3 ms·
> I think both sides are right, and that this is another example of why copyright is not a good abstraction. It ultimately doesn't make sense because the way we
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> I think both sides are right, and that this is another example of why copyright is not a good abstraction. It ultimately doesn't make sense because the way we learn how to do things is by imperfectly copying each other. Being successful means to successfully produce a stylish, architectural variation of combinations of fragments of things that you've seen before.
Making copyright last 10 years only sort of solves this issue.
- lurquer 4y agoWarhol could have simply asked to use the photograph. If the photographer declined, he could find another photographer and another photograph and seek permission. However, if there was something so special about that particular photograph that compelled Warhol to use it even without permission, then the argument that it was a ‘generic’ Prince photo falls apart. Or, god forbid, Warhol or one of his minions could have taken their own photo of Prince…
- amelius 4y agoI sometimes wonder: why do we so badly want artists to be able to make a living of their work? Don't we want art that is pure and that is made by people like us (when we are not trying to make money), instead of by people who live in some completely alternate reality? Copying has been a thing since the beginning of evolution. I'm ok with people making money through selling art, just don't bother me with human-made laws around copying.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt is not about art per se. Art happens to be covered under the same umbrella that researching medicine, writing software, drawing schematics, etc. When the initial cost of production is very, very high and the marginal cost of each additional unit very, very low, copyright is the solution that has so far been found to “work” to incentivize investment- assuming you agree it works. Not that the current implementation is best, especially the length, but the concept.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf copyright laws were removed, would we still have movies that cost $200 million to make? Probably not. Do we really need them? Not really. Cheaper movies would still be made, though. I've seen a lot of low budget movies that were better than the $200m ones. I don't need special effects to enjoy a movie, I need a plot. Check out "Dark Star", made for $50,000. It's far, far better than 95% of the scifi movies out there. Because it had an interesting plot. "Primer" is another example.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSurely the people that made Primer appreciate that they were able to get some compensation due to anyone not simply being able to copy and distribute it? Otherwise, what is the incentive to do all the work and take the risk to make Primer if it is just going to be on YouTube for the benefit of Alphabet’s ad revenue?
- 8note 4y agoThis assumes that without copyrights, they couldn't get any compensation. However, even today, there are plenty of ways to make money from a creative work. Eg. Product placement, patronage, or a subscription service
- WalterBright 4y agoYoutube hosts a billion videos where 99.9999999999% of the creators had no hope of recompense. The same goes for books and music. Here's a good reason: the movie itself is an advertisement. For example, Michael Jackson hired a famous movie director to create his music videos. What where those videos for? Advertising for his live concerts which were huge money makers.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAnd 99.999999999% of YouTube is not worth my time. Quality takes effort and talent, and putting a carrot at the end of the stick makes sense to me to incentivize expending effort and developing talent. Especially for media where the probability of success is very low. Movies might be advertisements in conjunction with just being a movie, but the creators’ multiple intentions do not seem relevant in this case.
- Jailbird 4y agoI've wondered the same thing at times. I eventually came to the conclusion that there are intangible things that society values and must create (concoct) laws to protect the ones that are much too easily subvert or bypassed in ways that effectively remove the valued thing from society. I'm not sure it's the best analogy, but I considered the protections given to real estate agents as something similar. Why can't people just go negotiate directly with the sellers? I won't go into all the obvious details but there's real work back there, just as with art, and the end result isn't protected very well on its own, hence the need for laws, even silly sounding laws.
- pessimizer 4y agoAs someone who was once paid to research the history of the NAR for the NAR, the answer is lots and lots of lobbying.
- Jailbird 4y agoThat seems plausible too, and also lines up with what's happened to copyrights in the US...I can't speak much to real estate, but I'd say copyright went way overboard.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Why can't people just go negotiate directly with the sellers? They can, unless the seller enters into an exclusive contract with a real estate agent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_sale_by_owner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_sale_by_owner
- Jailbird 4y agoTrue - I meant the unethical-but-mechanically-possible act of having someone show you the place, then being a jerk and contacting the seller directly. edit: to be clear, I don't condone that at all, I just mean that's what I considered in thoughts about why we need laws that cover such things.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoProfessional artists add both skill in the mechanics of art production and analysis that takes a broad view of art and culture. Can we manage without professionals? Sure, but --excepting some edge cases-- we'll miss out on a lot of cultural reflection and on a wealth of artwork. To my personal view, copyright is a good idea at the 7 year/14 year terms originally envisaged. Beyond that it becomes more of a harm to creativity and artistic cultural progression. However, you do need to protect individuals from corporations. If I submit a book to a publisher, they say "no", then they hold it for 14 years and decide to publish it ... I'd still want to be protected. Visual artists, painters say, often become popular later in their career; should commercial interests be able to exploit that lag to sell the person's earlier work without the person getting reward?
- parminya 4y agoI don't think your concerns about 7 or 14 year terms are actually necessary: > However, you do need to protect individuals from corporations. This is generally true, so much so that I think the only relevant action would need to be general, to protect individuals from corporations generally. Creators would benefit from protection regardless of whether the term is changed. > If I submit a book to a publisher, they say "no", then they hold it for 14 years and decide to publish it ... I'd still want to be protected. Presumably a much greater proportion of work would be prepaid (via mechanisms like the built-in ads on youtube videos) or self-published. Although they continue to add value, publishers are much less necessary at the moment than previously (as we can see from independent podcasts). The marketplace and output might be completely different if there are short terms, but it will not lead to a collapse in production or a failure to remunerate artists. In any case, the authors of copyright material are not presently engaged in free and equal relations with corporations. If nothing else, a corporation is generally able to sue you, whereas you're generally not able to sue a corporation. And a corporation will write contracts that regularly get tested in courts and get tweaked and improved, whereas you will rarely write contracts and you will rarely have opportunity to improve them based on problems. > Visual artists, painters say, often become popular later in their career; should commercial interests be able to exploit that lag to sell the person's earlier work without the person getting reward? This doesn't happen because their work obtains some additional quality through the passage of time, as though it were a wine ageing in oak. It happens because of the reputation of the artist; by buying the work, the owner has some kind of a relationship with a well reputed person. If anyone is selling a print, the print that is personally authorised by the artist will have a higher value. Therefore, I would suppose this isn't a problem that needs to be fixed. None of this means that everything would continue just fine. Reducing copyright to a few years would be revolutionary. It would result in actual cultural changes. For instance, right now you can use copyright to create artificial scarcity that lasts essentially forever. With a seven year copyright, the artificial scarcity only lasts a few years, so you need to make the most of it. That means that oldness is free and recency is expensive - a reversal of the current system (where oldness is expensive, because it costs more to get something that last a long time, but recency is cheap)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smitty1e 4y agoNot to contradict you, but it was my understanding that modern art--looking at you, Hunter Biden--is substantially a publicly visible form of money laundering.
- BurningFrog 4y agoSince I love art, I want dedicated professionals devoting their lives to making it. They produce so much better art than even equally talented people doing it in their spare time.
- amelius 4y agoOk, so you find an artist that you like and (perhaps together with some other fans) pay them a salary. No need for artificial constructs like copyright law.
- shagie 4y agoBecause the same laws that protect the artist with copyright also protects the code that I write as a hobby or release under an open source library to ensure that improvements to my code come back to the library. Without copyright, GPL and its deracinates have no leg to stand on to prevent it from being incorporated into closed source programs and forever locked away. Sure, you'll be able to copy the application without copyright protecting it, but you'd be unable to modify it. It would be the success of the free part at the cost of the libre values.
- thatcat 4y agoSome one will use free art to make money and none of it will go to the artist without any sort of protections.
- msrenee 4y ago>I sometimes wonder: why do we so badly want artists to be able to make a living of their work? Because art takes time, effort, practice, talent, and the cost of materials. If someone produces something of value, they should be paid for that value. In order to produce art, the artist needs a roof over their head and food in their stomach. As a society, we value it enough to spend millions on it every year. If you want art made by "people like us", buy it from them. If you don't feel like there is value in work by people who make their living painting or singing, don't buy it. If you want people to do it for peanuts because that means they're passionate about it, that just shunts them off with teachers, CNAs, social workers, park rangers, and all the other folks doing difficult and demanding work where their compensation doesn't even begin to reflect their effort and the value they bring to society. But they should shut up and smile while they do it because they're passionate about it.
- specialist 4y agoArt (culture) is a huge industry. Why shouldn't artists get some of that cheddar? Especially since artists are the ones creating the art. It's just basic fairness.
- BizarroLand 4y agoWell, having the opportunity to make a fantastic amount of fame and money and live a bohemian lifestyle is part of what makes art so alluring to potential artists, many of whom would never pick up a paintbrush if they knew that this path led only to penury. Art would be lesser if only wackos, hermits, trust-fund kids and ascetics were able to pursue it.