13 ms·
Why Is The Guitar Tuned Like It Is?
- elsherbini 4y agoI've experimented a lot with different isomorphic tunings on the guitar - that is where each string is in the same interval. The obvious one to try is perfect 4ths, E A D G C F. This one is great because the same shape works everywhere, drop 2 chords for instance have three sets of shapes you need to learn on standard guitar but only one on perfect 4ths. However, I hate giving up the open B and E strings. You can fix this by adding an extra fret on the highest two strings (or just using a capo on the lowest 4 strings) [1]. My favorite isomorphic tuning though is minor thirds tuning, where each fret becomes a diminished chord. This allows you to explore Barry Harris' harmonic concepts really easily, which describes major and minor 4 note chords as combinations of two diminished chords. I made a video showing how this works. [2] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fFX5AQRg8Ko https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fFX5AQRg8Ko [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Kg1m5KqaoQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Kg1m5KqaoQ
- contravariant 4y agoI have to say the phrase 'isomorphic tunings' is very confusing if you have a mathematical background. It apparently doesn't refer to tunings which are effectively the same (not entirely what this would mean, I suppose you could swap a few strings).
- Sharlin 4y agoI guess isomorphic tunings are isomorphic in the sense that you can move a fingering not only up and down the fretboard, but also from one set of strings to another, and the chord remains the same, just transposed.
- dwringer 4y agoIt means they are effectively the same as you shift rightwards or leftwards on the neck. So you can play a G major chord, move the same exact shape "down one string" and now it's a C major chord. This is not a feature of standard guitar tuning.
- mrob 4y agoWikipedia calls them "regular tunings", which I think is clearer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regular_tuning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regular_tuning
- elsherbini 4y agoTotally, my mistake. The correct term is regular tunings, which yield an isomorphic layout on the guitar (well, it would if you had infinite strings). In plain english, the same shape always corresponds to the same intervals no matter what strings you are playing.
- toolslive 4y agoBass players use "regular" tuning. Fe, 6 String Basses: B E A D G C
- kazinator 4y agoIf all strings use the same interval, you have less variety in fingering; everything is the same everywhere. The M3 interval between the G and B string is useful; you can allocate fingerings between those two strings to play certain things that don't work for a pair of strings that are a P4 apart.
- elsherbini 4y agoTotally agree, I think regular tunings are cool and easier for learning in a lot of ways, but the ergonomics of standard tuning or other non-regular tunings make somethings easy that are really beautiful. I think making whatever you consider to be desirable on your instrument also be idiomatic and easy to do is good.
- smilekzs 4y agoThe minor thirds tuning is incidentally the same setup as chromatic button accordions (a.k.a. Bayan's)! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayan_(accordion) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayan_(accordion)
- gleep 4y agoMajor thirds tuning, on the other hand, gives you a consecutive chromatic scale in any given position without stretching or changing the position. It's great for single note soloing.
- frakt0x90 4y agoA bit off-topic but if you're interested in some modern players that make heavy use of alternate tunings, I strongly recommend Ichika Nito and Yvette Young (Covet). Ichika has tons of videos of him playing in the weirdest tunings and it's quite entertaining.
- draegtun 4y agoAlso see "Ostrich" tuning used by Lou Reed / The Velvet Underground - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostrich_guitar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostrich_guitar
- camgunz 4y agoCan also recommend Covet, great songs, and the guitar work is pretty bonkers--really incredible what different tunings and tons of practice/talent can do. I watched a YT where Yvette Young was talking about how her 1st tele had Bill Lawrence pickups, which (after a truly mad dive into pickup research) I now also have in my main guitar (microcoils + an L45-S in a strat, not a tele, I'm not a monster). My point here is: be careful or you might find yourself up at 1am trying to decide what capacitors you want on your tone pots.
- jimnotgym 4y agoThats one rabbithole, but mine might be worse. I recently made my first pickups. First I made a coil winding machine, after lots of late night research. I bought an old sewing machine and took it to pieces for the main components. After my first build I improved my machine with some 3d printed parts. Then there is the process of choosing and sourcing the components, coils, wire magnets, wax... Then the actual process of getting the winding done...lots of broken wires later...my tele has an awesome set of pickups which sound so clear. The neck pickup is very non standard, more like a strat pickup. What a stupid hobby!
- tricky 4y agoI love that you did this DIY. I just had a guitar built by a guy who also winds pickups per your specs - I loved that I could have him dial in the tone exactly how I wanted.
- Sharlin 4y agoSee also the great, nerd-friendly blog series "Guitar Decomposed" by Bartosz Milewski[1]. Yes, the same guy who wrote Category Theory for Programmers. [1] https://bartoszmilewski.com/2020/05/24/guitar-decomposed-1-weird-logic-behind-tuning/ https://bartoszmilewski.com/2020/05/24/guitar-decomposed-1-w...
- shagie 4y agoThe original stack exchange post: https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/1723/why-is-the-guitar-tuned-like-it-is https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/1723/why-is-the-gu...
- Valgrim 4y agoI find it cool actually that this kind of knowledge (Q&A) can be readily downloaded and stored for offline consultation on any device.
- shagie 4y agoIf you want to spin up an instance... https://archive.org/details/stackexchange https://archive.org/details/stackexchange I will note that the kiwix.org site appears to not be completely correct with publicly hosting the data and the licensing requirements: > Ensure that any Internet use of the content includes a hyperlink for each author name directly back to his or her user profile page on the source site on the Network (e.g., http://stackoverflow.com/users/12345/username http://stackoverflow.com/users/12345/username), directly to the Stack Exchange domain, in standard HTML (i.e. not through a Tinyurl or other such indirect hyperlink, form of obfuscation or redirection), without any “nofollow” command or any other such means of avoiding detection by search engines, and visible even with JavaScript disabled.
- shams93 4y agoThe lute originally had this 3rd in its open strings, guitar came from the lute. Lute like guitar has all 4ths and then one 3rd.
- lioeters 4y agoI've always wondered about that kink between the G and B string, a major 3rd gap, when all the other strings are spaced perfect fourth. It bothers me because it's an anomaly that breaks the symmetry and increases the number of shapes to keep in mind. The whole thread is an enjoyable read, and the answer seems to be - like many things in Western music theory - it was a design decision, a kind of legacy code, with pros and cons. "Things evolve to meet a need." One of the answers talked about an all-fourths tuning, that some instruments use such tunings as standard. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_fourths_tuning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_fourths_tuning Theoretically it's more beautiful, and simplifies the shapes and their movements across the fretboard. It might be a pain to overcome years of learning patterns on the guitar with the kink - I'll have to try it. Sometimes it's good to shake up the foundation and see what new patterns emerge. Similarly, I love the logic (and I'd say even wisdom) of the piano keyboard - but there are some kinks in there too, which introduce complexity in the patterns and their transformations, making them harder to remember. I'm curious to try a hexagonal keyboard and other alternative layouts - I imagine the symmetry has practical advantages, and to my mind more aesthetically pleasing. Wicki–Hayden note layout - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicki%E2%80%93Hayden_note_layout https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicki%E2%80%93Hayden_note_layo... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isomorphic_keyboard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isomorphic_keyboard
- galangalalgol 4y agoHas anyone tried to approach music theory without any historical underpinnings (and preferably ignorant of it). I'm thinking of something that started with cog sci and signal processing, and maybe ML. Don't bother linking the obligatory xkcd. I know it is the height of hubris to think that approach would produce anything like quality music for decades, but I think it might give insight to things that were left over from technical limitations or random chance. How far down the rabbit hole have experimental composers gone in questioning everything down to the foundation, and then kept digging?
- zokier 4y agoThe problem with creating a new music theory is the question what do you want the music theory to do? The main value of classical music theory is exactly the historical underpinnings that you want to drop
- podoco 4y agoive always wondered if it would be work learning the all 4ths tuning. seems like the guitar would be much easier to play if you dont need full bar chords. but it might be hard to switch back and forth between the all 4ths tunings and standard.
- wilsonnb3 4y agoI’ve wondered the same thing in the past, mainly because my primary instrument is the bass guitar which uses all fourths. Once you play guitar for long enough you will understand why that major third is there, though. A small compromise in the “logic” of the tuning gives you so much utility.
- otikik 4y agoPlease link to the original source https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/1723/why-is-the-guitar-tuned-like-it-is https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/1723/why-is-the-gu...
- cousin_it 4y agoThe most beautiful and unusual tuning I came across is alternating major and minor thirds, something like ACEGBD. Then you can tune A,E,B down 15 cents and each group of three consecutive strings (open or mini-barred at any fret) becomes a _just intonation_ major or minor chord. You pluck three strings and it's like plucking one static string, a sound hanging in space without movement. Major and minor just intonation scales are also playable, though require some jumps.
- stakkur 4y agoThere are many guitar 'tunings', and many predate the 'standard' tuning the article refers to. Also, players make up different ones all the time, including using capos to temporarily change 'tuning' on the fly. The 'standard' tuning is by no means the only one.
- wilsonnb3 4y agoYeah but it’s called standard for a reason, probably like 80% or more of guitar music uses it. Include a few other tunings (drop d and below, dadgad, the more popular open tunings) and you can bump that up to 99%.
- _greim_ 4y agoWith EADGCF tuning, barre chords wouldn't work so well, since the top and bottom strings would be a half-step apart (disregarding octaves) creating dissonance. Or rather, EADGBE tuning works well with barre chords because the top and bottom strings are the same note. An open-chord tuning works even better with barre chords, but only for that one chord shape. EADGBE gained predominance partly because it strikes an uneasy compromise between different chord shapes and barre-chord friendliness.
- CPLX 4y agoIndeed. I've found that double drop-D has most of the same advantages and also is so close to an open tuning that it gives you most of those advantages as well. Worth noting. I don't know why I didn't discover it for the first couple decades I picked up a guitar.
- pohl 4y agoIf you just look at the shapes of the diatonic triads on each set of 3 adjacent strings, you can see a good reason. On the group of 3 smallest strings, and the next group over, the shapes are all very reachable by the hand. On the thicker string groups, the shapes require a wider spread of the hand — especially the half-diminished triad. The smaller, more comfortable shapes on the thinner strings are made possible by the kink between the G and B strings.
- timdellinger 4y agoThe list of different ways to tune a guitar is monstrously long: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_guitar_tunings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_guitar_tunings Same for banjo: https://zeppmusic.com/banjo/aktuning.htm https://zeppmusic.com/banjo/aktuning.htm