7 ms·
Free Markets Don’t Buy Peace
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- thewarrior 4y agoThis article seems to conflate peace with the exact American political setup of democracy, individualism and corporate influence on politics. Is the paragon of free markets the USA the paragon of peace ? The fact that America buys Iraqi oil didn't prevent it from being bombed back by decades. This seems to be people ruing that our project to dominate the entire world with an ideology that had us comfortably in charge is failing.
- stevenwoo 4y agoI don't disagree with your assessment of the American project as defined being wrong headed by the author, but the article lists the origins of the idea going to many other countries switchover and failing so it's not just America. However, I think Piketty's analysis of the same problem better in Capital and Ideology. i.e. free markets and trade by themselves to not be the end all solution, the lack of transparency that can lead even democracies to make wrong decisions because they do not have visibility to make correct decisions, and constitutionally protected rights of acquired capital/property over people means inertia in current systems make it extremely difficult to do the right thing.
- hackerlight 4y agoBut the fact that America buys Kuwaiti oil did prevent it from being bombed back by decades. That probably motivated the US to intervene in Saddam's invasion. Obviously, trade between a hegemon and a small country isn't going to deter wars of imperialism. Because the hegemon can force the trade relationship. But it should deter war between the US and China. China's leaders want to survive. If they stop the gravy train of trade, they're putting their own survival at risk.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoThe idea that countries always make rational and economical decisions is false. The Iraq war wasn't 4D chess it was much worse: Americans really believed in it. Which is ultimately also why they got their ass kicked: free elections were held and the Iraqis wanted the Americans out. Instead of installing a puppet government what they got was Iraqi politicians with agency.
- hackerlight 4y agoThis is the constructivist school of IR, which says that nationalism can cause war. We should not get wedded to a particular prism. They're all partly true. Trade and treaties deter war to an extent (liberalism). Nationalism can sometimes be a major factor as in Iraq 2003 (constructivism). And sometimes it's actually about defense concerns, e.g. the Soviet-Finnish Winter War (realism). These are all partly true theories.
- mantas 4y agoSoviet-Finnish war was an imperialist annexation attempt with defense concerns as an excuse. Just like Baltic states few months later.
- hackerlight 4y agoPopular support was imperialistic and nationalistic, but Stalin's personal motivations were probably defense. Stalin invested huge amounts of time in the negotiations before the war, attending many of the sessions personally, where they discussed land swaps. That shows an earnest concern. He was also paranoid and tended to act cautiously and opportunistically. So the defense explanation fits. Of course, we're reading his mind here, so it's hard to say for sure.
- mantas 4y agoStalin's personal motivation was world domination. Just Lenin before him and other USSR leaders later. Ribentrop-Molotov pact secret protocols wasn't „self defence“. Even though both parties knew they'll eventually go to war against each other. I didn't study Stalin's proposal to Finland that much, but essentially it was same deal as for other Baltic states. Take our military bases for „defence“ and we may sweeten the deal a little bit with a gift. Because who cares if we're going to annex you next summer one way or another :) Couldn't do that in 1920, but USSR thought it's strong enough in 1939. For example Lithuania and Vilnius case. Well, so nice of him to give back historical capital, isn't it :) Just to use sweeten the deal of installing army bases in Lithuania-proper and then using them to annex the whole country next summer.
- robto 4y agoThis article doesn't address the most salient argument in the free trade -> peace syllogism, which is that free trade between two countries reduces the chance of war between them only to the extent in which cutting that trade off (which is what would happen in a war) would cause domestic pain. So it's an incentive, not an absolute. Take the China example - China as of this September holds $3.055 trillion in foreign currency reserves. This makes the US and China mutually interdependent - if China stopped selling products to the US then it would cause a massive recession in China. If the US couldn't find buyers to finance its spending, it would default on its debt. If the US defaults, the entire international economy would likely go up in flames. So it's like mutually assured destruction, but instead of stockpiling nukes (though we do that, too), we're actually producing useful goods and services. And it doesn't make war impossible, but it does mean that war won't happen on a whim - it will be an utter last resort, with millions of wage earners and business owners wanting to try to make any other solution work, lest they lose their livelihood. It's hard to take the article seriously without this sort of analysis.
- karpierz 4y agoLargely agree on your post, but one nit: > If the US couldn't find buyers to finance its spending, it would default on its debt. Why would the US have to default on its debt, when the debt is denominated in a currency that the US can freely print?
- danuker 4y agoPrinting (currency debasement) could be thought of as a form of soft default.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoExtremely misleading to imply those two outcomes are similar.
- danuker 4y agoThere are two ways government influences the economy: monetary inflation and taxation. Whether prices get higher (government bidding up prices following monetary inflation) or taxes increase, the effect is the same: the good/service production in question will get modified relative to other parts of the economy. Inflation is just a tax increase on "everything but" what the government is buying.
- bassrattle 4y agoHere's an article about the evils governments do, while free markets are defined by the absence of government intervention. As Obama explained, government is defined by its legal monopoly on the use of violent force. It follows that with every regulation carries an underlying threat of violence, so it seems clear peace won't come from more regulation.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoObama might have mentioned that but he didn’t at all create it. Definitely not to any amount he should be contributed with it. I remember the first place I heard it was a military general… but we might as well attribute Mark Twain.
- hither_shores 4y agoIt's from Weber. Here's the relevant paragraph of Politics as a Vocation: > 'Every state is founded on force,' said Trotsky at Brest-Litovsk. That is indeed right. If no social institutions existed which knew the use of violence, then the concept of 'state' would be eliminated, and a condition would emerge that could be designated as 'anarchy,' in the specific sense of this word. Of course, force is certainly not the normal or the only means of the state--nobody says that--but force is a means specific to the state. Today the relation between the state and violence is an especially intimate one. In the past, the most varied institutions--beginning with the sib--have known the use of physical force as quite normal. Today, however, we have to say that a state is a human community that (successfully) claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory. Note that 'territory' is one of the characteristics of the state. Specifically, at the present time, the right to use physical force is ascribed to other institutions or to individuals only to the extent to which the state permits it. The state is considered the sole source of the 'right' to use violence. Hence, 'politics' for us means striving to share power or striving to influence the distribution of power, either among states or among groups within a state.
- danaris 4y agoThis is a very binary view of "peace" (and "violence"). There's a meaningful difference between a society that allows and supports a government that has a law enforcement body of some sort, and an active armed conflict.
- stevenwoo 4y agoI have a stupid question that may be just terminology - isn't the article talking about neoliberalism without saying neoliberalism? After I read the first few paragraphs, I searched for the term and did not find it.
- sfpotter 4y agoYou aren't likely to find the word "neoliberalism" used in politico, I don't think. All sources of news have an inherent bias that will constrain the acceptable range of discourse, along with terminology used.
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoThe reason why is because you won't find neoliberalism in IR. The author is an academic, I have a postgrad in IR, neoliberalism was a term invented by people who opposed the ideas, there is no accepted positive definition of neoliberalism, and it isn't a term you see often outside popular culture.
- sfpotter 4y agoI don't think this is the primary factor. As another commenter mentioned, Politico does indeed have a low incidence of the word "neoliberalism". Not all of Politico's contributors are involved in academic international relations, so this isn't an explanation. It might be that Politico is biased in favor of the worldview promulgated by academic international relations, but this is back to my point---news sources are biased, and this bias constrains the acceptable range of debate. (Please note that I am not personally making a judgment call as to whether or not this is good or bad. Just making an observation and answering the original question.)
- jeffbee 4y agoHuh, I assumed you were exaggerating but Google results for site:politico.com "neoliberal" really are surprisingly thin, orders of magnitude less common than any other kind of -ism.
- 4y ago
- bm3719 4y agoThis conclusion is being drawn from weak premises, though I'd agree with the article that we were sold this faulty assertion by our leaders. Is a free market even possible with an top-down, authoritarian, surveillance state like China? They even describe themselves as a "socialist market economy", which is pretty far from what economists would call a free market. I'd argue that from the outside, the only agency we have is to give an authoritarian state more customers. That might be liberalizing, or it could just empower and entrench the status quo. A debate about this might be more relevant to current times.
- JasonFruit 4y agoI'm not sure that the writer has a clear idea of what free markets are or what peace is. You couldn't by any exaggeration describe the trade situation between China and the US since 2008 as a "free market". Nor could you describe the system under which EU members buy Russian fuel as one; as long as governments pursue political goals by economic means, the market isn't free — and I don't think I'm moving the goalposts in saying that. And peace doesn't require that the Russians and Chinese become our friends; it requires that they recognize that trade would be a greater loss than any gains from war could recompense.
- cool_dude85 4y agoThen what is a "free market"? Are we back to definitions where no actor has market power, where rational actors have well-defined utility functions and there is no information asymmetry to be found? If so, we can't say much about such free markets as none has, will, or can ever exist.
- spaceman_2020 4y ago“True Free Markets Haven’t Been Tried Yet!”
- simonh 4y agoIt's a market free enough that the majority of participants trust that no other participants have an unacceptable systemic advantage. It's the participants that decide as a free association of people, it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks. That's my effort anyway. It's somewhat similar to the situation with democracies, there are many democratic systems. Each favours some over others to at least some extent, the question is whether there is a significant disillusionment among the electorate and an appetite among them for change. As a Brit I don't like the fact that a candidate for President in the US can get a majority of the actual votes, but lose due to the electoral college system, as has happened. An American Might deplore the fact that we don't directly elect our Prime Minister. There are those in each country that deplore these features of their own systems. Nevertheless our respective systems as a whole enjoy broad support among their electorates and that's what matters.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoUmm, who said that the global markets were free to begin with? It may be “free” for the west, but as soon as you step out of line with Washington, it doesn’t appear all that free. And I’m not talking about the most egregious actions like invading Ukraine, I am talking about things like monetary and energy policy.
- JacobThreeThree 4y agoYou mean bombing pipelines is not part of the free market? Well I never...
- hackerlight 4y agoThe idea isn't from economics. It's from the liberalism school of IR. It's not wrong, either. It's just imperfect. Like any IR theory, it's only a partial explanation, and things beyond the theory's scope happen. In fact, it's a fairly good theory. Autocrats want to survive. Which means they don't want to get sanctioned and cause a recession, because they fear protests. Other factors can often overwhelm that -- again, the theory isn't perfect.
- st-keller 4y agoAutocrats want to survive, yes. So if there’s an economic crisis, they like to distract people. Blaming minorities works as well a starting a war. Look up Idi Amin as an example par excellence!
- hackerlight 4y agoYes, he scapegoated Indians. But they also want to avoid an economic crisis to begin with, if it can be helped. Trade as deterrence is an imperfect but still partly true IR theory.
- peace_for_whom 4y ago[flagged]
- bryanlarsen 4y agoSometimes it works fabulously well. Compare the fate of Poland and the Baltic States with the fate of Belorussia. If Yeltsin hadn't been a drunk, it's possible that Russia would be more like the Poland of 2022 than the Russia of 2022. I still believe that being open with Russia was the right strategy even if it has blown up spectacularly in our face.
- KptMarchewa 4y ago>If Yeltsin hadn't been a drunk, it's possible that Russia would be more like the Poland of 2022 than the Russia of 2022. At the end, Yeltsin was just the face of KGB/FSB regime, and later directly abdicated power to it's representative, who bombed buildings in Moscow to get elected.
- VictorPath 4y ago> who bombed buildings in Moscow to get elected Actually Yeltsin abolished the elected parliament in Russia in 1993, and then had the army bomb the parliament. This was done openly and celebrated by President Clinton, the US Congress and the US press. The US put all its weight behind removing power from democratic elections and a parliament as it wanted to consolidate power under the Russian army and president (now Putin).
- KptMarchewa 4y ago>had the army This was FSB deciding what army does 101.
- 323 4y agoOne expert in Russia was arguing that by necessity the regime in Russia needs to be extremely authoritarian, otherwise Russia would split into a number of smaller republics.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThe idea that people are driven primarily by economic impulses is very America centric (to some extent, western centric). Any cursory study of recent history will tell you that people will readily accept poorer material conditions as long as amorphous ideas like pride, identity, etc. remain intact.
- bumby 4y agoI think the classic retort from an economist says people are governed by maximizing utility and that utility can take many forms from economic to varieties of subjective well-being.
- adolph 4y ago“The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.” ― F. A. Hayek, The Fatal Conceit: The Errors of Socialism https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/303269-the-curious-task-of-economics-is-to-demonstrate-to-men https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/303269-the-curious-task-of-...
- taolegal 4y agoThis is why everyone hates libertarians, it's an extremely modest ideology. The presumption of knowledge & power (hubris) is the basis for so much human suffering. Unfortunately it will never be defeated.
- bumby 4y agoDevil’s advocate: People like libertarianism as an abstract ideology but not as a practical one. In a practical sense, it may require access to good information, across all domains, to be acted upon by rational agents capable of synthesizing all that information into a decision. That may work with a yeoman farmer society, but is incongruent with modernity. Creation of institutions like a government and regulatory bodies may be the natural reaction to facing the complexities of modern society. As an example, I don't have the sufficient knowledge or information to assess the air-worthiness of an airplane and even if I did, fear may bias my decision toward the irrational. Instead, public institutions like the FAA create a system of regulations to standardize that decision. Same with electrical codes, drug quality, and a bunch of other common risks. People can’t get all the information they need to make good individual decisions in a complex environment. Even if they could, assuming people are rational may ironically be an extremely irrational assumption.
- malfist 4y agoThis article goes way off base in it's first point. It claims that EU's trade with Russia didn't prevent war, but weakened EU's response to Russian aggression. Except that's exactly wrong. Russia's trade with the EU 100% prevented EU going to war with Russia, and is preventing Russia from being more ambitious. Did it prevent the war in Ukraine? No. But it absolutely did prevent the EU from actually going to war with Russia over their actions in Ukraine. This article is basically making this argument: If Bob and Jane went to the grocery store, why doesn't Sally have food in her fridge? Clearly grocery stores don't sell food!
- sbuttgereit 4y agoAnother perspective of this work: https://www.city-journal.org/bad-faith-economic-history https://www.city-journal.org/bad-faith-economic-history
- simonh 4y agoI think this is the bit most salient to the geopolitical situation today: >Adam Smith, however, had a more nuanced view. The “father of economics” felt that a country with an absolute monarchy, such as France, did not have the requisite political virtue for free trade. He believed that its monarchical system was controlled by monopolizing merchants who would never let it trade freely. For French monarchy, substitute modern Chinese or Russian autocracy. If you have two mutually trading free democracies the interests of the people will always be best served by peaceful negotiation, so that is what they will demand of the leaders they elect. With autocracies what's best for the people isn't the primary concern, rather it's what's in the best interests of the autocrat that drives policy. As an aside I think it's pretty evident that Putin did not enter into the invasion of Ukraine with the intention to end up in a catastrophic trade war with the West, and bogged down in an un-winable quagmire in Ukraine. He was expecting a quick victory and lots of glory, presenting the west with a fait accompli as he did with Crimea. Nevertheless he was doing it to serve his own goals as an autocrat rather than because it was genuinely in any way in the interests of ordinary Russians. Nevertheless there's always the possibility of severe miscalculation. However in a democracy a plurality of the population has to miscalculate, while in an autocracy it only takes on person to get it wrong and you have a disaster.
- labrador 4y agoNo two countries that both have a McDonald's have ever fought a war against each other - Thomas Friedman, The Lexus and the Olive Tree Hold our beers - Russia and Ukraine
- jhbadger 4y agoUS and Panama. Operation "Just Cause" in 1989-1990 to get rid of General Noriega. Which was before Friedman even formulated the idea. I guess you can argue that the Panama invasion wasn't "officially a war" but that's true of many conflicts and is rather arbitrary.
- shalmanese 4y agoNeither is the "Special Military Operation" in Ukraine.
- adambaybutt 4y agoHappy to see HN comments largely explaining how the author of the Politico article wrote an ignorant dunk on free trade. Maybe there are some folks around here who still believe in liberty and are optimistic about technological progress.
- ghufran_syed 4y agoThe article uses the example of the US and China - but free trade is one-way with china, china could historically sell freely into the US, but selling into China was always made much harder by the Chinese government, by artificially keeping their currency low, as well as more overt control. This is one (of several) reasons why the top US tech firms dominate everywhere except china. Maybe there is a useful analogy here: mutual love and respect is a great foundation for a strong long-term relationship between two humans. But one party dominating or abusing the either is not a good basis for such a relationship. I suspect it's also true as another comment noted, that mutual free trade is necessary but not sufficient. As the old saying goes, "No nation has friends only interests." So if a core national strategic interest (e.g. "Taiwan is part of china" from the Chinese government's point of view) comes into tension with the idea of mutually beneficial trade, it's obvious which one will make way for the other.
- karaterobot 4y agoWhile far from a guarantee of uniform world peace, please try to name something that has worked better at preventing war than free markets. The existence of one or two counterexamples (dubious ones in my opinion) doesn't do anything for me except make me think "hmm, there sure are a lot fewer examples of international warfare in the last 80 years, compared to the 80 years before that. I wonder what's changed? Oh yeah..."
- tehjoker 4y agoc.f. Imperialism the highest stage of capitalism by V.I. Lenin for original research on this concept