9 ms·
Did an NYU professor get fired because students hate organic chem?
- GoodJokes 4y ago
- logicalmonster 4y agoI'm not sure I fully understand the exact timeline from the article, but is it possible that age indirectly played a factor in the students' unhappiness? His mind for organic chemistry might still be sharp as a tack. But at 84 years old, if he was the students' teacher during the initial part of the pandemic there's probably a chance he struggled with the digital adjustments to doing so many things online and delivered a subpar overall experience. If nothing else, perhaps eyesight and hearing fades a bit with age and makes trying to do stuff through Zoom and other online tools something very difficult for them making office hours and other things a challenge everybody resisted. This means that these students were far behind other years students. By the time they all resumed in-person activities, the teacher might have thought that his students were at the normal level he was used to through decades of experience, but he misread how far behind they were.
- Tomte 4y agoYou're heavily speculating about a person, just to write - essentially - a fictional story you happen to like. Your comment is ageist, nothing else.
- brudgers 4y agoThat's the kind of comment stories like this attract.
- dekken_ 4y ago> Your comment is ageist, nothing else. False, this is your opinion, they were careful not to state what is, but what might be the case.
- faeriechangling 4y agoI mean it’s literally true the comment is ageist, it’s transparently and shamelessly ageist.
- logicalmonster 4y agoHow many news stories from ArsTechnica even mention the subject's age in the first place? Can you please let me know specifically what about my comment was ageist, and specifically shamelessly so? I think I was very reasonable and respectful and clearly indicated that my post was speculation. Thanks Faerie. PS: As an aside, to be very pedantic, the word ageist is a subjective term, not objective. You can say that 2+2=4 is literally true, but can you fairly say that anything is literally ageist when that's subjective? Just something to noodle over about what that word even means.
- faeriechangling 4y agoAgeisms definition if we search “define ageism” is prejudice or discrimination based on age. Saying a 5 year old would be a bad theoretical physicist or that a 90 year old would make a bad NFL linebacker both would constitute prejudices based on age by the strictest definition. Your respectfulness or lack thereof is almost totally irrelevant to if your post is ageist. I don’t see “ageism” as a very useful word anyways since my attempt to narrow the definition makes it painfully subjective.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> Saying a 5 year old would be a bad theoretical physicist or that a 90 year old would make a bad NFL linebacker both would constitute prejudices based on age the way I see it. It seems like most people would agree with your examples. Do you view this sort of ageism filter as a useful tool for understanding the world? Does the word ageism automatically imply a negative connotation then?
- cm2012 4y agoIt's fine to be ageist against someone who is 84 years old. There are severe cognitive declines that almost no one avoids at that age. It is irresponsible to hire an 84 year old for any important job.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> It's fine to be ageist against someone who is 84 years old. There are severe cognitive declines that almost no one avoids at that age. It is irresponsible to hire an 84 year old for any important job. Would you turn down getting lectures from Donald Knuth even if he's older than dirt? Using age as one tool to understand a complicated world with incomplete information seems fair, but I think you have to judge the individual on their own merits and abilities or you can miss out.
- xdavidliu 4y ago> Would you turn down getting lectures from Donald Knuth even if he's older than dirt? There's a difference between giving lunchtime lectures and teaching an entire course while assigning grades that affect the careers of young people.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoKnuth was the first thing that popped into my head, thanks for posting this so I didn't have to.
- coffeeblack 4y ago“almost no one” You managed to contradict yourself within the same sentence.
- Y-bar 4y agoI think these two sections speak for themselves: > "NYU had in Professor Maitland Jones a faculty member with a one-year appointment specifically to teach organic chemistry," wrote John Beckman, a spokesperson for NYU, in a statement to Reason. "In one of his organic chemistry classes in the spring 2022 there were, among other troubling indicators, a very high rate of student withdrawals, a student petition signed by 82 students, course evaluations scores that were by far the worst not only among members of the Chemistry Department but among all the University's undergraduate science courses, and multiple student complaints about his dismissiveness, unresponsiveness, condescension, and opacity about grading." > Beckman continued: So, what exactly would be the argument for renewal of this appointment? NYU has lots of hard courses and lots of tough graders among the faculty - they don't end up with outcomes like this. Surely, among the many things a university should stand up for - including academic freedom, academic rigor, and a robust research enterprise - one of them should be good teaching. Good teaching shouldn't be pitted against rigor as an excuse for poor teaching; good teaching and rigor are perfectly compatible, and the latter is not a threat to the former at NYU.
- rahimnathwani 4y ago"NYU had in Professor Maitland Jones a faculty member with a one-year appointment specifically to teach organic chemistry," wrote John Beckman The statement is factually correct but misleading. He's been at NYU since 2007. Given he's on a one year appointment, I guess he's been re-hired 14 times.
- mcguire 4y agoThat seems to be the case, yes.
- glofish 4y agoWhen a professor gets the worst course evaluation scores among all courses at a university - just about always it means that there is a problem with the lecturer.
- generationP 4y ago
- hoppyhoppy2 4y agoSee also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33100836 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33100836 (18 hours ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33093467 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33093467 (1 day ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33083095 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33083095 (1 day ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33070843 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33070843 (2 days ago)
- Tomte 4y agoThis article has the same incident as its starting point, but is really about the question of using courses to filter students (and a bit of Covid musing). Unlike those other articles, the actual firing is not the main thrust.
- stephencanon 4y agoMy wife took his organic chemistry course at Princeton 20 years ago, and says he was an excellent teacher. Obviously many things can change in two decades, so take from that what you will.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if his teaching style changed in his late 70s early 80s; people can naturally tend to become much more inflexible at that age. He might still be a genius in his area of expertise but no longer a good teacher.
- dymk 4y agoWell the article doesn't give any evidence that that's the case. In fact it mentions that Jones' style is one that focuses less on drudgery and more on the interesting aspects of ochem.
- mcguire 4y ago"WSN also accessed student evaluation records for courses taught by Jones, which showed that his scores had been consistently low for years — long before the spring 2022 student petition. In the past five years, Jones’ co-professors teaching the same course typically had scores around or above 4.0 on a 5.0 scale, while Jones averaged around 3.3. In his final semester, his evaluation score dropped to 2.4. "They were part of an experimental semester, one that was forced to combine the in-person with the online, and Jones was not considerate of the need for change. The document explains that more work is not equivalent to more learning, and provides an estimate of how much time an average student spends on the class per week. Students said they spent 11 to 19 hours per week on the course — a course that traditionally takes up 10 to 15 hours per week." https://nyunews.com/opinion/2022/10/05/maitland-jones-nytimes-response/ https://nyunews.com/opinion/2022/10/05/maitland-jones-nytime...
- 7thaccount 4y agoNot sure about this case in particular, but I have a firm belief that a class should be in a certain aspect fair. Although that is subjective, I mean the class shouldn't be unreasonable. To give an example, I had an engineering class on electrical machinery. On one test, not a single person made an A. In fact, the highest grade was a "C" obtained by the class genius. I studied hard for the exam, attended all lectures, did all homework assignments, and got a ~45 on the exam out of 100 points. At that point, you have nothing like a bell curve. The teacher has failed to either teach or formulate a test that meets reasonable expectations. Something is broken. I don't think everyone should've gotten an "A", but failing an entire class of students that are not even remotely lazy (nearly all over achievers) is stupid.
- lbotos 4y agoWhat if the lesson was "sometimes things in life are really hard, and no matter how much you prepare, things may still challenge you beyond your current capability?"
- shafoshaf 4y agoHow does one get an A on that test, since grades are important as people move to jobs and graduate degrees? How can I compare an A from the University of Everything is Reasonable versus one that includes the grade every student gets on the Kobayashi Maru?
- unethical_ban 4y agoIf that isn't something taken into consideration by grad programs and top hiring firms, then the system is broken. How do you compare two "A"s, one from a mediocre place and one from a well established institution? By knowing the difference, of course.
- blix 4y agoWhen I was an undergrad looking for internships, many of the most desriable had hard GPA cutoffs. I'm pretty sure these were not flexibly adjusted for every single applicant depending on their university and specific course load.
- chris_wot 4y agoI've heard a number of stories in the UK, U.S. and Australia where the University employs the professor for research and not teaching. The Professor hates teaching and treats it like an inconvenience. Then students are screwed over.
- taubek 4y agoThis is true in some countries. You have to be a teacher in order to get/keep your job but you would rather be a researcher.
- yardie 4y agoIf you want to do only research than be a researcher. Universities and labs hire plenty of them. Professors do research and teach. It's a part of the profession. The requirements of being a professor aren't exactly a secret so there is no excuse to being a shitty teacher if teaching is literally a component of the job. The universities that pay their salaries and the students that pay the universities should demand more from their professors. If students get poor grades for not understanding the assignment then it is only fair that bad professors get a poor review for not understanding the assignment.
- rbartelme 4y agoThis professor was, quite literally, on a teaching only contract.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CptFribble 4y agoI went to a different school, but I've also experienced similar "teachers" only in chemistry, and even specifically OChem. Difficult/opaque lecture style, very high difficulty tests, openly mocking students in a 500+ person lecture if he deemed a question not intelligent enough, and on top of all of it, forced to buy a textbook he co-authored (homework questions taken from the required book, refreshed every year). For some reason this story seems to happen more often in chemistry than other disciplines. In my experience as a Biomedical Engineering major, my chemistry classes were by far the most difficult, almost like it was the point - just difficulty for difficulty's sake. And I had plenty of other hard classes, including AI/ML, Diff EQ, and a course on the physics of blood, but each of those professors, while rigorous, were also fair and kind, willing to help students understand the material, and definitely never refusing to answer what they believed to be a "stupid question." I even remember conversations with friends about how the chemistry department seemed to have a very high number of massively egotistical professors who mistreated their students. My chem major friends confirmed it was like this all the time. All of this is anecdotal, but soft-confirmed by multiple friends and friends of friends at the time. When this story broke I was honestly not at all surprised.
- melony 4y agoChem majors are not their target, the majority of orgo Chem victims are potential medical students. They take the class because they don't have a choice and it keeps the department relevant. Been that way for decades now. Imagine gatekeeping software engineering to people who can memorize and regurgitate the Intel CPU menus and implement the X86 standard from memory. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/it-s-time-to-retire-premed/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/it-s-time-to...
- maldev 4y agoIs that not what your computer arch class was? In mine we had to write every mips instruction and what it did, from memory, on pencil and paper. And that was the "Final" along with some demorgans.
- 4y ago
- Metacelsus 4y agoNote that the NYTimes article specifically mentioned it was largely premeds who complained. From my experience teaching o-chem, the premeds were always the pushiest. Probably because they need the A for medical school. Also Maitland Jones has a very good reputation as a teacher.
- knaik94 4y agoI have heard the opposite about Maitland Jones from people that have taken a course with them.
- dymk 4y agoWere they premeds that needed the A for med school?
- knaik94 4y agoTheir chosen field of study doesn't affect the teaching ability of a professor. That's not relevant information. Do you imagine the professor keeps track of every pre-med student and gives them a different teaching and grading experience compared to others?
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoIt's not the professor who's different, it's the students. Pre-med students were insufferable in Chem classes much the same way Civil Engineering students were insufferable in Circuits class, only instead of merely needing to pass the class, pre-med students NEED an A. It's basically accepted that pre-med students are doomed if they can't graduate with something very close to 4.0, so they are very sensitive to a tough class. Chem students who are planning to go to grad school or industry don't NEED straight A's, so they can be content with "Wow, that class was tough, glad I managed a B". Combine that with a class that is the first real hard step in a chemistry education, and thus will by necessity be tough, and you're in for a bunch of pissed of pre-med students.
- 4y ago
- SevenNation 4y ago> As for the inevitability, organic chemistry, at least as it's currently taught, is hard, involving a mix of memorization and problem solving (see today's Nobel Prize coverage if you want a greater sense of why). The memorization can be compared to committing dozens of flow charts to your brain, as each type of reaction will need different conditions and catalysts depending on the precise nature of the starting materials. Armed with that memorization, people are then ready for problem-solving: figuring out which combinations of reactions will build simple raw materials into a complex chemical like an antibiotic or polymer. This "organic chemistry is hard" idea gets trotted out pretty frequently. The paradox is that premeds also need to take classes in physiology, which in involves a lot of... you guessed it - memorization. Maybe more memorization. That said, there are as many ways to teach this course as there are teachers. I suspect some emphasize memorization because that's the easiest kind of knowledge to test for. But when approached conceptually, organic chemistry requires little more memorization than any serious scientific topic.
- mjhay 4y agoI've never taken any chemistry, but everyone seems to have horror stories. It seems like chemistry is uniquely obsessed with memorization. I can't fathom the purpose of memorizing the periodic table - who cares? Why not focus on what the periodic table actually means?
- kaesar14 4y agoMy education only went as far as AP Chemistry in high school but we did no such memorization of periodic table. The table is organized in a way that's extremely informative with regards to ionic charge and element classification. It pretty much is exactly what you say re: learning what the periodic table means. Any high level chemistry class that's focused on such trivial memorization is doing a huge disservice to its students. The memorization bits come with remembering nomenclature and equilibriums, which you just kinda have to memorize or you're not really learning any chemistry at all. They're the building blocks of all higher level chemistry that come after, organic or inorganic.
- 4y ago
- waylandsmithers 4y agoI remember hearing about "orgo" from my pre-med friends as the one specifically hated/difficult class, to the point where some would just take the class at a local state school over the summer and transfer the credit in to avoid it.
- Stamp01 4y agoIt seems completely reasonable to me that if you pay for an education and the person you're ostensibly paying to teach you is doing a bad job, to be pissed off about it. The student is the customer.
- frankthedog 4y agoI would argue that the university is the customer of the professor and the student is a customer of the university’s reputation. In this case the university’s reputation is now diminished so the students have harmed themselves.
- faeriechangling 4y agoSeems to me most people reckon the students did bad because of a pandemic and that ochem isn’t actually all that relevant in practical medicine. I think the students reputation would have been far more harmed by failing out. If anything has suffered a reputation hit from this story it’s organic chemistry professors in general who are broadly being portrayed in threads like these as sadists who care more about failing out future doctors than teaching them practical know-how who slid into standard medical education through an accident of history despite ochem perhaps being more appropriate as an elective topic.
- permo-w 4y agothis is an unnecessary complication of matters. the professors are workers and the students are customers. I would argue that attempts to obfuscate that are in fact attempts to maintain the university’s power over their students
- jdgoesmarching 4y agoOr, hear me out, the person paying money is the customer. Students are within their rights to criticize the services they pay for. I have no patience for professors on an ego trip. If a majority of students consistently fail your class, then you are failing as an educator. Besides teaching, it also includes designing an appropriate lesson plan for the level of their students. There are very few fields where we place the responsibility on customers to suck it up if they regularly receive a bad product or service.
- coffeeblack 4y agoAnother Ivy League uni suspended a professor because he said 那个 in a linguistics class, the Chinese equivalent of “ehm” (is it “ehm” in English?). Nothing surprises me anymore.
- humanistbot 4y agoThe Greg Patton case? No they didn't: https://poetsandquants.com/2020/09/26/usc-marshall-finds-students-were-sincere-but-prof-did-no-wrong-in-racial-flap/ https://poetsandquants.com/2020/09/26/usc-marshall-finds-stu... Also USC is not an Ivy League university, but that's another matter.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI'm always continuously surprised by how extreme, eye-catching news actually always turns out as overblown and yet collectively we as a society still follow extreme, eye-catching news. One would think eye-catching news would be seen similar to hot women washing cars on a car ad, clearly fake to sell product, but somehow people are still repeating the headlines and yet its considered unreasonable to run around pointing at random women and demanding they drop everything and wash their car.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- toss1 4y ago>>Attracting more students also boosts tuition income, but having 350 students in a chemistry class can tend to limit student satisfaction, which may have been a factor in the complaints. Right, so the ratio of [professors]:[students] is already too low, so fire the professor. Brilliant </s>
- aaron695 4y ago
- rossdavidh 4y agoSo, I have never taken organic chemistry, but in my Electrical Engineering studies at Univ of Illinois (a top-5 in the nation program at that time), math courses were used for a similar filtering purpose. In particular, Calculus and Differential Equations. In every EE course afterwards, we would in the first week or two solve problems using calc/diffeq, then get told "of course that's not how we want to really do it, so here's how you do it using algebra and complex numbers". It was pretty clear that Differential Equations, maybe even parts of Calculus, were not necessary to learn the engineering, they were a way of having another department (Math) do the filtering. In ten years of work in the semiconductor industry, I never once needed to use calculus or differential equations. I think there are a lot of fields that have "weed-out" courses, and the author of this article is right to point out that the more fundamental issue is whether or not this is the right way to do the (probably necessary) filtering.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> It was pretty clear that Differential Equations, maybe even parts of Calculus, were not necessary to learn the engineering, they were a way of having another department (Math) do the filtering. In ten years of work in the semiconductor industry, I never once needed to use calculus or differential equations. I’m a trained EE. Calculus and even differential equations concepts were used all the time before I became a manager. It depends on the type of EE work you do, but I would strongly disagree with anyone who suggests these math topics aren’t relevant to EE work.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoIt doesn't even make sense, really. Calculus is the "algebra" of higher level math. That is to say, it forms the base. Diff Eq teaches you the ability to create classes of equations (meta-math, if you will). My degree wasn't in EE, but I can't imagine neither of those are useful for an Electrical Engineer.
- whimsicalism 4y agoI can imagine diffeq not being useful for an electrical engineer merely because I wouldn't expect most diffeqs they encounter to be solvable analytically? And the entire point of most diffeq courses is to focus on the small subset of analytically tractable diffeqs.
- photochemsyn 4y agoOrganic chemistry being used as a weed-out system for pre-meds doesn't make a whole lot of sense, particularly anything related to organic synthesis and things like nuclear magnetic spectral interpretation, which doctors simply will never use. A main issue here is that any real (and interesting) understanding of organic chemistry requires a fairly solid understanding of quantum mechanics and things like electronic structure calculations. This is also true of spectroscopy, which is probably the main analytical and experimental tool used in the field. However, that would likely require QM as a prerequisite for organic chemistry, which is a course program that makes little sense for pre-med students. Hence, crude approximations, hand-waving arguments, and rote memorization are often used instead of trying to actually explain things based on more fundamental concepts like electron density. (This approach is sometimes called physical organic chemistry). Additionally, chemistry is one of the most patent-centric areas in the corporate university, and teaching tends to be a second-hand concern. The researchers with large grants aren't required to teach courses, so they farm the job out to temporary hires, grad students and this 84-year old who probably should have retired years ago.
- whimsicalism 4y agoThe goal is merely to reduce the supply of doctors to keep pay high, the way we go about doing it is not that important. At my school, there was a different organic chem class for physics/chem students that was based on physical understanding + QM.
- SilverBirch 4y agoThis article is pretty trash to be honest. Yes, organic chem is hard, yes it's a pre-requisite for med school, yes the pandemic has impacted teaching. Frankly, a huge amount of the writing about this boils down to old people writing "Kids these days are too darn lazy". Ok. Sure. The students didn't petition to get him fired, they didn't ask for that. The fact that NYUs response was to fire him, and his reponse was to go to the New York Times to bitch about his students being lazy, show that the problem here isn't the students and the students don't deserve to have their careers jeopardised by a clearly incompetent university.
- jeff_carr 4y ago> The students didn't petition to get him fired, they didn't ask for that If this is true, this isn't being reported widely enough.
- SilverBirch 4y agoFrom the article > The petition did not call for Jones' firing. Also notable, the petition isn’t publicly available either. Why? Because the students were actually being quite reasonable- they weren’t trying to get him fired.
- pmarreck 4y agoIt's certainly hate-worthy
- noasaservice 4y agoAll of these anecdotes - data - is why I have no degree. Sure, a student can be lazy. But in most cases like these, it's that you inadvertently hit a weeder course. It's effectively a landmine. And schools benefit from these too. It lowers GPA's, threatens loans and grants, forces you on a different path, and they still get paid for not doing their end of the implied bargain. And naturally, these "teachers" are nearly immune from criticism, which is why this story is being blasted everywhere.
- concomitant 4y agoI attended medical school and excelled in my organic chemistry courses as an undergraduate. In my view, organic chemistry is a difficult course for many because it is quite multidiscplinary and requires multiple modes of thinking/reasoning. - Basic chemistry (chemistry 101): Concepts like bond formation, electronegativity, acid-base reactions, etc - Memorization: Functional groups, reaction types, etc are fundamental building blocks (much like writing and speaking requires a knowledge of words). - Deductive reasoning: Getting from molecule A to molecule B requires long chains of intermediate steps that logically follow from previous steps - Visuo-spatial: This is probably the one faculty that comes naturally to some and absolutely does not click for others.. Understanding organic chemistry fundamentally requires an appreciation of how molecules and groups interact in 3-D space. Understanding spatial patterns and interactions also helps with memorization (e.g. it is easier to remember why certain functional groups behave the way they do) - Linguistic: This may seem trivial but many struggle with the grammar of naming molecules (IUPAC nomenclature) It is true that organic chemistry is a weeder course for pre-meds. However, I do think it is a relatively good filter to select people who excel across multiple cognitive dimensions, which is required for success in medical school. Now whether or not this is required to produce good doctors can be debated, but I suspect that in certain corners of medicine, particularly the more cerebral specialties like nephrology or academic medicine in general, rigorous undergraduate courses such as organic chemistry are absolutely pre-requisite. I ended up leaving medicine and am now a founder of a biotech startup, so take my opinions with a huge grain of salt :)
- knaik94 4y agoI think organic chemistry is hard enough as a subject to where students shouldn't have to face the additional difficulty of having adversarial teachers. A weeder course shouldn't be the same class students are expected to learn how to teach themselves material. If anything, a weeder course should have the best teachers in the department. How to help make sure the teachers don't burn out is a different issue. I imagine it's hard to be the teacher of these kinds of classes year after year.
- flowersjeff 4y agoMy 'fav' class as an undergrad was also the hardest. I was 'lucky' to have received a 'C'. There was one 'A', one 'B', my grade ... in a class of perhaps 30. When a grad student asked about the curve on the first exam - the prof calmly explained that he wasn't going to be that prof... That prof being one that curved everyone up to make their life easier by keeping everyone happy. Rather, we needed to learn the material and figure it out asap. I learned from that class, I didn't know how to learn - and was totally confused, as I was a great student with great grades, etc. But that talk hit me hard, I realized that he was correct - and I needed to change. That wake up call, nearly three decades ago, has since allowed me to learn novel tools, technologies, etc - where others struggle. I have benefited personally incredibly from knowing how to learn - many won't understand what I'm saying nor will they realize why it is important. Too often, my peers - other prof's will make an easy class/test/etc to make everyone happy and pass that buck forward (after all, admin is happiest when the customers are happiest). Are we really helping these students though? I've been lucky to work with teams from Brazil, India, China, etc - these folks have been pushed in ways that would seem inhumane by the standards I'm reading in the comments. These folks are the ones that industry (and the individual for that matter) wants and will want, as they know what they are doing and are able to learn novel technologies as they emerge. I tell my students the importance of learning how to learn, that their competition isn't in the room with them - it's thousands of miles away...They just want an 'A' for that six figure job that they have been promised. Indeed, whenever I hear that "six figure paycheck" my heart aches and I'm saddened that someone in advising/online/etc keeps pumping this idea out. In my opinion, a bit of discomfort in a synthetic environment like academia - for the possibility of a lifetime of ease now being taboo is beyond saddening.
- knaik94 4y agoI don't see how in a class of 30 students, having only 1 A and 1 B is a indicator of a good teacher. By definition the grades should reflect how well the students learn the material. Making your class artificially hard doesn't do anything to offset artificially easy courses. A class where 93% of students didn't properly master more than 80% of the material demonstrate a failure of the teacher not students. I am glad you gained something positive from that class, but I would say that is despite the professor, not because of them. Having good or bad grades is currently a poor reflection of how well a student will pickup new technologies exactly because of skewed grading methods like that of your professor. I am glad you gained something positive, but I wonder how many promising students were discouraged and pursued other interests over the years due to opaque testing standards. Tests are supposed to gauge how much information students are retaining from a teacher. In a high level class cross-listed for graduate students, the concern of lazy students shouldn't be an issue.
- knaik94 4y agoFrom what I've experienced certain professors make it very clear they dislike teaching and expect students to teach themselves. I dropped out of a pre-med track at my university due to failing organic chemistry. I wasn't set up to succeed. This was made clear by the fact that it was the year with the most failed students in organic chemistry in the last 10 years. I also learned more things every recitation than in both weekly lectures combined, and my TA made it clear that this was normal and he was going to help us not fail. That teacher was not invited to teach a large 200 level class again. It was a distinguished research professor, and being at an R1 research university, he was very valuable as faculty but it was clear that he had no interest in teaching. He was much more comfortable as a mentor/teacher for higher level chemistry courses where the students have already learned the foundations and focus on their own research or independent study. I ended up switching to CS, finished all of the required courses in 4 semesters instead of the usual 6+, and graduated only 1 year late, 5 years instead of 4. I even ended up doing an independent study and NIH funded summer research as an undergraduate in CS. I got to work in a grad lab on campus, one of the few non-phd candidates. Organic chemistry is interesting because the cognition required for it is pretty similar to the cognition required for software development. The underlying technique is about knowing fundamental puzzle pieces and putting them together in new ways to solve problems/equations. This is a generalization and the techniques are obviously distinct at higher levels. But there are strong parallels between the problem solving method and techniques in organic chemistry and software engineering. I should have really loved organic chemistry but I didn't. I still hate it to this day, not because of the material, but because of the negative emotions associated with the class. It's really frustrating that CS education has a strong culture, in the US, of having to teach yourself to be successful. This is true regardless of how great of a university you end up at. It's equally true at MIT and Stanford as it is at any state University. I understand the motivation to foster an environment of students passionate to learn on their own, but forcing them doesn't accomplish that, it just pushes the issue to the next year. I understand the need to make students learn that at a certain point in their academic journey, they need to be comfortable teaching themselves because no one else will really have an answer for them. This gets warped into this fear based teaching method of encouraging the idea that anything less than a B means failure but at the same time getting an A is impossible unless you're a prodigy. It's very damaging to the mental health of the students. Professors dismissing this fact shouldn't teach because they clearly can't foster a healthy environment for students. I don't know if that's true for every university, but it was true for mine, a respected R1, top 20 math, top 30 CS, physics, top 50 Bio, Chem program in the country. It was true for the 300+ level classes in biology and chemistry as well as math and CS.
- iancmceachern 4y agoA similar thing happened at the college I went to, the Colorado school of Mines. We had a physics prof, I think it was physics 2 that was the real tough one. It was known for being very hard, most folks didn't get good grades despite trying very hard in the class, and they famously never curved it, at all. The semester in which my buddies and I took the class was particularly bad. The class average was in the 50s or 60s, the highest score was in the high 70s, and half of the class or more failed the midterm. There was an uproar, so the prof held a town hall of sorts with the students in the class. In that town hall he didn't back down on the curve, it wasn't going to be curved. It also came out that the prof hadn't actually written the test, nor had he taken the test himself. It was written and graded all by TAs. The students were able to convince him to actually take the test amd report back. He took the test and reported back. He scored a 68 (or so, it's been a while). a bit above the average in the class but still not good. My buddy scored a 78, he did way better than the prof on his own test. In the end the prof agreed to set his own score as 100% and then basically bumped everyone score by 100%-his score. The folks that did better than his score just got 100%. It was considered one of thr weed out classes for all engineering disciplines at Mines. A teacher like this is failing his customers, the students. A educators job is to educate, not to sort or judge. Edited - typo.
- geebee 4y agoIt depends. There's a kind of professor I like to refer to as the "wheel of misfortune" professor. I think we've all known them - they're one of a group of professors who teach a standard part of a curriculum but teach a vastly different version of the class, with outlier levels of time commitment and grading standards. This professor can end up severely disadvantaging certain cohorts simply because the students had the misfortune to end up in the unfortunate class based on a spin of the wheel, because of what year they entered a program or what time slot of day happened to be open in their course schedule. Well connected students who ask around are often aware of who you need to dodge. I've known a few of these professors, and I'm not exaggerating when I say that a student who happens to have the misfortune of this particular professor for organic chemistry or intro to data structures and algorithms is measurably less likely to continue in the major or professional path than a student who happens to enroll in the same credit class with someone else. I remember a nature show about newly born fawns and grizzly bears. A fawn's survival to adulthood is largely a matter of chance, depending on which side of the river the hungry grizzly bear happens to be wandering down that day. These professors are the grizzly bears of the academic world, and they leave a real trail of destruction in their wake. To be clear - I don't know that this particular professor qualifies as a grizzly bear. A few red flags - such as cheating and not attending class - suggest to me that the scenario I described above might not quite apply. But I do know that these professors often invoke rigor and standards as a justification for the harm they do - as if the other professors, who assign higher grades and higher completion rates don't teach a rigorous class. When this happens, I generally see no need to "fire" someone - I'd just limit the professor's teaching load to advanced, intensely difficult electives at the upper division or grad level.
- mcguire 4y ago"WSN also accessed student evaluation records for courses taught by Jones, which showed that his scores had been consistently low for years — long before the spring 2022 student petition. In the past five years, Jones’ co-professors teaching the same course typically had scores around or above 4.0 on a 5.0 scale, while Jones averaged around 3.3. In his final semester, his evaluation score dropped to 2.4. The stark contrast between those numbers shows that students weren’t just complaining about the intensity of the course." (https://nyunews.com/opinion/2022/10/05/maitland-jones-nytimes-response/ https://nyunews.com/opinion/2022/10/05/maitland-jones-nytime...) The spring 2022 class was "experimental" (presumably due to the end of COVID restrictions) as well.
- sniperjoe360 4y agoI took Dr. Jones' course at Princeton and found it extremely reasonable. In fact hundreds of students over 10+ years took his course at Princeton and no one wrote a petition as far as I know about the difficulty of the course. I suspect this is because the test format at Princeton is rarely multiple choice, and mostly essay or problem solving based. Maitland Jones' class fits the bill in that the problems are mostly about synthesis of organic compounds. It is hard because it requires you to memorize dozens of reactions and their respective limitations, however there is not always "one right answer" as long as you can accomplish the synthesis of the molecule in a reasonable fashion. The class taught me to think in 3D about chiralty, and also how to problem solve through multi-step synthesis from simple products. I'm now a physician and I credit all of my understanding of organic chemistry to Dr. Jones and Gingrich who worked with him on laboratory portion. It was a perfectly fine class, hard but totally doable with a lot of effort.
- busterarm 4y agoMy lifelong experience with most NYU students is that they have more money than brains.
- mcguire 4y ago"...which culminated in about a quarter of his class of 350 students signing a petition that does not seem to be publicly available." I believe this to be it: https://nyunews.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Organic-Chemistry-I-Concerns-Meeting-Washington-Square-News.pdf https://nyunews.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Organic-Chemi... Linked from https://nyunews.com/opinion/2022/10/05/maitland-jones-nytimes-response/ https://nyunews.com/opinion/2022/10/05/maitland-jones-nytime... which seems to be the only coverage not from Jones' point of view.