8 ms·
Arecibo telescope won’t be rebuilt
- Zanni 4y agoIf you haven't read Ted Chiang's heartbreaking story about Arecibo (and parrots!), this seems like a good opportunity: https://electricliterature.com/the-great-silence-by-ted-chiang/ https://electricliterature.com/the-great-silence-by-ted-chia...
- j0hnyl 4y agoI got to visit this place a couple of years before it collapsed. It was one of the coolest most cyberpunk things I've ever seen in real life.
- pseudolus 4y agoAlso featured as the centerpiece of a James Bond Movie (Goldeneye): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vovVkvQhYEE&ab_channel=ostinatoscope https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vovVkvQhYEE&ab_channel=ostin...
- thinkcontext 4y agoAnd Contact.
- ninjin 4y agoAs well as The X-Files [1], although apparently filmed in Vancouver – as with most of early X-Files… [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Green_Men_(The_X-Files) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Green_Men_(The_X-Files)
- shiftpgdn 4y agoWhat would the cost to rebuild be? Could it be crowd funded?
- WJW 4y agoSome quick googling reveals that it cost 9.3 million in 1963, so inflation adjusted that would be about 100 million today. Not completely out of the realm of crowdfunding, but it would probably quicker to send a tweet to Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos and offer them to name it the "Jeff Bezos Arecibo Telescope" or somesuch if they fund the reconstruction by themselves.
- pavlov 4y agoShow Elon the 1974 Arecibo message and explain that it’s like an interstellar tweet, and for a mere $100 million he’ll be able to send those himself. Honestly sounds like a bargain compared to his recent tweet spending habits.
- closewith 4y ago> Show Elon the 1974 Arecibo message and explain that it’s like an interstellar tweet, and for a mere $100 million he’ll be able to send those himself. Or just show him Goldeneye. I feel he'd be more likely to do it for the meme.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bpodgursky 4y agoThe cost disease for infrastructure has expanded dramatically faster than inflation and I really doubt you could do this for less than $2B today. Unless you get a magic "no environmental review" exception (you won't).
- lupire 4y agoPR doesn't have the powerful NIMBY culture that California does. Folks there are less wealthy and more practical about the value of adding local economic investment.
- 4y ago
- cproctor 4y agoI don't see how $1-3M per year, for five years, is going to lead to "a world-class educational institution."
- tokai 4y ago$1m a year is not gonna get much. It might not be the case, but it smells a bit like a token amount to keep something going - so they don't have to deal with the drama of closing the site.
- evrydayhustling 4y agoMakes zero sense, and NSF's best answer is that they are soliciting ideas about how. Arecibo is somewhat remote -- it's in a karst terrain that was chosen because it was so bumpy that it formed a convenient bowl for the dish. Its easy for the roads connecting it to San Juan to get shut down or degraded by storms. Without the telescope, it's really hard to imagine which students would aspire to go there. But it's a great place for.... A telescope.
- boredumb 4y agoArecibo isn't remote. From San Juan I can get there in 40 minutes and it's directly off the 22 which is definitely not an easy freeway to be shut down short of a hurricane. It's also directly in between mayaguez and san juan both of which have a ton of students. I guess I don't see how using 1-3 million dollars to operate an educational center is nonsensical. It's a central area between major universities, fairly flat terrain, northwestern coast so it's generally not going to see the worst of the storms and also has some existing infrastructure. With that said it's a tragedy that they aren't going to rebuild the telescope in it's original glory.
- lupire 4y agoWorld class means it attracts people from around the world. It's 40 minutes from San Juan, which is on a relatively small island on the ocean. And hurricanes have a habit of hitting there. PR deserves great local institutions, but it is less accessible than most places that have much larger nearby population.
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoIt's a testimony that its ROI is too bad for this human epoch and technology.
- hiccuphippo 4y agoAnd yet we preserve places like Stonehenge, when modern calendars are considered superior.
- lupire 4y agoTestimony that technology has advanced to more efficient and less location sensitive telescope designs?
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoIt's decoupled of when that happens but tightly coupled with the rejection of that attempt.
- Miraste 4y agoI'm not sure what your point is here, but even if you look only at single-dish radio telescopes, humanity already has a better one in FAST.
- Robotbeat 4y agoTechnology hasn’t progressed past the need for large, filled apertures.
- newaccount2021 4y agoThe cost to rebuild from scratch would be trivial for the combined endowments of America's top universities, who are surely the primary users Harvard alone has tens of billions in its endowment. ...and yet, comments here are talking about crowdfunding??
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jmbwell 4y agoCrowdfunding comes up whenever those with resources are indifferent to those with need.
- ianai 4y agoPeople probably just don’t default think of universities. But yes universities have a history of funding stuff exactly like this. And it absolutely fits into their operant model. Maybe the way for us normies to push for this is to donate to our alma maters and write letters/emails to alumni associations and administrations to propose joint funding of this across multiple schools.
- toyg 4y ago> the way for us normies to push for this is to donate to our alma maters Unless you put explicit conditions on your donation, chances are you're just going to fund the next round of salary increases for university administrators.
- hedora 4y agoEven with explicit conditions, they often just shuffle other money around under the table. "This $100 must be spent on science" => "route $100 of the general fund away from science"
- ianai 4y agoNot really the point. Point is this could be funded by universities and that’s probably the only way for average any bodies to submit a (good/bad) idea to them directly. The snark is overly done on the internet. To the point of dismissal.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoThis is probably a plot by some villain to make everyone think that the facility is abandoned. Once everyone withdraws from the area, it'll be used as a lair, from which the villain will direct the execution of his sinister plans.
- tjpnz 4y agoI believe that was the plot of Goldeneye.
- dudeinjapan 4y agoThe most sinister thing about this plot is using a radio telescope to control a satellite orbiting in LEO, wasting the poor engineers' time. (Boris was lucky to be frozen in liquid nitrogen, consider it a mercy kill.)
- throw827474737 4y agoNo, you are wrong - GP wouldn't have said so if that would have been the case already..
- dr_orpheus 4y agoCan we get another Bond film to fund rebuilding it?
- rob74 4y agoThat's a better plan than what the US government announced for it. An "educational centre for science, technology, engineering and maths (STEM)"? In the mountains of Puerto Rico, miles away from larger populated areas? I mean, while there was a telescope there, that actually made sense, but now that it's gone?
- snowwrestler 4y agoWhy rebuild it? While cutting-edge when it was originally built, my understanding is that computationally combined arrays of smaller dishes are today considered superior to what Arecibo was, for radio astronomy. I’d be interested to hear from folks with expertise whether that is right or wrong.
- rahen 4y agoIt was supposed to be rebuilt as a phased array of about a thousand 10m dishes mounted on a steerable plate about 300m wide. That would have been some colossal engineering. Have a look: https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=518&v=2qiu86-ZZdU https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=518&v=2qiu86-ZZdU
- sigmoid10 4y agoThe thing is, even by rebuilding Arecibo the US (or more specifically, the NSF) would no longer own the largest radio telescope. China's 500m telescope [1] is already operational and while there are some minor differences when it comes to frequency range and field of view, there isn't much to justify the expenditure for another telescope in the US beyond mere political indulgences. From a strictly science based point of view, a new Arecibo is very hard to sell considering the implied costs. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-hundred-meter_Aperture_Spherical_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-hundred-meter_Aperture_Sp...
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoHow much does it cost? I see it was built for $9.3M in 1960. Now they're estimating the cleanup cost alone to be $50M. Inflation adjusted - it should cost ~$95M to re-build. I'm not sure how if you'd need to include the total $50M cleanup on top of that. Either way - if it can be re-built for $95M - that seems like a better deal than spending $50M to clean it up.
- jws 4y agoThere are 38,000 1mx2m perforated aluminum panels out there. I would pay a nice premium for them as a wall covering. Maybe not $50m/38000, but a good chunk of that. Having a section of the iconic telescope would be worth it. Now, are there thousands of people like me to make it work at scale?
- Aroga 4y ago
- softwaredoug 4y agoFWIW you can still buy Arecibo merchandise here https://ao-galaxy-eshop.myshopify.com/ https://ao-galaxy-eshop.myshopify.com/
- z3c0 4y agoSurprisingly cool merch. Love the Arecibo Message tee, thanks for sharing
- pantojax45 4y agoIs it in a particularly climate susceptible place? Seems like if it was just hit by a hurricane, there will be more in the future. Perhaps not a good place in an eta of climate change?
- rtkwe 4y agoIt's up in the mountains in a bowl though so it's shielded in many ways from the worst effects of storms. It weathered them fine for about 50 years.
- dudeinjapan 4y ago"For England, James?" "No, for me."
- superkuh 4y agoOn the plus side, the Green Bank Telescope has been fitted with a test radar transmitter and there are solid plans to put in a 500-kilowatt radar. This isn't quite a replacement for Arecibo, but it'll help fill the gap.
- mihaic 4y agoWhat I think this misses is that one of the main purposes of something like Arecibo is to be inspirational. The coolness factor is something that helps science as a whole, from making kids interested in scientific activities and even boosting morale for scientists in the field. Morale is one of those things that can't be quantified, but that can't be ignored.
- aardvarkr 4y agoThe main purpose was militaristic and science benefited as a result. We no longer need it to spy on the Russians so I highly doubt anyone is willing to pony up the billions just to have something cool and inspirational when it won’t even be cutting edge anymore
- rippercushions 4y agoEh. I visited Arecibo almost 20 years ago, and even back then it was more historical monument pickled in time (I still recall some exhibits celebrating the Space Shuttle as the greatest thing since sliced bread) than anything scientifically inspirational, much less "cool". It very much felt neglected and the subsequent collapse, while sad, was entirely par for course.
- rtkwe 4y agoThe Shuttle is IMO still really cool and there are missions it could do like repairing Hubble or the initial stages of the ISS construction that would be really hard to do with the tiny little capsules we've reverted to. It's size and separate airlock alone give it abilities you can't get in any capsule flying today.
- dale_glass 4y agoBut at this point, why not build a new one instead? It's old tech at any rate. Also, why not try an iterative approach? What would be the cost to build an extra copy? In fact, doesn't the Hubble share parts with spy satellites?
- Nokinside 4y agoTime passed it. FAST (five-hundred-meter aperture telescope) already exists and combining smaller ones is also an option.
- Robotbeat 4y agoFAST being in China is problematic. Emblematic of decay of American power that we aren’t rebuilding it. And a betrayal of Puerto Rico, for which this is a symbol of pride.
- seydor 4y agoLooking at the megatelescopes that they are building in Chile, i think its memory will soon be forgotten https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremely_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremely_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_Magellan_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_Magellan_Telescope
- rtanks 4y agoVery sad for the Puerto Rican people. My husband has great memories there.
- jeffheard 4y agoFeels like a prime opportunity for a National Park. Restore it to the point where it won’t degrade further, add a museum, plantetarium, library, and preserve the land around the telescope. It’d be really neat! I’d take my kids to be sure.
- bee_rider 4y agoI think (at least last time I looked into it, it may have changed since then) the problem was that some of the scientific equipment is heavy and suspended by cables which are degrading over time. I don't think it is like a battleship for example, which degrades into a battleship shaped hunk of steel which can be easily restored into a museum ship -- cables under tension fail catastrophically.
- nomel 4y ago> cables under tension fail catastrophically. I'm not sure there's much left, with the last failure: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PZsblS1BUc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PZsblS1BUc
- z3c0 4y agoApparently Arecibo was the source for the cover art for Joy Division's Unknown Pleasures. Neat. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/sa-visual/pop-culture-pulsar-origin-story-of-joy-division-s-unknown-pleasures-album-cover-video/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/sa-visual/pop-culture-p...
- soneil 4y agoEntirely unrelated, but I love that the actual album cover is a missing image on that article. They're talking about how iconic it is, and the image itself is the "broken image" icon - which is iconic in itself.
- mosburger 4y agoI've wanted to get the "Arecibo messsage" as a tattoo for a while now... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arecibo_message https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arecibo_message
- jl6 4y agoArecibo Memorial Skate Park.
- mikepavone 4y agoKind of a weird site for an educational facility. The Arecibo telescope was kind of in the middle of nowhere. That's a feature when picking a site for a radio-telescope, but not for education, especially when you don't have a cool-looking giant telescope to give people an excuse to make the trip
- RobLach 4y agoGood. Build something better.
- zackmorris 4y agoThe US federal government should start a GoFundMe to pay the IOUs from all the times it raided discretionary spending on science, the arts and social security
- ck2 4y agoHow about use all funds to build an interferometer to James Webb? Plausible? Would be most advanced imaging ever made?