4 ms·
The web is an everything app, and despite capture by incumbents it is still the most open platform we have and it is not illiberal. The reason for that is open
by seydor 4y ago
The web is an everything app, and despite capture by incumbents it is still the most open platform we have and it is not illiberal. The reason for that is open standards that are not owned by anyone. We need open identity standards and open payment standards so we can have an everything web that is liberal. But governments have to allow those things to happen. Right now their legislation favors the incumbent monopolies
- smoldesu 4y ago> But governments have to allow those things to happen. I very much doubt that. Hell, I think the government would be all-for open payment standards as long as they're dollar-based and conform to tax legislation. The real roadblocks are the current protocol-holders like Apple and Google - their ability to profit off these technologies leave them in direct opposition to what you consider progress. And if iOS/Android doesn't adopt your open standards, you can forget about the general public adopting it.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> Hell, I think the government would be all-for open payment standards as long as they're dollar-based and conform to tax legislation. The ones that are in favor of that already have open payment systems running (a lot do). If your country does not have one of those nowadays, it's because it's not important for the government.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> the government would be all-for open payment standards The caveat to that is to have regulated players the gov can control up to a point. Basically official banks. Since the dawn of commerce governing entities have made critical efforts to regulate circulating money, there's no reason our current govs would allow that aspect to get out of their hand without a fight (that's basically why Facebook's crypto effort got canned)
- afarrell 4y agoThe government would also want such a system to conform to anti-money-laundering and sanctions regulations.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoGreat!
- smoldesu 4y agoMoney laundering/sanctions laws apply regardless of the currency you use.
- afarrell 4y agoYes, and governments prefer technology reduces the cost of legal compliance.
- surge 4y agoYou haven't been paying attention. Or you're going by what they say, not what they do. Donations to wikileaks getting shutdown by payment providers under government pressure because they didn't like the journalism coming out of it exposing their wrong doings, donations to any inconvenient cause.
- collegeburner 4y agono, it wouldn't. the government wants to be able to freeze and seize and track money too. this is why it doesn't like crypto, or facebucks, or e-gold etc. because the government always wants control. so the next generation of digital payments will be made to run off fedwire (not shitting on it specifically, it's not a bad idea by itself) and later some CBDC. next time the canadians have a civil disobedience problem they will not have to go to a bank to freeze money. they will just do it directly.
- seydor 4y agoYes, we have to make it happen Governmnets are A-OK with outsourcing the police, secret services, public order etc to Google and Apple. It's cheap for them and easy , and nobody complaints. It shouldn't be any of those
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- iudqnolq 4y agoThat's not the definition of a everything app everyone is using for the purpose of this discussion. "app" has the colloquial meaning of an icon on your device that you tap on that opens a thingy controlled by a company.
- hunterb123 4y agoPlatform !== app (though platforms can have bundled apps) Browsers started as a document reader app, now they are deploy platforms as well. You need to develop apps with functionality for either OS or web platforms, or both.
- eptcyka 4y agoThere's Akamai, Fastly, Cloudflare, AWS and Googles CDNs and what else? To be able to serve an everything app to enough people for it to be relevant, the web platform, whilst clearly having a lot more choice than mobile or PC platforms, is not necessarily the panacea of liberty.
- bombcar 4y agoYou can serve the thousands or tens of thousands of users without any of those (it's harder, and more expensive, but it's not impossible). And once you're bigger than that, you start having other options available to you if you must avoid those. Especially if you stay away from video, it's not insanely hard. HN itself is two servers, IIRC.
- eptcyka 4y agoHN is not an everything app. If you want to serve images and preserve UX across a country like the states, you'll want a CDN.
- bornfreddy 4y agoWeb is not an app. Chrome is, and the dangers in this article apply neatly to a single-browser market.
- chrischen 4y agoChrome has a worrying share of the desktop market but luckily most people probably browse on their phones these days.
- DoktorDelta 4y agoChrome has a similar market share on mobile as well, especially since it's the built-in browser for Android
- chrischen 4y agohttps://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/mobile/united-states-of-america https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/mobile/unite... Not similar. Significantly lower. In fact, it’s not even number one because Android is a lot less popular in the US.
- Khalos 4y agoIf anything the mobile browser situation is much worse. On one major platform, there is Chrome by default (so even bigger market share issues). People can install other browsers, but far fewer do than even on desktop. For those that do, most use the Play Store which has some conflict of interest concerns. On the other platform it's even worse. The only option is Safari and the conflict of interest is fully realized because other browsers aren't even allowed on the App Store
- Mikeb85 4y agoWhere is there Chrome by default? Because Samsung is the #1 Android vendor and the default browser on Samsung devices is Samsung's own browser...
- kodah 4y agoOpen standards tend to lag behind innovation for a variety of reasons. If there's a point of increased capture, I'm guessing the time between introducing an "everything app" and open standards would be the capture window. That might be something to be concerned about, though I think we can only hypothesize what momentary capture to that degree would do. It's also worth pointing out, to the contrary, that unlike China the US markets are highly fractionalized. Some companies have tried to homogenize certain parts of the market, like Plaid, Stripe, etc but their homogenization is generally small when you look at the wider landscape. That's to say, to build an everything app and not start from scratch you'd have to buy many companies worth in the hundreds of millions and billions in order to build the conglomerate that could even shade this idea as "maybe possible".
- unethical_ban 4y agoNo, a global network of computers and programs is not an App. No single entity owns or operates it, and the few layers of the platform that do have dominance of it are very content neutral (TLS, DNS). One app that controls banking, P2P communications and mass media, with little to no competition, is a threat that should be protected against by law, if necessary.
- toiletfuneral 4y ago
- redbell 4y agoI, always [and still], believe that the web is the most open platform, but a while ago, I hit this [1], entitled "Gatekeepers: These tech firms control what’s allowed online". Only then did I start questioning my assumptions. I mean, while it is still the most open platform, the question I raised was "How far is it open?" [1].https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/03/24/online-moderation-tech-stack/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/03/24/online-...
- dylan604 4y ago>while it is still the most open platform that people have used to create closed systems that act as if there is nothing outside of its walls. if you drew a map of the "internet" so that closed systems (apps) with their walls are cities and everything else is unexplored areas marked with "here be dragons", then you'd see there's a lot more land mass outside of those closed systems.
- seydor 4y agoin principle, you can sidestep them, because they are gatekeepers only to their own garden, so the web is still in principle open, and it's one of the few systems that are still open. But if you do something they dont like or something they will shut you out. Or if you do something governments dont like, they will compell them to shut you out. This is the problem, our democracies are still supposed to be liberal. It will take political effort to change that very bad habit This is 2022. We can't pretend our governmnets can be tech illiterate anymore, and we should not be allowing it
- redbell 4y agoExcellent workaround indeed!
- uncomputation 4y ago> open identity standards and open payment standards Ah, but that won’t line Elon Musk’s pockets.