5 ms·
"Our brightest minds are making people click ads" ...
by amelius 4y ago
"Our brightest minds are making people click ads" ...
- api 4y agoA few generations ago many of our brightest minds were building doomsday weapons to incinerate all life on Earth, so maybe this is progress.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoProbably not, if you shoot a man, there's a perpetrator and an end. If you brainwash a man, forever his actions will no longer be fully his own. Plus most people view violence as something undesirable (see Vietnam war protests), but advertising still has many hawks who will never stop singing it's praises while all public spaces are consumed by corporate branding until we have no where uninfected
- appletrotter 4y ago> if you shoot a man, there's a perpetrator and an end I don’t know about this assertion. It does not ring true to real life for me.
- thih9 4y agoI'd say the state of "forever his actions will no longer be fully his own" is easier to reach with doomsday weapons than with ads.
- dryd 4y agoIs the claim here that working in the advertising industry is worse than working on “doomsday devices to incinerate all life on Earth”? What a hot take!
- goatcode 4y agoIs it? Would you rather be dead or a zombie?
- lghh 4y agoWould I rather be dead or use TikTok? Come on now, you know the answer to that.
- TobyTheDog123 4y agoDead. "Better to Die on Your Feet Than Live on Your Knees" as they say.
- paxys 4y agoI'd rather have the choice to do whatever I want with my life instead of a bomb dropped on my head.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoNuclear weapons have killed about ~200k people in all of history. Advertising probably kills that many people most months when you consider things like: * Convincing people that various groups needs to be genocided * Convincing people to use cars instead of less dangerous methods of transportation * Convincing people to use fossil fuels instead of less polluting forms of energy * Convincing people to eat unhealthy foods * Convincing people to smoke cigarettes I'm not convinced that advertising is less dangerous than nuclear weapons.
- api 4y ago> Nuclear weapons have killed about ~200k people in all of history. So far. Present performance is not indicative of future returns. All it will take is one nut job (who could still be Putin depending on how this turns out) escalating to even a "regional" nuclear war to add a zero or two to that number, and it could happen very quickly.
- vladf 4y agoI've seen and heard and said this before... where is this quote from?
- ashleyn 4y agoJeff Hammerbacher. https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/06/12/click/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/06/12/click/
- crucialfelix 4y agoIt's from a reworking of Howl by Allen Ginsburg, reframing it for our era. The original is an amazing poem well worth reading https://poets.org/poem/howl-parts-i-ii https://poets.org/poem/howl-parts-i-ii
- otabdeveloper4 4y ago"Making people click ads" is just applied computational sociology. Which is a good thing, since the sociology we had before clickable ads was unequivocally less scientific and useful.
- ggpsv 4y ago"good" and "sociology" are surely carrying a lot of weight in that statement. What does "good" mean applied in this context? I'm not sure I see the connection to sociology though, do yo mean behavioral economics?
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoAdvertising today is figuring out the preferences and behavioral patterns of different social groups. It's not based on economics, it's mostly stats and probability theory.
- amelius 4y agoBut the knowledge we gain is only about triggering the bad paths of human brain, like addiction, greed, FOMO, etc. And who is "we" anyway, this stuff isn't public.
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoNo, because literally every business that exists wants to advertise. (And also organizations that aren't businesses, like NGO's and government agencies and non-profits.)
- amelius 4y agoWell, advertising only stimulates consumption, to the detriment of our planet. Also, it is a loudness war, that is a race to the bottom in various ways. As an individual business owner you want it, as society you don't.
- 4y ago
- thih9 4y agoTikTok was not the first company that came to my mind when I read that comment. I see way more ads on Instagram, Twitter, not to mention YouTube.
- cmelbye 4y agoTikTok will make $11B in ad revenue this year. It is their business model. This is twice as large as Twitter's business, and a third of Instagram or YouTube.
- 65934 4y agoStill better than wasting away the intelligence inventing something that will never hit the market and make any impact
- sterlind 4y agono. it's better to contribute nothing than contribute net harm.