9 ms·
This goes to a little-appreciated fact about democracy - the evidence suggests that while there is a common perception that democracy has failed in any given ye
by roenxi 4y ago
This goes to a little-appreciated fact about democracy - the evidence suggests that while there is a common perception that democracy has failed in any given year, and that any given instance of incompetence will surely sink us all this time. But over time it consistently turns out that democracies are making consistently better decisions than the authoritarians. Similar to how liberty usually gets much better results but high-status people refuse to accept that the plebs can make decisions for themselves.
I think people just can't handle the complexity of distributed decision making, so are consistently biased to believe that small, centralised & appointed authorities make better decisions than the hive mind. Similarly to how everyone knows how a kingdom works, but people get hazy really quickly on how the successes of the worlds many parliamentary or republican systems of government actually function.
Dictators cannot manage multiple constraints simultaneously. Democracy is just better at resource allocation. Insofar as somewhere like China remains ahead of somewhere like India, I think it depends on the ability of the CCP to simulate a typical democracy internally. Once groupthink takes hold, without a release valve to turn over the people, I don't see how a government recovers.
- planetsprite 4y agoHuman thinking naturally aligns towards authoritarianism, winner-takes-all, strict unbreakable hierarchies. The only reason democracies are so common in the world nowadays is that they end up being so successful, even the minority accidental democracies end up having a disproportionate influence and growth over the span of history.
- goodpoint 4y ago> Human thinking naturally aligns... Citation needed.
- actually_a_dog 4y agoYou're wasting your breath. There is so much "citation needed" going on in this entire comments section it's pathetic. Practically every statement everyone is making is completely unsourced. I expected better when I clicked through.
- moffkalast 4y agogestures broadly at world history
- nosianu 4y agoWhat exactly are you pointing at? Long-term successful areas did not have authoritarian rule. Take Europe for example. There were all the many states, and even within them lots of struggle for power. Then there was the church (even after splits based on the same faith) as an additional layer parallel to the worldly powers. As far as I an tell it handily beat authoritarian competition. Sure, there existed plenty of local authoritarian rulers, but how did those places do long-term and not just during there often short rule? Maybe somebody knowledgeable could talk about China? They sure had plenty of strive and competition, but then they had dynasties and centralized rule. As far as I know, which is very little, European powers were quite successful in direct competition (when the two met) and also indirectly (overall results, not of direct encounters). This is something for reddit's (heavily moderated) /r/AskHistorians, and I highly doubt the TL;DR of a historian's reply would support the assertion or would boil down to the above "gestures broadly at world history". Genghis Khan or Alexander and other authoritarian rulers sure were great at conquering, but after that it was already over. And they accomplished it mostly by killing an incredible number of people, so instead of actually competing they just removed the competition altogether. Which only ever works temporarily. > Human thinking naturally aligns towards authoritarianism In addition, when we look at ape society and tribal humans, the statement is not true at all. Even the ape society is one of alliances, and brutal rulers are eliminated, for example "Scientists show that chimps will murder and eat their dictators" https://www.inverse.com/article/27141-chimp-murder-kill-cannibal-l https://www.inverse.com/article/27141-chimp-murder-kill-cann... Human monarchies often (usually?) had religious leaders with independent power rivaling that of the monarchs as far as I know (e.g. ancient Egypt)? For example: https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1026/clergy-priests--priestesses-in-ancient-egypt/ https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1026/clergy-priests--pr... > Throughout Egypt's history, the priesthood would serve a vital role in maintaining religious belief and tradition while, at the same time, consistently challenge the authority of the king by amassing wealth and power which at times rivaled that of the crown. Given that we don't live in a LitRPG or Xinaxia fantasy universe where individuals can gain world destroying god-like powers, and that humans naturally are all about equally powerful and not orders of magnitude different in the abilities of their bodies and brains, authority always is a question of the network and not of just that particular single individual appearing at "the top". Keeping that network in sync and focused seems to be very hard judging by the history of actual usually short-lived (by history standards, it may well last the lifetime of a person) authoritarian rule. So maybe the attempt may be natural, actual success not so much.
- arcticbull 4y ago> Democracy is just better at resource allocation. Only in certain ways. Counter-examples: Americans waste almost 40% of all the food that is produced in America, and for all sorts of reasons. 108 billion pounds of food is wasted, which equates to 130 billion meals. $218B per year. 19% of all crop lands, and more water than Texas, California and Ohio combined. [1] Grown, then thrown out. Enough to feed all the world's hungry. Free markets fail to price externalities all the time. Coal kills 25 people per TWh generated, and costs about $0.10/kWh. A human life is generally costed at $10M by actuaries for these purposes [2] so at 25 deaths per TWh, the human cost alone is $0.25/kWh. Coal power should cost $0.35/kWh, and yet, it's nowhere close. This leads to terrible resource allocation. On the other hand, authoritarianism built China 24,000 miles of high-speed rail since the mid-2000s. That's good resource allocation. The US has 49.9mi total. Without the need to plan for a 2-4 year election cycle, the government can execute multi-decade initiatives effectively. Like HSR, and like OBOR. [3] I'm of course not advocating for authoritarianism, however some introspection here is warranted, and the current situation isn't a 'pat ourselves on the back' moment. What we need isn't more freedom but just a little bit less, an approach where we staple the actual cost of the things we do onto them so that the market can then take over and do what it's good at. A little respect for our rivals would go a long way IMO. [1] https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/wasted-2017-report.pdf https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/wasted-2017-report.... [2] https://www.npr.org/2020/04/23/843310123/how-government-agencies-determine-the-dollar-value-of-human-life https://www.npr.org/2020/04/23/843310123/how-government-agen... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative
- fnfivyv 4y ago
- saint_abroad 4y ago> Americans waste almost 40% of all the food that is produced in America, and for all sorts of reasons. Put another way, free markets produce 67% more than required. When it comes to food, most populations that eat prefer a market that favors the buyer.
- hackerlight 4y agoDecentralized decision making is usually better because of the local knowledge problem. But not always. It's the wisdom of crowds vs madness of crowds dichotomy. That's why it's good to have constraints on democracy in the form of Constitution-type documents, and why representative democracy can sometimes be better than direct democracy. There's also the inescapable incentive conflict of 2 wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner. It's not really a just or perfect system, it's just the best one we have, to recycle that old cliche.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThough a more common failure state is 2 wolves telling 98 sheep that "democracy sucks, don't listen to these experts/socialists/Jews, we need a strong wolf in charge" and getting 1/3 of the sheep to vote for them, in a near literal "When I voted for the Leopards eating people's faces party, I didn't expect the leopards to eat my face!" situation.
- EGreg 4y agoThe most common failure mode is when governments don’t listen to the legitimate concerns of other groups, cherrypick the attacks made by a small minority, carry out reprisals to “deter aggression” and start to dehumanize the other population by claiming they are inherently fascist or dumb or bloodthirsty. Then their mass media selects only the things that reinforce “other group does bad things, our group simply makes some mistakes but has great intentions” and “other side must be defeated 100% or it will come back and can’t be trusted to uphold a deal”. Example: When both Ukraine and Russia were in one federation called USSR (similar to USA, Yugoslavia or EU) then Crimea or some cities moving from Russia to Ukraine would have been regarded as an administrative change, requiring various adjustments to signs and flags. No one would even think of killing each other over which republic’s flag would fly over what territory, let alone escalating to a nuclear war that threatens to destroy human life on the planet. Think about how insane that is. In a libertarian world, cities would simply vote for a free market of competing agencies providing police, road maintenance, etc. And the whole package of “services” from a state would be unbundled and not worth fighting over. The concept of “territorial integrity of a country” or “national armies” would not be something that would even matter. The people of Hong Kong or Catalonia or Kurdistan or Bangladesh would be pretty happy and not have to fight for their “independence”. Countries shouldn’t own people. People should self-organize to get their needs met in peaceful arrangements and that’s all.
- verisimi 4y ago> I think people just can't handle the complexity of distributed decision making, so are consistently biased to believe that small, centralised & appointed authorities make better decisions than the hive mind. I absolutely agree with this. There is a natural process that occurs, where people are able to route around or resolve problems with no authority to "help". It is our natural state. In fact I see authority as a parasitical attempt to control and steer individuals at mass for the personal benefit of the parasites. Still, government has become an entrenched habit it seems, with many people still believing it is worth the ~40% of their income they pay for its wars, military, governance apparatus, etc. Nb - we do not have democracy - we have representative democracy - we do not have a say on any of the thousands of decisions that government makes in our name, the person we elect chooses on our behalf, and can even do the exact opposite to what they promised with zero repurcussions! Hurrah, what a system! > Dictators cannot manage multiple constraints simultaneously. Democracy is just better at resource allocation. Insofar as somewhere like China remains ahead of somewhere like India, I think it depends on the ability of the CCP to simulate a typical democracy internally. I think you're dreaming that the CCP works on democracy! But, it is the chosen, future system. We will have (perhaps already have) citizen scores. We will be run (overtly, in future) by an unaccountable, technocratic elite.
- mmustapic 4y ago> But over time it consistently turns out that democracies are making consistently better decisions than the authoritarians. Similar to how liberty usually gets much better results but high-status people refuse to accept that the plebs can make decisions for themselves. And still, corporations are mostly authoritarian, with top down decision making and big hierarchical structures. And worse, the majority of people are ok with this even if they champion democracy outside the workplace. Most of us don't have a lot of influence in current democracies except by electing some representatives, but we do in the workplace, and there is where it's most restricted.
- rustybelt 4y agoNot really comparable as long as the corporations are still subject to market influence. Corporations that become so powerful they can ignore the wishes of their customers exhibit many of the same flaws as totalitarian governments.
- mmustapic 4y agoI'm talking about working for the corporation, not buying products from it.
- bjornsing 4y agoYou are free to start a corporation and structure its decision making any way you see fit.
- captainbland 4y agoTechnically you're free to buy a super yacht although funding that purchase might be a challenge. Worker co-ops tend to do quite well once they're funded. They're not exactly prone to blowing up into unicorns (although there is e.g Mondragon) but their survival rate tends to be quite high. Suma wholefoods is an example of the resiliency of co-ops, they've basically totally discarded market based compensation rates in favour of a more ideologically driven, flatter model yet have been going strong for decades. The problem is usually securing that funding in the first place. They seem to actually be more likely to pay off loans but less likely to get them. This is partly because banks generally want an individual to take responsibility for any loans and are uncomfortable with making a larger group collectively responsible. I suspect there's also a degree of prejudice against them because of the association with socialism even though they still operate in a market. Equity is generally a difficult one as well as generally the members' control of a workers' co-op is derived from their ownership stakes. There are hybrid co-ops where some of the shares of the company are sold to external investors, but obviously this dilutes the model. Worker co-ops have some success but require atypical financing to get off the ground which has limited the success of the sector.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoHow has no-one replied with the usual quote? > Many forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoWinston Churchill, 11 November 1947. https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/quotes/the-worst-form-of-government/ https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/quotes/the-worst-form...
- bjornsing 4y ago> Democracy is just better at resource allocation. It’s not democracy that’s better at resource allocation, it’s the free market. Authoritarian regimes can seldom allow the free market to operate, because if they do it accumulates too much wealth / economic power outside the authoritarian’s control. But there are examples of non-democracies with free market economies, e.g. Hong Kong under British rule.
- room271 4y agoI wonder if the two are not quite as separate as you suggest? Can the market be free without some kind of functioning democracy? Without democracy the market as you say is very unlikely to be free. Even with imperfect democracy we still see market failures due to monopoly power, externalities, and corruption.
- bjornsing 4y agoTrue. In practice they go hand in hand (except in very few cases, like Hong Kong under British rule). But I think the distinction is still important. For example I think there’s a good case for limiting democratically elected politicians influence over the economy, by enshrining private property rights and the independence of the central bank in the constitution (as e.g. Sweden has). How would you come to that conclusion if you think it’s democracy itself that allocates resources efficiently?
- parminya 4y agoDemocracy creates buy-in and legitimacy, and requires good ideas to be sold to the people rather than imposed on them. There is additional evidence that compulsory voting adds to this legitimacy (in ways that may be freedom-harming, if that matters to you - in particular, some people find evidence that Australia can typically impose stricter rules than other democracies because of compulsory voting). Some of this might go against the American tradition of democracy (which exists to help entrench freedom) but it is compatible with the Australian-British tradition of democracy (which is the goal in itself). Democracy acts as a circuit-breaker for entrenched inefficient resource allocation. For instance, if there was no usable legislative process, but only an executive and a precedent-based judicial system, markets would generally be free, but this would allow the intergenerational accumulation of capital/wealth until some people have almost total power, and some people are essentially serfs. But in democracy, the mere potential for the mass of people to vote themselves wealth limits the incentives to aggressively accumulate capital/wealth. For instance, if the rich want their property rights to be respected, they need to make sure that the mass of the country has enough property to also want protection. And if that potential doesn't work, it can actually be used and new taxes and rules can be introduced that distribute wealth more efficiently. As you can see, some might not agree with your conclusion that "there's a good case for limiting democratically elected politicians['] influence over the economy, by enshrining private property rights and the independence of the central bank in the constitution". By asking the question you did, you first presumed that democracy was inefficient and on that basis drew a conclusion, but then asked how a person who thought democracy improves efficiency would argue for the conclusion whose premises they disagree with.
- threatripper 4y agoI think it boils down to collection and processing of information. Add to that the fact that different actors in the system follow different kinds of goals. The real world is very complex and in order to transport information we need to simplify and quantify according to some model we made up. Further up instances work on the model instead of the real world. Those models become more and more abstract the further up in the chain you go. The reason for this is the limited information processing ability. One human brain can only handle so much. Talking or writing can only transport so much. An organization can only handle so much. We can have worse or better abstractions and less or more efficient organization structures and communication methods. But if your basic unit of information processing are humans with their limited brains it will always be difficult to do any central planning. Especially if the information gets distorted on the way and rules are not followed as they are intended. Then you need to add control systems that take further resources and control systems for the control systems and so on. I assume this is why central planning has failed in so many areas. But what if we could create a super brain that can handle all the detail information collected at the lowest level and integrate it into one huge model of the state of the world? There would be no misaligned incentives inside of this brain, no communication bottleneck, no abstraction loss. I'm sure that we won't "simply create" such a central instance and make it work in a single try. But I'm sure that it could work in some areas and produce very good results. Then it's up to our governments and society on how to use this power.
- sharpener 4y agoEfficient proprioception is useless if key behavioural incentives are misaligned with key aspects of the environment. Humans are quite good at creating collective organisations that are delusional, even though some of those organisations have excellent information about the state of their environment, because the invented incentive structures for action favour simplistic short term "maximisation" of fetishised behaviours instead of optimisation for (even) the medium term healthy future. Resource allocation is still looking frighteningly suboptimal right now, and simply empowering that with a "smart" central AI bot following the same patterns probably won't improve much. I'm skeptical about the human race getting past this. Humans want a lot of stuff, and are prepared to form huge organisations to get that stuff, without really thinking through whether they really need it, what the other impacts will be, or why they are even doing what they do. What is the human race trying to be? Why? How does the pattern of incentives get aligned? It seems like we only have the weakest responses to these questions right now.
- aiProgMach 4y agoI don't underestimate the importance of having the population (or most of it) has a saying in how their everyday life go (to some extent, e.g I don't think the moral laws can be determined by votes even if all humans voted on them). However, most of the benefits that usually attributed to democracy should be attributed to wealth, colonialism, and transparency/ no internal corruption (and no, democracy might help in reducing corruption and providing more transparency but it's not strictly required). When you look into (once) successful countries such as France, UK.. You can see wealthy and strong nation that win wars and keep overcoming obstacles, and you attribute that to the "democracy" and "liberal values" or simply you can ignore those liberal values and remember that "correlation doesn't imply causation" and then you can better explain things with colonialism and mass destruction of people, and nature to extract value, then it doesn't matter much how efficient you are. The British empire didn't conquer the 1840 famine by being a "democracy", it simply stole Irish people food making the crisis worse for them. Also when you look closely most of the democracies aren't that distributed, in every nation there are power structures that determine what the collective nation do, do you think really that all US people actually took the decision to destroy Vietnam? or fight Communism at any expense? or conquer and destroy Iraq? I don't think the American people are all that evil, the decision is cooked and it's enforced later via "democratic" channels.
- EGreg 4y agoThe crowd is just smarter https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2014/04/02/297839429/-so-you-think-youre-smarter-than-a-cia-agent https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2014/04/02/297839429/... But people don’t trust them to have free time with UBI or free consumer choice with vouchers
- api 4y agoDemocracy always looks broken and dysfunctional because what you see is closer to the truth. Authoritarian systems can look clean and efficient because they are systematically hiding all their problems all the way up the chain of command. Often the leadership doesn’t even see the true state of things. Recent example: Putin’s lack of awareness of the true dismal state of Russia’s armed forces.
- GoblinSlayer 4y agoThat hive mind is in fact a botnet that receives orders from TV, and it goes back to all the same people.
- vidarh 4y agoNote that while I partially agree with this hypothesis this graph (can't see the whole article) does not speak to that. What this graph shows is the reliability (or lack thereof) of the official statistics. The data still shows a number of unfree countries showing significant GDP growth even if you look at the satellite based estimate. Many of them are still above many free countries. This is not surprising, because many of those unfree countries are early in their development curve and have had a lot of easy gains to make. To support the hypothesis you present, you'd need to investigate how the growth rates of countries at a similar level of development, correcting for global trends, fare under different levels of authority. That said, personally, my hypothesis is that sadly (because it's depressing in terms of how little impact changing government potentially has) regulatory and legal stability matters far more than specific government type. E.g. look up China's reported GDP growth before and after Deng got into power. China's growth after the revolution until Deng got into power was growth punctuated by massive crises that reset things whenever the rules changed under people. Once Deng got into power it stabilised even before his economic reforms, because while the system was still deeply authoritarian, people learn to play the game however rigged it is as long as the rules don't change all the time. Even deeply brutal dictatorships can see sustained growth - especially in developing countries growing from a small base with lots of easy wins - as long as they're consistent. And that is exactly the primary danger of an authoritarian system for economic growth: It might well work fine for a while, and to stick to China they learned a lot from the stability Deng brought and have since been afraid to rock the boat, but with an autocratic system there's always a significant risk that the next leader will change the rules again. Meanwhile, even really broken democratic governments rarely manages to more than slightly change the trajectory (there's a certain irony that I'm writing this from the UK after the last couple of weeks chaos, but even though I think our current UK government are idiots, I don't think they'll have much of a lasting effect) because they tend to tinker around the edges rather than fundamentally change the rules (e.g. consider the massive backlash the UK government faces over tinkering with tax rates)
- modernpink 4y agoThis is the "economic calculation problem" critique of economic planning proposed by the Austrian school[0]. A planned economy is sort of like having a single sysadmin manage all the resource levers for a data centre, whereas the free market is more like Kubernetes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem
- samatman 4y agoHow is this the top comment?? It ends by saying that, if authoritarian China has done better than democratic India, which is hard to argue with, it must be... because China is democratic! The model must guide the data, you see! This should be roundly mocked, not upvoted.
- dan-robertson 4y agoYeah, I kinda agree the last paragraph didn’t make much sense. I would add though: - China and India have had quite different problems to solve over the last 80 years or so. - China got ‘lucky’ recently with a few good leaders (in the sense that the country developed massively under them) in a row. But it seems that Xi isn’t such a good leader in that sense (he is in the sense of consolidating power and becoming leader for life). But the narrative in the west may not have caught up yet with the idea that China doesn’t have some magical super-competent government. It’s maybe harder to tell if they’ve been lying about population and gdp and suchlike. - I think it’s more accurate to say that democracies allow bad leaders to be removed rather than that they allow good leaders to come to power.
- roenxi 4y agoI didn't say "more democratic". Democratic enough would be closer to the thinking. And if you have any real insight at all into how the CCP internals function, do link a source. Because as far as I can tell nobody knows. It is very opaque. I have only been able to find low-quality guesses and what may be well intentioned but is functionally anti-China propaganda. I wouldn't want to bet the farm on it, but for all I know they might be extremely democratic internally - similarly to how the UK is a model of democracy despite having an overt monarchy and system of nobility.
- einpoklum 4y agoYou're presenting authoritarian states and democratic ones as independent. But some of the democracies are part of a geo-political arrangement in which they benefit from the existence of countries with non-democratic regimes.
- anyonecancode 4y agoAnother factor I'd argue is important but often not explicitly called out is the ability of a group of people to change their mind. Democracy provides this via elections -- and when elections become too disconnected from decision making, eg regulatory capture or excessive veto points or other mechanisms or emergent practices that insulate decisions from electoral consequences, democracies stop working as well. Organizations, be they states or businesses or any other institution, that have a greater ability to change their collective minds aren't guaranteed to always make better decisions at any given moment, but over time they're able to course correct in a way that less flexible approaches simply can't.
- jollybean 4y agoDepends on competency, commitment etc.. Post-war countries tend to be best served by a truly benevolent, uncorruptable, honest broker who can carry out the necessary plans, which should be fairly obvious if there is decent planning. China was actually doing well when Xi came along, and there could be a very strong argument that as long as Xi stayed mostly at arms length that they would be doing just fine. Xi is stepping in hard and it will likely hurt. Singapore is a kind of authoritarian state and they're amazing in at least many ways. That said, Putin was mostly hands off on the economy and Russia is not healthy economically, were it not for Gas and Oil they wouldn't be in great shape.
- tootie 4y agoYeah, it's a question of expectations. Lots of people like to decry the "failure" of democracy or of a particular democracy and it's really just a failure to live up to the incredibly lofty expectations we've set. The political dysfunction we see in America or Britain today may seem worse than it used to be, but in a historical frame of reference we're still functioning pretty close to the peak of human accomplishment.
- benj111 4y agomy model of democracy isnt that it gets the good people in, just that it cycles out the people that have had their day. from my experience, a government does most of its good work in its first term. then it slowly slides until its doing active harm. from a uk perspective the tories recent (not a) budget pouring the currency down the drain. or gordon brown announcing the end of boom and bust, are 2 nice examples. this kind of hubris only comes after a decade or so in power. then its time to vote the other lot in.