8 ms·
Back to Android for the time being
- jeffrallen 4y ago> In addition, it'll crash while taking or making calls. Thanks for giving me flashbacks to my Hiptop days. I loved messing with the apps, and the camera. My friends pointed out that a phone that had a flip put keyboard and apps but often crashed while being a phone was not much of a phone. :) Luckily the Hiptop crew went on to make Android, which got to be rock solid, eventually!
- Tijdreiziger 4y agoWell... rock solid, except that sometimes it crashes when trying to call emergency services. https://www.androidpolice.com/google-pixel-phones-struggling-to-reach-emergency/ https://www.androidpolice.com/google-pixel-phones-struggling...
- simonh 4y agoA lot of problems obviously, many of which would be deal breakers for anyone, but the author expresses a strong emotional bias towards the phone. Unfortunately they don't say why, I'd really be interested in knowing what the advantages are of the phone that make it so loved despite all these issues. After all, some of us might be interested in having one as an additional device either for fun or as for the additional utility it might provide.
- Roark66 4y agoI too have a (fairly) strong emotional bias towards pine products. I can tell you why. For one, pine is the only manufacturer I know of that managed to obtain and release real down to register level documentation for the hardware they use. We have very comprehensive documentation from rockchip (a lot of it in Chinese, but auto translation tools are good enough). They publish schematics for everything. They let you download source code for so called "proprietary" drivers that work with old versions of Linux kernel. All this means, for a tinkerer/hobbyist one can do stuff that is simply impossible on any other hardware that has comparable performance (basically modern 64bit embedded systems like those in newest mobile phones). Then there is all the time we(hobbyists/devs) spend tinkering with this hardware. When one invests so much time into some product it is hard to just let it go. However, having said all that I would never use an unfinished product as my main phone. If I had a pine phone I woukd probably carry it as a secondary, but those devices are nowhere near the state people can rely on them in case of emergency.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- linmob 4y agoAs a person that spends way too much time on these efforts[0], here's what makes the phone still worthwhile to me despite being slow and at times buggy: It's nice to be in an ecosystem that does not have ad frameworks, that does not nudge you into using iCloud or where you have to use Play Services (or invest time into building around not having them (and more than once, did that for years)) for apps to work properly. (That aside, I have not had the problems OP describes - but the worst problems with PinePhone (outside of highly experimental software) I suffered through where with Manjaro.) [0]: https://linmob.net https://linmob.net, https://linuxphoneapps.org https://linuxphoneapps.org
- MikusR 4y agoLooks to be an old article reposted with new date: >Even running on the latest Manjaro build, as of September 2019, the phone is just ... crashy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- megous 4y agoThe phone's SW was unstable when not even developer editions were avialable in September 2019... :) Who would have guessed.
- Roark66 4y agoThe reason why modern smartphones have such good camera picture quality is primarily thanks to the ISP profiles developed by teams of people for the particular sensor in use. ISP is an imaging signal processor, a component of most mobile SOCs that sits between the camera and the rest of the system. It is a proprietary component that is essentially a black box controlled with a "profile" for specific camera chip. The profile specifies how to debayer, denoise, sharpen, color correct, adjust brightness and autofocus of the chip. Without a very good profile even a good camera sensor output will look like crap. I've spent few weeks of my (spare) time improving a Sony imx219 driver for a Rockchip rk3566 cpu that is used in few pine devices I own. I needed high fps video (I managed to get 120fps 720p - I think I could push it further to 140 perhaps, but this was OK for now) and as low latency as I could get. I wanted <20ms as I could encode 720p h264 frames in 7ms,unfortunately I got stuck with ISP (image signal processor) adding 40ms of latency even when in pass through mode. The modern ISP is a "black box" even with source code for the drivers. In addition every single ISP has its own proprietary format for those profiles. There are OS projects that try to make universal camera sensor profiles that work with multiple ISPs (libcamera for one), but it is still early days. What we need is a truly programmable/flexible isp. As it stands the only way to get sub 40ms of latency from a camera for a hobbyist is to use an fpga...
- pluc 4y ago
- megous 4y agoThe Pinephone Pro ISP is documented in RK3399 TRM (part3), and in various PDFs available online. It's not really a huge blackbox. It does not make the calibration (or preparation of profiles for various light conditions) easy though. There's a need for a bunch of HW tooling that is somewhat expensive for a hobbyist. And there's a lot of work and algorithm design that needs to be done outside of ISP for controling the autofocus, autoexpsoure and detection of type lighting in the scene and profile switching. None of this is particularly trivial.
- abxytg 4y ago
- pwinnski 4y agoI really appreciate seeing people committed to the open source or free software causes so much that they accept very clearly inferior experiences. I also really appreciate seeing that for some people, there are limits to just how inferior they are willing for those experiences to be. Very relatable. Thank you. from my closed-source iPhone 14 Pro
- mellosouls 4y agoTo test your hypothesis I just googled the articles Pixel 2 vs it's competitor iPhone 8. In both the top two search results the Pixel (narrowly) bested the iPhone, so looks like maybe a bit of rose-tinted brand-owners perspective in your case?
- pwinnski 4y agoWhen I spoke of inferior experiences, I was referring to the Pine Phone, not the Pixel 2. I'm sorry that wasn't clear! That said, the iPhone 8 is still supported by Apple (probably for the last year), while the Pixel 2, like the Pixels 3, 4, and 5, are no longer supported by Google. This likely doesn't matter to someone not running standard Google-supplied AndroidOS, though! My use of the closed-source iPhone is not solely based on feature quality, and I've got no illusions that every feature is the best in class. P.S. Just before clicking the reply button, I decided to do the search myself, curious. The iPhone 8 was a weird model; that was the year they released both the iPhone 8 and the iPhone X, because (IMO) they lacked the courage to switch things up in their flagship product so much in one year. (Okay, and maybe also supply issues?) Still, when I DDG'd "pixel 2 iphone 8", I got results[0] that seem to not be the same as yours. The first doesn't really make any determination, the second is mealy-mouthed but seems to give an edge to Pixel 2 based primarily on price ("the Pixel 2 is a better value, starting out at about $50 and £70 cheaper than the iPhone 8" vs "you'll actually get more bang for your buck with the iPhone 8"), and the third, well, it's right in the title: "iPhone 8 vs. Pixel 2: Why Apple Beats Google." So I don't know, I bought an iPhone X that year rather than an iPhone 8, and just replaced that with an iPhone 14 Pro this year after five years of faithful service. But choosing a 2017 phone today, either one, while very clearly a step up from Pinephone for all the of the reasons mentioned in the article, maybe still reflects a but of compromise in service of wanting to run LineageOS. In 2017, was photo quality the same when running LineageOS rather than Google's own camera software? Maybe it was after that they started to apply more and more AI to the photo-taking process, I'm not sure. 0. https://www.techradar.com/news/google-pixel-2-vs-iphone-8 https://www.techradar.com/news/google-pixel-2-vs-iphone-8 https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/iphone-8-vs-pixel-2-phone-comparison/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/iphone-8-vs-pixel-2-phone-c... https://www.tomsguide.com/us/iphone-8-vs-pixel-2,review-4779.html https://www.tomsguide.com/us/iphone-8-vs-pixel-2,review-4779...
- commiepatrol 4y agoInteresting how this coincides with SwiftKey leaving iOS which was the only good option when it came to getting Dvorak.
- pwinnski 4y agoDid you mean for this comment to be on the post about the Dvorak keyboard in iOS 16?
- kop316 4y agoI really wish OP would try a distro other than Manjaro. But since they are, frankly, I am not at all surprised at stability issues. I do not think I have seen any of these issues on a non-Manjaro distro. For some more context: https://drewdevault.com/2022/01/18/Pine64s-weird-priorities https://drewdevault.com/2022/01/18/Pine64s-weird-priorities.... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32495274 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32495274 Manjaro consistently applies incomplete and WIP patches into their builds, causing that sort of instability. Every time I have had a strange issue filed in a program I maintain, it has been traced back to Manjaro doing something like that.
- jm4 4y agoManjaro sucks. The thing is, it's really nice out of the box - frankly, it's probably the nicest OOB experience. Their desktop looks great and the layout switcher is cool. I also like the utility that lets you choose different kernel versions. The pamac package manager is great (if you ignore the fact that it has some problems with the way it works with AUR). Unfortunately, it has all kinds of problems under the hood that will eventually bite the kind of user Manjaro is trying to attract. It's a strange situation where one has to be familiar with Arch to understand why Manjaro isn't working. IMO, Manjaro should take the Endeavour route and just use the upstream repositories. Manjaro does a lot right and brings some good ideas, but they are really lacking on the reliability and professionalism fronts.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI don't understand why these users all love pain. Use Ubuntu or Fedora and just be done with it. The further off the beaten path you go the more of a pain in the ass things get.
- retskrad 4y ago
- mavhc 4y agoNot sure how either of those things mean Apple has won. Samsung outsells Apple, which has only 20% of sales.
- Sunspark 4y agoIt hasn't won at all. One reason I use Android is because it has apps I use that don't exist on iOS. File explorer, h/w accelerated video player w/ codec support, manga reader, etc. iMessage doesn't mean anything to me anymore. Apple waited too long and didn't open it up when they should have, same mistake BlackBerry made.
- Tijdreiziger 4y agoFile explorer exists on iOS. Manga reader - there are options, but less convenient than on Android.
- nehal3m 4y agoOne reason I use Android that has no viable replacement on iOS is call recording. I deal with government officials a lot and I want to hold them accountable (I live in a nation with one-party consent laws, in the sense that I only need my own permission to record a conversation). iOS will not let you do this natively, you have to add a call recording service via a three-way call whereas I can do this out of the box with /e/OS on a Fairphone.
- butz 4y agoAndroid is steadily going downhill, even using older Android version on 3 year old device. I wanted to install an application from "external source", so I downloaded it from F-Droid and tried using Total Commander to install it, like I did some time ago (I rarely install new apps though, especially ones from external sources). And guess what? Total Commander removed install functionality, because of risk from being removed from Google Play Store. Just great, now this makes TC less useful and requires me to use Google's own "Files" application, which I had replaced with Total Commander... Not to mention how Google Play app UI has degraded: now half of app updates screen is taken up by unremovable banner asking me to enable automatic app updates, otherwise I might "lose your right to make legal claims". Not sure what the future brings, but probably even more limitations. My next phone will probably be a "dumb phone", and all saved money I will spend on decent camera.
- rthomas6 4y agoI've had good luck so far with GrapheneOS. I still have Google Play but it only has normal app permissions, and it's in its own user profile that stays off unless I need to use an app that uses Google Play. I can install from external sources just fine, including the built in browser. Google Play Store is also an external source with Graphene's setup.
- butz 4y agoThank you for suggestion. I'll look into GrapheneOS, from first glance it seems to be something that I need.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoFiles is an Android system app included in AOSP
- pooper 4y agoYou are both right. com.android.documentsui is included in AOSP. com.google.android.apps.nbu.files is Google's app on the play store.
- stiray 4y agoUnrelated to android, but I would just like to mention, that today best working implementation of linux on phones is Sailfish OS ( https://sailfishos.org/ https://sailfishos.org/ - not connected with them all, but I use it as daily driver after years of searching; I was using angstrom distro on HTC Blueangel so you can imagine I have searched for long ). It would be really nice if the community would concentrate on one distribution instead supporting 674 of them and have none really usable.
- rjzzleep 4y agoI would agree and I find it sad/odd that it never really managed to get any active developer community traction.
- RussianCow 4y agoSailfish isn't fully open source, which makes the comparison to other Linux distributions moot.
- stiray 4y agoIt works, which gives everything else that doesnt work a joke prefix. I am not here to support Stallman style political warfare "who is more open source and less working". I am just stating the obvious. Sailfish works. Everything else I have seen is a non working joke, that is unusable. Feel free to prove me wrong. Not with bullshit, downvoting and PRing. URL please. Not political BSing about which project is completely open source but no one sane would use as it is completely unusable. Which is actually the topic here. Open source is great but < working phone (less than 10 years old), with usable front and back camera, 4g, phone calls that don't reset your phone, SMS messages that are actually delivered and... oh... ah... Bruce Almighty... working fingerprint reader.
- RussianCow 4y agoI'm sorry I touched a nerve. :) We already have a "working" Linux distribution for mobile devices: Android. But what projects like Pine and Librem are trying to do is build an alternative that is 100% open source (or as close as reasonably possible) and does not rely on proprietary, third-party services. If that's not important to you, that's fine, but don't dismiss the progress that's been made. Some of us actually care about this stuff. :) I'm also not sure how Sailfish is relevant to this discussion at all while Android exists and is the dominant (non-iOS) mobile platform.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoWhy is the camera so bad? I know author says the sensor is bad but I suspect it is more than that. It amazes me to see what raw images look like coming off a CCD and then what software stacks like the one in the iPhone (and apparently Pixel) will do to get such an amazing final result. I think there is a lot of secret sauce that perhaps is lacking in the Pine software stack.
- linmob 4y agoDefinitely, the GNU/Linux software stack needs improvement for everything that's not a UVC Webcam. libcamera is a relevant project in that context. Purism, who make the Librem 5, are working on that - they have a paid team, but it's small so this will take a bit. That said, the PinePhone camera app, Megapixels, recently got better post-processing thanks to postprocessd, which may have landed in OPs Manjaro or not.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoI assumed this was a "goodbye, iphone" thing, but instead it's switching from Pinephone back to Android.