6 ms·
Americans Are Too Fat to Donate Their Bodies to Science (2017)
- fny 4y agoThis makes no sense. If your population is fat, doesn't it make sense to study fat people? > The reasons are largely practical ones. Most medical school tables are not large enough to accommodate a human being larger than 200 lbs or longer than 6' tall. > Donated bodies also have to be moved by students and/or researchers, and heavier bodies are harder to move, posing injury risk. These also seem like bad reasons. Why not dismember the body? Why not use them for crash tests or other cadaver-driven science?
- oifjsidjf 4y ago
- cjbest 4y agoYes?
- DoktorDelta 4y agoIf your population is drinking Cyanide, then the issue is obviously systemic and studying their bodies may uncover a more exact cause.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoBut we know the exact cause... calories (food full of calories, ie. sugar and fat) tastes good, because historically when we found a calorie-rich source of nutrients, it was good for our survival to eat as much as we could (because who knows when will we get the next portion of food). We've had enough (and too much) food for maybe a 100 years, even less in some places, and evolution cannot adapt so fast, especially since most fat people die old enough to create new babies before that.
- zerohp 4y agoWe don't know why everyone suddenly decided to eat a lot more calories starting around 1980. It's not even clear that people are eating more calories than in 1880. Food was abundant in the US for most people long before that.
- numpad0 4y agoWe also don’t do cost/benefit analysis of life expectancy and productivity. It’s a horrible thought, but there could be positive financial effects in so-called obesity.
- roywiggins 4y agoAn effect like that has been found with smoking: "due to a shorter lifespan of 8.6 years, smokers’ mean total healthcare costs during the entire study period were actually €4700 lower than for non-smokers. For the same reason, each smoker missed 7.3 years (€126 850) of pension. Overall, smokers’ average net contribution to the public finance balance was €133 800 greater per individual compared with non-smokers." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3533014/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3533014/
- numpad0 4y agoSmoking at least had only downsides, we don’t know if obesity and sources of obesity has positive performance impacts, like X kg of weight correlating to Y dollars more per hour, of course after normalized by roles.
- Wyoming23 4y agoIt seems like we do know all the reasons though? It's multiple factors, but they're all mostly easy to observe, measure and identify. High-sugar, high-fat, packaged foods with preservatives, emulsifiers and artificial colors became cheap, abundant and normalized. These are essentially the perfect cocktail for obesity (by perfectly mixing calories, insulin response, gut microbiome changes, satiety, dopaminergic effects, etc). Simultaneously fewer Americans are working physical jobs, the jobs that are physical have reduced physicality and society in general has shifted to more car-centric and sedentary leisure (watching TV instead of going fishing on Saturday). Finally social changes. Women's liberation movement means more dual income households (and single adult households) which means less cooking from scratch and more fast food, packages food, etc. Also strong anti-bullying, body-positivity and self-esteem cultural norms prevent people from getting any peer feedback about their health/weight until it's a doctor telling them that they have diabetes and high blood pressure.
- jacobolus 4y agoIf people start drinking cyanide in mass, there are definitely a number of important things to study there, including (a) what led them to drink cyanide, (b) why didn’t they hear or accept counter-messaging advising them that drinking cyanide is a bad idea, (c) what are the effects on the body of drinking various amounts of cyanide, etc. This seems like an invented absurdity, but consider that people in the past few years tried a wide variety of “snake oil” prophylactics/treatments for Covid, including drinking bleach, snorting cocaine, and taking oleandrin (a poison with no known health benefits promoted by officials in the Trump administration), chloroquine/hydroxychloroquine (a malaria treatment), ivermectin (an antiparasitic), etc., even when these had been shown ineffective and were being actively discouraged by health officials. Of even broader impact (hundreds of thousands of extra lives lost in the USA, possibly millions worldwide), many people refused Covid vaccines under a variety of crank theories, driven by a large and organized disinformation campaign. Studying what happened and figuring out how to do better next time should be a significant priority for health research.
- cgb223 4y agoSounds like there’s a business opportunity here to make larger medical school tables with wheels to easily move patients
- Manu40 4y agoActually, if I remember correctly; Covid already made that a thing in some ways. Back during the pandemic, they had to figure out some way to turn over patients that were infected and too big to move easily; so a specialized gurney was created. (I think they are called gurney's but am not 100% sure.)
- swayvil 4y agoI will compete with your BIGTABLE.COM company by creating EZCORPSESPLITTER.COM
- cgb223 4y agoIt’s like microservices vs a monolith but the server is a corpse
- masklinn 4y ago> This makes no sense. If your population is fat, doesn't it make sense to study fat people? It makes a lot of sense, operating on obese patients is a lot more complicated than on regular patients, and so would dissecting one. That's like reading an article about how learning to weld has become complicated in florida because the state's underwater, and your reply being "This makes no sense, if you're under water doesn't it make sense to learn underwater welding?" But underwater welding adds a ton of complexity to what you're trying to learn. You don't try to do that when trying to learn the basics and are probably already overwhelmed. In the same way you don't learn a new programming language by switching your editor to windings and RTL.
- Jabbles 4y ago> Why not dismember the body? Why not use them for crash tests or other cadaver-driven science? Oh HN. Medical schools aren't just some kind of cadaver multiplexer, farming them out to other industries that want one for "crash tests". If you want your body to be used for "crash tests", say so, and then hope your body meets the requirements of that industry.
- nostromo 4y agoShockingly, that has recently been found to be true in some cases. “Arizona man finds out mother’s body donated to science was sold to be used in IED blast test” https://www.newsweek.com/donated-body-sold-army-brc-arizona-1451846 https://www.newsweek.com/donated-body-sold-army-brc-arizona-... "Dismembered limbs sewn together like 'Frankenstein' at body-parts donation center, FBI found" https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/dismembered-body-parts-sewn-together-frankenstein-donation-center-fbi-found-n1035131 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/dismembered-body-parts-... Here's a comprehensive overview of the problem from Reuters: https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-bodybrokers-industry/ https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-body...
- blairbeckwith 4y agoThis is now my dying wish.
- dehrmann 4y agoCue Adam Savage saying "for science!" But I dunno, it could save some soldiers' lives. It's only outrageous until you think it through.
- msrenee 4y ago>Jim Stauffer signed a form authorizing medical research on his mother’s body. He also checked a box prohibiting military, traffic-safety and other non-medical experiments. That's where it crosses the line between unfortunate and immoral.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bubblematrix 4y agoAnother Vice click-bait "America is bad for (x) reason" article. FYI - Mexico is the most obese nation in the world, surpassing the United States in both Adult and Child obesity.
- yazzku 4y agohttps://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/health-statistics/overweight-obesity https://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/health-statisti... Nearly 1 in 3 adults (30.7%) are overweight.2 More than 2 in 5 adults (42.4%) have obesity.2 About 1 in 11 adults (9.2%) have severe obesity.2 About 1 in 6 children and adolescents ages 2 to 19 (16.1%) are overweight.3 Almost 1 in 5 children and adolescents ages 2 to 19 (19.3%) have obesity.3 About 1 in 16 children and adolescents ages 2 to 19 (6.1%) have severe obesity.3
- bubblematrix 4y agoThank you, here's more information about Mexico's obesity problem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_Mexico https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_Mexico
- Bakary 4y agoI don't understand the argument proposed here. Americans should ignore what is an enormous (no pun intended) health crisis because other countries are slightly worse? It doesn't matter what Mexico is doing or not doing, the current figures for obesity are staggering
- dymk 4y agoI think this is less a whataboutism of "But Mexico is worse!", and more general eye rolling at another breathless, unquantified hate-on-America article. The article even admits it doesn't know if this is actually a problem or not. FTA: > There are no statistics that cover bodies donated or bodies offered to programs, no official way to tell how many Americans who fall into the overweight or obese categories have been turned away like McPherson.
- tptacek 4y agoIf you read the whole article, it turns out that Americans are often too tall to donate their bodies to science, too: the limit is 6'. The reason is pretty simple: the anatomy labs have tables that accommodate bodies of a certain size. In the good states, if you donate your body but it can't be used, they'll cremate it at their expense and return the ashes. A lot of hedging and hemming aside, I think I've pretty much captured the whole article.
- manmal 4y agoNot sure if the data I just found is reliable, but according to that, only about 13% of males and 0.03% of females in the US are taller than 6 feet.
- yamtaddle 4y agoThe second figure cannot be right. I'm just a hair under 6' and I see women taller than me way more often than that would suggest. I'd maybe believe 0.3%, but 0.03% can't possibly be correct. 3 in 10,000? Got to be higher.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- drdec 4y agoI think that it is easy to think that someone is taller than you that are the same height or even slightly shorter than you. Also, many women wear heels making them seem taller.
- bongoman37 4y ago
- 1123581321 4y agoIt’s in the ballpark of .1%. https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/2010/compendia/statab/130ed/tables/11s0205.pdf https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/2010/compendia/... If you’re seeing a lot of women over six feet, you’re either around a lot of Dutch women or they’re wearing elevating shoes (heels, tall flats/clogs.) Or perhaps you slouch. :)
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoIt's grown a bit tiresome when a company or organization needs to do something for a straightforward physical reason and then people try to blame them for "fat shaming". The article is pretty clear further down on the reasons for these limitations: > The reasons are largely practical ones. Most medical school tables are not large enough to accommodate a human being larger than 200 lbs or longer than 6' tall. Donated bodies also have to be moved by students and/or researchers, and heavier bodies are harder to move, posing injury risk. Dissection is also made more difficult when a cadaver carries more fat—the dissector has to cut through the layers of fatty tissue to reach the body's organs. But then the article also tries to hype up that not taking her donation is some kind of injustice: > But Scott McPherson knows first hand there's something unpleasant about denying a person's dying wishes, too. "My mom just wanted to donate her body for something she believed in," he says. Instead, the McPhersons founds themselves trying to figure out an after-death plan for their mother that went against everything she'd asked them to do. The whole irony in this is the journalist deliberately used (while true) an extremely insensitive title to get you to click, "Americans Are Too Fat to Donate Their Bodies to Science", but then tries to highlight how insensitive it is that schools won't/can't take obese full-body donations.
- Someone 4y agoIndirect discrimination (https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/pages/glossary/indirect-discrimination_en https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/pages/glossary/indirect-di...) is forbidden in quite a few countries. The only reason I can see why would not be judged to be a case of that is that the actual discrimination happens after death, but I don’t think that will hold.
- inglor_cz 4y agoWhy wouldn't it? Many laws do not apply to the dead. In Europe, a famous law that does not apply to the dead is GDPR.
- Someone 4y agoI think persons stop being persons the moment they die in most countries. However, I expect that the moment it becomes common knowledge or they tell you upfront about it, courts would rule living people who consider donating their body to science would be discriminated against. Given that, I would think keeping it 100% a secret wouldn’t work, either, as keeping crimes/misdemeanors secret never makes them legal.
- Amorymeltzer 4y agoI appreciate Vice including the (presumably automatic) header that the article is over five years old. Should be noted here as well.
- codingdave 4y agoThe part that confuses me about the family struggling to figure out what to do with the remains is that the family would still get the remains back even if the donation were accepted. Donating a body doesn't mean that it gets thrown away - they take what remains of the remains, cremate it, and give it back to the family. So there should be no struggle to find a plan here - do what the person asked for - cremate them. From the family perspective, that is exactly what would have occurred anyway, just with different timing.
- labrador 4y agoNot even to be blown up by the military? "Man learns mom's body donated for research was instead blown up in military testing" https://cbsaustin.com/news/nation-world/man-learns-moms-body-donated-for-research-was-instead-blown-up-in-military-testing https://cbsaustin.com/news/nation-world/man-learns-moms-body...
- threads2 4y agoI remembered Reuters doing an expose on this about five years ago so I couldn't empathize at all with the opening of this Vice article. This might actually be a better article. Shows some examples of how the bodies are set up to be blown up: https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-bodybrokers-industry/ https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-body... Wonder how many people would sign their bodies up for military testing if they made the distinction. Do they ask people already in the military if they want to donate their bodies for military testing?
- labrador 4y agoI would because I want my atoms scattered, not interred in a hole or a jar
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- idoubtit 4y agoThe journalist is not precise at all when stating: > a nation where two thirds of the population is now considered overweight or obese Their own link give a total of 73.1% for overweight among adults US peoples in 2018. The latest data of the CDC has 73.6%. In any case, it's almost three quarters, not two thirds. And that's before the covid crisis, which probably worsened the situation. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/obesity-overweight.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/obesity-overweight.htm
- m0llusk 4y ago> I don't think you need a room full of obese cadavers ...