9 ms·
Why 23.976 and not 24 FPS? (2016)
- quickthrower2 4y agoThis morning I was trying to get a monitor working a noticed the 60 and 59.94 options in Windows, and wondered what the 59.94 was all about. Now I know!
- petee 4y agoGreat answer for where 29.97 came from, but I seem to be missing the explanation of 23.976 fps which is suddenly introduced as just an effect of audio post, but not how or why exactly... Edit: more specifically, if audio was being converted to NTSC for dailies, why would it be 23.976 and not 29.97?
- cammikebrown 4y agoIt’s the same ratio. 30/29.97 = 24/23.976
- johntb86 4y agoThe traditional frame rate for film is 24fps, which is converted using 3:2 pulldown to 30 fps. 23.976 fps converts using 3:2 pulldown to 29.97 fps (23.976*30/24=29.97).
- Tempest1981 4y agoWhile reading about 3:2 pulldown, I saw that for PAL (25 fps) there is 2:2:3:2:3 pulldown to 30 fps.
- dylan604 4y agobut rarely does anyone actually do this. normally, a 4% speed change is done to get the frame rate to match. as for the audio, it totally depends on how much effort someone put into it to correct the pitch so that the frequencies are the same in both frame rates. typically, nope. things sound higher pitched in 25fps than they do at the original 24 or 24000/1001 frame rates
- anigbrowl 4y agoI remember living in the UK 20 years ago when my friend had got into Buffy the Vampire Slayer. He insisted I watch some episodes. But because the target demographic was 'nerdy night owls' on a non-prestige TV channel, they cheaped out on the conversion and by the end of each 45 minute episode the dialog had gone badly out of sync. My friend insisted I was just imagining it, but only one of us went on to have a career doing post-production in the US market. To be completely frank I've looked down on UK/EU broadcast techs a little ever since because being able to set everything to 25fps and forget about it is easy street.
- dylan604 4y agoI've made a career of taking pull down sequences out of videos to prep for DVD->Blu-ray->streaming. Where others have failed, I have properly restored. "Others" for example are FAANG's streaming services. Everyone wants it to be a single button IVTC, "set it and forget it" like you said. Shot on 24fps film, edited at 29.97 with pull down where every edit is a break in cadence, 30i graphics/bumpers, and some shows (I'm looking at you The Shield) where they shot 30fps film for a special look/feel during certain scenes, and a set-it-forget IVTC will not do well at all.
- ajanuary 4y ago> To be completely frank I've looked down on UK/EU broadcast techs a little ever since because being able to set everything to 25fps and forget about it is easy street. My experience has been the reverse. Because they can, people in UK/EU have historically cared much more about frame accuracy. It’s only in the last 10 years or so that people in North America have started caring about frame accuracy. In the past it’s been quite hard to do because of the non integer frame rate.
- axiolite 4y agoParent was obvious talking about converting 25fps PAL video to 30fs NTSC frame rate, which happens ALL THE TIME... NOT about converting from film to PAL. You are arguing with no-one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- assttoasstmgr 4y agoBecause audio for 23.976fps film is playing at the same speed as 29.97fps video. Which is really interlaced video at 59.94 fields per second. 3:2 pulldown is used to synthesize extra video frames to transfer to NTSC video so for a given instance of time, for every 4 frames of film you get 5 frames of video. (23.976/29.97 = 4/5) The instance of time remains unchanged so the audio is playing back at the same speed. This is all inherited from the CRT days before progressive video playback on flatscreens, and the video fps was tied to the local electrical frequency (50 Hz in Europe vs 60 Hz in USA / Japan) which is how the CRT timings were derived. Coincidentally PAL video plays back at 25fps, to convert film to PAL they just speed it up from 24 to 25fps, audio and all, which is why if you watch a Euro DVD release of the same film all the actors sound like they just ingested helium before the scene because the audio is playing back ~4% faster. This was largely fixed with Blu-Ray as films play back at their native rate[1] on progressive displays but our European friends who have only seen films on VHS/DVD or TV and not in the theatre or Blu-Ray have been done a disservice, because the video and audio is sped up on playback and not as the director intended it to be shown. [1] A notable exception is some unscrupulous distributors abroad release shitty PAL 25fps Blu-Rays of films which are simply upscaled PAL DVD versions that they then market as Blu-Ray but are worse than DVD quality but at marked up prices. This is more common than you think. Official releases from the studios are encoded at 23.976fps on the disc. TV shows shot on PAL video (native 25fps) will always play back at 25fps.
- gsich 4y agoPitch correction exists.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- garaetjjte 4y agoIt's not straightforward and might introduce artifacts.
- lecoyote418 4y ago
- lykr0n 4y agoThe amount of hidden engineering in Analog systems is mind blowing. Imagine how many hours were spent in a lab figuring out the exact right timings, chemical mixtures, and circuit design needed to make modern Cinema exist as we know it.
- nmilo 4y agoSometimes it makes me sad how "boring" digital transmission is. Just pack up your data and send it over IP. Life is too easy.
- lupire 4y agoThere are plenty of difficulties hiding in the OSI stack. MTU is a fun one.
- garaetjjte 4y agoOSI stack is dead, TCP/IP won.
- katbyte 4y agoTcp/ip is only 1 layer (transport) of the osi stack..
- mvhvv 4y agoYou made me stop and question myself for a second, but this definitely isn't right. Usually when people talk about "TCP/IP" it's shorthand for the whole "Internet Protocol Suite", but even naively TCP and IP are two different layers.
- qwery 4y agoYep, the slash is meaningful. I think of writing "TCP/IP" that way as in a fraction -- "TCP over IP" or "TCP on IP". At least, that was how my brain learned it.
- Lammy 4y agoI prefer to write them as 24000/1001, 30000/1001, 60000/1001 fields-per-second to avoid the ugly decimals and because I think it makes it a little more intuitively clear what’s going on to achieve those numbers.
- VanTheBrand 4y agoBut don’t you then have to then explain this every time you try to communicate with these numbers to someone else. Are you just writing this down for yourself?
- Lammy 4y ago> Are you just writing this down for yourself? “Teachable moment” I guess? I usually use that notation in my nfo blurb when encoding DVDs for a modern flatscreen target. Anecdotally, nobody has ever asked me to clarify. Small sample size though due to niche nature.
- astrange 4y agoUnfortunately most digital video formats don’t actually store them this way, either because the editing software rounds it off incorrectly or because the format itself stores timestamps in decimals for some reason (Matroska).
- mgdlbp 4y ago<rant>Ah...Matroska was nearly perfect, and then they chose nanosecond-precision timestamps. Countless attempts at frame-perfect seeking thwarted and videos imbued with jitter over the years, subordinate to the tyranny of 33 34 33 33 34 33... Even worse, not only is the recommended precision only 1 ms, but almost all muxers support nothing else, ffmpeg included*. A shame that despite such versatility, mkv is scuffed as an intermediate/archival format by lossy muxing, yet almost no one is aware. * https://lists.ffmpeg.org/pipermail/ffmpeg-devel/2021-May/280460.html https://lists.ffmpeg.org/pipermail/ffmpeg-devel/2021-May/280... matroska precision parameter coming soon? It's been over a year, though - looks like the patch is dead. Meanwhile, the bikeshedding of rational timestamps in the matroska lists can now be expressed with a timebase of decades....
- charcircuit 4y agoThis doesn't answer the question considering NTSC isn't used anymore. Why not 60 fps considering it's the standard refresh rate of practically all displays that are in use?
- CharlesW 4y agoIf you're asking why movies aren't shot at 60 fps instead of 24/23.976 fps, there are "HFR" movies shot at higher frame rates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_with_high_frame_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_with_high_frame_... From what I can find as I write this, the only movies distributed at high-framerates on Blu-ray are Gemini Man and Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk. Although HFR is technically an improvement, not everyone's a fan of the "feel". Relevant HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14616930 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14616930
- williamcotton 4y ago24fps has an aesthetic that "looks cinematic" because we have all watched decades of cinematic films at 24fps. From jump cuts, montage and flashbacks to the color saturation and frames per second of film, you've learned an entire visual language over all of these years of watching moving pictures!
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoIn the 1970s it seemed common for tv shows to be shot on video in the studio but on film outside, perhaps because video cameras were too large or sensitive for outdoor use. The audience simply became accustomed to the large difference in appearance between indoors and outdoors in tv shows. IIRC, Doctor Who and Benny Hill went through this change during episodes frequently. It also reminds me of the first time I went over to a friend's house who had a large tube standard def tv after I had switched to HD. The scanlines that had always been invisible to my brain were suddenly very obvious. Funny how we adjust.
- retrac 4y agoApparently, many people are so used to 24 fps that films shot at higher framerates are slightly unsettling (even if they don't realize why), and have even been, ironically, described as unnatural. I've noticed it myself; I watched a YouTube video recently that was at 60 fps and my attention kept going to the hands of the person talking as he waved them around. The motion was too fluid. Slightly distracting. I guess my brain is used to interpolating what it would have looked like from a blur at 24 fps, rather than actually seeing the fine details. Though I'm sure we'll get used to it soon enough.
- jamesbfb 4y agoTechnology Connections on YouTube goes into this quite in-depth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dX649lnKAU0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dX649lnKAU0
- nayuki 4y agoStand-up Maths has a great explanation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3GJUM6pCpew https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3GJUM6pCpew "Why is TV 29.97 frames per second?"
- lecoyote418 4y agoThis post was 2016. Six years later, this is no longer true, at least here in my area (Montréal). At my work in a post-production company, we finish around 8-10 long form fiction movies a year and a bigger number of shorts, and I would say around 90% of thoses projects are now shot 24.0 fps. All high-end cameras like the ones from Arri, RED and Sony can switch easily between 23.976 and 24.0 since many years. The sound recorders can now too, like the Sound Devices, which is the most common brand used (at least here in North America). The choice of shooting in 24.0 was already available in 2016, but not every gig would be used to shoot 24.0 so they chose 23.976 just to be safe, I guess. Also, in 2016 television was still a major deliverable, but this has changed. Video on demand, which supports any framerates, is now the main distribution channel when a movie has finished playing on the big screen. Documentaries are more of an exception because they are still aimed at television and also, they often use old footage which was telecine'd at 23.976 so it's easier to edit when everything's 23.976.
- wodenokoto 4y ago> The sound recorders can now too [record at 24 fps] What does that mean? I thought 44khz sampling meant 44.000 integers are recorded per second.
- spindle 4y agoI'm guessing, because I'm bored, and hopefully an expert will confirm or correct, but I think it means that they place sync markers every 24th of a second, to make syncing with video efficient.
- comprambler 4y agoFrame sync ability?
- pushrax 4y agoProduction audio and video recorders generate or intake an SMPTE timecode signal, and stamp recordings with this timecode. This timecode format is a timestamp with seconds resolution plus a frame count within each second. To properly sync, all the timecode generators must use the same framerate. In other words, the audio recorder’s timecode framerate needs to match the camera.
- elevaet 4y agoThe difference between 23.976 and 24fps is 1.7321cents, for the musically minded.
- infamousclyde 4y agoI fear that I will always be A lonely number like root three A three is all that's good and right, Why must my three keep out of sight Beneath a vicious square root sign, I wish instead I were a nine For nine could thwart this evil trick, With just some quick arithmetic I know I'll never see the sun, as 1.7321 Such is my reality, a sad irrationality When hark! What is this I see, Another square root of a three Has quietly come waltzing by, Together now we multiply To form a number we prefer, Rejoicing as an integer We break free from our mortal bonds And with a wave of magic wands Our square root signs become unglued And love for me has been renewed.
- axiolite 4y agoIt's not actually 23.976fps. That's just the friendly, rounded notation we all use in discussion. It's actually 24000/1001, or in integers: 23.976023976023976... fps.
- elevaet 4y ago1.730369 cents then!
- bawolff 4y agoBut is therea benefit to 24? I know its a nice round number, but aren't they all arbitrary numbers anyways
- Andrex 4y agoLess human error is a meaningful benefit, even if it has nothing to do with the tech itself. A new generation is always behind us, and explaining a nice, even 24.0 to them will just be a better situation.
- FranOntanaya 4y agoOne bewildering thing that I think isn't covered there is that old Quicktime video was specified as 23.98 simply because they were using fixed precision. An apparently harmless issue until you tried reading metadata and converting frame rates assuming that just doing the maths would work.
- wdvwdvw 4y ago“… by introducing a color subcarrier of precisely 3.579545 MHz (nominally 3.58 MHz). The precise frequency …” Does anyone have a circuit diagram for any of this? What were they using as a timing reference in the 50s that allowed a frequency lock accurate to 7 significant figures? There must be a fairly large error allowed.
- klodolph 4y agoIt's 315/88. Chosen to be a half-integer multiple of the line rate. The line rate was also adjusted so that the audio subcarrier is a multiple of the line rate. The audio subcarrier is 4.5 MHz. So it's really 4.5 MHz, multiplied by 35/44. In practice, you might buy a 3.579545 MHz crystal oscillator and then use dividers and PLLs to make all the other frequencies you need. The actual error is going to be based on the oscillators you use, but for the past few decades, we've just been using ordinary crystal oscillators and that means something like 50ppm, maybe (for cheap ones). Crystal oscillators were available prior to the invention of NTSC. Quartz oscillators achieved 0.1ppm accuracy at some point in the 1920s.
- robomartin 4y agoThe answer is a bit more complex when it comes to the transition to modern high definition television. It's a bit of a long story with very interesting twists and turns that involve politics, national security, the Pentagon, US Congress and none other than Donald Rumsfeld (CIA and Defense Secretary). The story is well chronicled in a book I read about twenty years ago: https://www.amazon.com/Defining-Vision-Broadcasters-Government-Revolution/dp/0156005972 https://www.amazon.com/Defining-Vision-Broadcasters-Governme... The title is intriguing enough: "Defining Vision: How Broadcasters Lured the Government into Inciting a Revolution in Television" I can't possibly do it justice here. I'll just mention that one would not be wrong to call Donald Rumsfeld the father of high definition television. His approach to wrangling the ATSC and FCC into adopting a cornucopia of standards was, from a business perspective, nothing less than genius while, from a technical perspective, a complete mess. The fractional frame rates would have evaporated from this planet had it not been for this part of the story. Well worth reading for anyone interested in the technology or working in associated industries. Your jaw will most definitely drop as you get deeper into the story.
- Katie69 4y ago[dead]
- londons_explore 4y agoSo this probably explains why my 60 fps screen slightly jitters about once every 2-3 minutes... Looks like a dropped frame, and is really frustrating when you've spent lots of money on AV gear... 59.94 fps vs 60 fps...
- qwerty456127 4y agoI still don't understand why can this be needed when everything is digital signal received over IP and presented over HDMI nowadays. Or do many Americans still watch RF TV?
- jcpham2 4y agoNow image having these same discussions circa 2000 ish on IRC channels devoted to re encoding pirated VCD/SVCD to Microsoft’s accidentally released DiVX 3.11 alpha codec on multi pass encodings to hit 700mb exact The strangeness of PAL vs. NTSC lives on