6 ms·
I sympathise with the frustration here. However: - There isn't a big pool of people willing to devote time to Free Software. If we had a big pool of people who
by roenxi 4y ago
I sympathise with the frustration here. However:
- There isn't a big pool of people willing to devote time to Free Software. If we had a big pool of people who are better than Stallman and more willing to work on the cause then we'd talk about them. Stallman may not be unique, but he is rare in being simultaneously 1) principled, 2) motivated, 3) willing to work very hard for not a lot of money or prestige in the circles of power and 4) willing to put himself out there pushing a message.
I can find any number of people who are 2/4 on that list. 3/4 is rare. A lot of people who want Stallman gone are going to trade off their principles when they realise that they can get invited to very expensive parties put on by the likes of Google, Microsoft and Amazon. Or plan on just fading in to the background. I think there is an interesting wound to be reopened in the Eich v. Mozilla topic on this point as well.
- No related to this article, but people have completely unrealistic standards for volunteer leadership. The man is human and has flaws. Everyone has flaws. We can tolerate some flaws in people who are doing good work.
- joshuamorton 4y agoThe article quite clearly debunks 3, and all of the others are sort of redundant. Someone who is principled, motivated, and wrong to proselytize might better be described as "obstinate", and we don't generally like those people. (To be clear, re #3, there exist people who have done as much or more for free software as RMS, but people don't idolize most, except perhaps Linus, to the same degree)
- tooltower 4y agoI will dispute this notion that volume of technical work is related to how famous someone is. Today, there are lots of people in opensource doing backbreaking work that we rely on, but whose name we don't even know. Indeed, fame is often the result of them being outspoken.
- stormbrew 4y ago> We can tolerate some flaws in people who are doing good work. Sometimes people's flaws prevent them and the people they work with from doing good work. A lot of people I'd describe as "principled" don't want to be anywhere near Stallman for various reasons, often related to their principles. Maybe he's just cleared his orbit of anyone else who actually fits your 4 criteria, so only appears to be unique. This seems like a rather common failure mode of personality cults, tbh.
- MBCook 4y agoI agree with tolerating “some flaws”. People can be eccentric. RMS’s behavior is way past “some flaws”. No company on earth would have let him stay this long.
- pishpash 4y agoAs if companies are the source of truth on things?
- Espressosaurus 4y agoCompanies aren't the source of truth, but they do represent a floor of acceptable behavior for people working together in a group. Which is what matters for this discussion.
- r3856283 4y ago> they do represent a floor of acceptable behavior for people working together in a group Huh? Working together in a group at a company does not imply any kind of standard for behavior, although companies pretend outwardly that there is some professional standard they abide by. The truth is that work places are filled with all kinds of horrible human behavior, always have and always will be. People work together in bands, on art projects, on house renovations, on family housework, on adventures, on radical political movements, and it is OK for them to have complicated human relationships while they do so and capitalist companies do not deserve to have a say.
- Tostino 4y agoNot agreeing or disagreeing, however I believe their point is that companies care about profit over principles and as long as an employee Disable the produce or foster work that is used to produce profit, thats is really all that matters to them. There isn't really an ideological bent there that can throw a wrench in the works unless you are doing harm as a company.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> We can tolerate some flaws in people who are doing good work. Stallman's principles are important, the man saw really far into the future towards which we have been heading. However, in the GCC AST case these principles really got in the way of good work. Free software is supposed to be the superior software. It seems obvious to me that superior software would be easy to interface with and build upon. GCC should have been no exception but he chose to make it hard on purpose because some proprietary software somewhere might interface with it some day and he didn't want to help those people. It's my understanding this is one of the many reasons why clang is so relevant today. This unwillingness to help proprietary software shows up in other parts of the free software culture as well. For example, nobody seems to care much about binary interfaces, only source code that can be recompiled.
- bruce511 4y ago>> Free software is supposed to be the superior software. Superior, yes, but only for "some definition of superior." It's not meant to be "better in every way" and could never be that anyway since "best" of anything, is always a compromised nuanced collection of competing interests. With the FSF there aren't competing interests, there is one overriding interest and all others are subservient to that. Thus GNU software is always the "most free", but is also unsuitable for most users. Emacs may be free, but my mom uses MS Word. Her definition of "best" might be different to mine, not least because her goal is writing a letter, not analysing source code. To the original author I suggest the following - let the FSF be the FSF and decide for yourself what tools best suit you. There are plenty of alternatives to GNU software for anything that matters. If gcc doesn't do done thing the use clang etc. The "pure" FSF approach to computing is not meant for the masses, it is meant for a tiny few. You are not one of those few. (I mean that in the pragmatic, not pergoritive sense.) Programmers see computers as "a thing" - 99% of the world see it as just another tool to get through the day. My mom cares about her computer about as much as I care where, or how, paper is made. She cares about her software about as much as she cares about her coffee machine. In one sense RMS is a visionary leading us all to software nirvana. In another he's irrelevant. In many ways he can be both at the same time. It doesn't matter whether emacs does this, or gcc does that. We don't really need a more pragmatic FSF - there are already lots of open source advocates filling that space. If you want to be pure, the FSF is the home for you. If you want to be more pragmatic then find somewhere else. Personally I am not one of the tiny group of perfectly-pure users with no reasonable phone or laptop. Personally I think the FSF stance is absurd in most cases and out of touch in most others. But I completely respect their mission, and I completely enjoy many of the freedoms that mission has brought me indirectly. Open Source exists because of the FSF stance - a happy side effect of it maybe - and that is a very important thing. The world needs extremists who model an alternative extreme. Homesteaders don't make me want to live off-the-grid, but they do inspire a model of more sustainable living, I'm encouraged to use alternative water for some uses, perhaps install some solar and so on. Long may the FSF set a standard for impractical, unwavering dedication to an unrealistic computing standard. They set a boundary for the rest of us to see in the distance, and they allow a middle ground far closer to that boundary than we would otherwise aspire to. The FSF is gloriously irrelevant, and long may it last.
- r3856283 4y agoI will also point out that this is an anonymous blog post from someone who has published no way to contact them privately and has never posted to the emacs mailing list (at least from the domain of their blog). It is a one-sided view, and I see at least one important inaccuracy. FSF and RMS were certainly not asked for their view. Given that, would it make sense for RMS or FSF to write anything about this post publicly to give it validity and attention? Very doubtful. Given all that, I found this bit pretty amusing: "I'd be surprised if he or any of the people with any influence even read it", how would the author ever find out? lol. It is sad that this person cares about emacs, but dropping a big dis track and walking away without even suggesting any practical solutions really does not help things. Emacs has a very few core maintainers, FSF has a small staff augmented by volunteers, this is not some faceless entity like a big corporation or government. Update: the author has since published their email address. Good for them.
- mort96 4y agoI'm not sure what sorts of "practical solutions" you could possibly imagine. The core problem here is that Stallman has strongly held positions he won't budge on which harms the competitiveness of Free Software, and that all of GNU is subject to his whims. Would you have been more happy if the post had ended with "GNU and the FSF must replace Stallman"? Maybe if it ended with "GNU shouldn't be under the BDFL model anymore, there should be a leadership committee"?
- wisnoskij 4y ago
- IntelMiner 4y agoCareful. You'll attract the infamous "GNU plus Linux" meme that has been attributed to Stallman for decades
- mort96 4y agoI'm not sure what Linux has to do with this?
- jahewson 4y ago> If we had a big pool of people who are better than Stallman and more willing to work on the cause then we'd talk about them There 100% was such a pool of people but Stallman scared or domineered them all away.
- guerrilla 4y agoBullshit. If there were, they would have started their own orgs, forking whatever with most of the work done for them already.
- mjhay 4y agoThat's not such an easy thing to do, you know.
- guerrilla 4y agoThat's my point. It's hard and apparently nobody else is capable of it, even with most of the work done for them.
- raydev 4y ago> most of the work done for them You say this as if there's not much more work to do, not many more features or improvements to be had. So your point appears to be wrong.
- CJefferson 4y agoThe problem is, how many people has Stallman personally put off working in GNU software? Certainly me, and at least two of my friends. I can't know exactly, but I bet lots of others.
- patrick451 4y agoMaybe you aren't the sort of contributors he wants. If RMS were more milquetoast, perhaps you and your friends would contribute, but at what cost? How many hardcore free software zealots would be repelled?
- iLemming 4y ago> We can tolerate some flaws in people who are doing good work. Not trying to be snarky, I'm genuinely curious. I know that RMS has been very active in the emacs-dev mailing-list. Not sure if he's become more active after he was forced to step down from FSF board, and what impact (if any) his return has made. Aside from turning emacs-dev mailing list into a weird place where one has to be a bit careful even when asking technical questions, what "good work" has RMS done in the past decade? Again, I'm not trying to downplay his achievements and accomplishments in the past, I'm sincerely interested to know about his work. I know he wrote tons of essays, but he doesn't contribute to Emacs codebase anymore, right?
- discardable_dan 4y ago
- scombridae 4y agoAll four virtues boil down to the third: devoting one's waking hours for a non-profit cause. This puts Stallman in a pretty massive demographic, one that includes the clergy, public school teachers, and professional baduk players.
- eqvinox 4y ago> We can tolerate some flaws in people who are doing good work. The real question is whether RMS is actually doing good work. I don't question his intent, but the outcome is… let's call it "debatable." And, arguably, the gaussian on that outcome very much includes negative results — not sure where the overall curve goes…
- pvaldes 4y agoThe outcome is several pieces of software that millions of people adopted as optimum solution for a long list of different needs, and that are stable and work really well. How this could be tagged as not good enough work for somebody is beyond my comprehension.
- eqvinox 4y agoThat might be the outcome of his work in the 1980s and '90s. I'm more concerned about the outcome he's achieving now.