8 ms·
Parent time
- seanhunter 4y agoThere's nothing quite like a quasi-profound insight such as this delivered via the medium of a series of tweets for maximum banality.
- ilikerashers 4y agoNot to be a party pooper but I feel like I've heard this "revelation" on Twitter and LinkedIn about 10 times now from influencers.
- goodpoint 4y agoNext on HN: water is wet.
- TaupeRanger 4y agoIt's an entire (and very popular) waitbutwhy article. I'm skeptical that the story in the tweets even happened.
- jonas-w 4y agoA bit easier to read it unrolled: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1571137341997318147 https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1571137341997318147
- josalhor 4y agoI saw this idea some time ago also in HN [0,1], it has also stuck in my brain pretty hard. The way Paul words it is like this: > Having kids showed me how to convert a continuous quantity, time, into discrete quantities. (...). If Christmas-as-magic lasts from say ages 3 to 10, you only get to watch your child experience it 8 times. And while it's impossible to say what is a lot or a little of a continuous quantity like time, 8 is not a lot of something. (...) (...) > When I ask myself what I've found life is too short for, the word that pops into my head is "bullshit." I realize that answer is somewhat tautological. It's almost the definition of bullshit that it's the stuff that life is too short for. And yet bullshit does have a distinctive character. There's something fake about it. It's the junk food of experience. > If you ask yourself what you spend your time on that's bullshit, you probably already know the answer. Unnecessary meetings, pointless disputes, bureaucracy, posturing, dealing with other people's mistakes, traffic jams, addictive but unrewarding pastimes. This reflection in general has transformed not only how I look at time, but also how I look at work. I ask myself, is _my work_ bullshit? Is this _task_ bullshit? Is my way of spending _time_ bullshit? [0]: http://www.paulgraham.com/vb.html http://www.paulgraham.com/vb.html [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16729555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16729555
- laurencei 4y agoAnother article along those lines that I think was on HN previous is "Life Is Not Short" I found it quite eye opening: https://dkb.show/post/life-is-not-short https://dkb.show/post/life-is-not-short
- iforgotpassword 4y agohttps://youtu.be/sz4YqwH_6D0 https://youtu.be/sz4YqwH_6D0
- matwood 4y agoThe idea that time is finite and we are all going to die is as old as humanity. In 1-2 generations most of us will be completely forgotten. I glad someone already posted something to Stoicism and Seneca.
- 4y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoAlong the same lines, this advice from Paul Graham also changed my life: > If Christmas-as-magic lasts from say ages 3 to 10, you only get to watch your child experience it 8 times. http://www.paulgraham.com/vb.html http://www.paulgraham.com/vb.html
- sixhobbits 4y agoI flagged this because it's way too clickbaitey/buzzfeedy in both _form_ and _content_, but to solve the form problem at least Better title: "If you see your mid-sixties parents once per year you'll see them 15 more times" The actual tweet (3 down from the first one which is all just suspense building) ``` The moment of vulnerability sparked an interaction that changed my life: George: “How often do you see your parents?" Me: “Maybe once a year now.” George: “And how old are they?" Me: “Mid-sixties." George: “Ok, so you’re going to see them 15 more times before they die.” ``` Nitter link without login wall [0]. [0] https://nitter.net/SahilBloom/status/1571137341997318147 https://nitter.net/SahilBloom/status/1571137341997318147
- sgallant 4y agoThank you!
- kreetx 4y agoSame here, and also from the twitter thread: "Follow me @SahilBloomfor more writing like this."[1] I think waitbutwhy (or someone) had a blog post about this a long time ago. This thread doesn't add to that thought, and then asks to follow him.. [1] https://twitter.com/SahilBloom/status/1571137376969453575 https://twitter.com/SahilBloom/status/1571137376969453575
- ethanbond 4y agoSurely someone has commentated that “life is short” in one form or another before waitbutwhy, right? IMO it’s good for these sentiments to be rephrased and restated repeatedly. The reason is that these things have to hit you at the right time and in the right way to make the impact that they’re “supposed to.” The first 999 times someone says life is short, you shrug it off and walk straight into another day in zombie-mode (nothing wrong with that!). But the 1000th time someone says it, and you happen to have just gotten off the phone with your mother telling you she has some illness… that’s the time you need to hear it. So you pack up and move across the country.
- phtrivier 4y agoThat's the idea behind "The tail end" https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html
- Trasmatta 4y agoIt's a bit more complicated when you don't have a great relationship with your parents. I live across the country as well, and I'm content with the fact that I may only see my parents a few more times. I don't hate them, but being close to them and spending time with them is a net negative on my mental health.
- firecall 4y agoFor people feeling bad about not seeing your parents, then you should remember that the reverse is true! You don't owe it to them to spend your life living close enough to see them weekly. (or insert schedule you like). If they want to see you or your children, they could equally move to be close or visit. And sometimes Parents do just that!
- giantg2 4y agoThis is less likely to be true if moving from a lower COL to someplace with a high COL like CA.
- Arainach 4y agoExactly. My parents aggressively saved for retirement and are quite comfortable where they live even factoring potential future inflation, but there's nowhere within a couple hours of Seattle/SanFran they could afford to live.
- Trasmatta 4y agoThe thought of my parents moving closer to me just invoked a very mild panic reaction in me, which is a good indication of why I've chosen not to be near them.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoEven though my mom and I talk almost daily, I like having my parents a comfortable distance away. For mine, 6~10 hours is ideal. Too far to make a car trip frequently, not far enough to justify a plane flight. I drive to visit them often enough to keep them away from where I live. So far, only 4 visits in 9 years. Still too many, but manageable. :)
- martyvis 4y agoMy wife and I have 4 married children and two very new grandchildren by our 2 daughters. Every second weekend we try to catch up with one of the families - 3 are in one city 90 minutes drive away and other family is 2 hours away. We are cognisant that we are probably able to be more flexible (that said my widowed MIL is ill and needs some extra attention at the moment). My own parents aren't the easiest to deal with so while I do keep in contact it can be quite stressful. My sisters are 1000+ KMs away. The reality of family life isn't trivial.
- giantg2 4y agoThe real thing isn't how much you'll see them. It's how much you'll need to take care of them in the final years and what you'll have to sacrifice. Sounds like the author is well off and can afford to change jobs, move, etc. If their parents lived in a more rural area, it would be a much tougher decision since there's not much work there. Sure, there's remote, but we're not all great at that (and except for the top companies and specific industries, it's only a matter of time before wages are massively pushed down to compete internationally). Some of us might not be capable of landing another job anyways.
- bborud 4y agoI got this wakeup-call somewhat indirectly. I was looking at what books I want to read in the coming year (a constant struggle :-)) and I realized that at my current rate of ~80 books per year, and perhaps 30-40 years left to live, I'll probably only get to read another 2500-3000 or so books. Provided I'll even be able to absorb books at my current rate. Then I started thinking about how many times I will experience other things that matter in my life.
- donatj 4y agoHow’s your retention on 80 books a year? I manage 6 or 7 a year, and they really need time to ruminate.
- shanusmagnus 4y agoAny tips that have been effective in that rumination? For people who want to get a lot out of the books they read, as you do, I'm always curious about the strategies they've come up with.
- bborud 4y agoAs I pointed out in a different comment I have three strategies: - note-taking including writing down my own ideas - use audio books and trying to associate what I'm listening to with where I am (for me, exertion increases retention :-)) - re-reading or re-listening to books/chapters I suppose if I could find people to discuss what I'm reading with, that would be even better. But I'd drive most people mad.
- bborud 4y agoIt depends on what kind of book we're talking about. A lot of the fiction I read is just for entertainment then and there. Not retaining it isn't a big loss. In fact, it is probably just good for me to forget. I read between 10 and 20 books per year that are worth retaining. The number of nonfiction books I read depends a lot on how much spare capacity I have for reading and absorbing them. They usually tend to take longer to read in total, and I often re-read chapters, make marginal notes, or take notes in notebooks. I don't often read my notes. I mainly take notes because note-taking itself helps me process and remember what I read. (In general I take a lot of notes and have notebooks going back a few decades). One thing that helps is actually exercising while listening to the audio book version. If I can listen to an audio book while hiking or bicycling, and I vary the route, I can often remember where I was when I heard something and thinking about a particular hike helps me remember what came next etc. The harder the physical exertion, the better I retain what I heard. (For instance, 8 years ago I was listening to the audio book version of an introduction to immunology and the chapter I remember the most of was the one I listened to while carrying my broken bicycle down a steep hill) Retention also depends a bit on how the book is written. Some authors write books that have low information density, which makes my mind wander. However, the real challenge isn't retaining the contents, but who wrote it and in which book. I remember ideas, arguments, and often quite a lot of detail - but I forget names and book titles. This is really inconvenient when recommending books I've read because I first have to figure out who wrote it or what the book's title was. (For work-related books I can usually check my notebooks).
- Xcelerate 4y agoI have always considered myself relatively aware of how quickly time goes by, but having a child drove the point home in a way that’s very hard to ignore. Month-to-month (and sometimes even week-to-week) I see how quickly she grows up, and it’s a bittersweet combination of joy and melancholy. I also moved back to be near family and am working remotely now. I don’t like where I live at all, and I enjoyed working in the office much more than from my house, but seeing my daughter every morning and being next to family is irreplaceable. (Although to be fair, I wanted to stay in California and just travel to visit family more frequently; my spouse wanted to physically move next to them. I suppose her solution is better for the planet even if I don’t like it as much.)
- newaccount74 4y agoI think there was an xkcd comic about the limited time we get to spend with relatives but I can't find it. Can anyone remember the title?
- cannonpr 4y agoSo I am an immigrant, close to 20 years away from my family, I had a similar interaction with my father who passed away from covid a few years back. He was someone who I spoke with on science and politics daily for at-least an hour and remained sharp as ever till his death. “Should I come back to spend more time with you and the family ?” “Why would you ? Live for the future, contribute, do something new, teach some young kids some politics” I think that do what’s important to you is excellent advice, it’s not remotely the same for everyone’s family though.
- movedx 4y agoYour old man sounded like a legend to me. What a reply. I would have loved to have had a chat with him. I hope you're finding peace and happiness in whatever you decided to do, friend.
- exitb 4y agoThanks for that. I look at the situation from a different angle - having a young son I put so much daily effort for him to end up in a life that he's happy with, whatever that may turn out to be. I'd hate for him to be ever held back his parents. Im not saying that this move was not the right choice for him, but it's definitely not a general advice.
- stephc_int13 4y agoI don't think that not seeing his parents very often should be universally considered bad. As an adult, you're making your own decisions and building your own family. Your spouse might not really like spending that much time with your parents. And you might not really like her or his parents. From my experience, staying close to the same people who raised you will keep you in that comfortable but limited childhood state for longer than necessary.
- daoist_shaman 4y ago> As an adult, you're making your own decisions and building your own family. Yeah, this is 100% true. You can, and should, sever ties with abusive individuals where you have the power to do so. You have the power to choose your family, but some people think it’s an unbreakable life bond and will try to guilt you for all eternity for disagreeing.
- latexr 4y ago> Your spouse might not really like spending that much time with your parents. And you might not really like her or his parents. Heck, you might not even like your parents. There are a ton of selfish people in the world and many have children. I know my fair share of individuals who were (or are) held back in their own life, happiness, and mental stability because of their emotionally manipulative parents. More than once I’ve seen someone in this situation being temporarily forced away (due to studies or a job) and flourish in all areas of life, only to regress when they return close to home. It’s harrowing. Parents aren’t universally good, yet our society is constantly trying to sell us on the idea of “family above all”. Screw that. You didn’t pick your family. You’re under no obligation to suffer your whole life if they’re shitty. Pick good friends instead.
- oceanplexian 4y agoYour parents can also be the most wonderful, easy-going, caring people the word but it still gets really old, really fast living with them or spending several days a week with them over the years. It also seems super illogical you would constrain yourself to one geographical place in the world based on what your parents thought was a good place to live, not based on what you actually want. That sounds stifling to me. Distance also makes family relationships more meaningful, not less. My parents, grandparents, and siblings all live in different states or countries thousands of miles away. We still plan vacations and meetups and holidays each year, we talk on the phone, online, etc, so the idea I’ll only see them X times before they die don’t add up.
- xcambar 4y agoMy wife, our kids, and I live abroad from our families. Kids and grandparents get to see each other once a year or so. Yet, we do not plan to move back closer to our families. The reason is simple: our relation to our parents is fulfilling as it is and our parents educated us in such a way that we build our own family for ourselves, because the one thing that was granted to us (quoting my own parents) was their unconditional support and love. Distance sure prevents a lot of small yet meaningful interactions and it sometimes hurts, but the support that we received helped us settle where we wanted and become who we wanted, independently from any geographical or otherwise constraints. We're infinitely grateful to our parents for that.
- gtirloni 4y agoDo I still have to see them 15x more times? Geez /s
- xiphias2 4y ago,,If the average life expectancy is ~80 years, my parents are in their mid-60s, and I see them one time per year, the math—however depressing—says I will see them 15 more times before they are gone.'' The math (and life) is even more cruel: there's more than 50% chance that at least one of his parents will die before 80. I'm right now on a vacation with my mom, but it's not the same as when both my parents were alive (a year ago).
- CaptArmchair 4y agoEach of us has two lives. The second one begins once you truly realize life is finite.
- martyvis 4y agoThere are two numbers doing the rounds lately. One is 4000 - that's the number of weeks we have in our life. More specifically for most of us it might be the number of weekends and hence might make us think about how we recreate or best spend that time which we often look forward to. The other number is 80000 referring to the hours we have in our average working life. Again it probably seems such a small number and yet so many of those hours are filled with less than productive tasks like attending meetings that we shouldn't, and we aren't making the most of those others to make sure our career is fulfilling and productive
- somecommit 4y agoIt has nothing to do with the conversation itself, it's a very common case of middle age crisis (You will note his parent are 65, he's certainly something around 40). All human arriving at this age experience the same. It's a very sane crisis, once you sink you have limited resource and limited time, you can really accomplish interesting projects.
- _gfwu 4y ago> We spend most of our lives playing a game: > Everything we do is in anticipation of the future. When that future comes, we simply reset to the next one. > “I can’t wait until I’m 18 so I can [X].” > “I can’t wait until I’m 25 so I can [Y]." > “I can’t wait until I’m 45 so I can [Z]." Really? Do "we"? I don't. Maybe Sahil does, but he also realised his parents were mortal and our lives are finite in his 30s (?). I find this trend on social media and in blogs where people make a personal discovery and frame it as if it applies to everyone really condescending. I don't even mean to sound so cynical, but somehow it just rubs me the wrong way. The same with how he just assumes everyone was lucky enough to have parents who love and care about them (and each other).
- emadabdulrahim 4y agoSahil tends to write these clickbaity Twitter threads. I find that I vehemently dislike this style of writing. I'd much rather read the source of the ideas[0] than someone's unoriginal take on them. [0] https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html
- nyokodo 4y ago> he just assumes… He’s not assuming anything so much as writing for a target audience that perhaps of which you’re not a member.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nvarsj 4y agoIt's why I dislike LinkedIn so much. Almost every post on there sounds like this twitter post. Devoid of real meaning but meant to sound profound.
- machinerychorus 4y agoTime is fleeting. I made this android wallpaper so I would be reminded of that fact. Every time I look at my phone I think "am I doing what I really want to be doing? am I making the best use of my limited time?" App: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.machineryc https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.machineryc... Source code: https://github.com/ethanmdavidson/DeathProgress https://github.com/ethanmdavidson/DeathProgress
- nidnogg 4y agoPlay Store link (from this comment) is dead. A bit on the morbid side though, no?
- david_allison 4y agoFixed link: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.machinerychorus.lifeprogresswallpaper https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.machineryc...
- machinerychorus 4y agoPerhaps a bit morbid, but very realistic. Death comes for us all, even if you ignore it. By consciously forcing yourself to confront it you can reduce the chance that you'll wind up with a ton of regrets when you're old.
- mt_ 4y agoStop using Twitter for these kind of essays..
- Grustaf 4y agoThis is quite possibly the oldest insight in the world. Dressed up as something new and clever in order to promote his twitter account. Oh God how I hate social media.
- dominotw 4y agoHow desperate is that guy to recycle internet cliches into BS george stories. https://youtube.com/shorts/kgPTJKwh6vc https://youtube.com/shorts/kgPTJKwh6vc
- bloak 4y agoPerhaps it's not that old because there seems to be something very 20th-century and American about it: the idea of trying to get maximum return out of your time/money because time is money and money is time. I'm not a philosopher and haven't analysed this very carefully, but the "lesson" implied by the story strikes me as not just trite but also wrong. Perhaps I'm just too cynical or the examples chosen (parents, Christmas) are particularly off-putting for me.
- rippercushions 4y agoQuite some time ago, I ran into a website on HN that let you easily calculate how often you are likely to see a person before they die. I couldn't find it anywhere though, on HN or the wider web. Anybody remember?
- CubsFan1060 4y agoI found this video to be a bit eye opening as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXeJANDKwDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXeJANDKwDc Somewhat along the same lines. I ordered one of the posters from the video (not sure I can link it here)
- jarek83 4y agoMy ex-wife just died because of cancer. It brought me very similar thoughts and hopefully a lesson. I've spent too much time in my life on virtually 'nothing'. I need to change it now. I feel big desire to live through the tiny moments which turn to be the most precious in life. All the best to you all, good people.
- tromp 4y ago> If the average life expectancy is ~80 years, my parents are in their mid-60s, and I see them one time per year, the math—however depressing—says I will see them 15 more times before they are gone. The fact that his parents survived until their mid-60s means that they have a life expectancy better than the ~80 year average, as that average includes many people that don't make it to their mid-60s.
- Havoc 4y agoYeah I’m on the other side of world from parents and realised that too. Opted to phone them every ~3 days. Not ideal but it does help a bit
- tmountain 4y agoPaul Graham talks about this in one of his essays, Life is Short. This part really drove it home for me. “Having kids showed me how to convert a continuous quantity, time, into discrete quantities. You only get 52 weekends with your 2 year old. If Christmas-as-magic lasts from say ages 3 to 10, you only get to watch your child experience it 8 times. And while it's impossible to say what is a lot or a little of a continuous quantity like time, 8 is not a lot of something. If you had a handful of 8 peanuts, or a shelf of 8 books to choose from, the quantity would definitely seem limited, no matter what your lifespan was.” http://www.paulgraham.com/vb.html http://www.paulgraham.com/vb.html
- watwut 4y agoTo be entirely honest, when I read quotes like this, it always makes me think that they must be made by people who don't spend much time with their own kids overall. Weekend with your 2 years old is kind of the same as workday with your two years old, unless of course you just dont spend time with your 2 years old except on weekends.
- maerF0x0 4y agoI cant refind the website right now, but i once encountered an interesting website that took this concept further. It demonstrated that many of us have already spent between 95-99% of the time we will see our parents. Eg: * presume your parents have you at ~30 * Live at home 18years x 365 days per year = 6570 days * You see them a week per year for the remainder of their life = 50 years * 7 days per year = 350 days therefore at 19yrs old you have 350/(6570+350) days remaining ~= 5%
- maerF0x0 4y agoWhen I moved from Canada to the Bay area I thought, and everyone said, that they (friends, family) would come visit. Spoiler: I got 2 visits in 8 years, both by my mom. This despite me going back to see varying people roughly twice per year. I've sadly learned that many of those relationships are a one way street of convenience. They're happy to see me when I come, to walk down memory lane. But they'll never put in the effort to come see me. Sadly this realization has been the demise of many of those relationships that I was carrying. The difficulty of replacing the depth of relationships you have is a cost that few immigrants realize until "too late"[1], and making new ones is quite difficult because many people who remain in their place/culture will be reasonably satisfied by the quantity/quality of their relationships and thusly not really that open to starting new ones. This is one that that (at one time) made the bay area pretty special, maybe true of Austin now, it's _full_ of people from someonewhere else who are in the same situation -- looking to replace lost relationships and unable to break into calcified cliques. [1] yeah yeah pedantic HN it's not to late unless your both dead, sure. But it's also awkward af to sit in a room with a friend you havent seen in 10 years and be like "oh what's your wife's name?" (and he gives you a smile "we've been married for 6 years, how can you not know <Jane>'s name?" or similar idea with their kids. You'll come to find their world has moved on and changed, and what you had is just a nice memory.
- harryvederci 4y agoReminds me of this Kurtzgesagt video, which explains that if you're an adult, you've probably spent 99% of your total time with your parents: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXeJANDKwDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXeJANDKwDc
- dominotw 4y agoI call BS on his George story. There are million internet reels about this https://youtube.com/shorts/kgPTJKwh6vc https://youtube.com/shorts/kgPTJKwh6vc
- hiidrew 4y agoPosted this on the other thread but wanted to share the link here: Tim Urban has a great post on this, helps you visualize the timing: https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html Anyway, this makes me a bit sad considering I've recently moved a 15 hour drive away from my parents. Happy that they have a guest room and for remote work though. It also makes me ponder the differences in western culture and other places. I know in some cultures family is much more integrated, e.g. the grandparents move-in instead of sending them to a home or something. I love my city life but I do sometimes imagine living in a compound with my close family. I think it would be tolerable if everyone had their own space but was close in proximity.
- geodel 4y agoThis is in same category as How many weekends/sunrise/sunsets/friend visits/famous place/restaurant and so on one can have before they themselves or other party die? To me all these numbers sound reasonable. Either I took conscious decisions to reach this situation, in that case there is nothing to be surprised about. Or maybe things just happened one after other, then how can I suddenly change and take control of things and do it differently.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- f1shy 4y agoThis: “Ok, so you’re going to see them 15 more times before they die.” I'm living far away from my parents. And I see them once a year (except the last 3 years because of COVID). I came myself to this math, the first time I was to them, and we had a pretty heavy discussion. I understood, I was going to see them 10 to 20 times, 20 days each time, which boils down to about... 1 year? It really makes you take those 20 days very differently!
- strangattractor 4y agoWish I had gotten that advice.