5 ms·
All told, yikes. That’s a pretty damning — and funny — insight into how much Google's own employees believed in the browsing mode's privacy, which is to say not
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
All told, yikes. That’s a pretty damning — and funny — insight into how much Google's own employees believed in the browsing mode's privacy, which is to say not a lot.
As a former Googler, I'll say this: You will have a hard time finding people more critical of many of the actions of Google (the company) than Googlers (the employees of said company.) Even after all these years, and into the Sundar times, there's a rather healthy internal culture of critique there. Usually with the best interests of the broader mission statement of the company at heart.
Naturally much of this is necessarily muted in external communications, and in some forms of writing... for legal reasons. Sounds like some people slipped up here and didn't pay attention in their mandatory communications training.
TLDR it's not "damning" -- geeks inside Google are much the same as geeks outside. They're just taking a paycheck.
- kotlin2 4y agoIt’s pretty damning for Google, the company, which clearly had knowledge they were misrepresenting “incognito mode”. Whether or not it’s damning for the individual engineers is a matter of debate, likely depending on whether or not they worked on the feature or if they had the ability to do anything about it.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoAs others have pointed out, that's pretty nonsense. When you open an "incognito" tab it says right there: "Your activity might still be visible to: Websites that you visit Your employer or school Your Internet service provider" Not exactly ambiguous or misrepresentative. It's for browsing porn without your spouse knowing. That's about it.
- dunham 4y agoI occasionally use it for sites that uMatrix is a bit too aggressive with. On Mobile Safari I use private browsing for my kid's youtube, so my recommendations aren't full of minecraft videos. But now that I think of it, it might be fun to teach youtube that people who watch minecraft videos are also interested in type theory and Edward Kmett videos.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoDon't expect much. My YouTube feed is full of Terraria and Minecraft and Skyrim thanks to my son... mixed with CMU Database CS lectures, telemark skiing, gardening, and LoTR mythology videos, but let me tell you that YouTube has failed to syncretize anything interesting from this fusion :-)
- stjohnswarts 4y agoIt still surprises me that 100% of HN people aren't using ublock...
- lamontcg 4y ago> alleges the Silicon Valley giant misled the public about how much data it collects from users even when they're in its Chrome browser's "Incognito" private browsing mode. That warning doesn't include Google tracking you as well.
- wrs 4y agoThe internal controversy seems to be that it doesn’t warn that your activity is still visible to Google (for ad targeting and conversion tracking). Which is arguably much less obvious.
- ikiris 4y agoReread what they said. The only thing incognito ever offered was not saving local history.
- gruez 4y agoThat seems to be covered by "Your activity might still be visible to: Websites that you visit"?
- sooyoo 4y agoIt's tracked by Google even if you never visit a page operated by Google. Non-Google websites that include Google tracking are contributing here (which is most of the web). The sentence you cite suggests that it's "just" such sites that see your activity, while it's a third party (Google) that does as well and that is the issue here. Sure, technically you could argue that the tracking is "part" of the website that you visit, so it's technically still "only" the site that's tracking you. But let's be honest here, no reasonable non-hair-splitting non-geek would read it that way.
- thewebcount 4y agoThank you for pointing this out. It's strange the contortions other posters here are going through to pretend that a normal person wouldn't understand that when Google tells you're in incognito mode, Google still tracks you. If I put Firefox in private mode, I'm pretty sure the Mozilla Foundation doesn't get to see a bunch of my activity. It's pretty simple.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- sshine 4y ago> It's for browsing porn without your spouse knowing. That's about it. #notallspouses! It's for being able to open a tab while screen-sharing with strangers (colleagues, friends) without the browser suggesting porn sites with matching keywords.
- sneak 4y agoThey’re so critical of Google they go to work there every day to further the company’s interests. This is plain apologism.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoRidiculous personal blame-ism. Do some travel around the world and see the damage that the American military or western capitalism has done in some places. Or what the oil industry has done to the planet. If I judged everybody by their hypocritical involvement in injustice, I'd have no friends, and I'd hate myself to boot. (Ok, those two might already be true, but...) Solutions to systematic problems require a systematic approach. Personal blame solves nothing. I chose to leave Google, and I took a huge financial hit for it... but I wouldn't reproach anybody for staying there, especially around here where the other employment options aren't so great.
- chrismarlow9 4y agoIt's entirely unrelated to the topic, but I hope you were joking about having no friends and hating yourself. You're a valuable person and I'd be more than happy to be your friend.
- trasz 4y agoIn this case the systemic problem is precisely the belief that it’s somehow not your, nor your friends, fault. Being Americans you are directly profiting from it; destroying other regions of the world is a fundamental branch of American economy.
- Pigalowda 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roland35 4y agoNot surprising at all. These tech journalists find some out of context quotes from internal Meta communications and write click bate articles all the time, and it can be pretty frustrating. I think it's good to have a critical culture of our own products - otherwise we would have blind spots!
- Gravityloss 4y agoThis. Is there a company where everybody's so bright eyed they don't find anything to improve? That would sound almost like a cult to me...
- mkl95 4y agoIt sounds like Oracle
- saghm 4y agoCan they not find anything to improve, or do they just know that speaking out internally will not work out well?
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoIt’s just not part of the culture to look for things to improve in the first place. The overwhelming attitude towards product speak was that it’s not an engineering question, so if it makes marketing happy to go around babbling about how the database is “autonomous” because it uses “machine learning” there’s no sense thinking about whether those claims are true.
- mkl95 4y agoThis is sadly common in the industry. I recently found out a C-level guy was selling our next thing as a fully automated solution despite the fact it's not even close. It was the rare occasion where he was caught early enough that something could be done about it, but AFAIK he's done similar stuff in the past, and by the time someone found out it was too late.
- ocdtrekkie 4y ago> geeks inside Google are much the same as geeks outside. They're just taking a paycheck That's a huge difference. Between people willing to take blood money and those not.
- sooyoo 4y agoI wouldn't express it in such drastic words, but it should be obvious that there is a selection bias which leaves out people to even start a job at Google for pure ethical reasons, even though they would rock the interview. To make the statement true ("geeks inside Google are much the same as geeks outside.") the average Google geek would need to be significantly more critical (internally) than the average outsider among the population that does not rule out a Google job for ethical reasons. That's hard to believe.
- yibberish 4y ago
- Spivak 4y agoGood lord people, it’s a search engine and an ad network. Even if you assume the absolute worst of Google in all aspects it’s still at best mild hard to even quantify harm.
- lamontcg 4y ago> You will have a hard time finding people more critical of many of the actions of Google (the company) than Googlers > Sounds like some people slipped up here and didn't pay attention in their mandatory communications training. "You can say whatever you like inside the company, but never talk about it outside"
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoSomewhat fair, except that Google has historically been more tolerant of the "outside" leaks than many others. Just stop to imagine what would happen to the people involved if something like this were to leak from Apple. It's inconceivable to imagine them keeping their jobs. From what I have heard and seen from Apple, there is a veil of heavy internal secrecy that falls even between departments and projects. Zero tolerance for external leaks. That kind of thing was starting to creep into Google before I left, but on the whole that wasn't the culture there.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoI mean, you're comparing them to Apple. I'm pretty sure the Illuminati are less secretive than Apple.
- renewiltord 4y agoWell yeah, because if I told my coworker to "kill all the Apaches" they will wisely figure out that it means web server processes while you guys will post shit like "There is some evidence that Google is trying to kill Sacheen Littlefeather and commit literal genocide while suppressing whistleblowers". So logically there's a dude who sits in between the raging unwashed and my pure genius whose job it is to transform my pearls of Platonic percipience into something consumable by the gut flora of the lay people. This is necessary because the lay people are ever so eager to find witches and burn them - this act mostly out of sheer pleasure than self-defence.
- yibberish 4y agowhat I find impressive is how the employees are critical and the company stays on course. the criticism from its employees somehow neutered/ignored. I suppose a corporation is not a democracy but a private entity, so then, what are the employees? free citizens? who has more power the government -- which was supposed to guarantee that the citizen's voices would be heard, or the company? how different is google from the usa government really?
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoYeah I can't honestly say that internal criticism altered much. Maybe just slowed it down at times. Or forced management into a deeper level of secrecy. Like, I'm sure some arm of Google is still doing all sorts of work in defense, just without most of its staff knowing. Despite the big uproar some years ago.
- aeturnum 4y ago> TLDR it's not "damning" -- geeks inside Google are much the same as geeks outside. They're just taking a paycheck. Without pretending to know enough about the circumstances of any individual person, I hope you can come to see how this description encompasses both "bad" and "good" (or at least "excusable") conduct. There is some line, which is difficult to see and controversial, where one can no longer justify their work by saying they are just a cog in a machine. We can talk about that line and that line is clearly different for different people (do they need the money, do they support others, how easily could they leave, etc). Asking people to account for the machine they are working for is a fair and normal social act and we should all be reflecting on it.
- sooyoo 4y ago> You will have a hard time finding people more critical of many of the actions of Google (the company) than Googlers (the employees of said company.) More critical than people who wouldn't even take a job at Google for ethical reasons? C'mon..
- trasz 4y ago>geeks inside Google are much the same as geeks outside. They're just taking a paycheck. Nothing wrong in making world a worse place if you’re being paid for it, right?
- bmacho 4y agoI mean if not me, then someone else will do the some, probably even worse than me.
- salawat 4y ago>didn't pay attention in their mandatory communications training. Arguably, if you did pay attention to said training, and deliverately sought to not call a spade a spade you are part of the problem. If legal tells you to call something something else, that's when you need to start getting suspicious.
- rtlfe 4y agoWhen you have 100k+ employees, there's obviously going to be somebody complaining about every decision.