3 ms·
> Well, they're doing something right when a median home costs $272k compared to the $1.5m one needs to live in the Bay Area growing up here. You can get a hou
by seanmcdirmid 4y ago
> Well, they're doing something right when a median home costs $272k compared to the $1.5m one needs to live in the Bay Area growing up here.
You can get a house for $75k (median) if you want in Gary Indiana. I'm not sure how lower housing prices can be directly correlated with "doing things more right".
- volkk 4y agoisn't Gary Indiana a failed city? I would imagine Houston as relatively thriving given work, safety and industry levels?
- Entinel 4y agoYou're missing the point. They are saying Houston having lower housing prices is not an indicator that Houston is "doing something right."
- volkk 4y agoi'm not missing anything, i'm just pointing out that using Gary doesn't make any sense. if you're going to use other cities to counter the OP's point, then choose something like Dallas or Tampa, or Miami. Gary is literally decrepit.
- Entinel 4y agoThat is the point you are missing. It is not just about price of homes but quality of life while the OP is just comparing $ vs $ when there is more to it than that.
- volkk 4y agoi am saying that the example of Gary doesn't prove that Houston ISN'T a thriving city only based on housing costs. you need to use a city that is a bit more comparable to Houston to drive the point that low housing costs don't equate with a successfully run city. it's a bit like someone arguing that Land Rovers are bad cars because they are built poorly, and then someone else coming in and saying well at least they don't cost the amount that a lamborghini costs, they must be doing something right. and then a third person coming into that argument and saying "well, actually you can't use price because a bicycle costs 200$ and that doesn't mean a bicycle is better than a Land Rover based on price alone" ...the point they're driving could be correct, but the comparison is apples to oranges. you can't compare bicycles to cars to drive the point, just like i wouldn't use Gary to make the argument that low prices does not mean a thriving city. a better argument would be to use something that is comparable to a Land Rover (Houston) like say, a car that is within 10-20k range that does the job but is still largely a piece of crap to argue your point that price alone doesn't dictate success.
- api 4y agoThe difference is that Houston has more diverse and better job opportunities yet still has reasonably affordable housing. There are tons of places with very cheap housing and no jobs. Nobody moves there except maybe a few teleworkers looking to optimize hard for surplus or people with other reasons to go there like family ties.
- nilkn 4y agoHouston is the home of the US oil & gas industry and has one of the largest and most advanced medical centers in the world. There's a lot of money in Houston, and the city has incredibly ritzy neighborhoods like River Oaks and Piney Point Village, among many others; keeping overall housing relatively affordable with so many affluent people competing for it actually is an accomplishment.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoI'm sure Houston works for you, but it just isn't the happening place on many people's radars. We could split hairs about its benefits; e.g. * Economy comes and goes with natural resource boom bust cycle. * America's most obese city * A huge sprawl with bad traffic and poor public transportation There are other cities that match some of those qualities that I don't much care for, but I can see why a lot of people wouldn't mind and go for the cheap housing there as a decent trade off. But in my original comment, my only point was that you can't judge how great a city is based on how cheap its real estate is (and the correlation often goes the opposite way).
- nilkn 4y agoThe most expensive house listing for Gary right now seems to be for $575k; for Houston, it's $20 million, a difference of 35x. The average sale price in Piney Point Village is apparently just under $3.7 million (https://www.har.com/pineypointvillage/realestate https://www.har.com/pineypointvillage/realestate) and the average rent is $8500/month. So on and so forth. I think you're imagining all Houston real estate as cheap/affordable, when in reality the city has lots of extremely expensive real estate. It just also has affordable housing due to widespread construction of townhomes, apartments, and condos. Something like Gary just isn't comparable.
- selectodude 4y agoGary is a suburb of Chicago and comparing it to Greater Houston seems a bit absurd. Chicagoland has many units that are listed for $15+ million.
- crawl_soever 4y agoI live in Gary and there are many factors that can factor into the economics here, mainly a single employer planning the entire city and that employer collapse. A house is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it
- Maursault 4y ago> A house is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it Are you kidding? Its easily worth twice that. Wait until I show you the upgrades, new paint and wall to wall carpet. The bathroom's been renovated with new fixtures, and that is genuine imported Mexican tile. You'd be a fool to pass on this. Just think of the possibilities.
- sershe 4y agoExcept Houston is a fast-growing city, and Gary is a dying city. Houston managed to keep housing affordable while growing faster than most/all major cities.