3 ms·
Summary of the results (page 137): Protocol Sniffing Injection Plexgear Yes Yes Rapoo Yes Yes Logitech No Yes Cors
by wongarsu 4y ago
Summary of the results (page 137):
Protocol Sniffing Injection
Plexgear Yes Yes
Rapoo Yes Yes
Logitech No Yes
Corsair Yes Yes
iiglo Yes Yes
Exibel Yes Yes
Razer No No
Choice quotes from Chapter 6 (Discussion):
The results show that 9 out of 10 keyboards have at least some form of vulnerability. Out of all the keyboards, 8 of them were shown to contain new previously unknown vulnerabilities that could grant an attacker full control of the computer of the keyboard. The severity of these vulnerabilities in combination with how prevalent they are show that the usage of wireless keyboards should in no way be used in any situation where security, privacy, or integrity is of any concern whatsoever.
[...]
Out of all the keyboards, only one of them actually promised any form of encryption as part of the marketing of the keyboard and this is the Corsair K63 Wireless. The keyboard is marketed with 128-bit AES encryption but as the results of the penetration test show, this is not the case. The keyboard’s only obfuscation of the wireless transmission is a simple XOR of the payload with a static key that can potentially be reverse engineered automatically with some very simple calculations.
[...]
Razer BlackWidow V3 Pro was the only keyboard not shown to contain any vulnerability. As a result of this, it is deemed the most secure of the targeted keyboards but it could still be vulnerable to some unidentified vulnerability that requires more time and resources compared to the rest of the keyboards
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> The keyboard is marketed with 128-bit AES encryption but as the results of the penetration test show, this is not the case. The keyboard’s only obfuscation of the wireless transmission is a simple XOR of the payload with a static key This sounds like fraud to me.
- aliqot 4y ago> Fraud - the intentional use of deceit, a trick or some dishonest means to deprive another of his/her/its money, property or a legal right. You don't 'accidentally' mistake weak XOR obfuscation with AES, so this is fraud. However whether that results in any tangible legal action is debatable. I have strong doubts given the corporatocratic nature of the corporate judicial outcomes in USA. Are these sold online? Wire fraud is a common enhancement to a lot of criminal charges involving fraud taking place online or over phone.
- i_k_k 4y agoI remember thinking that XOR with a password was awesome encryption. Then again, this was back in the BBS days, 3DES was the tits, and I was thirteen.
- abeyer 4y agowell, it kind of is... it just has the unfortunate requirements that your password be the same size as your data and never get reused.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoThe other aspect is reduced trust. Razer has more than just keyboards. I trust their laptops or headphones less now than I did before.
- throwaway27727 4y agoDo you mean Corsair?
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoSorry, yeah.
- mjcohen 4y agoI use quadruple rot13 for extra security.