15 ms·
I think both sides are right, and that this is another example of why copyright is not a good abstraction. It ultimately doesn't make sense because the way we l
by pessimizer 4y ago
I think both sides are right, and that this is another example of why copyright is not a good abstraction. It ultimately doesn't make sense because the way we learn how to do things is by imperfectly copying each other. Being successful means to successfully produce a stylish, architectural variation of combinations of fragments of things that you've seen before.
Part of the quality judgement on a work is in the nature of its comment on what has come before. This is whether you're putting on a play, designing a skyscraper, or designing the API to a website that keeps track of people's coin collections. If you fail to stylishly or profoundly reference things that have come before, your art is probably bad.
edit: and by "I think both sides are right" I mean that I think the pieces of art are completely different to the point of barely resembling one another, just the shape has been retained. I also think that the photographer contributed as much to the work's construction as the artist, and deserves as much of the profit and say in the decision-making about how it is used. And I should use collective pronouns for the artist, because Andy Warhol likely just told somebody to paint on the photograph, and suggested colors, then approved the best of 10.
- tgv 4y agoWhen we learn something to make something (through copying), it's usually not our first idea to sell it. And in this case, Warhol didn't learn anything from Goldsmith. > I think the pieces of art are completely different to the point of barely resembling one another I must have read a completely different article.
- pessimizer 4y agoI'm just going to accept that if I put your urinal in my art gallery, it becomes my fountain. I'm going to accept that because I enjoy it, and because that is the consensus.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> I think both sides are right, and that this is another example of why copyright is not a good abstraction. It ultimately doesn't make sense because the way we learn how to do things is by imperfectly copying each other. Being successful means to successfully produce a stylish, architectural variation of combinations of fragments of things that you've seen before. Making copyright last 10 years only sort of solves this issue.
- lurquer 4y agoWarhol could have simply asked to use the photograph. If the photographer declined, he could find another photographer and another photograph and seek permission. However, if there was something so special about that particular photograph that compelled Warhol to use it even without permission, then the argument that it was a ‘generic’ Prince photo falls apart. Or, god forbid, Warhol or one of his minions could have taken their own photo of Prince…
- amelius 4y agoI sometimes wonder: why do we so badly want artists to be able to make a living of their work? Don't we want art that is pure and that is made by people like us (when we are not trying to make money), instead of by people who live in some completely alternate reality? Copying has been a thing since the beginning of evolution. I'm ok with people making money through selling art, just don't bother me with human-made laws around copying.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt is not about art per se. Art happens to be covered under the same umbrella that researching medicine, writing software, drawing schematics, etc. When the initial cost of production is very, very high and the marginal cost of each additional unit very, very low, copyright is the solution that has so far been found to “work” to incentivize investment- assuming you agree it works. Not that the current implementation is best, especially the length, but the concept.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf copyright laws were removed, would we still have movies that cost $200 million to make? Probably not. Do we really need them? Not really. Cheaper movies would still be made, though. I've seen a lot of low budget movies that were better than the $200m ones. I don't need special effects to enjoy a movie, I need a plot. Check out "Dark Star", made for $50,000. It's far, far better than 95% of the scifi movies out there. Because it had an interesting plot. "Primer" is another example.
- hilbert42 4y ago"…"I think both sides are right" I mean that I think the pieces of art are completely different to the point of barely resembling one another, just the shape has been retained." I think here both sides are actually right in this instance—and I don't disagree with you saying that the images ”barely resembling one another" but I would not go that far (as I think there is a significant recognizable resemblance). That I disagree with you isn't the problem per se—as it'd be a damn boring world if we all agreed or experienced the same perception—rather it's that in cases like this the judgment relies on a subjective analysis by the person(s) doing the judging and that everyone's subjective judgement is different, moreover, to further complicate matters, such differences are likely to alter over time. Thus, if courts allowed it, this case could go on indefinitely with no one being adequately served. This is an obvious case where copyright law has broken down and it's clear the law needs to be changed. It seems to me that royalties ought to be split in this instance but I don't want to get embroiled in a discussion about how the law should be altered as that's not the issue here. Rather it's that we have to face the fact that current copyright law is broken in many areas and it desperately needs reform to make it fairer and less contentious. It needs more than just a fine tuning, instead it requires major reworking, and for that we need to bring a much more sophisticated and nuanced approach to the problem. 'Fair use' provisions are already under considerable strain by the hardened attitudes of many copyright owners—especially from large corporations, Sony, Disney, Elsevier, etc.—and tightening them further by a precedent in this case would likely have significant negative repercussions elsewhere. If the law is tightened writers and artists who don't have big pockets won't dare risk doing derivative works even if they plan differences that are much larger than those in this case and that will twart innovation (if the law becomes more restrictive then copyright holders are also likely to become more litigious). There are also other issues that make copyright law unfair such as the unreasonable increases duration of copyright, excessive restrictions on the use of orphan works, the right to copyright works that are only trivially different to works already in the public domain and the absolute rights of copyright owners with respect to licensing—that is that copyright law does not acknowledge those who are in a position to copyright material are also members of society who, in many instances, have developed their talents at public expense (their education etc.) and in return they have some obligation to society (which implies that some form of enforced arbitration ought to be a part of copyright law). I'm not advocating that rights holders not be paid fair dues for their works—clearly they should, but at the same time they should not be allowed to exploit consumers of copyright material as has so often happened in recent years. The difficulty with this case is that a fair decision in this instance could likely result in a net increase in copyright restrictions which will only increase the unfairness of copyright law. It's why we need urgent copyright law reform—and that won't be easy given the many complexities involved.