7 ms·
What the $24.6B Kroger-Albertsons Merger Could Mean for Groceries
- sixstringtheory 4y agoMy town has two krogers and two safeways, so i’m interested to see how this might play out. Thankfully there’s also a costco and a local co-op nearby. Support local co-ops if at all possible! And costco, as i’m a shareholder ;)
- yunruse 4y agoPaywall-free link https://archive.ph/Leyqa https://archive.ph/Leyqa
- InCityDreams 4y agoThank you - and to everyone that provides these links.
- subpixel 4y agoThese huge grocery store empires have largely pursued a strategy of moving upscale in the last 5 years or so. While this has been very successful, it may prove a challenge in the next 5 years or so, as less shoppers care about finding the perfect cave-aged cheese and more care about affording staples.
- bombcar 4y agoI’ve noticed it across all the grocery stores - even Walmart(!!) - I think the upscale stuff is an attempt to maintain some profit when faced with squeezing margins. Though I have to wonder how much of the upscale stuff never sells and gets thrown away, dumpsters behind grocery stores are depressing, never look in them.
- conductr 4y agoRetail as a whole has split into economy and luxury. Brands serving the middle struggle. Since Walmart is tough to compete with on economy pushing most traditional stores towards luxury. They’ve also seen the growth at Whole Foods and such in an otherwise low growth, low margin business. I think Walmart is just constantly experimenting and their overall strategy is to be the economical choice.
- colinmhayes 4y agoAldi moved into my city and is now the "budget" grocer after the old one tried to become more upscale.
- newaccount2021 4y agoIf anything, Albertson's took their acquisitions lower-end.
- josefresco 4y agoYou can't talk about grocery stores in the US without mentioning the roles of "dollar stores", "pharmacies" and the food desserts that created such a demand for these alternative grocers. Maybe traditional grocers moving upmarket is a reaction to the low end needs being serviced by these market gap-fillers. Edit: Fixed one spelling mistake but not the other that I was called out for ;-)
- yuuu 4y agodeserts
- conductr 4y agoDessert is twice as good. An elementary teacher said that once and it’s still the only way I remember the difference 40 years later. Pass it along.
- malfist 4y agoI was taught "Which do you want more of?" You want more desserts, so desserts has more s's than desert.
- josefresco 4y agoDoh! I'm one of those guys who spell checks every meaningless post to death and this was the ONE TIME I didn't lol - oh well I love this place ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- bayouborne 4y agoI think Aldi's strategy of cheap, quality staples will continue to get traction. Lidl's trying to have it both ways and doesn't seem to be as successful.
- rawgabbit 4y agoI am Traders Joe fanatic. I luuuuv Traders Joe. I know TJ is owned by one of the Aldi brothers though I can never remember which one. It doesn’t matter I like both TJ and Aldi (America). My other favorite grocer is Costco and Hmart (Korean).
- themitigating 4y agoDollar stores however are growing rapidly. Where I grew up used to be upscale now there's dollar stores everywhere.
- bfrog 4y agoNothing good is going to come from this, what amounts to grocery store monopoly.
- leereeves 4y agoMonopoly? I thought so too, until I found out that Walmart is the largest grocer. This is a merger of #2 and #3 (at least in the West - Safeway (Albertsons) isn't even #3 nationwide).
- takk309 4y agoSafeway is under the Albertsons umbrella already. https://www.safeway.com/about-us.html https://www.safeway.com/about-us.html
- leereeves 4y agoTrue. I said Safeway because that's the brand they use where I live.
- coldcode 4y agoHere in FL there is a Publix on every corner.
- kasey_junk 4y agoIf this merger goes through it will result in a grocery store chain that is more than 3 times the size of Publix (in store count).
- throwup 4y agoAn oligopoly is not much better.
- lapcat 4y ago> Walmart is the largest grocer. I rarely shop at Walmart, for a number of reasons, but on a couple occasions I've picked up some milk at Walmart, because I needed some and wasn't near my other grocery stores. Never again though. The last time was ridiculous: Walmart marked up every brand of milk to absurd prices much higher than other grocery stores, except for their "store brand" milk, which wasn't cheap either. I didn't even bother getting a full gallon, just the smallest I could find and got the hell out. I couldn't imagine shopping there every week.
- cpsns 4y agoAmericans will get a little closer to what we deal with in Canada and reduced/nonexistent choices.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y ago
- affinepplan 4y agoI don't think it's super productive discourse to call an entire country, especially one as large, diverse, and developed as Canada, "mediocre" in its entirety.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoAs someone who lived there for a long time, Canada is the most mediocre and overrated developed country of the lot.
- lordnacho 4y agoIMHO mergers should be illegal. Just never allowed, maybe exceptional circumstances like charities that wouldn't otherwise be able to survive. The reason is I think it tends to reduce the usefulness of the free market. We want a bunch of firms competing to create value for consumers. A bunch of little experiments that say "hey I bet people want purple toothpaste", with a bunch of little failure domains that keep the damage small when it turns out blue is the best color. Mergers incentivize people to make businesses for reasons other than creating and sharing value with consumers. For instance, a lot of VC backed firms get bought by a larger giant without ever turning a profit. This basically blurs the market's view of whether the widget they're selling is of any use. Creating larger firms also encourage monopolistic practices about which plenty has been said. But also it means failed products take longer to be taken down as they share infrastructure with non-failed products. And when a giant dies, a lot of fallout happens.
- voisin 4y agoMonopolies can and do occur outside of mergers. And sometimes mergers allow smaller firms to join together to better compete with more dominant firms. I think the answer is to better enforce anti trade laws to ensure competition.
- lordnacho 4y ago> Monopolies can and do occur outside of mergers. They can, but often you find a firm that has grown organically ends up swallowing up a load of smaller firms. For sure trade laws need to actually be followed, but there's a discretion there that is vulnerable to lobbying.
- michaelt 4y ago> Monopolies can and do occur outside of mergers. You're right - and we might want additional rules to address that. But IMHO it's one thing if facebook gains market dominance because users choose their product - that might just be a sign they've got an excellent product. On the other hand, if facebook feels the need to buy Instagram and Whatsapp because users aren't choosing facebook's product? That's a completely different matter.
- kotlin2 4y agoWhat are the economies of scale in groceries? Seems like at a certain point there will be more overhead due to the management required for managing the entire chain of stores, and also lower quality of product due to only being able to source products from massive producers.
- mdasen 4y agoRecently, Market Basket (a family-owned New England chain) was rated #1 during inflationary times (https://www.supermarketnews.com/retail-financial/market-basket-named-top-inflationary-times-grocer https://www.supermarketnews.com/retail-financial/market-bask...). Market Basket made news a few years back because their non-union employees basically organized a strike to save management - yes, the workers were standing up for the CEO that got ousted. The chain was co-owned by two sides of a family and one side wanted to oust the CEO and co-owner - but the workers loved how he treated them and basically forced the other side of the family to sell to the CEO. Not only employees, but a lot of suppliers wanted to stand up for the ousted CEO. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_Basket_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_Basket_protests One of the reasons that they wanted to oust the CEO is that they wanted a dividend while the CEO instead decided to cut prices by 4% for the entire year. It was kinda amazing going grocery shopping and looking at the receipt and literally seeing 4% come off the price of every item. No, they didn't hike prices just to give the feeling of 4% off. I bring this up because while Market Basket has economies of scale, it isn't an international company like Ahold Delhaize of the Netherlands which owns Stop & Shop, Giant, Hannaford, Food Lion, and over 2,000 stores in the US (and tons around the world); it isn't Walmart or Amazon; it isn't Albertsons with 2,250 stores or Kroger with 2,700. It has 90 stores. Yet they seem to be incredibly profitable while offering better pricing to consumers. A friend of mine who worked in the supermarket business in Nebraska knew about Market Basket because they were such an example of how well-run a supermarket could be. No loyalty cards, no self-checkout, employees have profit-sharing, healthcare, and sick time, and instead of hiring outside execs they've tended to promote from within - people who have worked for the company for decades, sometimes starting part-time as teenagers. At the same time, this seemingly old-fashioned company is thriving. In some ways, it makes me question a lot of what companies do to optimize things. Yes, there are all sorts of things companies can do like surge pricing, but that can leave a bad taste - and it leaves people wanting to do it back to you if they ever have the power. Sure, you can try and exploit suppliers, but that can create a hostile, unstable relationship. How much money are you burning trying to see exactly how little you can pay? Do you hire expensive execs, an army of data scientists and economists, etc. to see how you can use your power to get a little bit extra? I do think the Kroger-Albertsons merger will be good for the companies/shareholders. Before, if you were a supplier, you'd have these two 2,000+ store chains to sell to. Now there's one less buyer and economists research this a lot (and there's been a lot of good work on monopsony/oligopsony recently). If you're a worker, there's one less supermarket employer to work for. However, those aren't economies of scale - those are just market power gains. I do think there are still economies of scale, but they do become smaller. When you already have 2,000+ stores sharing an inventory system, its cost can be pretty small and moving to 4,000+ stores might not really change things much. Plus, there's a lot of cost and pain integrating systems to save that money and companies spend years doing it. Still, it certainly doesn't seem like a necessary merger to remain competitive. Small chains like Market Basket (90 locations), Wegmans (109 locations), Central Market (10 locations), and Heinen’s (23 locations) get top marks from Consumer reports (https://www.consumerreports.org/products/grocery-stores-supermarkets-34741/grocery-stores-supermarkets-33753/view2/ https://www.consumerreports.org/products/grocery-stores-supe...) way ahead of the mega chains (many of which are near the bottom including lots of Albertson's brands, lots of Ahold Delhaize's brands, Walmart, etc).
- digerata 4y agoAs a frequent Kroger customer, my immediate gut reaction was no way should this happen. But then looking further, how much geographic overlap is there between the two companies? Not much from my quick search. Certainly not in the area I live. And a stated goal of this merger is to fight the evil empire, Walmart. So I'm warming up to it...
- spiffytech 4y agoBoth brands are the parent companies for quite a few grocery chains. I wonder if this gives them more overlap than appears on the surface.
- RSHEPP 4y agoIn DFW metroplex there is major overlap. They will have HEB competition here soon though.
- splitstud 4y ago
- sf_rob 4y agoThere's major overlap of sub-brands in some regions: * Mountain states: King Sooper vs Albertson's * PNW: QFC/Fred Meyer vs Safeway * California: Ralph's vs Safeway And that's only the regions I'm familiar with.
- iandanforth 4y agoSo, if I wanted to build a map that showed where competition would be eliminated by this merger, does anyone have any good datasources (other than trying to scrape google maps, or the Kroger/Albertsons/Subbrand websites)?
- humanlion87 4y agoI think Kroger also own QFC and King Sooper's. Hence you have to include their locations as well. Apologies if you were already implicitly referring to them when you mentioned Kroger.
- taylodl 4y agoI don't understand all the talk here about grocery store monopolies - there's still Walmart, Target, and Aldi, with Lidl now starting to move in on that action, not to mention the regional chains such as Giant Eagle, Meijer, Marc's, Publix and Piggly Wiggly amongst several others. At least where I live I'm seeing more and more competition in the grocer space, not less. I don't see how this merger is going to change that.
- jvolkman 4y agoAs I posted elsewhere, Seattle has about 30 standard chain grocery stores within city limits and all are owned by Albertsons or Kroger. The rest are smaller operations, boutiques like like Trader Joe's, or higher-priced like Whole Foods. There is no Walmart in Seattle, and many of the 4-5 Targets are smaller stores with limited selection.
- galdosdi 4y agoKeep in mind that both Kroger and Albertsons each already own several other large grocery store brands, so some of that abundance of choice is an illusion.
- taylodl 4y agoGood point! Didn't think of that.
- xienze 4y agoDepends where you live I suppose. I live in an area where there must be at least a dozen different grocery stores in a twenty miles radius. But I'm sure there's plenty of places in the country where that's not the case.
- socialismisok 4y agoMany, many places don't have that competition. Plenty of communities are at risk of losing their two local grocery stores and seeing them become just one. Grocers are not evenly distributed, so while you are correct that at a national level there exists competition, it doesn't exist everywhere. And while a monoculture in an area might represent an opportunity for a grocery store to disrupt things, the people living in that monoculture gain no benefit from that opportunity - they have to live with the monoculture until someone maybe fixes the problem.
- socialismisok 4y agoWhat it could mean is nothing good. Less competition, more worker exploitation, fewer brand options, less incentive to provide good quality service. Just like ISPs merging to become the one and only ISP in some markets, this could absolutely create a trend of only one grocery chain in certain markets.
- malfist 4y agoKroger is unionized