21 ms·
Sound
- hollowturtle 4y agoThis. This is the internet. I’m glad we can still enjoy quality driven content. To author if you’re here: any ways to support your work?
- primarydonkey 4y agoYou can support him on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski
- Nition 4y agoI think my favourite part of this is being able to draw your own waveform and then play it. Super cool. You can learn about something so much faster when it's right there and instantly tweakable.
- cyclotron3k 4y agoI drew a sine-wave, at double frequency (e.g. ◠◡◠◡), but it didn't really affect the frequency that I heard - it only changed the timbre. I wonder why...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JusticeJuice 4y agoSide note. I have always wondered, if we can hear the multiple frequencies caused by wave interference in soundwaves (e.g. square vs sine), why can't we see multiple frequencies in light waves. I assume it's just too fast?
- amluto 4y agoWe can, but we lump them into three bins, L, M, and S. The usual red, green, and blue are derived from those. L, M, and S are sensed by different cells. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LMS_color_space https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LMS_color_space Similarly, our ears are sensitive to a rather larger number of frequency bins, and and each sensory cell senses one of these bins. Neither of these sensory mechanisms is particularly sensitive to phase and, in fact, we can’t hear phase differences very well.
- SamBam 4y agoIt's more useful in an evolutionary sense to look at a banana and see that it's yellow, than to feel distinctly that your red and green cone cells are each being stimulated separately. The combination happens in our brain because it's transforming those separate signals into useful information.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vladstudio 4y agoIf you have not yet seen this site, please free a couple of hours and browse through archives, it's the best educational material I have ever seen! https://ciechanow.ski/archives/ https://ciechanow.ski/archives/
- maest 4y agoAny idea what framework (if any) this is written in?
- nwsm 4y agoView the source of the articles and you will find thousands of lines of readable HTML, handwritten JavaScript using canvas and WebGL, and handwritten audio manipulation using window.AudioContext. Similar stories for the author's other incredible articles.
- phailhaus 4y agoIt's hand-crafted WebGL with no frameworks, which is insane. If you View Source on the page, you'll see that the JS is readable because he doesn't minify at all.
- mortenjorck 4y agoOrdinarily, I follow the HN best practice of clicking through to a link first rather than upvoting based solely on the headline and domain. Seeing there's a new Bartosz Ciechanowski explainer might be my one exception to this rule.
- sebmellen 4y agoI did the same. The minute I saw it on the homepage, upvote.
- green-eclipse 4y agoI'm a simple man. I see ciechanow.ski and I upvote.
- symlinkk 4y agoReddit: Orange Edition
- giarc 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=ciechanow.ski https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=ciechanow.ski A link to all the HN submissions from ciechanow.ski
- Waterluvian 4y agoI love the web audio API. I've been making a game where the theme is "I don't do art" so my assets are CSS, emojis, and manually made sounds using frequency and sinewaves and such. The one lesson I learned the hard way is that if you run a full-volume sine wave long enough you can permanently destroy your laptop speakers.
- Minor49er 4y agoReminds me of DOS terminal games like Rogue and ZZT which used ASCII characters to draw everything. I hope you post it once it's ready
- Waterluvian 4y agoIndeed it's a dungeon crawler. Don't hold your breath. It'll be rudimentary. I'm making it for my own joy and learning, but will probably publish it by EOY.
- n4bz0r 4y ago> if you run a full-volume sine wave long enough you can permanently destroy your laptop speakers Minutes? Hours?
- Waterluvian 4y agoMinutes. I never repeated the experiment. Maybe my laptop was a dud or something.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nyanpasu64 4y agoReminds me of Marcan trying to make Asahi not do that on MacBooks, and so far failing (https://github.com/AsahiLinux/linux/issues/53 https://github.com/AsahiLinux/linux/issues/53). I didn't know that Windows laptops also had speakers that would burn out with high-volume playback.
- tambourine_man 4y agoAudio is not working for the three keys on iOS. Amazing content as always otherwise.
- 0x5345414e 4y agoWorks fine for me on iOS 16
- incanus77 4y agoMake sure your alerts aren’t muted. I’m on an iPad and I had to check the widget in Control Center to get sound, but then it worked fine.
- tambourine_man 4y agoRight you are, thanks :facepalm
- incanus77 4y agoI still don’t understand why this mutes functionality like this page’s, but not web video or audio players or the like in web pages.
- tambourine_man 4y agoYeah, iOS sound is an enigma. If you lower the sound, does it change the ringtone? How about the alarm? No one knows for sure, one of the true mysteries of the universe.
- HankB99 4y agoI'm not getting any audio on Linux/Chrome (Debian.) No audio from this page either https://d21u3ic0kp9e91.cloudfront.net/choir/04/index.html https://d21u3ic0kp9e91.cloudfront.net/choir/04/index.html, much to the dismay of our grandchildren. I checked system audio settings and see nothing muted.
- Scarlxd 4y agoThe resources were awesome! Everyone should check this out!
- igtztorrero 4y ago
- MichaelZuo 4y agoGreat information, well organized with intuitive flow.
- mfwit 4y agoIncredible stuff as always from Bartosz.
- nonrandomstring 4y ago+1 for the recommendation for "The Scientist and Engineer's Guide to Digital Signal Processing" by Steven W. Smith. I spoke to Steven many years ago about his putting all of the book PDFs online for free and since then have recommended at least 5 university libraries to buy it because the students could get free copies of a great book that can be referenced in the library. FWIW the The Scientist and Engineer's Guide doesn't actually cover a lot on sound. It starts in a particular DSP way with frequency domain definitions and convolution - and I actually think Steven's background is in medial imaging, though I could be mistaken.
- belkarx 4y agoThe book is amazing: http://www.dspguide.com/ http://www.dspguide.com/ (link for the lazy)
- sporkl 4y agopdfs are the chapters are available freely on that website, but if anyone wants to spare themselves the effort of combining them all into one for easier perusal, feel free to email me (in bio) and I can send the combined pdf. I'm currently around page 200, and it's been great as an introductory resource as someone with no other background in DSP.
- ahaferburg 4y agoHere [1] I found a link [2] to download all chapters in one .zip file. [1] https://www.analog.com/en/education/education-library/scientist_engineers_guide.html https://www.analog.com/en/education/education-library/scient... [2] https://www.analog.com/media/en/technical-documentation/dsp-book/dsp_book_dspguide.zip https://www.analog.com/media/en/technical-documentation/dsp-...
- WhitneyLand 4y agoWow. Such a profound insight could not get published for 15 years because others couldn’t grasp it. Including Lagrange! It’s an uncomfortable reminder of how essential reputation and credibility are in the machinery of science. ”The paper contained the controversial claim that any continuous periodic signal could be represented as the sum of properly chosen sinusoidal waves. Among the reviewers were two of history's most famous mathematicians, Joseph Louis Lagrange (1736-1813), and Pierre Simon de Laplace (1749-1827). While Laplace and the other reviewers voted to publish the paper, Lagrange adamantly protested. For nearly 50 years, Lagrange had insisted that such an approach could not be used to represent signals with corners, i.e., discontinuous slopes, such as in square waves. The Institut de France bowed to the prestige of Lagrange, and rejected Fourier's work. It was only after Lagrange died that the paper was finally published, some 15 years later.“ from chapter 8 http://www.dspguide.com/ch8/1.htm http://www.dspguide.com/ch8/1.htm
- qazpot 4y agoThis is awesome, reminds me of some of Bret Victor's work.
- aidenn0 4y agoWhen I started playing around with square/triangle waves, I couldn't help but hear https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyMKWJ5e1kg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyMKWJ5e1kg
- drcongo 4y agoI'm starting to think Bartosz Ciechanowski is from another planet. Everything he does is the very best explainer on that subject.
- brnaftr361 4y agoI'd really like to learn to do what he does. It's always so impressive, clear, concise and comprehensive. I feel like everything he does is a perfect pedagogical modality. I just wish everyone could get on board, especially university professors and publishers.
- aubanel 4y agoI love how every Ciechanowski post starts explaining from the very basics, but makes things so beautifully explained that my 10s attention span magically extends up to the way where I can learn a lot.
- imadr 4y agoThe three keys piano at the beginning is so responsive and nice that I was stuck playing with it for 5 minutes, that's how you hook someone to read an article
- jcims 4y agoI love it when I'm halfway through something and take a second to pause and wonder why someone put so much effort into it, and them I appreciate that they did. This is amazing. One thing that surprised me the first time I learned it is how 'dense' air is under normal circumstances. The 'mean free path' is the mean distance that a particle travels before changing velocity (typ due to collision). The mean free path of atmospheric air at standard pressure is ~65 nanometers, with ~2x10^19 (20 billion billion) molecules per cubic centimeter experiencing about 10^33 collisions per second. This is roughly the volume of an adult's ear canal.
- moritonal 4y agoWhilst I imagine he'd produce content regardless of income, he does have a slightly successful Patreon. To encourage this effort, consider supporting him in some form, if you don't.
- jcims 4y agoNice callout. Done.
- jarenmf 4y agoI was able to reach 10^-7 mbar with a good vacuum system and I though I would have few thousand molecules, turns out there is a billion (10^9) molecules per cubic centimeter at that vacuum level.
- jcims 4y agoAnd yet somehow, as far as we know, the energy of every molecular collision is faithfully preserved during a supernova, when effectively the entire volume of a star collapses into its core in less then a second. Reality is very strange.
- gattr 4y agoThat's not accurate. Only the inner core collapses (hence the "core-collapse supernova"; there are also other types), the rest rebounds, is heated up by core-produced neutrinos, and gets ejected. The Wikipedia article is a good start, also there are plenty of good papers on arxiv (e.g. on still-not-too-successful numerical modeling of the aforementioned "heating", without which the thing simply doesn't go bang).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bullen 4y agoImagine if the later demos had stereo!
- bnert 4y agoBartosz, you're a legend! Thank you for these amazing articles!!
- hiidrew 4y agoQuick babe wake up, new Ciechanowski intractable dropped.
- lagrange77 4y agoThis guy!
- mNovak 4y agoI'm really curious to know how he selects the topic of each article; the archive has quite a range! This is the type of blog I aspire to make, one day
- zebracanevra 4y agoHmm, on Windows 10 Chrome/Firefox the demos with the movable ears don't work very well when the position changes. Both browsers output horrible audio in those sections. edit: If I limit Firefox to 60fps (down from my display's 280hz) then it seems to work fine.
- fuy 4y agoWhat a neat switch from metric to imperial units! I wish more web pages had this.
- krinchan 4y agoI appreciate the mention and demonstration of Fourier Transforms. It makes a lot of previous sound codec discussions click a bit more now.
- sgraaf 4y agoBartosz' blog posts are in a league of their own. They way he is able to explain complex subjects by starting from first principles, gently adding more and more layers, with beautiful, custom-made figures and animations is truly, literally, awesome. I strongly recommend supporting the author via his Patreon if you enjoy his blog posts.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- armchairhacker 4y agoThe article on mechanical watches had so much depth and such good explanations I thought he was a mechanical watch engineer or enthusiast who happened to also have web design, 3d animation, and writing skills
- MezzoDelCammin 4y agoWho says he isn't? We all have our strange hobbies that we pick (and sometimes discard/change) throughout life
- zls 4y agoHe does :) hope he doesn't mind me sharing from his Patreon: > I myself don't even own any traditional watches, so the topic was very new to me. Thankfully, it was easy to understand the gist of how mechanical watches work just from watching some YouTube videos and I decided to give the topic a go. If you subscribe -- you should subscribe!! -- you can read his "making of" posts which are also fascinating. I don't think he's a domain expert in anything he's written about, he just does a ton of research and only produces a few articles per year.
- MezzoDelCammin 4y agoaah, thanks! IT's true that I haven't bothered to go hunting besides the blog posts...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lozzo 4y agoInteresting. Just earlier I went to Bartosz website to see if there was anything and there was not... and then he publishes sound and I see it here on hackernews. I am going to enjoy this. thanks
- woliveirajr 4y ago> at room temperature the average velocity of a particle is a staggering 460 m/s so to make the particles visible I’m showing their motion significantly slowed down Isn't 460 m/s the speed of the shock waves? I mean, it you make some "air particle" move, it'll hit a nearby particle, and so on, and this wave has a speed of 460 m/s. In a solid object (wood, for example) the particles are close together and the speed will be greater. If you remove air particles it'll decrease the pressure and the speed will be slower...
- jcims 4y agoYes, IIUC basically that's the point where the local particle speed is no longer sufficient to clear the leading edge of the wave.
- pqn 4y agoSpeed of sound isn't too directly affected by air pressure I think (holding all else constant): https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/146207 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/146207
- naillo 4y agoNothing really to say about this other than excellent work again and this really inspires me to make amazing web-based material in ways I haven't really experienced since the ~2012 era.
- mabbo 4y ago> As a side note, I’m using metric units here, but you can *switch* to the imperial system if you prefer. Clicking on the word 'switch' does exactly that. That's a delightful and clever touch that of course comes from Bartosz Ciechanowski.
- system2 4y agoPhenomenal post. Hard to find these type of posts unless I look at HN.
- Erwin 4y agoI was surprised by how much I was surprised by the very first fact -- that air molecules move around at extremely high speed of 450m/s, but just bump into each other cancelling this speed out, and this speed is based on pressure & temperature. And it's due to this speed, despite air's low density, the force air exerts is enormous -- equivalent to 10 tons per square meter. Somehow, the human sandwich does not explode nor implode due to equivalent pressure coming from the other side and inside.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoNote that diving to a depth of only 10m will double the external pressure on your body yet humans can easily survive this. Indeed the all time record is >300m which is something like 32x pressure. So it’s not merely that there is equivalent pressure from inside.
- TremendousJudge 4y ago>this speed is based on pressure & temperature I'd say that pressure & temperature are a consequence of the speed, not the other way around
- gtirloni 4y agoHow can one learn to create these visualizations?
- skilled 4y agoBy inspecting page source. If you mean technical, you have no choice but to actually study the topic and understand it so that you can create examples like the author did.
- exikyut 4y agoDepends what point on the spectrum you refer to by "how". Implementation, creativity, or the focus and discipline required to combine the two? :P I had a quick look; as always with the presentations on this website, all the un-minified JavaScript is right there for you to pour over: https://ciechanow.ski/js/sound.js https://ciechanow.ski/js/sound.js So that covers the implementation: a giant pile of WebGL to power the rotatable boxes and animate effectively using the GPU, alongside in this case a bunch of Web Audio code. Unfortunately that doesn't cover the focus/discipline part, which I would definitely appreciate some pointers on... one of these days I'll find some that fit within my ADHD address space xD
- phailhaus 4y agoI don't want to dissuade you, but you probably should not try to do it the same way he does: completely from scratch using pure JS + WebGL and without any frameworks. He's able to pull it off because he clearly has an incredible depth of knowledge of how it works, but mere mortals like you and me will likely get stuck in the bog of minutiae. I recommend starting off by playing around with Three.js, which will get you up and running really quickly while still staying pretty grounded in WebGL. [1] You can make blog posts very similar to Ciechanowski using ObservableHQ. [2] [1] https://threejs.org/docs/index.html#manual/en/introduction/Creating-a-scene https://threejs.org/docs/index.html#manual/en/introduction/C... [2] https://observablehq.com/@mbostock/hello-three-js https://observablehq.com/@mbostock/hello-three-js
- gtirloni 4y agoThank you, very useful pointers.
- meta-level 4y agoBartosz, you have to choose another name, I just upvoted by reflex, when I saw it's you again
- mathfailure 4y agoThis man is a legend now. The awesomest quality of articles.
- apitman 4y agoI was 20 minutes into this before I realized the interactive bits were automatically turning themselves off and on based on which one was visible in the viewport. That seems obvious, but the fact that it worked so intuitively and without bugs on my system says a great deal. This is what master UX design looks like.
- lelandfe 4y agoThat it all worked perfectly on my phone is testament to a ton of testing.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoIt’s a few lines of standard JavaScript. Nice touch used by many sites, not difficult.
- behnamoh 4y ago> not difficult. And yet, not so common especially on popular websites with $$$ development costs.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoSomeone has to care enough to notice, often the case.
- pigcat 4y agoHow is it done? Could you point to the section of code in the source code?
- harrisi 4y agoThe relevant few lines are these: if ("IntersectionObserver" in window) { const observer = new IntersectionObserver(entries => { entries.forEach(entry => { entry.target.drawer.set_visible(entry.isIntersecting); }) }, { rootMargin: "300px" }) all_containers.forEach(container => observer.observe(container)); } else { all_containers.forEach(container => container.drawer.set_visible(true)); } You can read more about it here: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Intersection_Observer_API https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Intersectio... As a side note, all of the code is very pleasant to read. It's interesting that it's seemingly (almost) all hand-written, given that there are commented-out rules in the CSS, for example. I'm not sure what's going on with the HTML though, probably some custom generator.
- PostOnce 4y agoThis man needs a genius grant, and this is about the 6th time I've thought this. Any one of these pages would be a feat, an achievement to be proud of, but as a collection, it forms one of the greatest educational resources of its type that I have known. These things can give you more intuition about a subject in 45 minutes than a textbook might be able to in 3 months, because it's interesting and not dry. I wish I had more time to rant about this right now, but I haven't, so: Kudos. Another amazing job.
- ianklug 4y agoA fantastically written and extremely technically performant page as always from Bartosz. Several of the piano key demos ask you to observe what happens when you play multiple keys at once. Is there a way to do this on a desktop PC that I am missing? I had to switch to my phone to try those sections.
- croddin 4y agoFor me, on desktop, there is a paragraph that says keys can be played with the W E and R keys, and each key has a W E or R on it, but this isn't present on mobile. Maybe the site thinks you desktop browser is mobile for some reason?
- dmd 4y agoUse the (computer) keyboard.
- ianklug 4y agofacepalm Thanks. Next time I'll try actually reading all the text on the page. Amazing that on a page with such exemplary UX my tired brain still managed to gloss over the massive letters on each key.
- iammjm 4y agoSuperb
- bkallus 4y agoI haven't taken beyond high school physics, so this question is probably obvious, but I haven't been able to find the answer (probably don't know the right terms to search). When I increased the slider that allows you to change the flow of time for the gas in the cube, it really looked like visualizations I've seen of increasing the temperature of a gas. Is there a deeper relationship here? Could an observer tell the difference between a cube $A$ of gas in which the flow rate of time were doubled and a cube $B$ of gas with normal time passage, but a correspondingly increased temperature? If so, what would give it away?
- keonix 4y agoIIRC temperature is proportional to velocity squared so increase in simulation speed will result in squared increase in temperature. But even if we account for that we are not dealing with ideal gas in real world, there bound to be collisions that break molecules apart or even start nuclear fusion at certain speeds
- TremendousJudge 4y agoThe thing is, temperature is just motion at very small scales. On a solid, particles are attached to one another via the atomic forces, and a "temperature increase" means that the particles are jiggling more. With high enough jiggling, the particles start to break apart and the substance undergoes a phase transition. Now, when it's a gas, the particles are jiggling so much they aren't attached to one another, they are flying around at very high speeds as shown in the visualization. So, your intuition is correct: increasing the speed of the particles then is in fact the same as "increasing the temperature" of the gas.
- xani__ 4y agoYup, and that is how ultrasonic heat pumps work! JWST has one https://webb.nasa.gov/content/about/innovations/cryocooler.html https://webb.nasa.gov/content/about/innovations/cryocooler.h... basically, make a standing wave of gas in a pipe and the peak of pressure will be hotter than the valley. Put the thing you want to cool in the valley, radiator in the peak, and voila, a heat pump.
- extantproject 4y agohttps://archive.ph/woqkb https://archive.ph/woqkb
- patel011393 4y agoAs an educational psychologist, there's a lot to love here and I catalog posts like these as examples of expert exposition. One suggest to Bartosz: breaking one long essay into many smaller pages or hiding content until the viewer has indicated understanding of previous steps will be even more useful (see: https://tigyog.app/d/H7XOvXvC_x/r/goedel-s-first-incompleteness-theorem https://tigyog.app/d/H7XOvXvC_x/r/goedel-s-first-incompleten...). Explorable models are a great way to increase engagement and understanding. Beyond that, I would supplement this with highly frequent comprehension questions to check for learning. I bet you'd find a way to make it fun and approachable.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoPlease no! Part of the beauty of this exposition is the respect for the reader knowing their own mind and controlling the consumption themselves. You don't understand it but want to? Don't scroll. You don't want the next bit? Don't scroll. Will this work for teachers in a classroom? Likely not as the kids who don't care, will skip everything they can. And this page will let them, because if you don't care to understand then this page is not for you.
- prasoon503 4y agoCan u share your catalog, i really liked both the op's post and the tigyog.app one. And i am looking for more!
- duderific 4y agoIncredible work as always, thanks Bartosz. Interesting side note - using the "basic" frequency/amplitude slider section, you can tell if you have any hearing loss in a certain ear at a certain frequency, as well as high frequencies in general. As an ex-musician, I have some hearing loss caused by playing and being around extremely loud music. Between 6KHz and 7KHz, I felt the sound shift towards my right hear, indicating some hearing loss at that frequency in my left ear. Between 10KHz and 11.5KHz, I felt a strong shift toward my left ear, indicating hearing loss at those frequencies in my right ear. Above about 12.3KHz, I lost the sound entirely. One very gentle bit of feedback (haha) to the author would be to provide anchors to each section so they could be more easily linked.
- xani__ 4y ago> Interesting side note - using the "basic" frequency/amplitude slider section, you can tell if you have any hearing loss in a certain ear at a certain frequency, as well as high frequencies in general. If you're on headphones maybe but might "only" be shit speakers
- singingfish 4y agoI'm not convinced it's possible to be an ex-musician
- duderific 4y agoHa, good point. I'd like to get back to it someday but kids, work and lack of place to set up drums make it extremely challenging.
- singingfish 4y agoIf you've got a spare few hundred bucks get yourself a korg wave drum :D
- marcodiego 4y agoWARNING: sounds you can't hear can still damages your ear. DO NOT INCREASE THE VOLUME ON INFRA OR ULTRA SOUNDS BECAUSE YOU CAN'T HEAR THEM
- owenfi 4y agoWould love some additional info on this if you are aware of any. My intuition says (and could very well be very wrong) sound at one frequency would only damage that or very nearby frequencies hearing range? If wrong I'm curious what the range of damage is (I'm interested in exploring ultrasound data protocols, so curious what frequency I have to go to to avoid damaging anyone's - and potentially animals as well - hearing). I also assume if you are starting at a reasonable (laptop, small desktop speakers) at a low-to-medium level (say 50-60dB), increasing a bit won't cause immediate damage even if you can't hear the sound?
- marcodiego 4y ago"With protracted exposure, inaudible ultrasound can also contribute to hearing loss." https://www.health.belgium.be/en/ultrasound-and-high-frequency-sound https://www.health.belgium.be/en/ultrasound-and-high-frequen...
- marginalia_nu 4y agoOperative word being protracted. It's also important to realize that especially with infrasound, you're always exposed to it along with most regular sounds. The modulation applied to sound to turn it into speech (i.e. amplitude and frequency shifts on order ~0.5-2 Hz) shows up in the frequency spectrum at those sorts of frequencies. If you say "hey hey hey hey hey", that's a 1 Hz-or-whatever sound wave you're producing with a higher frequency carrier wave.
- 48cfu 4y ago[dead]
- pruthvishetty 4y agoThis is a PhD thesis in itself!
- rvba 4y agoI wish there was a post like this about fire. On atomic level. Like atoms oscilating? How many photons are emitted when say 5 carbon atoms connect with 5 oxyxen particles? I tried searching and no avail.
- CKMo 4y agoIncredible! Approachable and fun to learn. All education should aim for this bar
- vhold 4y agoAll of this with 207 kB over the network. The two slowest requests were to google analytics.
- dharma1 4y agoWas just teaching this stuff to my 12 yo son - this is way more thorough! What a gem of an interactive blog post.
- iamgopal 4y ago…and the fact that site works perfectly under load from being top of hn shows his skill with selecting and maintaining right kind of server setup.
- mark-r 4y agoI'd guess that most of the work is being done client side, leaving the server to just push out the text and code. I haven't tried to verify that assumtion though.
- lekevicius 4y agoIn addition to all the recommendations about supporting his Patreon, I also recommend following him on Twitter and clicking the bell icon: he only tweets when new articles are published, a very worthwhile notification.
- robofanatic 4y agoMind blown, what a guy he is !!! and all his JavaScript is open source and not uglified.
- NaturalPhallacy 4y ago>If it wasn’t for the collisions with other molecules, those fragrant particles could travel the distance to your nose in a fraction of a second. That's kinda crazy to think about. Someone across a gymnasium room farts, and you smell it milliseconds later. Ugh.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIf his site goes down, is the internet backing this up? Amazing work.
- d11z 4y agoAs a millenial with no degree+vague/little prospects of being able to one day purchase my own home, I've already saved his entire website and put it in my "very important things" folder. As someone who really likes math, programming, and visual design as well as having spent hours upon hours practicing often short, yet incredibly complex lead guitar riffs by himself for many hours as a kid, I never quite grasped music theory back then and I realize now that essentially the only reason that is the case is because it was never presented to me in such a fun, digestible, and incredibly beautiful way; a way that I've been very much seeking to discover myself my whole life. There are people who pay others to build schools, and then there are those that build things far more capable of transmitting the most optimally distilled form of knowledge and intellectual achievement that mankind has to offer to us today. I don't really have much words right now, other than I want to kiss this man's feet and then maybe hope to stop crying eventually.
- Jack_rando_fang 4y agoTHIS is why I read HN everyday
- prng2021 4y agoI'm just as stunned as many others here after seeing this blog. What an incredibly talented engineer, writer, and artist all in one! He should be famous. Can't believe I hadn't heard of him.
- nathan_f77 4y agoAwesome! I really enjoyed the mechanical watches post as well: https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch I might send this to some of my friends who are high school science teachers.
- _qua 4y agoThis reminds me of spending hours digging through Microsoft Encarta as a kid. It was full of cool animations and demos like this (though these are much better).
- ByThyGrace 4y agoMakes you wonder if Wikipedia could be set for an interactive animation overhaul.
- NickC25 4y agoThis is absolutely phenomenal. This is how a lot of education should be. What blew my mind is how the author gradually increases the density of subject matter, going from the basics to the most advanced concepts in such a way that things just flow naturally. To say nothing of the interactive-ness of the page itself, which helps explain things exceptionally. Superb post.
- srcreigh 4y agoA cool physical sound apparatus is a speaker port. This is the hole(s) you may find in some speakers. https://blog.fluance.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Ported-Vs-Sealed-Speakers.jpg https://blog.fluance.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Ported-V... Is the hole to help get the sound out..? No. As this article shows you, the speaker already moves back and forth, this will create changes in pressure yada yada. The speaker port is not just a hole, it’s a tube. The air in that tube has a mass and due to changes of air pressure inside the box, the air mass in the tube will move back and forth just like a plate in the article. The result is that you basically have 2 “moving plates” which create sound: the speaker cone itself powered by a motor, and the air mass in a tube powered by the air pressure in the speaker enclosure. Cool video about speaker design https://youtu.be/23q3zoKiuGs https://youtu.be/23q3zoKiuGs
- xani__ 4y agoTo elaborate, the tube is tuned right below where in closed box the speaker would lose efficiency, so the frequency shift is 180 degrees, and as it takes air from behind it (which is shifted by 180 so it gets to 360 total). But that causes the frequency curve to drop steeper below that. There is also variant of that where instead of pipe hole there is an extra passive membrane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radiator_(speaker) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radiator_(speaker)
- jzer0cool 4y agoWhat did you use to create the particles in the cube? And then to the browser? Very nice.
- shmerl 4y agoKudos for metric system toggle!
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 4y agoOMG yes!!!!!! there was a post on sound years ago that was excellent, a bit similar to this, but i could never find it again. i genuinely want to know more about how sound works. looking forward to reading this
- ivanche 4y agoIt even has a different explanation text how to use keyboard (2nd paragraph), depending on whether you open a site from a desktop or mobile! Impressive!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- navi0 4y agoI hope this gets extended into a class about radio frequency communication. Everything here applies to all the wireless gadgets ubiquitous in our modern society, yet many haven’t the foggiest idea how antennas, carrier waves, and modulation combine to beam the Internet everywhere.
- d11z 4y agoIf anyone who is capable is reading this: What we (the unmanicured masses) crave most is a clear blueprint for reconstructing the new Internet once our consumerism-based, debt-aggregation system inevitably comes to a screeching halt, complete with a spectacularly bloody and sparkling implosion. I lack the proper academic terminology to even understand the field enough to discern what exactly it is that I don’t know that I don’t know, and personally my time “wasting time learning things on my own for seemingly no reason other than wanting to know” has recently been cut short, and I am left aching for someone to emerge from this chaos and hopefully be receptive to these messages/instructions/explanations before they are pulled from beneath us.
- forrestthewoods 4y agoDoes anyone know what tools are used to make the visualizations? They're silky smooth and work just as well on mobile as desktop. The elements are just a <canvas> element so I'm not sure how they're populated. Edit: Oh, I think the answer is 6493 lines of artisanally hand-crafted javascript + WebGl. Beautiful. https://ciechanow.ski/js/sound.js https://ciechanow.ski/js/sound.js
- hamasho 4y agoLovely article. For interactive reading about sound and music, I also recommend Ableton's "learning synth" site. It leverages web audio capabilities and provides exciting learning resources about how to create synth music. https://learningsynths.ableton.com/ https://learningsynths.ableton.com/
- codeisawesome 4y agoBartosz if you’re reading this, please make one about electronic circuits, starting from atoms to CPUs if possible! :)
- user_7832 4y agoNot really identical, but I'd recommend the course Nand to Tetris (I believe on YouTube/also some online platforms) and this introduction to assembly - https://github.com/hackclub/some-assembly-required https://github.com/hackclub/some-assembly-required
- hoseja 4y agoI was waiting for a step where pressure waves would be shown in the particle simulation. Probably too hard to make...
- vollcheck 4y agoit would be lovely to have some personal note from Bartosz on how is he working on these articles - every single one looks like a masterpiece and at this point I'm wondering if he does not have issues with procrastination or lack of motivation
- lloydatkinson 4y agoDoes he use a framework like react + three.js, plain three.js, or raw canvas, I wonder?
- helb 4y agoLooks like vanilla js/canvas/webgl without any framework: https://ciechanow.ski/js/sound.js https://ciechanow.ski/js/sound.js
- tsp 4y agoI encountered a strange bug on iOS: after visiting the Sound website, which uses the Web Audio API to play sounds, web-views in other apps (e.g. Lieferando, a food-delivery app) would play the same sound. So it seems like all web views share the audio context. Really weird.
- distcs 4y agoAnyone here knows what tools are being used to make the wonderful animations in the OP article?
- tmnvix 4y agoApparently it's done by hand in WebGL. See the top comment/thread in the previous mechanical watch submission. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31261533 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31261533
- tomrod 4y agoThis is how I imagined textbooks would be when "multimedia" became the dominant discussion in the tech world. This was great.
- euph0ria 4y agoI wish the learning experience in school was similar to this. Excellent writing and the playing-around-with-the-subject really easied the learning for the concepts.
- sethammons 4y agoNo sound plays for me on iphone 11 with firefox, chrome, nor safari. I can play audio from other sources
- sillysaurusx 4y agoTurn off silent.
- sethammons 4y agoAh, works! Thanks!
- deepzn 4y agoI took a Physics of Sound class for my minor in Physics during undergrad. One of my favorite classes I've taken.
- darzu 4y agoFor those looking for more interactive content like this, albeit with more of a game dev focus, I highly recommend https://www.redblobgames.com https://www.redblobgames.com One of my favorite articles is this one on hex grids: https://www.redblobgames.com/grids/hexagons/ https://www.redblobgames.com/grids/hexagons/ it blew my mind the first time I noticed that all the interactions and code change when you toggle between "flat topped" and "pointy topped".
- 01092989663 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]