13 ms·
Most PPP loans have been forgiven, despite signs of possible fraud
- axus 4y agoI've been really surprised that this hasn't been a political issue. These loans were a good deal larger than the student loans that've been forgiven, and a dream come true to anyone who's ever made money from fraud.
- pirate787 4y agoPPP fraud is a feature, not a bug.
- Clent 4y agoPolitical memory is so fleeting. The bill was stripped of any oversight by the allies of business.
- houstonn 4y agoPeople are so used to watching billions of dollars go missing or wasted that it has become background noise.
- prottog 4y agoI'm entirely unhappy about the whole PPP situation, but I think the reason why it's taken up less space in public debates is because ostensibly it was to compensate businesses for being forced to close. Student loans had no equivalent government mandate to have people take them on. I would prefer the counterfactual where nobody was forced to close (any longer than maybe the first couple of weeks) and therefore nobody got helicopter money; but since that isn't what happened, the next best thing would be aggressive prosecution of fraud. One can dream.
- PopAlongKid 4y agoPPP loans went to "job creators", always a favorite politically-protected class. >it was to compensate businesses for being forced to close More specifically, it was to "protect paychecks", to keep workers on the payroll who otherwise would have been let go. Sometimes, but not always, one of those workers was the business owner. In theory it was a pass-through benefit aimed at workers, but the employers not only had the loans forgiven, but also got a tax deduction for spending the government's money, and even sweeter in some cases, got increased tax basis in their business for the loan money they never repaid.
- indymike 4y agoBefore I hit the unpopular opinion part, yes, PPP and EIDL had a lot of fraudulent applications that were approved. That said, I'll share a little of what I learned because my company survived losing 85% of our revenue in 2020 because of EIDL and PPP. I and my other cofounders took huge pay cuts to get through 2020 and 2021, and without PPP we would have been out of business, and 12 employees would have lost their livelihoods. > PPP loans went to "job creators", always a favorite politically-protected class. Both PPP and EIDL were to businesses. Not to individuals. PPP was not a loan program. It was a grant. EIDL was a loan, and that was the program that had forgiveness. Being awarded PPP money required that you disclose payroll data before, during and after, and if you failed to meet terms, it would be converted to a loan. EIDL worked differently, if you met forgiveness, a percentage of your loan would be forgiven (I seem to recall 60% being the cap, but I could be wrong). In PPP there were caps on the amount a business owner could claim for their own compensation as a worker in the business. > got increased tax basis in their business for the loan money they never repaid. PPP was not a loan, it was a grant to cover payroll and unavoidable (i.e. rent) expenses during the initial lockdown. The IRS initially wanted to tax that (and for small businesses, that is at the personal rate of the owner) grant amount, which would have blunted the effect of PPP by 25-30%. The Trump adminstration stepped in and told the IRS to stand down, and changed the rules to prevent that. The purpose of PPP was really to ensure that businesses did not shut down permanently. The fact is that most small business only have sufficient cash to handle about 90 days of payroll and rent. Keeping the businesses alive would enable a faster rebound, because there was a study that estimated it would take eight years to re-grow that sector if those businesses were forced to shut down.
- efficax 4y agogiving away money to business owners is always OK by the lights of people in power, since business owners help make the people in power rich. giving money to loser normies who can't pay their student loans? what's in it for them?
- dmix 4y agoThis is a cute theory but in reality it's far more likely to be usual government malaise, laziness, and disregard for long term consequences than some organized secret push by millionaires with pull in the government.
- colpabar 4y agoYeah, anyone who thinks wealthy people have any pull in the united states government and use it to make themselves more wealthy must be some crazy alt right conspiracy theorist. Probably a white nationalist too. We all know everyone in the government is just dumb and all the trillions of dollars they waste is just because they make mistakes in excel and stuff.
- prottog 4y agoSure, one should always ask "Cui bono?", but it's equally important to also examine the incentive structures at play which drive the leviathan that is the government. At its core, the trillions of dollars of wasteful spending happens because politicians are rewarded for spending money and punished for asking where that money comes from or how effective the spending actually was, many years later. A good example is the Covid lockdowns that benefited the likes of Amazon or Home Depot at the expense of Main Street businesses. Cui bono? Certainly the wealthy class did. But did they collude and whisper into the ears of the halls of power in federal, state, and local levels (which all played roles in lockdowns) to make sure that people were forced to lock down harder and longer? No -- it's just the incentive structure. Politicians and bureaucrats had the choice between being rewarded for taking "decisive action" against the spread of the virus or pilloried for doing nothing, even if in hindsight it appears that we would have been better off doing nothing. Stuff like this is precisely why conservatives argue for limited government and more delegation of powers to lower levels of government. It's much easier for a wealthy person to have pull on a single US senator to make themselves more wealthy, than for that same person to have pull on twenty different state senators, or five hundred different city councilors.
- readams 4y agoPPP loans were always supposed to be forgiven from the beginning. Nobody would have taken the loans otherwise. It was not really a loan it was a payroll subsidy to keep the economy from collapsing. Also, this was actually authorized by Congress and not declared by fiat in an enormous executive overreach.
- leshow 4y agoIf anything it's a good case of why "trickle down" economic policies don't work very well. Many businesses who got the loans still fired employees, the cost of each job saved was high.
- Scoundreller 4y agoYeah, just write every human a cheque and let the businesses that are already teetering on bankruptcy without anyone willing to rescue them go bankrupt.
- leshow 4y agoPretty flimsy strawman you've constructed there.
- Scoundreller 4y agoWe’re arguing for the same thing.
- robswc 4y ago>Many businesses who got the loans still fired employees, the cost of each job saved was high. Which businesses? We're also looking with hindsight bias. There's no way to see what would have happened if businesses weren't bailed out.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoIt's not a political issue because both parties were in favor of it.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoIt's sort of interesting. Just the mental gamesmanship aspect of the entire thing. There are people who will swear up and down that welfare is the root of all evil. That bootstrap pulling is necessary, that there's opportunity for everyone regardless of their situation, and that all you need is hard work and dedication to succeed in the US. They will wring their hands about the federal deficit and will howl about the size of the national debt. Just look at the student loan forgiveness issue. But if you dangle a $6K per head loan in front of them, with no consequences whatsoever, every one of these same people will take and say "what did you expect me to do? I've got a business to run." Because for the vast majority of them, complaining about welfare was never about their taxes, or even considering the plight of the individuals who need the money. It's about the thing that they complain the "woke" masses of doing. It's virtue signaling. It was never about the money. It was about self-justification.
- prottog 4y agoIs your point that people are hypocrites by complaining about welfare and turning around and taking welfare for themselves when it's offered with no strings attached? I suppose the hypocrisy is true, but it also doesn't come with a lot of weight. It'd be like pointing out that the people who post "no human being is illegal" signs on their lawns don't actually take in refugees or vagrants in their homes. I don't know about welfare being the root of all evil, but there are valid discussions to be had on that topic from people arguing in good faith, and I think it's perfectly justified for someone to feel that their taxes are too high or that welfare benefits provide too much.
- Aunche 4y agoI don't like PPP forgiveness, but at least it was voted on by Congress. Also, student loan forgiveness is literally fueling the problem that it's trying to solve. It will increase the willingness to pay of people of college, so colleges will increase tuition. Unlike businesses that reinvest their money to expand, colleges reinvest their money to chase prestige, so they have no incentive to keep prices constant.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAFAICT, there's nothing stopping the government from charging recipients with fraud even after the loan is forgiven.
- PopAlongKid 4y agoIRS advises that improperly forgiven Paycheck Protection Program loans are taxable https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-advises-that-improperly-forgiven-paycheck-protection-program-loans-are-taxable https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-advises-that-improperly-for...
- bombcar 4y agoThis is what people forget. The mills of the gods grind slowly, but they grind exceeding fine - the government will slowly gather data and eventually charge some of the most egregious examples of fraud. Sadly, this usually is the people who tried a fraud for the first time instead of those who are experts at repeated frauds. Nobody follows the letter of the law like someone violating the spirit.
- kotlin2 4y agoThat just seems so unlikely. There were so many PPP loans (over 10 million forgiven). The government can't possibly go through even a small percentage of the fraudulent loans with enough rigor to build a compelling case of fraud. We'll be lucky if they reach 1000 cases of fraud.
- 4y ago
- BWStearns 4y agoWhen I was in college in DC during the financial crisis, friends and I were at a bar and some guy comes in and pays the whole bar's tabs. Shouted "TARP MONEY!" and leaves. Pretty sure that guy was doing some fraud, but he was nice enough to share so I guess that's something. It's hard to make a program like that quick enough to be effective without allowing fraud so I get the free for all style distribution. But especially with programs like TARP/PPP where the recipients are generally _already wealthy_ and the payments are relatively large, I'd like to see some after-the-fact scrutiny where people who commit fraud are punished, otherwise it reinforces the impression that money buys impunity.
- CrazyStat 4y ago> But especially with programs like TARP/PPP where the recipients are generally _already wealthy_ and the payments are relatively large, I'd like to see some after-the-fact scrutiny where people who commit fraud are punished, otherwise it reinforces the impression that money buys impunity. This is happening, it's just slow. For example [1]. [1] https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/california-man-sentenced-over-11-years-27-million-ppp-fraud-scheme https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/california-man-sentenced-over...
- alistairSH 4y agot's hard to make a program like that quick enough to be effective without allowing fraud... Wasn't that the reasoning behind structuring PPP as loans? Get the money out as a loan, then forgive/not-forgive later after the borrower submits paperwork proving the funds were used appropriately. It appears that second phase isn't happening - the government is just forgiving everything.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- panarky 4y agoI don't know if that was ever stated as the rationale, but many people inferred that it was. It's a defensive inference, to defend our belief that authorities wouldn't attempt to solve a crisis by just transferring a trillion dollars from lower rungs on the economic latter directly to higher rungs on the ladder. We want to believe that the distribution of wealth is caused by individual behavior, that every person deserves their station in life however opulent or impoverished. We want to ignore the systems of power and privilege that exploit the low to further enrich the high. But PPP strips away even the veneer of fairness and lays bare the brutal mechanics of wealth distribution based on power instead of contribution or merit. Perhaps the reason PPP was structured as loans instead of grants was to maintain that fig leaf of fairness, to allow us to continue to defend the indefensible.
- fasteddie31003 4y agoWas it a mistake to drop interest rates to 0 and give out free money to business owners during a pandemic? I think monetary and fiscal policy overreacted to the pandemic, but we'll never hear from anyone in power that it was a mistake. I don't think our government leaders have learned anything.
- testfoobar 4y agoIt was a massive over reaction and a massive mistake. Inflation now is a direct consequence of indiscriminate spending. Politicians do not seem to understand basic economics. E.g. California's inflation relief checks going out right now.
- yojo 4y agoThis is correct in hindsight. At the time, a lot of smart people were forecasting economic armageddon. Businesses screwed up too; big, well financed companies like Airbnb did massive layoffs. My superhost acquaintance went on to have her best year ever. None of this excuses the lack of oversight, but the initial overreaction may have been rational. Inflation related stimulus is of course farcical.
- fasteddie31003 4y agoI think the overreaction should not be viewed as "rational" from a hindsight perspective. Society should learn from its mistakes.
- yojo 4y agoWhen you have a systemic shock with unknown impact, rational can still be ultimately wrong. If there’s a 50% chance of total economic meltdown, and you can avert it with a few years of high inflation, that might still be the correct decision, even if the doomsday scenario doesn’t come true.
- 4y ago
- stvswn 4y agoFraud aside, which is a problem, the "forgiveness" of the loans was the plan all along so it's not as if businesses were expected to pay them back. The program was really a bailout so businesses could maintain their payrolls when everything was shutdown. Instead of writing the checks directly, the government decided to frame it as a loan that would be forgiven if businesses stayed in business and spent it on their payrolls. This was a good strategy for the government, because it would have been pretty tough to enforce otherwise. So the loan forgiveness was by _design_ and the point of the program was to keep businesses alive when the governments themselves were (for perhaps good reason) making it impossible for them to operate. It's not really "forgiveness" in the sense of, say, the college loan forgiveness program.
- brightball 4y agoExactly. You kept people employed and on their employers insurance, benefits, etc. You let businesses try to remain as operational as possible during the shut down. The alternative was going to be mass layoffs, unemployment and medicaid/aca applications. The people who keep harping on PPP seem to forget everything else that was done in the same time period.
- nrmitchi 4y agoThere’s a difference between people complaining about PPP as a concept (which I don’t think many are?) and complaining about PPP abuse, funds being given to companies that were not impacted by shut downs, straight up fraud, and people taking PPP money and buying lambos.
- tastyfreeze 4y agoThere was another alternative of not forcing businesses to shut down in the first place.
- hirvi74 4y agoFrom what I have gathered, 1.06 million Americans have died from Covid. Are you implying that more people should have been sacrificed to keep businesses profiting?
- testfoobar 4y agoIndiscriminate programs like PPP were a direct contributor to the inflation we see today.
- 1MachineElf 4y agoAs was the indiscriminate shutdowns of US businesses during the pandemic - the PPP raison d'être.
- some_random 4y agoIt's been interesting seeing people freak out about the stimulus checks and student debt forgiveness and just... forget about PPP. I don't get it.
- ryandrake 4y agoIt's also interesting that politicians want to means-check every penny that goes to the general public, including the stimulus and debt forgiveness but also welfare, food stamps, medicaid, and so on. It's imperative that nobody is taking advantage of the system! But when it comes to PPP and other handouts to corporations, suddenly they have no way to means-check or figure out in some other way whether the recipient actually needs it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ProfessorLayton 4y agoInterestingly this is missing an important piece of context that led to PPP in the first place: A novel worldwide pandemic that was/is killing a lot of people and forced businesses to close — causing an immediate and brutal financial emergency for small businesses in particular. Small businesses account for roughly 60% of all jobs in the U.S. Yes, adding processes to reduce fraud would've been helpful in reducing waste, but how do you suppose that should've happened? What kind of infrastructure do we have to means test that many businesses? Could it have happened within a typical pay period or two? How were workers/businesses supposed to eat and pay bills until then?
- houstonn 4y agoIt is interesting how stimulus checks and PPP aren't treated the same way. However, debt forgiveness is not the same. The government did not compel students into debt. They did compel businesses to close and people to lose their income.
- anon291 4y agoTo be clear... I support stimulus checks and PPP, but not student loan forgiveness. I do believe that those whose educations wer disrupted by the pandemic should be compensated by having their loans forgiven. This has to do with government mandates causing monetary harm.
- josefresco 4y agoAnecdotally (of course) of the handful of business owners that I know (personally) who received PPP funds, 75% of them didn't need the loan and all of them had their loans forgiven. Some of these businesses had their best years ever (revenue).
- giarc 4y agoThere was probably a lot of "I'm going to get mine" attitude, but I also suspect many took the loans in anticipation of needing them. Remember, very smart people said the economy was going to get destroyed so it would be prudent for businesses to prepare. If you didn't need the loan, but were told to prepare for the worst, why wouldn't you get the loan?
- meroes 4y agoSame. Someone I know claimed he/the owners received $5 million for a single restaurant location over the pandemic. The owners didn't "need it" unless you count not being less wealthy by pumping in their own money a need. But hey, that's the system and they chose to play it. Maybe a requirement to post on the physical business how much pandemic money they've got would be an easy middle ground. I'm glad he told me though so I can I understand what really keeps businesses going.
- boole1854 4y agoSince we're sharing anecdotes... Anecdotally of the handful of business owners that I know personally who received PPP funds (3 businesses total), all needed the loan, used it to maintain payroll, and all of them had their loans forgiven.
- vkou 4y agoSince we're sharing anecdotes, anecdotally, the only business owner I know personally who received PPP funds (My wife's employer) needed the loan, kept everyone on the payroll, paying them to do nothing, until PPP funds ran out, and once that happened, laid off half the staff. He then continued running the business at a loss, paying out of his own pocket for the next year and only now has returned to something resembling profitability. Why was the business operating at a loss? Because of the social changes brought about by COVID, it took over a year after the mandates were lifted for his customers to return to the status quo.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Proven 4y ago
- treis 4y agoThis article is really misleading. The study they cite says: >Overall, we find 1.41 million questionable loans representing $64.2 billion in capital with our primarƒy measures. These measures inevitably contain some false positives, which would lead to overstatements, and some flagged loans may have been legitimately eligible for smaller loans. However, the measures also miss many forms of suspicious lending, and sensitivity analysis indicates this total is likely substantially understated. Slightly lowering the threshold on the high implied compensation and considering excess loans in industry-county pairs beyond the number of establishments reported by the U.S. Census results in a total suspicious lending estimate of $117.3 billion. So 64.2 or 117.3 out of 800 billion is suspicious at some level. That doesn't mean the entire value of those loans is fraud. Just that they were goosed to increase payout. So anywhere from a few percent to 15 percent. Which for how large and how fast is actually pretty darn good. The real scandal here is that it was an ill-conceived program. The political powers at the time acted like we'd lock down for a few weeks and then everything would go back to normal. But that was pretty obviously not going to happen. Ultimately PPP had a marginal effect on what businesses survived. Most of the ones that did would have anyways. PPP was just money directly into those owners' pocket. Even worse, lots of businesses went gang busters during Covid. So most of this PPP money went to the winners of the Covid economy instead of the losers. It was just one gigantic blunder.
- spookthesunset 4y ago> The political powers at the time acted like we'd lock down for a few weeks and then everything would go back to normal. I mean we should have. It was quite clear very early on that the computer models predicting 4% IFRs were off by almost an order of magnitude.
- treis 4y agoEven if we legally went back to normal that doesn't mean consumer demand would have gone back to normal. It was pretty clear that it wouldn't have gone back to normal until the vaccine was rolled out.
- 4y ago
- ck2 4y agoCrowdsource finding individual fraudsters with a bounty per successful prosecution. Is there a statute-of-limitation on prosecution?
- GartzenDeHaes 4y agoPoliticians are not stupid and they are not incompetent. These laws were very effective at their intended purpose of helping political cronies steal the money. Whether it's emergency flu fighting F35's or programs for the homeless that do not help the homeless, these results are intentional.
- fwipsy 4y agoAnyone else seeing massive memory usage (multiple gigabytes) in Firefox under Ubuntu on opening this page?
- ranprieur 4y agoStop using the word "forgiven". Borrowing money is not morally wrong. A better word is "canceled".
- ontehuontuheou 4y agoThe etymology is instructive. for-give https://www.etymonline.com/word/forgive https://www.etymonline.com/word/forgive The reason it's associated with morality is because the idea of wronging someone implies that the one who is wronged is owed something. By offering forgiveness, what was owed is remitted. This also applies in the idea of sin, an offense against that which is divine. And it applies in the context of a loan, where one party is owed something by another. So, in the concept of forgiveness, it is the owing that is important. Any implication of morality is incidental. But, also, there are indeed moral systems that consider borrowing money to be wrong. Although that's uncommon, and perhaps you were arguing that those moral systems are incorrect.
- chatterhead 4y ago
- shagymoe 4y agoThis is straight up theft.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gumby 4y agoThis shuldn't be a surprise: they were always grants de facto. They were simply implemented by wedging them into an existing program which was a loan program. If anything is surprising it's that less than 100% weren't forgiven. As for fraud, well, the feds know how to prosecute it whether it was for a loan or a grant.
- victor106 4y agoPPP is one of the biggest frauds in modern America. How could the US government allow this to happen is beyond me. https://youtu.be/LhhoQbzupug https://youtu.be/LhhoQbzupug
- jesuspiece 4y agoBut student loan forgiveness is the problem, sure
- stylefinance 4y agoNEED AN INSTANT LOAN HELP TODAY? £$€R 10 000 - £$€R 50 000 000. Fix Rate AT 2% Flexible repayment terms. *Apply Now. Qualify Now. GET PAID! NOW (Terms & Conditions applies) Nationwide Financial assistance. lifestylemarketingfinance@gmail.com WhatsApp: +27724423389 Sincerely.