11 ms·
Patients can now access all their health records digitally
- pbronez 4y agoPaywall
- pessimizer 4y agoThis is great. Now let us delete them.
- leovander 4y agoGood luck with that. If the medical group you are a part of is in their regional, statewide or a country wide HIE, you'd have to check with every connected partner to see what other systems may have queried for your data and potentially have copies as well. You typically won't have your data in too many other systems unless you are hopping between different medical groups/hospitals. There's just a possibility that the above could happen because, seeing and making the sausage, I wouldn't trust anyone to be able to tell me who has seen my health records.
- ecommerceguy 4y agoOr you can request your MIB, which is basically like a credit report for healthcare. https://www.mib.com/request_your_record.html https://www.mib.com/request_your_record.html The providers I've seen have had my records online since at least 2015 so this regulation doesnt really affect me much. You just have to know who what and how to ask. I can see something like this negatively impacting what doctors say to each other.
- VadimPR 4y agoWhy?
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoPrivacy, “right to be forgotten”, self-determination, etc. seem like likely reasons for someone to want that.
- mod 4y agoYou may have read the comment the way I initially did: as "Now let us (let's) delete them" I think his meaning was "give us the right to delete them" which IMO should be the standard.
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoBecause patients should have the right to decide whether and where their confidential medical data is stored.
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoAstounding to me that anyone is downvoting this sentiment. I would love to hear some sort of rationale from anyone who believes that individuals shouldn't have the right to control who has access to their own private medical information and who stores it.
- JoshMandel 4y agoNot the down voter, but if you look through guidance from the malpractice insurance industry (e.g., https://www.thedoctors.com/articles/medical-and-dental-record-retention https://www.thedoctors.com/articles/medical-and-dental-recor...) you will see that defense against potential malpractice claims is a key driver of retention practices. Introducing a right to be forgotten in healthcare would presumably require concomitant reform of the medical malpractice landscape. I'm not arguing against the sentiment (and indeed I think patients should have a much stronger ability to audit and control how their records are shared, including the ability to opt out of sharing) -- but when it comes to records retention by the originating organization, it's important to evaluate these practices in the broader context.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shishy 4y agoNothing sets off my fuse than a clinic refusing to send me my data so I can get it to another doctor for another opinion, ESPECIALLY around cost / prognosis (well, they don't "refuse", they just delay for so long). So, so glad to hear this.
- hotpotamus 4y ago> Reminder #5 – How IB actors make EHI available for access, exchange, and use can and will vary based on who the IB actor is, their technological sophistication, and who it is that is seeking to access, exchange or use an IB actor’s EHI. > The information blocking regulations do not require IB actors to adopt or use certain technologies or platforms. IB actors may use “patient portals,” other web interfaces, application programming interfaces (APIs), and a multitude of technologies and platforms to make EHI available for access, exchange, or use. The information blocking regulations focus on practices that are likely to interfere with, prevent, or materially discourage access, exchange, or use of EHI. For example, while the information blocking regulations don’t prescribe specific technologies, how IB actors design, implement, use, or limit technologies in relation to the access, exchange, or use of EHI could implicate the information blocking regulations. This is the part I had to go looking for. I've been in this space for just a bit now, and I can tell you that like most of American healthcare, it's a shitshow. Get ready to develop an app against your doctor's EHR API if they don't expose this via a patient portal. I don't think the docs are too happy about giving you access to "their" work product, AKA your health data. And to some extent I sort of see where they're coming from - if they were photographers, they'd actually hold copyrights over images they take of you. But the goals here are at least laudable and there is some rather glacial advancement.
- galangalalgol 4y agoIs this always the case for photographers? If they are employed by a business and the pictures are taken for pay, wouldntthe company own them? Can you specify the same in a contract with a freelance photographer?
- hotpotamus 4y ago
- dfxm12 4y agoI was hosting some friends who were on vacation. They live across the US. Long story short, one of them had to go to the emergency room and was subsequently diagnosed with cancer, very far from home. He said OK, I don't live anywhere near here. You will just transfer all this info to my "home" doctor, right? The doctor seeing him said "not necessarily." Assuming I'm reading this article right, thank fucking god no one else will have to go through that.
- Zigurd 4y agoI fell ill far from home and while the care was subpar I did get to take along a CD with my xrays on it. Nobody seemed to know what to do with it and I ended up getting a redundant set of xrays within days of the first set. No weird file formats, they were full-resolution and exactly what the xray tech and docs were looking at previously.
- sdfhbdf 4y agoThe title should be amended to point out that it concerns only US
- nimbius 4y agoI really want to be optimistic about this but as a us consumer of us healthcare its almost impossible to get even my vision prescription. I'm betting whatever I get from the hospital is in an ocean of binary formats too arcane to digest, from a graveyard of bankrupt health data applications and in a shorthand I'll never comprehend because the legend to it is in some healthcare billing system only god and bill collectors can see.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoApple Health successfully scrapes my medical records from multiple health systems (as well as Labcorp) using OAuth authenticated public API endpoints provided by their Epic EHR instances. I'm somewhat optimistic because of this. The technology implementation was not the problem, the policy stick was lacking. Thwack. Tangentially, if you have an iPhone, I highly recommend connecting your health systems so that the records are retrieved and stored in your iCloud account, from a data sovereignty perspective. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fast_Healthcare_Interoperability_Resources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fast_Healthcare_Interoperabili... https://fhir.epic.com/Documentation?docId=fhir https://fhir.epic.com/Documentation?docId=fhir https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208647 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208647
- larrybud 4y agoSlightly off topic, but why is there no ability (as far as I can tell) to lock your Apple health records with a password/pin/faceid? Seems crazy that every other app containing pii (bank, airline, etc) is lockable but my health records are wide open to anyone who picks up my unlocked phone.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://www.apple.com/feedback/health/ https://www.apple.com/feedback/health/
- Dig1t 4y agoOne big limitation of this standard is imaging data. X-Ray radiographs, MRI scans, PET scans, etc are not part of the USCDI standard V1 that'll be available to US patients. The current story for getting these scans still sucks and isn't close to being actually available to patients in the US. The best you can get is a set of DVD's containing that stuff, if you are lucky. The problem is that the protocol used by imaging devices (DICOM) is ancient, and connecting with a DICOM server is a pain. There is a sort of modern standard that I've heard talked about called DICOMweb, that I think will be hooked up with FHIR and be made apart of the USCDI eventually (probably). But we still aren't very close to being able to see X-rays on our phones. Also, one funny anecdote I've heard from working in this space is that some doctors do not like the Clinical Notes story (https://build.fhir.org/ig/HL7/US-Core/clinical-notes.html https://build.fhir.org/ig/HL7/US-Core/clinical-notes.html) since it means that their personal notes about their patients will be made available directly to the patient, something that was not possible in the past. Doctors often write down their real thoughts about the patient in there and can say some things the patient might not be happy with.
- ch4s3 4y agoDICOMWeb over FHIR sounds miserable.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoGot a dental 3d scan recently and I also couldn’t get that as any sort of digital file
- cocoricamo 4y agoNot available upon request or not offered? Recently had an MRI and they copied the files to a thumb drive I gave them after asking due to not having a CD reader at home for over 5 years. A printed copy was more expensive.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoRequested but never received, they were sorta like “oh nobody ever asks for those”
- dogmatism 4y ago*laughs in hospital still on Meditech "Magic" which is essentially a TUI even sitting at the terminal, I can't get the fucking records I need
- nradov 4y agoHave you looked at the Meditech API documentation? https://home.meditech.com/en/d/restapiresources/pages/apidoc.htm https://home.meditech.com/en/d/restapiresources/pages/apidoc...
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoHah, at least they have public API documentation unlike others
- lifeplusplus 4y agoI really love it when I want records from Doc A to be sent to Doc B, then the Doc B offices refuses to get records and insist the patient need to do it, despite signing over all the papers, and then Doc A refuses to send them because they can only give to patient - even though patient is begging to send them. Quadruple the pain if you need records from multiple doctors. This is why now I prefer going to chain hospitals like university clinics. At least they can access records from doctors within their network. Like NYU, Mount Sinai, Presbyterian, etc.
- petilon 4y agoMy experience is that Doc A sends the thumbnail of the image to Doc B. Doc B is happy that Doc A sent an unusable file because he now gets to charge for a new image. Hospitals track MRIs and other images ordered per doctor, and doctors are under pressure to hit their quota.
- obloid 4y agoNot sure where you got the idea that there are "quotas" doctors have to meet for ordering diagnostic tests. I can't speak for other countries but in the US this is not the case.
- shapefrog 4y agoCan confirm that in the "socialized" health care system of the UK, the "quota" is more like a "cap" and the optimization done is towards 0 not infinity.
- petilon 4y agoYou can't speak for other countries, but you can for all of the US? Then explain these articles: "Doctors Under Pressure to Meet Quotas and Fill Hospital Beds" [1]. "Once hospitals have made such a huge investment, experts like Dr. Zietman say, doctors will be under pressure to guide patients toward proton therapy when a less costly alternative might suffice." [2] "While payments vary widely, doctors often collect $500 to $700 for a typical M.R.I. done on an outpatient basis in this area." [3] [1] https://www.thehealthlawfirm.com/blog/posts/doctors-under-pressure-to-meet-quotas-and-fill-hospital-beds.html https://www.thehealthlawfirm.com/blog/posts/doctors-under-pr... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2007/12/26/business/26proton.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/12/26/business/26proton.html [3] https://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/13/business/an-mri-machine-for-every-doctor-someone-has-to-pay.html https://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/13/business/an-mri-machine-f...
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoI occasionally wonder if it would be the cheaper, sustainable approach to just give everyone an iOS device containing their full medical record in HealthKit and require that all data requests go through your device, where you have full control on who gets access and for how long. A simple back-of-the-envelope calculation results in $1 000 per iOS device x 300 000 000 = $300 000 000 000 (three hundred billion). To put that into perspective, the CDC says that $3 795 000 000 (three-thousand seven-hundred and nine-five billion) was spent on healthcare in 2019. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/hus/topics/health-care-expenditures.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/hus/topics/health-care-expenditures...
- bpodgursky 4y agoThis just isn't realistic. No hospital EMR is going to act as a proxy for a thousand customer iOS devices hooked up to the WiFi or whatever. Just imagine the doctor trying to pull up your chart, and failing because you forgot to charge your phone. Yeah, no. Or, even better, you get admitted to the ER in critical condition and now nobody can pull up your blood type or even enter your medical records, because you don't have your phone on you. Not going to happen.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoNon-emergency intake procedures would be a great point in the workflow to get the authorization handshake out of the way. In emergency situations, getting medical records isn’t even a guarantee, today. If all a paramedic had to do was plug in a dead phone and wait 15 minutes to get access to medical records that would otherwise require potentially hours and fax machines, it might be a tic in the acceptability matrix, there. Using the device to manage your data, with whatver access controls you are allowed, doesn’t necessitate that the data be solely stored on the device. Using notifications and other operating system functions ought to cover a wide variety of workflow needs. The device would be able to take the place of any signature machines, on-premises, for example. Finally, as it is today, you can configure iOS and watchOS to display emergency medical information even while locked. Let alone any future enhancements that could really make a dent in the overall healthcare software ecosystem. edit: how environmentally sustainable it is to make 7+ billion iPhones, is a different topic though
- mod 4y agoAre doctor's notes part of this? I wonder how many doctor's are going to regret some things they wrote.
- NegativeK 4y agoNotes have been part of your portable data for a while now. Doctors who haven't learned to write appropriately (or cryptically) have been foolish for a while.
- mayhaffs 4y agoThank goodness
- smithmayowa 4y agoAs a co-fouder of https://www.medorbit.co https://www.medorbit.co (shameless linking my startup I know but in my defense no one here is my possible user) who is trying to make this possible for the African patient this is very motivating.
- praveen9920 4y agoBenefits aside, purely from security stand point, This might become vector for bad actors for stealing medical by social engineering.
- anaganisk 4y agoI wonder if the data will be “accidentally” leaked to insurance company by oxford analytica :p
- rejectfinite 4y agoWe have had this in Sweden for like 10 years... we have a national BankID for verification though. https://www.bankid.com/en/ https://www.bankid.com/en/
- usr1106 4y agoHaven't lived in Sweden for 35 years, so not familiar with that. A web search found https://1177.se https://1177.se , is it that? We also have it in Finland as https://kanta.fi https://kanta.fi. You can see all your healthcare visits, but only short summaries. Results from examinations are not there. Got the analysis of my last blood samples on paper. But that was a friendly doctor, often you get nothing. I think legally you have the right to get everything, not sure, haven't been ill... But you'd need to request it and there is no standardized way to do so regardless of healthcare provider.
- rejectfinite 4y agoYes, https://1177.se/ https://1177.se/ is the site/phone number.
- ecmascript 4y agoInteresting, wasn't this possible before in the states? In Sweden we've been able to access our medical journal for years, not really sure of when it first arrived.
- martyvis 4y agoDon't get your hopes up as to how useful this is. In Australia we have had federal government digital health record capability for something like 5 years now. There was all sorts of moral panic about issues at the time it was mooted - around privacy and so on and was opt in. I saw it as a great idea, as I have chronic health issue and thought it as a useful journal for use by medicos in my ongoing care. However despite having GP (physician) visits and haemotologist visits multiple times a year, and blood tests and even surgical biopsy tests there are no records of these being added. I mention it to my doctors and the boxes are ticked as far as I know on forms. The only things that make it to my record are simple scripted medicines (presumably because they have government reimbursement, through the PBS) and immunisation records such as for COVID and flu. Certainly no effort has been made to scan or digitise any CT records and similar imaging from before the health records system was brought in. So it all seems a bit of a boondoggle and waste of resources.
- troad 4y agoInteresting. My experience is somewhat different, but also does not commend the Australian system. I did not opt in, but my general practitioner uploaded everything anyway. Important details were entered incorrectly - I was listed as having conditions I do not have - which I imagine could have had catastrophic consequences had another doctor relied on any of it. I don't think I was even notified the record was created, I seem to recall discovering it by chance, but I could be misremembering. Worth mentioning is the fact that under the law as it was passed, this (in my case incorrect) data could never be deleted. Once the botched roll-out began, the law was thankfully amended, and I was allowed to have the whole thing taken down.
- rickysahu 4y agoMany of the APIs being used here are also available at a population level. So there's analytics and ml work possible too especially when working through payers and providers, not just patient mediated access. If anyone wants to do something about improving this space i started a whole company around these regulations and APIs. https://1up.health https://1up.health I'm Ricky @ if you want to chat
- sergers 4y agoEpic has really increased interopability between separated owned instances and definitely leaders in the EHR space and functionality of providing patients their data. Like with careeverywhere, of mychart where patients can download digital diagnostic imaging/view reports/ lab results..
- NeveHanter 4y agoCan I ask for adding country/region information to such titles? I'm not from the US and I need to assume tribal knowledge that this is about US.
- reaperducer 4y agounfettered access to their full health records in digital format. No more long delays. No more fax machines. No more exorbitant charges for printed pages. Some of that is true, some of that is hype. Last week I asked a mid-sized healthcare company for my records from ten years ago. I was told that they could not be transmitted digitally, only on CDROM. And that the price for duplication started at $500 and would go up from there. I was also told that if my current doctor requested the records, it would all be free. So yes, the records can be moved around digitally, but actually personally owning a copy of the records dos not seem "unfettered."
- dylanwenzlau 4y agoIf those were already electronic records, your provider broke federal law by declining and trying to charge you that much. You can submit information blocking reports here: https://www.healthit.gov/topic/information-blocking https://www.healthit.gov/topic/information-blocking. This isn't totally a legal problem, it's also an adherence problem. I'd estimate about half of providers don't know what exactly they are required to do and at what cost. Our company helped patients request their own records and half the time we had to call and talk to the provider about the legal requirements and ask them to comply or reduce the price. Even before October 6 and the Cures Act, HIPAA law already required very cheap access to your own medical records. It's something like a base maximum cost of $6.50 plus a per-page printing fee but ONLY if you request paper format. HIPAA law directly states that the format requested by the patient MUST be given if readily available. Digital format doesn't require printing.
- reaperducer 4y agoAlready filed a report, right after it happened. I got an email a little bit later asking follow-up questions. It seems like something might happen. Or at least I'll be part of a tally of violations.
- adunsulag 4y agoBefore people get their hopes up on this, remember there is no enforcement mechanism currently. OIG has to issue a final ruling on the penalties for HealthIT which I've heard from some insiders could take as long as another year. For providers, a preliminary ruling and then a final ruling has to be made which could take years. So yes, the law mandates that your entire EHI* designated record set be made available there is NO enforcement mechanism to penalize bad actors at this point in time. Also its important to note that HealthIT and providers can make a claim to continue to block information if it falls under 8 categories (patient privacy, patient harm, financial costs, content exception such as psychotherapy notes, etc). The proposed penalty is 1 million per Information Blocking claim for HealthIT. So HealthIT has a huge incentive once the final ruling is made to make sure there is no information blocking, but providers right now don't have any kind of penalty themselves. *EHI = Electronic Health Information, note this moves beyond the USCDI V1 standard someone mentioned in another post to the entire Designated Health Record Set including claims, payment information, imaging data, and anything that is used to make a healthcare decision by providers. * Disclaimer I've done work for an open source EHR and I've been forced to become pretty familiar with this stuff.
- seba_dos1 4y agoIn United States.