9 ms·
UK Plans for Three-Hour Power Blackouts in Event of Gas Shortages
- sgt101 4y agoOne thing that this will do is accelerate the move to domestic solar in the UK. With a battery it's pretty viable already, throw in the possibility of 0 power it becomes pretty compelling - if you have the cash.
- belter 4y agoTwo months ago: https://youtu.be/q-88_6K3KAQ?t=55 https://youtu.be/q-88_6K3KAQ?t=55 https://youtu.be/h2RbupviJMM?t=59 https://youtu.be/h2RbupviJMM?t=59
- baybal2 4y ago
- mmastrac 4y agoThe UK is speedrunning 1970-1990 here (different underlying causes, obviously)
- makomk 4y agoThings happening in the UK seems to get a lot of attention abroad, probably because we're an English-speaking country, but realistically speaking the more mild of the two scenarios here would likely involve severe power shortages on the European mainland and the more severe of the two a serious global energy crisis. Both of those things are at serious risk of happening this winter, which is why these contingency plans exist.
- adammarples 4y ago"plans for" is a funny way of saying blunders into
- AngusH 4y agoThis appears to be a contingency plan 'in the "unlikely" event supplies of gas fall short of demand.' The report showed, under a base case scenario, that margins between peak demand and power supply were expected to be sufficient and similar to recent years thanks to secure North Sea gas supplies, imports via Norway and by ship. Any operator that didn't have such contingency plans would be negligent. Is it going to happen in reality: hopefully not Edit: I have a feeling that the article may be referring to the 3 hour Loss of Load Expectation (LOLE) service level target for the year. This isn't quite the same as a three hour blackout. I'm not sure though because the sky article doesn't reference its sources. Which may be this: https://www.nationalgrideso.com/document/264521/download https://www.nationalgrideso.com/document/264521/download or it might not? edit2: actually I think it's this: https://www.nationalgrideso.com/document/268346/download https://www.nationalgrideso.com/document/268346/download edit3: Found it, its not the LOLE target, but the response to scenario 2 on page 10 of the second link: scenario 1: "In this scenario we assume that we have no electricity interconnector imports from France, Belgium and the Netherlands (these are assumed to provide a de-rated capacity of 3.9GW in the Base Case). It is assumed that we import 1.2GW from Norway and export 0.4GW to Northern Ireland and Ireland." scenario 2: "In this scenario we assume the same assumptions as Scenario 1, but with an additional 10GW CCGTs unavailable for a two-week period in January1. These assumptions have been chosen to illustrate the potential impact on the electricity system if there was insufficient gas supply in Great Britain." "Should this scenario happen, it may be necessary to initiate the planned, controlled and temporary rota load shedding scheme under the Electricity Supply Emergency Code (ESEC). In the unlikely event we were in this situation, it would mean that some customers could be without power for pre-defined periods during a day – generally this is assumed to be for 3 hour blocks. This would be necessary to ensure the overall security and integrity of the electricity system across Great Britain. All possible mitigating strategies would be deployed to minimise the disruption." Which I think would then follow this set of rules: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/995049/esec-guidance.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... final: I think my information here is mostly right. But you should not base your electricity operational decisions on it!
- sefrost 4y ago
- hulitu 4y agoUK dependent on russian gas ? Who could have thought /s
- Lio 4y agoFrom the UK Government website: Unlike other countries in Europe, the UK is in no way dependent on Russian gas supply. Our single largest source of gas is from the UK Continental Shelf and the vast majority of imports come from reliable suppliers such as Norway. There are no gas pipelines directly linking the UK with Russia and imports from Russia made up less than 4% of total UK gas supply in 2021. IMHO giving up the 4% of supply that came from Russia is more than worth it to help Ukraine. We should move to increasing the share of renewables we use, from the current 37%, and get rid of foreign energy dependencies once and for all. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/russia-ukraine-and-uk-energy-factsheet https://www.gov.uk/government/news/russia-ukraine-and-uk-ene...
- rvieira 4y agoIt is true that it is not dependent _directly_ on Russian gas, but that is a bit naive. The UK is highly dependent on Norwegian gas which now has to bid against Germany for, as an example.
- f1shy 4y agoI'm totally ignorant of the energy production share by method in the UK, but I was convinced they are pretty much autonomous (to a 95%). Aren't they (you)?
- sct202 4y ago"The UK imports around 50% of its gas from the international market and most homes in England and Wales are heated by mains gas supply. Gas is also used to fuel around a third of the UK's electricity generation, so rising gas prices will usually lead to rising electricity prices. Norway is typically the UK's largest gas supplier. In 2021, the UK imported £14.5 billion of gas from Norway, which accounted for 77% of all gas imports (Figure 3). Other countries the UK imports gas from include Qatar, the United States and Russia. Almost half of the UK's gas exports in 2021 were to Ireland (47.2%), and the Netherlands was also a large export partner (28.2%)." https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/nationalaccounts/balanceofpayments/articles/trendsinukimportsandexportsoffuels/2022-06-29 https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/nationalaccounts/balanceofpay...
- bayareabadboy 4y ago…Anarchy in the UK
- booboofixer 4y agoIf you have lived in a country with load-shedding and have experienced this before, as far as your average household goes, 3 hours without power is barely an inconvenience. If the winters are harsh though, probably not as easy.
- RichardCNormos 4y agoOr, if you live in California. 3 hours is nothing! A while ago, we went for a week without power in the northern part of the state.
- booboofixer 4y agoWhy?
- tb_technical 4y agoCalifornia's energy policy needs a little work. Their environmental laws made creating power plants impossible in their state, so they almost exclusively purchase power from other states at sub-optimal rates for any new power demand. Edit: phrasing and tone
- gsbraitberg 4y agoIn 2021, California produced about 200 TWh in-state and imported about 85 TWh, meaning they imported about 30% of total electricity. Not exactly "almost exclusively" imports. Also, California regulations certainly permit building new power plants (and many new plants have been built in the past decade), just not new coal fired plants. https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/california-electricity-data/2021-total-system-electric-generation https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/califo...
- Alupis 4y ago> just not new coal fired plants. Or hydro-electric, or nuclear, or anything that would have meaningful impact on the state's situation. More solar and wind are great, but they do not respond well to surges in demand, and there is no current way to store energy either. So some impressive total production number might sound great, but the reality does not follow unfortunately. For a non-trivial portion of the state, electricity isn't a guarantee throughout the year anymore.
- tomcam 4y agoNot great for people hooked up to home medical equipment
- alexchamberlain 4y agoWon't medical equipment have back up batteries? (I'm not saying it's a good thing, just not a crisis moment.)
- Lio 4y agoYou would hope that they have uninteruptable power supplies for anything like that.
- gwbas1c 4y agoI remember when I used a CPAP, I didn't have a UPS. Where I lived, the power was so reliable I just didn't think of it. After a blackout, I went looking for a UPS. The problem was the alarm. For all the models in the store, I wasn't sure if I could keep the alarm silent, or if the model had an alarm at all. I never bought a UPS. (I had surgery about 18 months later, and turned in my CPAP.)
- sebazzz 4y agoYes, but the grid in Europe is generally so reliable (especially when not living in a rural area), that such stability might be taken for granted.
- jandrese 4y agoMight be a good time to look into home battery systems. Regular 3 hour blackouts are exactly the sort of situation where they shine. It's even possible to build DIY systems out of rack batteries and generic charge controllers, although you will need permits and probably professional install to hook it to your home electrical panel.
- tnjm 4y agoI installed a backup system (in the greenhouse rather than the house... priorities) to cope with these kinds of problems. Using a Victron Multiplus 1.6kVA system with 2x 110Ah 12V Gel batteries was remarkably cheap and simple. The whole lot came to just over €1k and took ~1h to set up, mostly setting jumper switches. It keeps the pellet boiler, circulation pumps, backup gas heaters and control gear going all night when necessary. The automatic switchover from mains (<20ms) is so fast that none of the PLCs, Arduinos, Raspberry Pis or heating equipment notices. Upgrading its capacity simply involves plugging in another 2x batteries (it's a 24v unit) in parallel. The only thing I wasn't thrilled about was that it doesn't protect against power surges, and a storm fried the boiler logic board AND the gas valve in the backup heater simultaneously in midwinter. (Victron unit was fine though!) Lesson learned. A similar installation in the house could easily power our (non-electric) central heating system, LED lighting and wifi for plenty long enough to stay civilized, and we're being prepared for 2 hour rolling blackouts here this winter.
- sebazzz 4y agoWord of warning: Just like solar inverters, not every home battery system is made to be grid independent. For instance, the Tesla Powerwall does, but the Sessy home battery does not and needs an active AC sinus on the grid. Even if you do have a home battery system that can generate its own sinusoidal AC wave, you still need an (automatic) transfer switch to disconnect your home from the failed grid, otherwise your home battery might be attempting to power the entire (local) grid which of course doesn't work.
- chasd00 4y ago> otherwise your home battery might be attempting to power the entire (local) grid which of course doesn't work. and some random line worker may think there's no electricity flowing when there is.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThe UK does not plan for anything. This is just someone pointing out what will happen, there is no program to get extra supply online or shed some load or make sure people with medical equipment can still get power. Quite the opposite, we're spending more than we spend on education to discourage people from using less...
- connordoner 4y agoTo be honest, that isn't the case. I run a start-up in crisis management and there's a lot of planning being done across the public and private sectors — it's just that those most senior in Government won't listen.
- gizajob 4y agoIf you want to know the result of successive Tory governments and forty years of deregulation and mismanagement, then power blackouts and people not being able to heat their homes is it. The Tory agenda now seems fixed upon ensuring the very rich have everything and everyone else has absolutely nothing.
- theGnuMe 4y agoMaybe just maybe the UK as learnt the lesson?
- was_a_dev 4y agoI highly doubt it. Any lessons will be shortlived, and probably will be forgotten by the electorate before the next election
- brnt 4y ago> The Tory agenda now seems fixed upon ensuring the very rich have everything and everyone else has absolutely nothing. It has always been thus.
- pharmakom 4y agoBefore the riches of globalisation somewhat masked the damage.
- seibelj 4y agoThe US is the most deregulated, pro-market, capitalist developed nation of size and we are doing much better than the UK. Jobs are plentiful and our corporate titans continue to dominate global equities. Maybe the issue in the UK isn’t as simple as tax rates. But you can always try to pivot hard left, maybe it will work this time. Capital does tend to flee when serious attempts to expropriate it occur…
- adrianba 4y ago> The US is the most deregulated, pro-market, capitalist developed nation of size Well, here in the US, I still buy electricity from the government. Consumer energy deregulation in the UK started in the late 80s and electricity has been sold through private companies for years.
- marsven_422 4y ago
- halffaday 4y agoJust have your mates bring you a few gallons of wind turbine.
- jeffalyanak 4y agoI recently built a small home solar battery system with the goal of keeping my low-power DC devices charged and running during outages like this. I've only been running it for a few months now, but I've been using it to keep all of my USB devices charged during that time. In an actual power outage, I can even plug in my modem, router, and AP—using DC barrel jacks for the modem and router and a DIY PoE injector for the AP—so as long as the upstream infrastructure is still powered I'll be able to keep working. Since I rent, I can't do a roof-mount or grid-tie system, so I opted instead to build a 12V DC system. I purchased a used solar panel and I've assembled a ~0.5kWh battery from used packs. I'm using insulated nickel strips to pass the solar panel cables through a closed closed window in a way that doesn't require drilling holes and has a minimum impact on the insulation seal of the window (although insulation in the UK really sucks anyway). Most of the fittings and wiring have been used and come mostly from automotive scrap (an advantage of using common 12/24V standard fittings), so the financial cost has been very low. That said collecting use battery packs, testing cells, and assembling them into new battery packs certainly takes time.
- exabrial 4y agoFor me, I could care less whether or not my apt has power for most of the day or night. It's pretty well insulated; even with our wide temp swings (104f peak in the summer, -32f in the winter) it takes a while before it moves either direction. The big conveniences are hot water, washer, dryer, dishwasher of course but if push came to shove, I'd be ok, especially knowing I was given the finger to the Russians. This certainly isn't an option for every structure, especially free standing older homes built before 2000.
- joenathanone 4y agoWhat about your food?
- exabrial 4y agoI don't really see this as an issue... potatoes, pasta, etc would be on a stove when power is avail, or I already have a camp stove I could use. Same diet as when I'm in the wilderness. I think the point you were trying to make is good that spoil wouldn't be available, but that's a small price to pay for not paying for Russia's war.
- fy20 4y agoOne of the big problems in the UK is that housing is not built like that. In most of the UK it rarely gets below freezing, yet even new homes come with big gas boilers because of how poorly insulated they are, and if you turn it off for half a day, it will get cold inside. The housing energy certification in the UK is very misleading, as a home built with walls with a U value of 0.25W/m2K is rated as "very good" (the maximum). Where as in my country all new homes built in the past 5 years have required a U value of less than half that - of course that doesn't tell the full picture as need to know how thick the wall is, but you don't see new UK homes with 1m thick walls. Even with the pretty lax requirements, very few new homes in the UK have an A energy rating. One major issue is that homes are still built the same way as they were 50 years ago with a cavity wall. Facing bricks are porous, so you need to allow water to escape, and the cavity wall is usually open at the bottom and the top (usually into the attic) to allow that. If you were to wrap the interior wall with a layer of 200mm PIR board and ensure it is air sealed, you could have a pretty well insulated wall, but often the cavity is filled with mineral wool pressed tightly against both walls. Then it inevitably gets moist which impacts the material's thermal performance. And that's just one the most basic things, other modern high performance items such as triple glazing, mechanical ventilation and heat pumps are also rare. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavity_wall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavity_wall
- O__________O 4y agoAnyone have a link to the actual report? Only report I found appears to say that 3-hours downtime a year is an acceptable downtime — unable to find anything about intentional blackouts as a power management strategy.