5 ms·
I'm quite familiar with this whole lawsuit, and I still think it's total and complete bullshit (and, to be clear, I have huge concerns about Google's tracking a
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I'm quite familiar with this whole lawsuit, and I still think it's total and complete bullshit (and, to be clear, I have huge concerns about Google's tracking and surveillance).
Incognito Mode basically puts you in a mode as if you had installed a fresh, new instance of the browser every time, e.g. none of your past cookies can be accessed by any websites. Websites, though, can still use analytics APIs, including things like Google Analytics, to track you within that Incognito Mode session. They may also be able to correlate you by, for example, matching your IP address. And, to be clear, the Incognito Mode new window has always made this clear.
I can still be really concerned about Google's overall tracking and also point out this lawsuit is a bullshit money grab from lawyers hoping for a lotto payout.
- ericmcer 4y agoI always felt this was obvious, what did people think incognito mode was? It literally says "Now you can browse privately, and other people who use this device won’t see your activity." when you open an incognito window. It doesn't claim to be a VPN or anything.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoIt's also literally called incognito mode. If they want to rename it to "temporary profile" or something, I for one would be a lot happier.
- muro 4y agoA lot more bland/boring too
- Spivak 4y agoSo this lawsuit is just concern trolling? Nobody is actually upset about the feature itself, some people are just taking the worst faith interpretation that nobody irl actually has and pretending to be mad about it?
- shadowgovt 4y agoWorst case scenario, it moves the Overton Window on the "reasonable person" principle.
- JadeNB 4y ago> So this lawsuit is just concern trolling? Nobody is actually upset about the feature itself, some people are just taking the worst faith interpretation that nobody irl actually has and pretending to be mad about it? Websites mediate a significant part of how a significant chunk of the people in the world live a significant part of their lives. You and I know what incognito mode is and isn't, but can you seriously claim that, among a significant chunk of the population of the world, no reasonable person overestimates the privacy incognito mode offers?
- Spivak 4y ago> no reasonable person The standard is would a reasonable person and the answer is absolutely not. Among non techies people assume that Incognito/Private Browsing provides less protection than is actually offered. You go into private browsing when you don’t what sites you visit to show up in your browser history, that’s it.
- JadeNB 4y ago> > no reasonable person > The standard is would a reasonable person and the answer is absolutely not. Among non techies people assume that Incognito/Private Browsing provides less protection than is actually offered. You go into private browsing when you don’t what sites you visit to show up in your browser history, that’s it. You quote my referring to what a reasonable person would do, and then seem to be offering a rebuttal by saying that it's about what a reasonable person would do …? Anyway, I think we must just disagree on a reasonable person's expectations.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> You quote my referring to what a reasonable person would do, and then seem to be offering a rebuttal by saying that it's about what a reasonable person would do …? Yes. What's confusing about that? They didn't say it was wrong to talk about a reasonable person, or anything like that. But you were applying the reasonable person test incorrectly. You don't make a pile of reasonable people, and then check if any of them are confused. You look at what a single median reasonable person would think, basically.
- divbzero 4y agoYes, the naming of “Incognito” or “Private” browsing could be improved, but the messaging in Chrome is pretty clear. In addition to: Now you can browse privately, and other people who use this device won’t see your activity. However, downloads, bookmarks and reading list items will be saved. It also explains: Your activity might still be visible to: • Websites you visit • Your employer or school • Your internet service provider
- lamontcg 4y agoThe whole point is that list does not mention "* Google"
- Spivak 4y agoThe argument would have to be that Google was using Chrome itself to track you in Incognito because they controlled the browser, otherwise they are just “websites you visit.”
- lamontcg 4y agoYes, that is in fact the subject of the lawsuit. From literally the first sentence of the article: > alleges the Silicon Valley giant misled the public about how much data it collects from users even when they're in its Chrome browser's "Incognito" private browsing mode. The accusation is that Google is leveraging Chrome to track you even in incognito mode, and it does not give any notice that it is doing so. It warns about the websites you visit, about who owns your local network, and about the ISP, it doesn't warn that Google is still actively tracking you in incognito.
- Spivak 4y agoEvery source about this lawsuit has said that what is meant by this is Google tracking you on Google properties. Unless they outline how the tracking is done it’s pointless.
- 4y ago
- just_boost_it 4y agoI think the law would look at many questions like these by asking "what would the normal person think incognito mode was". Most people can't even write an excel formula. Not only do they not know this mode wasn't private, they don't even know enough to know understand the ways in which it wasn't private. Youre saying it doesn't claim to be a VPN, I'm saying that even if it was, mot people don't know what a VPN is, so they can't tell if they need it or if it's even a good thing.
- insanitybit 4y ago> Now you can browse privately, and other people who use this device won’t see your activity. However, downloads, bookmarks and reading list items will be saved. Learn more > Your activity might still be visible to: > Websites you visit > Your employer or school > Your internet service provider It's pretty obvious that the only thing it's promising is to hide information from other users on the same device, and it goes out of its way to state that it won't protect against other tracking.
- LightG 4y agoTo the HN crowd this is entirely obvious... to others, perhaps not so much. I think we're on the same ballpark as calling lane-assist Autopilot. Those who know, know. Those who don't, don't. I mean "RTFA" arose for a reason, right? Stuff literally needs to be "what it says on the tin"... and even then.
- nightfly 4y ago> I think we're on the same ballpark as calling lane-assist Autopilot Is aviation autopilot really any different than lane-assist?
- LightG 4y agoA little. A pilot under Autopilot is at least allowed to take their hands off off the wheel/yoke/control-stick during cruise-control elements of the flight ... However, the connotations associated with "Autopilot" (to the wider public) mean it was a terrible term for its intended use on the road. Maybe this issue is so well known now (I assume, in my bubble thinking) that it's no longer an issue ... but it is a relevant example.
- wutbrodo 4y agoIt also goes out if its way to mention ways in which you can still be tracked (employer, isp, etc). This salacious headline is nonsense: Google employees joked internally about facts that the product clearly provides to users.
- rco8786 4y agoConsider that the vast, vast majority of people have no idea how networks or browsers or sessions or cookies or VPNs work. I think it’s just fine and I don’t think Google misrepresented anything. But certainly there’s an enormous amount of people out there who still don’t understand the actual implications of what incognito mode means.
- Aachen 4y agoI might not understand how my car works, but I don't sue the manufacturer after putting it in first gear on the highway and it coming apart ("the gear was available for selecting, this should have done what I thought it did!"), or for making the radio have a button that doesn't do what I thought it did.
- BeefWellington 4y agoYou might, however, sue the manufacturer if they sell you an automatic parking feature that routinely crashes into other cars.
- rco8786 4y agoI explicitly said "I don’t think Google misrepresented anything" so not terribly sure what your point is here.
- bspammer 4y agoThe new page tab for incognito mode literally says Your activity might still be visible to: * Websites that you visit * Your employer or school * Your Internet service provider I know people don't read warnings, but really I don't know what they could do to make it more clear.
- greatgib 4y agoBased on what is written there, if I'm a standard non tech user, and that I don't know anything about Js cross site requests, then, when I browse a news website (that is not Google), I don't expect google to be able to see my activity. As, again, it is not their website that I'm visiting. In addition, Chrome is distributed by Google itself and they clearly advertise it as made by them, better and safe. They make it explicit that it is entirely under their control. So, it would be logic for a standard non tech user to expect that google do not track them when they are using the "google" chrome incognito mode. Keep in mind that a lot of users would not know the difference between a client and a server. Also, remember that google do everything to blur the lines when it was convenient for them: When you are logged in Google, your own browser is logged with a special profile icon. If you look at it you can launch a Google search directly from the url bar or from the "new tab" page. Even as a power user, can you easily reply to the following question? is the new tab your browser domain or Google domain? Hint: some content here is dynamic depending on your Google account...
- trungaczne 4y ago> I don't expect google to be able to see my activity. The incognito default tab says that your activities are still visible websites. The incognito mode even explains that other people using the same device won't see what you browsed - which is the primary use of it anyway. I don't know what is the concern here - are people angry that a mode which doesn't promise untrackability doesn't give untrackability? > If you look at it you can launch a Google search directly from the url bar or from the "new tab" page. What is this meant to to poke at? You can change what the search bar does to another search engine (in fact I believe Duckduckgo is also one of the choices in a new install of chrome). > When you are logged in Google, your own browser is logged with a special profile icon. Doesn't Firefox also have the same browser sync service? It's a useful feature to track your browser tabs unless you're security conscious or paranoid (or both). There's a difference between _not_ understanding what a browser does and misinterpreting what it does, which is what this entire post is.
- shaky-carrousel 4y agoThat is not entirely correct. Incognito mode shows as incognito, meaning you can tell apart a guy using incognito from a guy with a freshly installed chrome.
- kevincox 4y agoIIUC it doesn't directly advertise this (and in many cases tries to hide this) but it can be fingerprinted.
- SilasX 4y ago> Websites, though, can still use analytics APIs, including things like Google Analytics, to track you within that Incognito Mode session. They may also be able to correlate you by, for example, matching your IP address. Well, that’s kind of what breaks intuition about it. Compare to a burner phone. People expect that eg calling the same place with the same number will tip off the recipient that you’re the same person. But what if every business fed a voice analysis profile of everyone caller to a central database — without keeping a voice recording, of course — and associated each one with a number. And imagine it was cheap for some people to access this database. That would kind of break most people’s expectations of a burner phone. But that’s basically what websites can do. So even if you know the general structure of how websites and Incognito work, you might still fail to appreciate how unhelpful the anonymization is.
- potatototoo99 4y agoI don't think it's that clear. For instance different incognito windows, opened separately, share everything among them. This was not at all clear to me, though I suppose at least for tabs in the same window it makes sense.
- colejohnson66 4y agoThat’s news to me, too. Makes sense though. I assume it’s because you can drag tabs from one window to another. So if you open two incognito windows and drag one windows’ tabs into the other, the browser needs to decide what can be shared. You could keep their states separate, but what if you then you open a new tab in that shared window? What state/profile object is the new tab associated with? Just sharing between all windows is easier to handle.
- jereees 4y agoIndeed. This is not the case in Safari, for example, where every incognito tab is isolated from the rest.
- renewiltord 4y agoBut Safari has its own problems. For instance, despite promising to be a safari I noticed that I am still located in exactly the place I started. If it doesn't rename to Apple Web User Agent then it is clearly misleading to the non-technical user.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"And, to be clear, the Incognito Mode new window has always made this clear." But the spy icon and the name hint something different. I mean we technical folks do understand the words and explanations with one short glance, because we know a browser cannot make us anonymous nor invisible just like that. But common folks who understand computers as dark magic not so much. So it is somewhat missleading, even though I do not see a evil intention here, rather misscommunication.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoFirefox and Safari call this "private browsing". Firefox also uses a mask icon. Are these any different? And, to be clear, the whole focus of this lawsuit is the plaintiffs are saying that since Google also owns server-side Google Analytics, that incognito mode is inaccurate because "Google is still tracking you". But the only way for Google to handle that would be if (a) Incognito mode specifically handled GA differently, and that would be a privacy violation, or (b) GA detects you're in Incognito and stops tracking, but all the browser vendors have gone to great lengths to try to make private modes as "unsniffable" as possible, and I view the very effort to sniff for privacy mode as a violation.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"Firefox and Safari call this "private browsing". Firefox also uses a mask icon. Are these any different?" Well, "private" is clearly different from "incognito". But the mask with firefox is misleading, too. And the article is misleading as well, because it implies that chrome is still tracking you in incognito mode, which is not right. Google might be tracking you. But to comment on the lawsuit, I lack details.
- BeefWellington 4y agoFirefox and Safari actually behave differently with the cross-domain tracking requests being complained about here. So yes, they are different.