6 ms·
Why does a football arc through the air and not tumble?
- falcolas 4y agoTL;DR: Footballs follow ballistic trajectories thanks to their spin imparted by spiral throws and punts. But they also can tumble, particularly on kickoffs, to make their trajectory harder to predict
- ncallaway 4y agoA while back I was working on a VR football game, and had been looking at these kinds of articles about the physics of the arc. We added a fake aerodynamic force that nudged the ball towards it's direction of travel if it was reasonably closely aligned, and scaled the force with the rotational velocity of the ball around it's the "spin" axis. It worked quite well and felt pretty good. The ball would still tumble if released poorly, but a well thrown ball would arc nicely.
- digdugdirk 4y agoInteresting. How did the dynamics of a VR football game work? I've always considered American Football a dynamic sport - the excitement of the game is that everyone on the field is in a tightly choreographed dance. It seems to lose its luster if you were just sitting/standing in a room with a VR headset, unable to run around.
- ncallaway 4y agoWe pretty much just implemented the quarterback and passing game. So, you could drop back in the pocket, step side to side a bit and throw the ball. There's a version of football called "7 on 7" which is basically just the Quarterback, Receivers, and Pass Defenders. It's common as a scrimmage practice for the passing skill positions, and it's a sport in its own right (see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2cckOaEOWM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2cckOaEOWM for an example). So that's basically what we implemented. We also had, basically, minigames, which would focus on one receiver and throwing the ball to them in the right spot of the route. Between play selection, pre-snap defensive reads, post-snap defensive reads, needing to release the ball within a few seconds, and having to release the ball with good form at the right time, to the right position on the field, there's a ton going on at the quarterback position, which is why we started there. Once you released the ball, your job was basically done, and you watched the rest of the play unfold. It worked pretty well, it was a bit of downtime, and there was some randomness in the result (players could miss a tackle, for example) so it was kind of engaging. One thing that was very satisfying was hitting a wide open receiver perfectly in stride and not even bothering to watch them run into the end-zone because you knew they were going to score.
- aidenn0 4y agoWas that really Rodgers-Cromartie playing in that game? [edit] Yes, https://giantswire.usatoday.com/2021/09/02/ex-new-york-giants-dominique-rodgers-cromartie-captures-affl-title/ https://giantswire.usatoday.com/2021/09/02/ex-new-york-giant...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kerblang 4y agoSpin acting against the force of air, which acts as a force against the end of the ball just as gravity acts as force against the bottom of a spinning top. In other words, it should not tip over if thrown in a vacuum. We've known that spin prevents an object from tumbling thru the air since at least the invention of rifling (a little before the American Civil War). It's the tipping over that was unexplained.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jjtheblunt 4y agogyroscope made of a football, when thrown in a spiral?
- kube-system 4y agoIf it acted just like a gyroscope, wouldn't it remain tip-up when the receiver catches it?
- jjtheblunt 4y agoi'm not sure, but that's a great question. Precession?
- kube-system 4y agoThe answer presented in the article (er.. video) is that the drag from the air on the ball's trajectory is the stronger force, and it changes the attitude of the ball.
- gadders 4y agoCan we add the word "(American)" before the word football please?
- marcosdumay 4y agoOh, thanks. I got here wondering why a ball would tumble.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jimbob45 4y ago"Gridiron" is more universally recognized IMHO.
- Bakary 4y agoIsn't "Handegg" the official term?
- cortesoft 4y agoFootball games aren’t called football because you kick the ball with your foot, but because they are played on foot rather than on horseback.
- acjohnson55 4y ago
- amelius 4y agoImagine a football made of steel, and rotating very fast, e.g. at 1M rpm. My gut instinct tells me that it will keep its orientation in space regardless of the trajectory and regardless of any air pushing against it.
- tantalor 4y agoOr a football in a vacuum
- FredPret 4y agoA spherical football in a vacuum
- stncls 4y agoYour gut instinct is correct. That's because, in this example, you are scaling the mass of the object (giving it huge inertia), while keeping its size constant, hence leaving unchanged the magnitude of the forces exerted on it by air friction. As a very rough estimation, the work performed by the forces that lead to a change in angle will be identical. But due to the larger inertia, that work will result in a much smaller change in orientation. What would your gut tell you if now that same steel football rotating at 1M rpm was also propelled at an initial speed of mach 1.5, yielding 3 or 4 minutes of flight?
- leetcrew 4y agomy gut tells me I really don't want to be a wide receiver in this game.
- aidenn0 4y agoI think any part of your body that touches that football will tell you that...
- amelius 4y agoI think that mass does not even matter, i.e. even with the same mass, with 1M rpm rotation, and propelled at the original (slow, subsonic) speed, the football would have enough angular momentum to keep its orientation, regardless of trajectory or air.
- citizenpaul 4y agoIt tumbles when I throw it. Ba-da-da clang. I'll see myself out.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoMy guess is because of the rotational forces from spinning. Like a rifle spins a bullet. Seems pretty obvious. Not clicking because Vox.
- gumby 4y ago> Not clicking because Vox. Do they have an enormous number of trackers not screened out by ad blocking? The paper, written by a physicist, deals with the non-obvious behavior by which the ball launches with one end pointing up and lands with that same end pointing down, which does not happen in other cases like (literally) a loaf of bread or a box of girls scout cookies.
- cafard 4y agoAbout 1970, the Washington Redskins (now the Commanders) had two quarterbacks, Sonny Jurgensen and Billy Kilmer. Jurgensen was a better passer, and said that Kilmer's passes offered the advantage that a receiver could choose which end to catch. So even at the pro level, sometimes footballs tumble.