7 ms·
Glut of Fake LinkedIn Profiles Pits HR Against the Bots
- civilized 4y ago"Hmm, https://virus.def.inite.ly https://virus.def.inite.ly looks shady, but all the Fortune 500 CISOs are posting I need to download this immediately or my computer will blow up"
- tyingq 4y agoI'm wondering how well Google is going to fare against the next wave of things like GPT-3, DALL-E, etc. The quality of content+link farms, comment spammers, etc, is going to continue to improve.
- aquaduck 4y agoMy cynical prediction: Google search (as we now know it) will be retired. Google will provide AI-generated text which attempts to answer the user's prompt, with links to results in a handful of curated sources such as wikipedia.
- fny 4y agoI already use GPT for this purpose, and it works terrifyingly well. You can even ask it for citations, and it provides you with a link. Beware--it's prone to bullshitting. This one time I asked it for the symptoms for pulmonary hypertension: shortness of breath, chest pain, lightheadedness, and fainting. Check. Then I asked it for a citation... It linked me to an article on hemorrhoids.
- vertis 4y agoOr is it smarter than all of us and detecting some link between pulmonary hypertension and hemorrhoids.
- bryanrasmussen 4y ago"This study showed that patients with hemorrhoids displayed a 27% increased risk of CHD after adjustment for the confounding factors. Risk factors for the development of CHD are more common among subjects with hemorrhoids than those without hemorrhoids except for diabetes mellitus." https://journals.lww.com/md-journal/fulltext/2017/08040/association_between_hemorrhoid_and_risk_of.22.aspx https://journals.lww.com/md-journal/fulltext/2017/08040/asso...
- drexlspivey 4y agoCan you post your prompt/params ?
- makk 4y ago> it's prone to bullshitting. We may be closer to human-level AGI than I thought.
- stevewatson301 4y agoTheir fields of research, such as large language models and image generation and the newly demoed “multi search” feature all strongly point towards this being the case.
- joegibbs 4y agoHow would this work with new information, e.g. breaking news? Would Google be manually putting in anything new that comes up or would they have the legacy Google crawler running in the background to feed to the AI system?
- theonlybutlet 4y agoHow will Google monetise this though?
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoAds will still exist.
- 4ggr0 4y ago"Dear GoogleBot, how can I center a div?" - To center a div horizontally on a page, simply set the width of the element and the margin property to auto. Or, you can use WebSiteBuilder® which simplifies it for you. Use 'this' affiliate link for 10% off in the first month.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agothat's first year second year: there are 25 different ways of centering a div with potential fallbacks for older browsers and user technologies, please consider WebSiteBuilder® for all your div centering needs. Otherwise click here to read about the 25 different ways to use, text guaranteed 86% accurate. third year: WebSiteBuilder®
- thatjoeoverthr 4y agoI’ve started doing this already. Just last week I had a question about how to interpret labeling on construction wood. Google came up with nothing for SEO spam. GPT3 explained it completely.
- jondwillis 4y agoWhat did you use to “ask” GPT-3?
- nickfromseattle 4y ago>Google search (as we now know it) will be retired. I think so too, but I think it's still pretty far out. In order to do this, Google's AI-generated text needs to be better than the web results they return today, 100% of the time. It's the same reason why Google has never made 100% of the first 10 results ads. If users make a search and advertisers aren't bidding on the keyword, Google will return 0 results, and the user is less likely to come back and make a new search. Google's AI needs to consistently be better than the content created by webmasters. Across billions (trillions?) of different search phrases. Maybe there is an intermediary step where Google uses AI-generated text in a small subset of searches, and then expands out gradually. But there is so many unique searches it seems like a tall task. Also, if Google displaces webmasters with AI-generated content, what incentives do websites have to create the new content Google will need to train their AI on to answer whatever humans want to know over the next 50 years?
- rishsriv 4y agoAlgorithmically generated content by itself might not be a bad thing for users' search experience IMO, as long as the engine can differentiate between "right" and "gibberish" content. Linking to verified sources (research papers, official websites, verified social media accounts) when writing about these topics might make this easier. LLMs will then be able to understand if one if misrepresenting what was stated in the linked sources or not.
- malandrew 4y agoAny sufficiently advanced spam is indistinguishable from content.
- djohnston 4y agoLinkedIn is uniquely positioned to avoid site integrity issues because there is an honest to god source of truth - HR itself. Federate the data custody and allow company and employee to publish who is working where.
- tdeck 4y agoThat puts companies in control over if and when their employees can advertise their work history. I'm not sure that's something I'd want, since updating a LinkedIn profile is many peoples' first step to finding a new job.
- rootusrootus 4y agoYeah, I wouldn't want my employer to have any control whatsoever over my LinkedIn profile. I would abandon the service instantly if that were to happen.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoYes I can’t wait for a vexatious employer to rewrite my employment history for me. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/02/10/apple-associate/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/02/10/apple-a...
- CharlesW 4y ago> …there is an honest to god source of truth - HR itself. Or alternatively (and what LinkedIn is doing), employees can "open their employee-only experience" by verifying their work email address associated with a company.
- nitwit005 4y agoThat is already public for things like executive positions, but you'll still have the problem of verifying that it's the actual person creating the account.
- xxs 4y agoThat would fail in the EU regulatory wise (GDPR)
- smt88 4y agoI'm also seeing these used to spam people with sales pitches. Fake profiles seem incredibly easy to avoid because LinkedIn is one of the few "real identity" social networks. I can only conclude that they don't care.
- webdoodle 4y agoLinkedIn is creating an excuse to purge people, not fake profiles. Like most of the corporate social media sites, it is heavily censoring people who speak out on subjects they are experts on. Covid and Ukraine being high on the list, but even disparaging Queen Elizabeth will get your account restricted.
- Double_a_92 4y agoUnless you work in the medical field or for the military, why would you even talk about such irrelavant things?
- suoduandao2 4y agoWell now, Robert Malone was recently deplatformed for his views on the Covid Response[1], despite being an expert in the sort of tech used to build these vaccines with citations going back to at least 1990. I'd hardly call his opinion 'irrelavant'. [1]https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0ZCLBEbktYqp1lSheZS81E https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0ZCLBEbktYqp1lSheZS81E
- myvoiceismypass 4y agoOh the guy that claims he invented mRNA but pushes hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin?
- cm42 4y agoHelp! Police! FBI! Ministry of Truth! Somebody! A non-physician is over here commenting on medications they've never prescribed!
- suoduandao2 4y agoIs that what corporate journalists say about him? You'd do well to go to primary sources when there's misinformation about. His publication history is a matter of public record. He's actually pro-vaccine as a personal choice, his objection to the public policy at the time centered on the need for informed consent to medical procedures. What well-meaning people find so dangerous about that I'd love to know.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI constantly have to contact LI to remove users from my company l, LI requires a 4 week window for the account to respond to the removal request. My company is less than 10 people and I’m marked as the founder on LI. All I can say is good. The sooner LI put in actual usable controls, the better.
- walrus01 4y agoYou know the scene in the 2014 Godzilla movie where the Japanese Godzilla expert says "Let them fight..."? That's pretty much my reaction to recruiters and HR wasting time on linkedin bots.
- ramraj07 4y agoUntil it becomes standard practice to require verified LinkedIn work history.
- walrus01 4y agoWhat's when I move to a yurt in the forest
- jeffrallen 4y agoPlease verify your yurt. Click on the real yurt from the following 6 pictures...
- 6stringmerc 4y agoHello I’m from the high speed train project and we’re going to eminent domain your yurt. Get packing!
- mellavora 4y agonot until you click on the right "does this picture contain a high-speed train" image
- z9znz 4y agoThat will never happen. LinkedIn has long since peaked. Since it became cluttered with odd influencer types posting largely meaningless fluff, and more and more recruiters who make no effort to read candidate pages before spamming, its value has continually declined each year.
- miked85 4y agoLinkedIn seemed useful at first (10+ years ago), now it really is just a source of spam and "recruiters" sending emails for totally irrelevant jobs.
- toast0 4y agoI worked at a large internet company when LinkedIn was growing. It was an immense source of spam because it encouraged people to upload the whole address book. And for years, they wouldn't let you tell them not to send you anything else unless you created an account, which yeah, not going to create an account at viral spam central, thanks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- specialist 4y agoI once arranged a date. 2007. My date said "I'm glad LinkedIn's good for something."
- nottorp 4y ago... but HR are bots. 90% of those on Linkedin at least.
- origin_path 4y agoIt's curious how every single fake profile is of a woman. Suggestive of honey trapping, perhaps, but then why so many accounts.
- glouwbug 4y agoIt's like reverse tinder
- ReptileMan 4y agoI hope bots win. They will show more humanity than HR.
- 6stringmerc 4y agoBut then out of work HR people might learn how to program bots in their image…shudder…
- ianpurton 4y agoI don't understand. Why would someone create lots of fake profiles?
- martin_a 4y agoThe most obvious reasons might be spam or stealing contact information from the site. Those profiles could also be used for mass-liking of posts, to trick the algorithms for the feed.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agowell we have been seeing fake people going for jobs posts here, so if you create profiles A,B,C C gets enticing job offer from recruiter You hire actual user D you based your profile on to take tests etc. You get job offer but we need recommendations Please talk to my friends A and B!
- Eumenes 4y agoRecruiting firms often create fake developer profiles to attract other recruiters messages. Then, they'll recruit for that ideal profile and present the candidate blindly to the companies HR or hiring managers, hoping to secure a relationship/placement fee.
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agoAI bots vs HR bots, popcorn time.
- woutr_be 4y agoAll you have to do to beat an HR bot is request a JD, the company and a salary. 95% of recruiters refuse to answer this. (At least based on my experience)
- Bouncingsoul1 4y agoBack in the days before I got into SWDev, I was working as eventtech(sound/light), which is quite a shady buisness at time. Most companies only have minimum employees and hire freelancer when needed, for events obviously. Anyway since not all events are successfull, paying and agreements may not always be honoured, which results in lot of backtalk and rumour regarding liquidity and/or payment practice of said companies. Anyway of course this was also mirrored in online discussion of specific forums, for Germany especially in the PAForum. The answer from PAForum to counter fake accounts was actual proof of identity, by sending a copy of passport and a phone call. This made this forum no1. for jobs and feedback about companies, since people needed to add their reputation for it. Services are hard to scale and need a lot of moderation but for specific needs it may make sense.
- dijonman2 4y agoAs a hiring manager I’m encountering a tremendous amount of hiring fraud. One person interviews and another shows up. I have seen most of this activity with an address out of the DC area and I suspect they do this systematically and collect 2-3 weeks pay until fired at multiple companies.
- burpee 4y agoThere's thousands of bots with obviously recognizable pictures from Thisdoesnotexist on both LinkedIn and Quora. Quora is arguably more insidious as these are ranked and spreading huge amounts of disinformation. Someone should really step in and create a neural network to recognize and flag artificially generated profiles
- Tyr42 4y agoWouldn't that be a GAN but with more steps?
- bambax 4y agoI recently created a fake LinkedIn account, because I don't like the fact that some users are notified when I lookup their profile, and it's impossible to use LinkedIn without being logged in. The fake profile is an ordinary tech worker, not esp. skilled in anything and with a short work experience; but it's a lot of fun to be fake... My alter ego has 50+ connections now. There are moments when it feels quite real...