9 ms·
History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money with no backing. For a historical example, the Confederacy
by WalterBright 4y ago
History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money with no backing.
For a historical example, the Confederacy had high inflation. The printing press was in Richmond. When Richmond was threatened with a siege, the Confederacy hustled the printing press out to get it to a new, safer location.
Confederate inflation paused during the move.
The reason is pretty simple - the Law of Supply & Demand. The more currency there is flooding the economy, the less value that currency has.
- foobarian 4y ago> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money. Of course, that is almost a tautology. The devil is in the details. No inflation is bad because the economy stops. High inflation is bad because of erosion of purchasing power and negative impact on nearly every participant in the economy. So what do you do to get that sweet spot of about 1-2% inflation? I'd say raising interest rates was a pretty good start, if a bit late in the game.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoWhy are interests rates as a money sink preferable to the more direct approach of simply sinking money out of supply via tax? They seem to amount to the same thing at the end of the day - siphoning dollars out.
- bombcar 4y agoBecause you don't have to subject it to a vote. People vote against taxes, they kinda ignore moderate interest/inflation.
- merely-unlikely 4y agoThat is also a valid approach but I'm not sure it is more direct. Tax policy is generally only set once a year and only affects tax payers. Interest rates can be tweaked more frequently and (I think) directly impact a larger subset of economic players. That and the Fed doesn't determine tax rates.
- atq2119 4y agoYour point about how tax rates are set compared to interest rates is true, but could be changed. I don't follow the second part though: pretty much everybody pays a significant amount of taxes, if only the likes of sales tax. Far fewer (though of course still many) players have substantial interest income or expenses.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWhy governments don't do monetary policy by fiscal means? Well, because the central bank is the authority on monetary matters, and the congress the authority on fiscal matters. They don't even usually agree on what direction to go. (Things are this way on every democracy.) But that specific question, nobody would take money out of the economy by fiscal means, even if they could. You would need huge fiscal changes to have the same effect of a small monetary restriction. And you don't do huge fiscal changes, ever.
- badpun 4y agoThis way, you'd only be vacuuming dollars held by US entities (citizens, companies), while USD is a global currency held by everyone in the world. This policy would greatly benefit non-US entities, at the cost of US entities.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoInteresting. It isn't obvious to me how the Fed(a US org) setting interest rates necessarily affects non-US entities. Could you explain the causal chain?
- atq2119 4y agoDo non-US entities tend to have more assets in USD or more debts? I'd assume the former, which means that a US interest rate increase is actually net beneficial to non-US entities.
- em500 4y agoThe Federal Reserves implements interest rate increases by selling the bonds that they own (bought in the past) in the market in exchange for cash ("Open Market Operations"). This takes cash out of the hand of the public (in exchange for cash that can be spent in the future). That's about as direct as it gets. Removing cash in the public's hand via taxation has several drawbacks, as mentioned by other posters. It's a very slow legislative process, because it has much more direct distributional effects (who is going to be taxed?). Additionally, most academic economists believe more taxation reduces real, as opposed to nominal, economic activity ("distortionary effects of taxation").
- ryanisnan 4y agoI'm not very versed in economics, but can you explain "No inflation is bad because the economy stops."?
- foobarian 4y agoThere are some other comments that probably described it better, but as an example: let's say inflation is negative. That means it is good to keep cash. What happens is everyone starts hoarding cash under their mattresses and there is no liquidity around to help exchange goods, and everything slows down. With a small inflation, there is no incentive to hoard cash, and there is enough liquidity to make sure goods get exchanged without too much delay. At the end of the day that is what an economy is, exchanging goods.
- IncRnd 4y agoBut, the economy doesn't stop when there is no inflation or deflation. Well, I suppose that depends on your meaning of the word economy.
- foobarian 4y agoCertainly I was wrong if you take those words literally. You got me. At the end of the day hopefully you got positive insight out of it. :-)
- IncRnd 4y agoI didn't "get you". What is your non-literal definition of economy?
- rolisz 4y agoNo, I didn't get it either. People will still need food, electricity, gas, clothing. Buildings will need maintenance. Are you saying people will decide to not eat because deflation? Or not fix their broken windows?
- virissimo 4y ago> No inflation is bad because the economy stops. How much net inflation was there in Europe between the Napoleonic Wars and the start of WWI? Do you think "the economy stops" is a fair description of this time period?
- WalterBright 4y ago> Of course, that is almost a tautology Inflation lags the money printing, so it isn't a tautology. > So what do you do to get that sweet spot of about 1-2% inflation? I'm amazed that propaganda of a sweet spot gets so heavily embedded into the popular wisdom. If there is a sweet spot for inflation, it's 0%. Note that the US had net 0% inflation from 1800-1914, while growing from subsistence farming to superpower.
- foobarian 4y agoI don’t know, the concept just makes sense to me intuitively. There are enough weird effects in systems and math when things are at zero that I just can’t tell what would happen. Example, in queueing theory when input rate is equal to output rate under reasonable randomness you get large backlogs. When everything drains at just a few percent over zero it just seems like a better system. The US also had a civil war during that period. And then repeated brutal boom and bust cycles until Breton Woods.
- WalterBright 4y agoWe still have boom and bust cycles, but with persistent inflation. As for the Civil War, the US government printed fiat money during it.
- mixmastamyk 4y ago^Became a superpower in the 1940s gearing up for WWII and then the only country left standing with brand new factories.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- woodruffw 4y ago> Note that the US had net 0% inflation from 1800-1914, while growing from subsistence farming to superpower. This is grossly ahistorical: in 1914, 2/3rds of the US lived in abject poverty[1]. Individual farming, including subsistence farming, didn't peak until the 1930s[2]. The US's ascent to superpower status can be traced, at the earliest, to lending programs begun during WWI (and repeated, to fantastic effect, during WWII). The US's phenomenal ascent in international status and power is directly tied to its monetary policy, a policy that has more or less kept inflation around 2% since 1935[3]. [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20150720050803/https://www.irp.wisc.edu/faqs/faq2.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20150720050803/https://www.irp.w... [2]: https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistics-charting-the-essentials/farming-and-farm-income/ https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistic... [3]: https://www.thebalancemoney.com/u-s-inflation-rate-history-by-year-and-forecast-3306093 https://www.thebalancemoney.com/u-s-inflation-rate-history-b...
- sidewndr46 4y agoI've never heard anyone tell me they were going to quit working because the US government wasn't printing money fast enough. I have heard people tell me they weren't making enough money to cover their expenses on a month-to-month basis as a result of cost increases. These happen to correlate with inflation. There is no way an economy would stop just because there was no inflation. Would Microsoft suddenly decree that if the US government won't print US dollars, it won't sell you a Windows license key? Even in the case of extreme deflation, it only becomes an issue when you have people trying to do weird things with physical currency like cut a penny into 1/4s and use it to buy different goods.
- colinmhayes 4y agoThe people who couldn’t afford their expenses due to rising costs likely would have lost their job in the recession that was averted due to inflation.
- sidewndr46 4y agoI really don't think we can call something "averted" if people can no longer actually afford to live.
- colinmhayes 4y agoThe recession was averted. The outcome was still bad, but it would’ve been much worse.
- Consultant32452 4y agoHave you ever noticed you get raises roughly based on last year's inflation and not an estimation of next year's inflation? When the money printers print the people who touch the new money first get to buy assets before the price inflation occurs. Then, once the new money eventually circulates to the peasants, they get to use it to buy goods and services at the new, higher prices. Inflation is a wealth transfer from the poor to the wealthy. It is not, by any means, necessary. https://mises.org/wire/inflation-its-wealth-redistribution-scheme https://mises.org/wire/inflation-its-wealth-redistribution-s...
- imtringued 4y agoIsn't it amazing that Austrian economists completely ignore that providing liquidity creates costs for the providers of liquidity? Businesses give money value by offering products and services, meanwhile the holder of money expects the business to keep providing this costly service at no cost. In other words, there is a constant flow of free liquidity provisioning services toward the holders of money which makes the providers of liquidity poorer and the holders of liquidity richer if they market that liquidity. After all, money is worth more than the purchasing power it represents, it can buy anything available in the payments network. Money that buys bananas and apples is more valuable than money that only buys apples even if both have the same amount of purchasing power. Since liquidity is paid for by the general enterprising public, the holders who have none of the costs can just loan out and market their liquidity for a price and they get to pretend that they are providing a service, even though they haven't done anything for it in any way. People who still have a need to transact must now pay the costs of liquidity to someone who doesn't provide it when they borrow money. The person who borrows money is now stuck with the costs of liquidity even if they spend it. When they spend it, they no longer benefit from liquidity but they must still pay for the liquidity that someone else owns. That person then can lend his liquidity out without paying for it. The end result is that liquidity costs must be paid twice. This is an endlessly compounding system. Like a pyramid scheme. Money acts like a perpetuity where the yield is paid out in liquidity which can through borrowing be turned into money. Previous perpetuities are paid by creating new perpetuities. Very interesting scheme and Austrian economists are even denying the above so they are complicit.
- ForHackernews 4y agoOk, but why now? Why not 14 years ago, or 10 years ago, or 5 years ago? We've been in a zero-interest-rate, QE world for quite a while. Somehow I do not think it is as trivial as your 8th grade econ textbook might suggest.
- rnernento 4y agoI don't think you realize just how much of the money has been printed in the last 2 years. See fed balance sheet over time: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren... See M2 over time: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL
- UncleMeat 4y agoSo? The argument is that inflation always happens when there is fiat printing. We printed a shitload of dollars between 2000-2020, yet inflation was low throughout that period. So the explanation is clearly insufficient.
- prottog 4y agoThe government is sandbagging CPI figures in order to lower its obligations that are tied to the official inflation rate, like Social Security payments. This isn't some underworld conspiracy theory; look at some of the academic discussion around ShadowStats. If we take home prices, comparing 2000 to 2019 (before the pandemic-related craziness in the real estate market took place), they went up by 85% in that time period[0], compared to 48.5% in the CPI[1]. [0]: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ASPUS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ASPUS [1]: https://www.minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/inflation-calculator/consumer-price-index-1913- https://www.minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/infl...
- WalterBright 4y ago> The argument is that inflation always happens when there is fiat printing. The whole point of fiat money is to print excessive amounts of it. It's attractive for governments because they can then spend money buying votes without having to raise taxes (though inflation is a tax). Meanwhile, they blame "speculators" and "profiteers" as scapegoats for the inflation. > yet inflation was low throughout that period The cumulative was a lot, and note that there was never any deflation.
- lagrange77 4y ago> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money. That's what you hear a lot, especially these days. But is it really true? What exactly is the signal path, that leads from more money to a higher inflation? I guess, there is a fair amount of psychology involved.
- rnernento 4y agoI mean it's pretty straightforward right? There are now more dollars in play all after the same amount of goods, each dollar has less purchasing power. Why are you so quick to throw out the simplest explanation?
- fladrif 4y agoBecause sometimes you lose the important details in the generalization. Counter example would be that the dollars created aren't spent depending on how they're distributed. If put under people's mattresses, put into the stock market, or sitting in a savings account, those don't enter circulation and increase the flow of money.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat happens to the dollars you put into a savings account or bought stocks with? Do they disappear?
- jollybean 4y agoBecause the 'simple straight forward explanation' doesn't make much sense. As economies grow and expand, they need more money supply to keep prices stable. If you're using 100 tons of Gold as your 'fixed money supply' then you run into deflationary problems. Also, if there is a crisis in which people get really anti-liquid and tend to hoard and do other bad things, and/or the system needs to allocate resources somewhere fast or else face destruction - then if you only have a big pot of gold split between owners, you are screwed. Mad Max style. If a country is invaded or has a pandemic, most regular levers may not work. But helicopter money can help. It implies an 'unfair' re-balancing of who owns what, but so long as the community at large accepts that, then it's fine. It means a price adjustment for everyone.
- zie 4y agoThis is a very simplistic viewpoint. One could also argue that Inflation happens when people don't trust that their government will pay back all the money borrowed. The US govt has been on a spending spree as of late, but hasn't yet bothered to mention how they are going to pay for it. In 2008/2009, the US govt was also on a spending spree, but did promise to pay the bill eventually. Inflation didn't spike in 2008/2009. The bottom line is, nobody really KNOWS, we just have guesses. My guess currently fits all the facts, where yours does not, but that doesn't mean my guess is right, but perhaps it's more correct than your version.
- dasil003 4y agoThere’s also a tipping point where inflation is self propelled because everyone is used to it so they just proactively raise prices on a regular basis. I experienced this growing up in Brazil in the 80s and 90s. It’s hard for Americans to relate, but essentially the mentality is spend/invest every penny you get before it loses value. Took some creative policy to break the cycle: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plano_Real https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plano_Real
- WalterBright 4y ago> There’s also a tipping point where inflation is self propelled because everyone is used to it so they just proactively raise prices on a regular basis. This is called cost-push inflation. Unfortunately, that theory doesn't explain where the extra dollars come from.
- dasil003 4y agoWhy would you expect there to be some unifying theory of inflation? It's an emergent phenomenon resulting from the actions of many individual actors. I'm quite sure the people raising the prices every week had no idea how much cash was in circulation.
- WalterBright 4y ago
- tsimionescu 4y agoYou keep claiming this, but it is fairly obvious that prices can be forced up by factors that have nothing to do with the money supply - most notably, constrained supply in basic raw materials (especially oil and its derivatives) can force virtually all prices up, regardless of the amount of currency available.
- WalterBright 4y agoSince you know all the obvious answers, try these on: 1. Where does all the money come from to pay for increased gas prices? 2. When gas prices go down (and they often do go down by multiples), why doesn't deflation happen?
- tsimionescu 4y ago1. There's no extra money - poorer people just consume less. 2. Because companies just take all of the difference as extra revenue, and prefer to increase salaries (if not just keep everything as profit) rather than reducing prices. Note that I'm not claiming that increased money supply doesn't cause inflation. It obviously does. I'm claiming it's not the only cause of inflation. It's sufficient, but not necessary for inflation to happen.
- JamesianP 4y agoIt's not so simple though since there's indirect effects that immediately follow. 1. Everyone consume less. Even rich people have to buy less of something else to pay for the higher-priced gas. So demand goes down elsewhere driving down other prices. 2. If margins or salaries increase then it increases the incentive for competition to enter the market and compete on price.
- tsimionescu 4y ago1. Rich people already have much more income than they consume, they would likely only reduce investments/savings. 2. It takes a very long time to create a new manufacturing business, and it's hard to know how gas prices will evolve in 2-5 years time (which is a decent conservative estimate on when you would be able to start selling your products if you start today).
- sbf501 4y agoThe more currency flooding the economy, the less wealthy the rich people are. Inflation occurs because the owners need to remain wealthy, hence prices go up everywhere. If it were possible for the top few to do with a little less, prices wouldn't have to skyrocket.
- seer-zig 4y agoI disagree about framing it as the top few. I recommend you look into Islam's Zakat system for something that actually works, and is fair across the board.
- merely-unlikely 4y agoI'm skeptical of that claim since the rich hold more assets than dollars. To the extent inflation hurts the economy then your claim is true but that is a second order affect. All else equal, inflation can simply lead to asset inflation in which case the rich maintain their wealth. In economics circles inflation is generally considered a tax on the poor who only hold cash and whose wages are slower to rise vs price inflation.
- WalterBright 4y ago> I'm skeptical of that claim since the rich hold more assets than dollars You should be. I doubt the rich hold any dollars at all. They invest it all. There aren't any Scrooge McDuck cash vaults. (Criminals often do hold lots of cash, and they try to get rid of it by laundering it.)
- WalterBright 4y ago> Inflation occurs because the owners need to remain wealthy, hence prices go up everywhere. The fun thing about HN is I hear all sorts of unique economic theories not found in any econ book. P.S. If the wealthy (or everyone else) needs more money, and just raising prices will work, why don't they do that anyway? The answer is Supply & Demand, it's the Law, and is in every econ textbook.
- 4y ago
- jollybean 4y agoNo - this is completely false. As an economy expands, it needs more currency to facilitate growth. A 'very hard currency' would strangle an economy with ugly deflationary issues. Moreover - with a 'hard currency' the system will fail and collapse when it faces an existential shock such as an internal failure (bank collapse), war, pandemic. The objective is to provide 'the right' amount of liquidity for the economy as needed, and, during times of crisis to be able to release enough liquidity to see the economy through the crisis. Yes, the 'price will be paid' in later years for excess liquidity in terms of higher prices, but that's not necessary a bad thing, it's just accounting. It depends on the distortions. If the community accepts that 'yes, resources needed to be diverted to pay for xyz' then that's 'the cost' and it's going to be borne out in higher prices. And yes, if Central Banks print wily nilly and provide too much supply this will result in hyper inflation. But fundamentally, this idea that fiat = untenable is completely false.
- WalterBright 4y ago> A 'very hard currency' would strangle an economy with ugly deflationary issues. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33087419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33087419
- wpietri 4y ago> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money with no backing. You do realize that the US has had fiat money for decades, right? Including our longest period of low inflation, a run of nearly 4 decades. So it would seem history teaches us the opposite. "For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong." -- H. L. Mencken
- WalterBright 4y ago> You do realize that the US has had fiat money for decades, right? Yes, since 1914 when the US switched to fiat money. > Including our longest period of low inflation, a run of nearly 4 decades The US had zero net inflation from 1800 to 1914. How much net inflation do you think happened in those 4 decades? What would a 1914 US dollar be worth today? I'll help you out. $29.92 https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/ https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/
- wpietri 4y ago> The US had zero net inflation from 1800 to 1914. This is just absurd. Not only is this a period so different than a modern economy that it's not useful for comparison, but during that period it was a roller coaster of inflation and deflation, both of which are terrible for people. Those curious can see the volatility here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Historical_Inflation_Ancient.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Historical_Inflat...
- WalterBright 4y ago> This is just absurd. Not only is this a period so different than a modern economy that it's not useful for comparison, I hear that a lot. Nobody is ever able to explain what law of economics changed in 1914. The Law of Supply & Demand was just the same as it always was. > but during that period it was a roller coaster of inflation and deflation, both of which are terrible for people. Those curious can see the volatility here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Historical_Inflat https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:US_Historical_Inflat... All of the spikes were the result of the US government meddling with the economy (such as bimetalism and other nonsense, see Friedman's "Monetary History of the United States"). Except for the big one, coincidentally coincident with the California gold rush. Or is that a coincidence? Tons of gold flooding into the economy, what would the consequence of that be? Hmmm.
- boole1854 4y ago> History teaches us that inflation will continue as long as the government keeps printing fiat money with no backing. The government (to be correct we should say: the Federal Reserve) has not been "printing money" for around a year now. Monetary base has actually declined by ~12% in that time: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=UrKo https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=UrKo
- WalterBright 4y agoIssuing debt is the same thing.
- boole1854 4y agoIssuing governance debt is definitely different from increasing the money supply ("printing money"). Debt can be financed by borrowing from the domestic or foreign private sector or from foreign governments / central banks.
- Proven 4y ago
- vkou 4y agoInflation will continue as long as the economy grows. If you want to experience deflation, all you need to do is start shrinking the real economy over the long term, and make everyone else aware of it. You'll also shut down lending, strangle spending, and remove all incentive to invest, but fortunately, the dragon hoard of cash that one has hoarded will start increasing in real value year over year.
- JamesianP 4y agoYou can also cause deflation by increasing productivity, which happens in a growing economy. More competition finds more efficient ways to produce.
- imtringued 4y agoThat can't explain the era of extremely low inflation and it can't explain what is happening in Japan. It also cannot explain the Wörgl emergency money.
- gizmo 4y agoThe "extremely low inflation era" was also a time of very high inflation in long duration assets. It was an era where we saw one company after the another being valued at over a trillion dollars. It was an era where startups without revenue could get 30bn valuations based on hot air and fanciful renderings. Printed money has to go somewhere. If it just sits somewhere it doesn't do anything. If it goes to investments you'll see inflation there. If it goes towards goods you'll see prices rise there. For inflation it doesn't matter whether you have a lot of money flowing at a low velocity or a smaller amount of money flowing at a higher velocity. When velocity of money drops because people are worried about the future then you can print money to compensate without producing inflation in either good/services or the stock market/real estate. During a stock mania velocity of money increases and idle money turns into investment money with asset inflation as a consequence. Wörgl -- economy suffered from too little money in circulation. Printing money fixed it. Japan -- economy has been stagnant for decades. Printing or borrowing at near 0% is fine for them because idle money doesn't do anything. When the Japanese economy starts growing again and velocity of money increases they'll get inflation, just like everybody else. Having no growth and a flat stock market for 30 years is not a good place to be at. It's all monetary, but the effects aren't immediate. Prices rise only when it's known the market will support these higher prices, and this price discovery takes time.