12 ms·
Poll: Is there a negative stigma toward articles written in Medium?
Creating a poll on behalf of theanonymousone for https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33223124
Will I/my articles get negativity within dev and tech communities because they are written in Medium?
Please comment if you can think of better alternatives to Medium
- lemursage 4y agoI see a lot of folks touch on the UX of the Medium website. For me it's the content -- the paywall and overall layout would be digestible if not for the awful lot of generic Medium posts that regurgitate for the nth time the same basic tutorial of X, or repeat ad nauseam the particular set of ideas found on some independent blog sites. I don't deny there's some quality content out there, but I feel it's not well curated and every other search phrase, I'm getting bombarded with tons of bland tutorial-blogposts (in ML domain especially) which really makes me disdain the website itself.
- kuba-orlik 4y agoOne way would be to publish on Medium but link to https://scribe.rip/ https://scribe.rip/
- axegon_ 4y agoYes, ever since Medium turned into tumblr...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 4y agoFor me, the stigma is more about the paywall thing that usually fires up and hides all but the first paragraph of the article. Otherwise, I don't care about the domain in the url.
- humbleferret 4y agoGhost [1] and Substack[2] seem to be popular alternatives within dev and tech communities. [1] https://ghost.org/publishers/ https://ghost.org/publishers/ [2] https://substack.com/ https://substack.com/
- candiddevmike 4y agoSubstack is moving towards the same paywall setup as medium AFAIK
- cratermoon 4y agoWho didn't see that coming, though? The web has become broadly influenced and geared towards a certain way of doing things that happens because: 1. it costs money to create and maintain a substantial web property. Medium, Substack, Patreon, gumroad, ghost, buttondown, etc all run on top of services that cost money. Maybe AWS, maybe Google App Engine, plus Cloudflare, Heroku, Netlify, Digital Ocean, etc. Oh and Stripe, PayPal or some payment processor, if the site has a subscription model, too. 2. the web of the 2020s really has only one way to make enough money to pay for these services: advertising. There's only one way to get enough money through advertising to be profitable, and that's to have some portion of attention-getting, clickbaity, top 10 list content. That content generates enough 'virality' to show up on Twitter, FB, here, or wherever. A no-paywalled, no-ads site (like Hacker News) is a cost center maintained as a sort of vanity project for a company that makes money elsewhere. What people are complaining about around Medium is really a complaint about how content on the web is, and must be, monetized, if it is to be a money-making business, as opposed to my blog, say, which is just money out of my pocket. It's going to take a concerted effort to break away from the current economic model of the web. Just turning up our noses at Medium or Substack and pivoting to the NEW new thing won't change anything, as the new new thing inevitably gets dragged into the web economy or goes broke.
- joshspankit 4y agoI’m kind of surprised we don’t have a “decentralized Medium” at this point. Yes, Mastadon and others exist and have traction, but they don’t fit the specific demographic that Medium does (an easy place to write content that gets ranked and monetized). With less costs would come more sustainable integrity, as well as a bigger share for writers.
- ninethirty 4y ago
- mfashby 4y agoMaybe something like https://bearblog.dev/ https://bearblog.dev/ ? But I don't write on medium so I don't know what's missing in comparison.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cableshaft 4y agoI like bearblog, and it seems like quite a few posts on there are getting well received on HN lately. I've been meaning to start up a blog again, and I've been debating doing bearblog as an easy way to get started again since my Hugo blog has sat in a half-finished state forever, and it seems like they can get decent visibility.
- joshspankit 4y agoMedium used to be a viable and easy way to get started, which is one of the reasons self-hosting is an important selection criteria (even if you never use it)
- denton-scratch 4y agoDoesn't look like you can self-host bear.
- HermanMartinus 4y agoSure, but this is a comparison to Medium, not too self-hosted blogs.
- forgotpwd16 4y agoYou can't self-host it as an individual blog but it should be possible to self-host the platform and then open a blog on it.
- thrtythreeforty 4y agoYes, but only because they are aggressively making their reading experience terrible. I'd argue that a WordPress site with the default template is less offensive at this point. The typography and layout on Medium is fine, it's the popups, nags, paywall, and the like. For a while there was a lovely extension called "Make Medium Readable Again" but they aggressively broke that too. I'm happy to let Medium fall off the tech community radar.
- tonystubblebine 4y agoMedium CEO here. I saw this thread too late for many people to see my response. I love that the result is basically unanimous. I agree with nearly everything here. I am a programmer, I've written a programming book, I used to work at a tech publisher (O'Reilly). From O'Reilly, I know a lot about how to build a system around programmers that puts out important and accurate information. Medium started in the ballpark of that and then went in the wrong direction. I think we can do a lot to change that. For me, change is less about changing our reputation and instead just getting the utility right. We have syntax highlighting coming out in a week or so and I'll do a bigger post then about what is changing for technical readers and authors.
- Jamie9912 4y agoMedium works completely fine with Javascript disabled ;)
- ectopod 4y agoSomebody at Medium must have been reading! Two days later and it's completely broken without js.
- generationP 4y agoDoesn't that disable all images too?
- cratermoon 4y agoWhen's the last time a Medium article had useful and relevant images? I usually just see some generic stock art from Unsplash.
- andyjohnson0 4y ago> Please comment if you can think of better alternatives to Medium In my opinion a personal blog or website on a personal domain is the most credible way to publish your ideas.
- melenaboija 4y agoAgree. To me a personal blog shows more commitment from the author for two reasons: you have to spend some time to ser it up and search engines tend to position them high when you search for the author name. Even Medium posts being signed I don’t know why it gives me some anonymity feeling and makes it harder to navigate through other content from that same author.
- jotm 4y agoCommitting to SERPs is challenging. Unless your domain itself has your full name, a Medium article with your name in there will rank higher than your personal blog... Although I remember there being some option to verify a website for name searches on Google. That plus having a Twatter/Fecebook/HN/etc account to confirm the official site should be enough to reasonably avoid impersonators.
- prepend 4y agoIs this an issue? I’ve never run into people impersonating real people with websites. Are there situations where someone pretends to be John Doe and to rank higher? To what end?
- tkgally 4y agoI agree. I get a positive impression from articles on self-produced websites with personal domains. They show that the author has put some thought, effort, and money into the presentation and preservation of their writing. Creating such sites might be out of reach for a lot of nontechnical folks, but people in the dev and tech communities should be able to handle it.
- 4y ago
- wodenokoto 4y ago> Will I/my articles get negativity within dev and tech communities because they are written in Medium? Not broadly, but definitely within the HN community, and probably a few others. But with that being said, I also don't think it will affect your ranking on HN negatively, at least not by much. Medium articles regularly hits the frontpage (and as of writing this, there's a medium blogpost just below this poll on HN)
- candiddevmike 4y agoMedium was a textbook "free to gain traction, then paywall" bait and switch.
- naillo 4y agoIt's not like substack is much better. I can't recall a time in the last 5 years I've stumbled upon a substack or medium post that didn't feel like a waste of time. The only worthwhile sources seems to be small niche tech bloggers still keeping their head down in code the majority of the day (not selling stuff, just sharing their findings).
- nicoburns 4y agoAside from any stigma, I believe medium will PayPal your articles, so lots of people won’t be able to read them even if they wanted to.
- dadoge 4y agoUgh - coulda saw this coming 5 yrs ago when Medium was “free” and well liked Lesson learned again and again: all blogging platforms have a limited shelf life, and there really needs to be a better way to own your own content beyond self-hosting.
- wahnfrieden 4y agowhy not just make self hosting far easier
- LinuxBender 4y agoSome VPS providers are starting to do just that [1] with the theoretical goal of making it just a couple clicks to deploy web applications and provide automated backups. I have not personally used these services because I like to tinker and add things myself but I know that isn't for everyone. [1] - https://www.linode.com/marketplace/category/website/ https://www.linode.com/marketplace/category/website/
- wahnfrieden 4y agoThanks. I'm particularly interested in providers that I can easily resell / affiliate refer through my own software products, to let casual users self-host their UGC. Bunny.net CDN (I have no association, yet anyway) is one great example of that - prepaid (so no runaway bill risk with metered services), generous referral program ($20 on first spend), and low barrier to entry ($1 minimum spend, one time, which is plenty for many UGC use cases). But their services are still limited, no compute besides DNS scripting. Linode has a nice referral program at $20 per paid signup (90 day+) and fixed prepaid cost (though recurring, unlike Bunny). Cost of entry could be lower but not bad at $5/mo. However the onboarding experience is likely still bad for all these for casual b2c users.
- joshspankit 4y agoWe had cPanel years ago
- adrianh 4y agoYes, for two reasons: * The software: Medium somehow managed to make majority-plain-text articles slow to consume in modern web browsers, negating decades' worth of web browser optimizations. * The culture: Medium is overrun with self-promoting "thought leader" types.
- tacker2000 4y agoAgreed. The comment section on Medium is also buggy as hell. Its always jumping around up and down. How this simple functionality is not “solved” yet is beyond me.
- Ensorceled 4y agoI like polls on HN because sometimes the answer is nuanced, so on HN I can say "Yes, articles on Medium have a negative stigma" but then upvote @tyingq's and @thrtythreeforty comments that capture that nuance.
- arinlen 4y agoTo me, Medium is a platform for those who desperately want to monetize text even (and mainly) if they have nothing to write about.
- hateful 4y agoVery much this for me. It was so bad a couple of years back that I seriously considered writing a browser extension to hide and/or highlight medium posts so I would stop accidentally clicking on them. The site has been better more recently, but the stigma is still there, at least for me.
- ur-whale 4y agoAlternative: <HTML> <HEAD> </HEAD> <BODY> Things I want to tell the rest of the world go here </BODY> </HTML> Never really understood what the supposed added-value of medium above the above actually is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- haha69 4y agoGithub pages is pretty good https://pages.github.com/ https://pages.github.com/
- adeleine 4y agoYour own blog, as many have said, is probably the best. When it comes to getting people to buy your articles: Well, I've never met a person who pays for their articles. Ever. Maybe you should sign up with a writing team that has a big website, I don't know, The Verge or something, and write there and get paid for it? If it's for good SEO, well, as of now Google is flooded with low-quality, copied click-bait articles full of trackers, ads and spam.
- anovikov 4y agoI think problem about Medium is that too much of its content is written by desperate people who are actually trying to live off cents Medium is paying them. It creates a negative expectation of quality.
- Vosporos 4y agoCan't have a stigma against the article if you can't read it.
- ahurmazda 4y agoDon’t know about stigma. I’m sure Medium is a business like many others. They are selling things. And I don’t particularly want to “buy” their products. Consequently, I don’t go to that shop.
- togaen 4y agoMake your own web site. It’s hard to take “developer” articles seriously if they’re published on a platform intended for non-developers.
- humanrebar 4y agoDisagree. I don't expect embedded engineers or language designers to take a large technology detour just to write.
- ahelwer 4y agoCloning the jekyll example repo on github then writing some markdown is not a large technology detour. Although I personally prefer hugo on gitlab.
- nottorp 4y agoSo those hypothetical embedded engineers and language designers should evaluate how many options? You just enumerated two. I doubt they're the only ones.
- ahelwer 4y agoThey're all pretty much the same. You could choose any one at all and be much better off than using medium. It's easy to switch afterward anyway.
- sithlord 4y agoThat's like saying you can't take a doctors advice seriously unless you are in the room at the doctor office. Elitism at its best. I mean how dare someone focus on writing and not on maintaining.
- sharikous 4y agoYes, unfortunately. I speak only for myself though. I found some very good articles there and even then I couldn't help getting turned off when I read them because I associate them with the mountains of subpar material that get published there and the horrible reading experience. A curated personal lightweight website attracts me more: see https://lemire.me/blog/ https://lemire.me/blog/ (Wordpress) https://lilianweng.github.io https://lilianweng.github.io (powered by https://gohugo.io https://gohugo.io)
- revskill 4y agoMedium or any kind of paywall sites need to be stopped.
- Aardwolf 4y agoI have nothing against the articles itself, but medium is way too heavy and regularly doesn't work in some browser / plugin combinations which is inexcusable for static articles of text and images
- Roark66 4y agoThe best alternative IMO to medium.com from the reader's point of view is a personal blog. I much prefer them. However, if you want your articles to be found by people looking for them via Google. Probably best is putting them on Github or other non-scammy site with good page rank. I noticed it is next to impossible to get personal blog articles in own domain onto Google search results unless they are specifically crafted for Google bot and not for a human reader (it seems to like a thousand words of introduction followed by a thousand words of historic context, then a lengthy personal anecdote and then at the very end - possibly on next page actual answer the reader is looking for). This includes really niche subjects where almost no content exists. Google still favours showing you forums where people ask similar questions (unanswered). And lots of unrelated stuff rather than an actual blog post that has an exact answer+tutorial in under 300 words.
- SXX 4y agoI personally dealt with indexing issues of numerous e-commerce projects I worked on and solution is almosrt always straightforward: more link mass. My humble personal blog of 5 pages and one single content-worthy article on it was always well indexed regardless of fact that I did nothing special for that. I guess the best recipe to get your blog indexed is: * Make sure you have robots.txt with correct host and sitemap.xml * Link it everywhere: on your Linkedin, Github, Reddit and every profile. * Make re-posts on social networks, reddit or other related resources. * It must be fast and never down so reliable hosting with CloudFlare. * Google loves when you have Google Analytics. Surprise surprise. * Do add it to Google Webmaster so your search overloard can connect your domain to Google account. So yeah people who hate CloudFlare and Google Analytics with passion are more likely to have issues to getting on google search result page.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>>So yeah people who hate CloudFlare and Google Analytics with passion are more likely to have issues to getting on google search result page. This sounds like something the FTC and /or anti-trust should be looking into.
- generationP 4y agoYes, because of the paywall for obvious reasons.
- spamizbad 4y agoI will admit to a personal bias against them. I wish medium writers would edit their posts more carefully and would entertain the idea that writing is a craft. Arguments, even ones that I agree with, tend to be poorly shaped. Paragraphs are filled with too much fluff. Arguments are poorly structured. Theses buried underneath digressions and rambling. I just skim them.
- binarymax 4y agoMeta: HN polls would be better if you couldn’t see the vote totals until you voted.
- rickrollin 4y agoYes, I think they sometimes influence the answers people tend to make.
- mjburgess 4y agoIn this case, I mouthed "Yes" even before I clicked the link.
- tacker2000 4y agoThis. Also, why can i vote for multiple options? That shouldnt be possible.
- raingros 4y agoYes, Medium is neither fish nor fowl. It's neither a site for blogs nor a Magazine. To be honest I don't know what it really is. WordPress for personal blogs and Substack for (paid) newsletter articles seem to be much better.
- HermanMartinus 4y agoI run https://bearblog.dev https://bearblog.dev which I would consider a pretty good alternative to Medium. Super simple, privacy centric, without all the paywalls.
- freediver 4y agoThank you for your great work!
- watashiato 4y agohttps://git.sr.ht/~edwardloveall/scribe https://git.sr.ht/~edwardloveall/scribe made the occasional consumption of medium content a decent experience for me. Pick an instance (or selfhost) and set your browser up to automatically redirect to it. https://github.com/einaregilsson/Redirector https://github.com/einaregilsson/Redirector and https://libredirect.codeberg.page/source_code https://libredirect.codeberg.page/source_code are good options.
- celsoazevedo 4y agoMedium used to be fine, but with time their website became worse (popups, images not loading, way too much javascript, etc) and now I avoid Medium links. If I'm on a computer, I usually open a cached/archived version of the page. Substack... it was okay, but it seems that now there's a full page popup that comes up while we're reading the post. I'll probably start to avoid their links too. As for the alternatives, if all you need is a place to write about stuff, why not a blog? WordPress (self hosted or not) + your domain + simple theme.
- branon 4y agoI don't think so, the site is a bit heavy but I enjoy all the Medium articles that make their way onto HN.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoNegative stigma? Generally, yes. The "You've used your 3 free reads..." thing is annoying, especially when one or two wasn't worth it. But lets bqck up a second...it would help to know your objectives, as well as your target. For example, might video be a better medium? No pun intended. Possible stigma aside, Medium is a tool. It does have a "community", but so does LinkedIn and YouTube. Maybe it's some combination? You goals, target and budget* all matter. * e.g., Do you have time to build a Twitter following, and use that community to drive traffic to anything you publish? If not, then maybe - at least for starts - start where there is a community you can "borrow" traffic from.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoTo me the stigma is because of the terrible quality of the content. If I see an article on Medium I assume it's from someone who doesn't know what they're talking about. It used to be that only passionate people would write content, but now there is this pervasive idea that you must produce content to demonstrate your expertise. Producing good quality content is really hard and time consuming and people who are only motivated by sending some expertise signal to recruiters and potential employers produce troves of garbage, often on Medium. A Medium article is the writing equivalent of an empty GitHub profile with a few unmodified forks in it.
- s__s 4y agoThe quality is alarmingly bad. I get occasional notifications from the Medium app suggesting programming articles on their platform. They usually go ignored but recently I’ve checked a few out. What I saw was really bad advice, plain falsehoods, and grade-school level coding. The only positive thing I saw is that at least the comments were full of people calling out how bad the article was.
- 0x6c6f6c 4y agoThis is definitely one thing that worries me. My forks are merged upstream and now it just looks like an unmodified fork. Perhaps GH needs to improve their signaling here with this kind of mentality being prevalent.
- yinyang_in 4y agoTrue, some mechanicm to close olds forks. Now thinking should write some script for it and clean GitHub profile. It’s seriously bad as I see now
- asimpletune 4y agoBut if the modifications were yours then that much is clear, and at the very top of the commit history. Right?
- alisonatwork 4y agoJust delete the fork. Forks that don't have any commits on top of upstream are pointless. People who are interested can already tell if you are an active contributor by looking at the other public feeds on your profile even if there aren't any forks.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoIf you have something interesting to say why would you want the first thing someone sees when they reach your article be a cookie banners, sign up boxes covering half the screen. Try viewing your articles in a private browser to see just how bad the experience is for most of your readers.
- svnpenn 4y agoIf I see a Medium article on HN, I immediately hide it. As others said, its a garbage site that is ONLY interested in making money for itself, at the cost of everything else, including user experience. If you want me to read your article, DO NOT put it on Medium.
- hungern 4y agoBefore I read it, I assume any article on any site is some biased crap that's trying to sell me something or has other underhanded motives. That way I can be on my guard, but also be pleasantly surprised if it turns out to be genuinely decent and useful. There's nothing special about Medium in that regard, I've seen decent articles and rubbish and everything in between.
- SXX 4y agoIt's called Medium, because so much of it is neither rare nor well done.
- ycombiredd 4y agoYour comment. Umm. Well done. :-)
- ekianjo 4y agoAnything is better at this stage. The constant reminder to becoming a paying subscriber is annoying.
- lifthrasiir 4y agoNo matter how much I dislike Medium for its increasing annoyances, I think most dev and tech communities simply don't care. In fact, to my knowledge, HN is the only community where a negativity towards Medium is significant enough.
- habibur 4y agoI check the url, see "medium" in it, and then skip reading it, no matter how catchy the title might have been.
- leephillips 4y agoThe far better alternative: your own website, using your own domain. Or, you can go professional: https://lee-phillips.org/whypay/ https://lee-phillips.org/whypay/.
- jeroenhd 4y agoMedium is great for writers because it's a content hub just like Youtube and it can actually pay out as well. However, it's terrible for readers. The dynamic loading of images is mediocre on anything but a fiber connection, the web pages are slow and the pay wall is an instant turn-off. Even if you get into the free experience, half your screen is covered by banners and side bars. I think Medium is great for a specific audience: Medium readers. Some people like to browse Medium and the blogs it hosts and for those people, the setup is perfect. For anyone who doesn't like to browse Medium but rather gets linked to it occasionally, it's an awful experience. Personally, I prefer plain old websites. You don't need a domain and a server, throwing something into Github/Gitlab Pages is more than enough. You can set up a whole CI/CD system for static site generation or write a document in Word and export it to HTML if that's what you want. You'll need to rely on platforms like HN and Reddit to get new people to discover your site, though, but from what I've been recommended on Medium, the articles that get attention seem to be very SEO-optimized and not very technical. Listicles and terribly written blog spam that just repeats the same basic information in several ways get a lot of attention. There are also opinionated articles about subjective things (UX design etc.) that only exist for the author to make their preferences known to the world; there are great articles on there that reference sources and research, but it's not what I see pushed on the website because outrage clicks and reactions from people disagreeing are worth more than people consulting the website for information. If you want something easy and hosted, WordPress still has a free tier. Your options are very limited but if you care about the content more than building a specific look and feel, they're fine.
- reaperducer 4y agoPublishing a tech article on Medium is the equivalent of suggesting a Google search, or having an @aol.com e-mail address. People will assume you lack basic technical skills, and that will tint what you wrote.
- ipunchghosts 4y agoI find these articles very pedestrian, nothing I couldn't infer from a quick Google search or my own intuition.
- cristoperb 4y agoI use uBlacklist to prevent medium.com articles from showing up in my Google results: https://github.com/iorate/ublacklist https://github.com/iorate/ublacklist
- qubex 4y agoIt just occurred that I was chatting to a friend on Facebook Messenger and wanted to share some old Medium posts of mine, and it turns out just copy and pasting the URL didn’t work… needed to share, copy, bla bla… quite irksome. Not a walled garden (exactly), but perversely clunkier than a free alternative that doesn’t try to integrate largely unwanted social features and content control. Very dissatisfying.
- willmadden 4y agoYes, ever since they decided to censor and rate limit content that contradicts the current narratives. Almost everything on Medium is freemium content based marketing and milquetoast garbage. Substack is the new medium.
- motohagiography 4y agoThe medium is the message, truly. However, coincidentally, just this morning before hitting HN I was scanning through my emails from substack writers and thinking how even though I was putting together material and seriously considering writing a blog, I didn't want to become like them. It's not just Medium, and while I get the sentiment, it's perhaps a bit unfair to single them out. When I wanted to write, I wanted to create the experience of curling up with a good book that changes how you relate to the world after. I don't want to be a part of someones community of subscribers, I want to become someone who has read this thing. That's what books were and represented. Online, there is zero investment in anything we read. It's what people do with wasted time, and in this sense a blog can only be as good as a recycled waste product. There is no value created by investing it in reading a blog, it is not enriching whereas finishing a book made you a kind of steward for that experience and interpretation. This was the difference, this idea of reading and writing as an enriching experience. The largest possible impact a blog post can have is to shift or dent a narrative - but what if you don't value the attention of people whose experience is an artifact of narrative? Only a decade ago, the idea of someone having a conversation about the characters in supermarket tabloids was kind of pitiful, but now we seem to live in a competition where everyone online tries to angle and align themselves to these dramas. It's not Medium, it's the medium, and the whole thing is an inferior substitute to living.
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoSooner or later, every online forum reaches the point where its primary objective is to driver users away.
- D13Fd 4y agoYes absolutely. I looked at using Medium a few years ago but ended up just putting together my own blog website on my own domain. When you read Medium content, much of it is junk optimized to hoover up as many views as possible. Articles often have an optimized-for-Medium tone that is just off putting. Plus there is the the constant sword of Damocles hanging over your head any time you read because they might cut you off for having read too many Medium articles without paying (or at least there was, I don't know if they have updated the model).
- nottorp 4y agoThe problem with a site that wants me to pay for opinion pieces is that they're probably not opinions but "copy" written to make money. Which brings the opinion's value to about zero. Marketing by threats doesn't help either. You have used 1 out of your 3 free reads! Subscribe to the newsletter! With no obvious way of closing the popup. Yes, I'm looking at substack now. This is an attempt to continue paper magazines, but done wrong. Back then you could impulse buy a paper issue with no commitment. And perhaps another. And more randomly. If you liked it enough, you maybe subscribed. Skip the no commitment transactions and spam people and the trust goes away.
- motoboi 4y agoYes. I and logged in just so I could vote yes. That's how much yes this is for me.
- bardan 4y agoChoosing "unsure" because we shouldn't be shown the ongoing results of the poll. Otherwise I believe I would also have chosen "yes".
- photochemsyn 4y agoA rather large percentage of tech articles across the web are little more than marketing hooks for some product or service, especially paid training courses. Medium has this issue, but so do many other common sites that typically hit the top of the list in search engine results. Wading through such results looking for something in-depth is too tedious for me. As others note, the articles I bookmark and come back to tend to be from personal blogs more often than not. For real depth, however, I still turn to books.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tinfoil_knight 4y agoYes. Medium has a paywall & annoying pop-ups. I'd prefer the author maintain their own websites. With services like Netlify & Vercel, it's incredibly easy & cheap to do so. (Free if you don't care about the domain.)
- andybak 4y agoThe question is poorly worded as it's not clear whether you just mean "Does Medium itself have an association with poor content that creates a stigma" or whether it would also include reasons such as "I don't click Medium links because of the paywall or bad UX" Strictly speaking it sounds like you're asking the former but the latter is the reason I don't tend to read Medium content. I would argue that this kind of ambiguity means your results are probably worthless. (On the whole I find most surveys suffer from an issue like this)
- invalidname 4y agoI voted yes. Hashnode is much better. I still use Medium for syndication with canonical links back. The value there is the publications in medium which are pretty nice.
- truthwhisperer 4y ago
- tibanne 4y agoMedium can die. They force me to open an incognito window to read an article that I need to get something working.
- tibanne 4y ago> Please comment if you can think of better alternatives to Medium https://read.cash https://read.cash
- dmix 4y agoSubstack meanwhile I tend to value, as they’re usually much higher quality. Medium is for Twitter style clickbait that didn’t fit in 150 characters.
- firefoxkekw 4y agoPlease comment if you can think of better alternatives to Medium > https://pages.github.com/ https://pages.github.com/ Example: https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2021/12/12/a-correction-on-ai-chips.html https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2021/12/12/a-cor...
- giantg2 4y agoI evaluate each one I read individually, but I go into it with low expectations. The platform is cluttered with low value, biased, or uninteresting content.
- pyb 4y agoYes, if only because Medium articles render incredibly slowly on my phone.
- joshspankit 4y agoWith addendums: I have compassion for those writers who wrote on Medium at the beginning, when there was integrity and a dream, as well as those who for one reason or another believe that that dream is still viable. But even then I am more likely to see a good title, see medium, have a moment of silence for the author, and not click through.
- IceDane 4y agoMedium is full of people who are intentionally trying to "game" it to make more money. They produce garbage content en masse, and then they try to get as many people to read / like / whatever it as possible. This is just what medium has brought onto itself with this sort of incentive model.
- StevePerkins 4y agoI don't know about "stigma", but I've certainly starting seeing Medium articles the same way that I see blog posts on LinkedIn. There's zero authenticity there... it's just some crap that you're mechanically writing, in order to put "thought leader" on your resume or CV.
- caiomassan 4y agoit became a shit product with the naggin and paywalled weirdness.
- tomp 4y agoGithub pages, or GutHub repo served by CloudFlare
- fmajid 4y agoAbsolutely yes. I will often downvote posts I am otherwise neutral about for daring to inflict Medium onto me. More often I will see medium in the URL and simply not click.
- lajosbacs 4y agoAbsolutely, e.g. 'towards data science' always comes on top when searching anything ml related and is always a disappointment -- code without syntax highlighting, meme pictures over half the screen, etc. I extrapolate this to Medium as a whole.
- aliasxneo 4y agoI don't do anything with ML and yet I routinely see this site sitting in the top results. They appear to have a large amount of "generic" content that is probably purpose-built to show up in common queries.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoI block medium.com urls via pi-hole. It has been a quality of life improvement. Every now and then there appears to be a medium.com article that might be worth unblocking the domain but more often then not I regret it when I do.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoYeah, on multiple levels. If you're genuinely into tech, you know how to set up your own website and host a blog with very little effort or hassle. It's kindergarten stuff. Hosting a tech blog on medium is like a chef putting instant noodles on the menu. It sends really weird mixed signals, and makes me think you're yet another one of those vincent adultman types on medium attempting to make a career in tech by chinese rooming barely coherent tips from other people's writing while knowing jack shit about anything they're saying. Probably sounds really harsh, but that's the sort of assumptions I go into a medium article with.
- jasonjmcghee 4y agoFor what it's worth asking "is there stigma" might not be as useful as "do you hold stigma" because, of course there's stigma, but what % personally feel it would be interesting to know.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- squeaky-clean 4y agoThere's technically 2 questions here, the title and the question in the text body. I voted according to the title (so yes) > Will I/my articles get negativity within dev and tech communities because they are written in Medium? I don't think the author or their writing will get any ire for being hosted on Medium. The negativity is purely towards Medium itself. However I probably won't read your article if it's on Medium unless it's in the #1 spot on HN.
- tromp 4y agoI've written several articles on Medium (such as [1]), unaware of this negative stigma. Now I'd like to move them to my github pages. Is there some tool to export a medium article to readable html or markdown? Or will I have to copy-and-paste the raw text and add back all the formatting myself? [1] https://john-tromp.medium.com/sk-numerals-9ad1b5634b28 https://john-tromp.medium.com/sk-numerals-9ad1b5634b28
- citizenpaul 4y agoI've actually blocked medium.com in ublock because of how poor the quality is. It seems to have become a target site for low quality tech tutorials that are filled with errors and often times just plain don't work. Also its a wasteland of copy paste from the documentation of the subject official website. I learned a while back that if the article had code in image format there was 100% certianty it was not functional and I could close the article without reading.
- diek00 4y agoWhat I hate about Medium, is that have created multiple other websites using the pay model all hiding ready remind you how many free articles you have left.
- jdeaton 4y agomedium has been on my uBlacklist for a while now, since when im searching for ML references to read theres often some halfassed medium article above the actual paper.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoReading experience is pretty bad, and many authors on Medium use shady techniques and clickbaity titles to drive traffic to their articles.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RamblingCTO 4y agoI don't care. Sometimes there's good content and there are lot's of other pages with bad quality. But I won't click on something from dev.to, that's 99% beginners writing garbage.
- throwaway343u64 4y ago
- bArray 4y ago> Will I/my articles get negativity within dev and tech communities because they are written in Medium? I can't view text without JS and I don't want to turn it on so Medium can track the anal cream my neighbour uses on their cat. > Please comment if you can think of better alternatives to Medium Markdown + Pandoc + static page host. With that you get control and personality.
- 8note 4y agoI mostly remember medium articles starting to show up at the same time as svtle ones, and the svtle ones were always more interesting
- jacooper 4y agoEffortless alternatives to medium: Hashnode(tech focused) Substack
- over_bridge 4y agoI associate Medium with people who crank out one article a day to grow their audience. No one on Earth is interesting or knowledgeable enough to write one self contained thing of value per day. Therefore anything you read on there is someone's daily dump of content rather than something useful. Like trying to read LOTR by stopping by Tolkien's desk each day and reading one post-it note you found there. These people ruined Quora years before they did the same to Medium.
- pbteja1998 4y agoFor tech or dev articles, https://hashnode.com/ https://hashnode.com/ is the best platform. It supports adding custom domains and it also has a very active community. If you use Notion to write your articles, you can check out https://feather.so https://feather.so. It converts your Notion pages and builds a blog out of it. You can then assign your own domain to it. https://ghost.org/ https://ghost.org/ is also another excellent option that you can check out.
- n8henrie 4y agoMedium-hosted content is blanket blocked at my place of work (a US federal government facility, though I don't know if this is a local firewall setting or something national). So yes I am disappointed when content is only on medium. Thankfully using Google Cache or Pocket can usually still get to the content, but requires a tiny bit of extra effort.