wcarron 4y agoWe are rapidly approaching Fahrenheit 451. I was about to purchase a COROS fitness watch to track and aid my return to distance running. This article reminded me why I should not.
- deltree7 4y agoYour life would have not been affected one way or the other. This is just persecution complex suffered by elite, liberal class who literally have nothing to worry about anything but want to feel the same outrage as people who have real sufferings
- jspotanski 4y agoI have an old COROS and picked it precisely because it's not much more than damn good running watch with a battery that lasts for weeks. It's definitely not necessary for road running, but I needed it for unfamiliar trail running routes.
- wcarron 4y agoYeah, that's what I wanted it for. I trail run 80+% of the time, and use my clock + google maps to figure out my avg min/mile on road workouts. In general, though, these fitness devices are onerous privacy invading devices. If I get one, I'd never wear it anytime other than when actively running.
- buildyourown 4y agoAs nerds we have an advantage here. We can use prosumer/professional oriented tech that respects your privacy more. Don’t get a Ring. Use your own cameras and a Synology and, if you must, their e2e-encrypted backup solution. If there’s no privacy-respecting equivalents, then… do without.
- WWLink 4y agoUse your own cameras. Like the ones made by Dahua! I mean, that's bad so just buy the ones with the Amcrest sticker slapped on them that still runs the same firmware and has the same hardware. :D Source: I have a few Amcrest cameras and am sad at how much it'll cost to switch over to Unifi Protect.
- germinalphrase 4y agoI’d love to hear the community’s take on UniFi Protect as a (more privacy respecting?) option.
- smoldesu 4y agoPeople said the same thing about recycling. It's fun to go through the motions of faux privacy optimism, but a handful of good-doers don't offset the harm caused by a mob of complacent laymen.
- buildyourown 4y agoRecycling is a scam. It mostly just gets trashed on the other end. All the time and money spent on it would be better spent elsewhere. It’s just a massive feel good exercise.
- colechristensen 4y agoRecycling metal isn’t a scam, especially aluminum where a surprisingly high percentage of the amount of aluminum ever produced is still in use and it can be recycled to a pristine state with much less energy than producing from ore.
- Havoc 4y agoPeople desire the sensors and metrics and integration etc...not the Amazon overlord part. The article pitches it as something people willingly embrace which doesn't seem correct to me. Its more like reluctantly accept due to the benefits. I'm personally hoping that a lot of this becomes more accessible via the Matter protocol
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vineyardmike 4y ago> ..not the Amazon overlord part. If anything the really successful implementations of this generally are overlord free. You can quibble about how trustworthy apple should be, but people generally consider them more trustworthy. Especially due to their "on device only" stance. They're also the most successful smart-watch and biometric tracker. They're also making great progress on the voice assistant front too. > more accessible via the Matter protocol Unlikely IMO. Matter just isn't there yet, and doesn't mandate local only, and doesn't apply to camera/audio, which is big on the invasiveness front.
- Havoc 4y ago> Matter just isn't there yet, and doesn't mandate local only I was under the impression that it does make ability to do only mandatory?
- vineyardmike 4y agoIt doesn’t mandate only local networking. It does mandate at least local networking. You shouldn’t assume there is no cloud abilities for matter devices. Eg a lightbulb will have to talk over lan to a hub/controller for on/off/etc, but for non-matter features (eg sync to music) it can still talk to the cloud. Yes you should be able to ignore these features, but in many cases you’re still putting it on your network so it’s free to talk to whoever (by default). In fact, several companies (Philips hue, SmartThings) have already stated that their matter devices will still have non-matter features that are tied to proprietary cloud APIs.
- cr4nberry 4y agoThere's something weird about wearables and also recent advances in home surveillance. I see people posting here that the customers don't want surveillance, they want metrics. But, like... why? What's the appeal? People will spend hundreds of dollars on something like an Apple watch, and all it really does is make texts and calls slightly more convenient (I don't buy it) and give you little metrics to look at. People are paying hundreds of dollars to see their heart rate or mobility data? Does it really mean this much to them? Imo the wearables are more of a status thing than anything, but whenever I see someone wearing one it just pisses me off. Specifically the more expensive ones, but also the less expensive ones. I'm sure there are valid (niche) uses like if the wearer has some health condition, but for the general market? Not only this, but once you normalize them who's to say things like this[0] won't happen? Who's to say insurance companies don't start nudging them harder until Congress does something about it? Something that I'm not entirely opposed to are wearables that don't connect to the internet and let you see local sensor data. This makes sense from a metrics standpoint. But why exactly is the phoning home to Apple/Google even necessary? What value does it add (for the customer)? [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/with-fitness-trackers-in-the-workplace-bosses-can-monitor-your-every-step--and-possibly-more/2019/02/15/75ee0848-2a45-11e9-b011-d8500644dc98_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/with-fitness...
- Gigachad 4y agoOne thing the watches really do well is they make it much easier to notice a call or message in a loud environment. Before getting a smartwatch, you'd easily miss a call if your phone is in your pocket/bag and you are in a crowded/noisy space. You basically always notice if its a vibrating watch unless you have your hands on something vibrating. But yes, largely the Apple Watch doesn't enable new activities. It just makes a whole lot of common ones easier and faster with less pulling you phone out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jefftk 4y ago> It just makes a whole lot of common ones easier and faster with less pulling you phone out. Which also reduces distraction for many people, since often when you get your phone out you end up getting into various time consumption apps that aren't actually how you intend to be spending your time.
- smitty1e 4y agoIt's all tradeoffs. We have to externalize agency to aggregate human effort and do civilization. The Pareto optimal point doesn't have us optimizing too far in any one dimension. One great example of "good enough" is scanned paper ballots at elections. We want ease and accuracy, but the "luxury surveillance" risk of purely electronic voting is a slippery slope sliding into tyranny. Wisdom will draw a line and let technology support improving standards of living, while confining that tech in well-defined ways.
- Roark66 4y agoPeople can enjoy the benefits of AI assistance without having their privacy violated. Running ML models on edge devices will become the norm whenever possible. Then we will allow such devices like Alexa to talk to web endpoints to get data, but not to submit any info the other way. I definitely can see a whole new niche of software called "privacy protection firewalls" that would sit on the network between "Alexa" and your wifi router (perhaps running on the router) and do smart filtering what "Alexa" and other devices alike are allowed to do. We're not very far from being able to run pretty powerful AIs on edge devices. For one today's newest android phones all support vulkan and are equipped with GPUs that can run pretty sophisticated models. Also our better understanding of those models will lead to optimisations in their size. So, let's not throw the baby out with the bath water. Let's not paint AI assistants watching over out sleep as something bad. It is not. It is bad only when we have no control over what it does with the data it collects.
- bo1024 4y agoAgree with a lot of this, but what a sad situation if the best we can hope for in "control over what it does" is distrust my own device so much that I install firewalls to keep it in check. A much better version of this vision is FOSS.
- notriddle 4y agoFOSS is useful, and may be a part of the solution, but it is not the solution in and of itself the way Free Software advocates portray it as. Most people aren't programmers, people who are programmers don't read the source code of everything they run even if they're allowed to, and even people who try to read the source code for everything they run won't necessarily be able to catch every potential nefarious act. The ingredients list on the back of the box is not the only form of consumer protection in place for food. It shouldn't be the only consumer protection in place for software, either.
- mpalmer 4y agoThat's interesting. It's like the "edge" in edge computing/caching is sort of a fractal developing over time. An edge becoming more and more tightly looped and furled, while topologically, the network stays the same shape. It's market forces that are causing the edge to fractalize, pushing the computing and storage hardware closer to the customer, but only to a point. It may take a different market and different forces to push the edge to its end state. I think centralized compute and storage could very well end up ceding some ground to private, redundant, locally networked dedicated computing/storage substrates, which might take increasingly smaller and more exotic forms. What an interesting time that would be!
- andrewjl 4y agoI avoid things like Echo, Roomba, and closed ecosystem IOT-type devices for just this reason. And I'd never allow these in my home. To get around this problem, it would be cool to see something like a DIY merged with quality industrial design where the owner gets end-to-end custody of resulting data. Unfortunately this doesn't lend itself to being a favorable investment for corporate monopolies.