5 ms·
"It also establishes a precedent, allowing private companies to set opaque, moralizing, and arbitrary censorship terms without oversight." Yes, this is done wi
by giantg2 4y ago
"It also establishes a precedent, allowing private companies to set opaque, moralizing, and arbitrary censorship terms without oversight."
Yes, this is done with other things as well.
On one hand, I think that the free market would create payment processors willing to work with the groups rejected by others.
On the other hand, it seems that many financial things are set by international organizations, which the processors would still need to follow to be included in the central systems, such as the coding (does adult content have its own code, or is it under entertainment?).
- izacus 4y agoCorporate consolidation made sure that a lot of important markets aren't free anymore. Vertical integration between corporations made that even worse - e.g. if Visa won't process your payments, people with Apple phones won't be able to pay either. These kind of things - there's too little competition across many markets so big players just itegrate with themselves and newcomers simply can't compete due to integration and network effects.
- dbingham 4y agoIt's important to point out that this is a natural consequence of a market system, and it's exacerbated by allowing capital to rule those markets. Until we recognize that, we're not going to be able to fix it. One can't just declare that "If only the market were truly free, it wouldn't be like this." We've seen this play out on the freest market that has ever existed (the early internet) and we ended up in the exact same place - with a few massive players buying up all their competitors and completely dominating their verticals. There was as little regulation or government interference in the early internet as there has ever been in just about any market. And we still got there. Corporate consolidation is a consequence of free markets, not a corruption of them.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoIt's late stage capitalism. It's how all 'free markets' end up eventually. The biggest players gobbling up all of the competition and essentially having a monopoly. All you have to do is drive through middle america to see the Ruby Tuesday/Strip Mall-ification effect on most of the United States. I love capitalism when it's functioning it's the greatest system ever invented. When it's just a market full of monopolies it's akin to dysfunctional communism from a consumer choice perspective. I don't know what the solution is.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> It's late stage capitalism. It's going to get so much worse. Years from now you'll look back at the 2020s and think "I though THAT was the late stage? Boy I had no idea."
- pas 4y agowhy will it get worse? what's the model that predicts this?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThere seems to be no limit to the insanity people will tolerate with sufficient conditioning, so there is no reason to think there is a natural limit to how bad any economic or political system, capitalism or otherwise, can degrade. If you can't imagine how things could get even worse, then watch some science fiction or read some history books. Tearing people's hearts out to appease the sun god, or to repossess the organ after unpaid medical bills. We're not there yet, but that could be the sort of madness we're heading into.
- pas 4y agoI agree, people can adapt to basically anything, but we have pretty clear precedents about who does what when faced with this or that. In the face of constant legally sanctioned/mandated exploitation the frequency of outlaw group appearances increases, similarly revolts start from time to time. (Not saying their success rate was any great.) Repossessing organs doesn't sound scary. The fanatics do scare me more, after all North Korea and every other successful oppressive regime was built on that. But it remains to be seen if it's possible to scale up totalitarianism to bigger scales.
- BirAdam 4y agoIt will get worse because the US federal government will not be able to pay debt service indefinitely. This will either mean a lowering of interest rates and acceleration of both inflation and debt accumulation (merely delaying the collapse of the dollar system) or US federal default which will collapse the dollar system. When dollars quit flowing to the states in return for federal program enforcement there will be little incentive for state governments to continue adhering to federal rules. Warriors likewise don't usually fight for free, so there's unlikely to be a large military presence to hold it all together. From many perspectives, you could consider this to be not the end of capitalism in the USA, but the end of empire altogether. Of course, the politicians, bankers, and managerial elite of the USA have kept this going far longer than I thought possible, so it may not happen that way at all.
- floor2 4y agoThis statement is fundamentally flawed on two different core aspects. First, the phenomenon you're referring to is "natural monopolies" which is a well understood situation which appears in every freshman-level Economics 101 class, but that only applies to certain industries. For instance, utilities are natural monopolies because it's far more efficient to run one set of wires to every house rather than try to have 10 competing companies all run their own power lines. But most products & services don't fall into this category. Second, "free market" is a specific economic term which means markets which are free from governmental intervention in terms of price controls or subsidies, but are also free from monopolies, cartels or other anti-competitive behavior by any participant. Using the government to break up a monopoly or cartel moves the system towards a "free market". Having zero regulation which allows one or two participants to distort the market moves the system away from a "free market".
- dbingham 4y ago> First, the phenomenon you're referring to is "natural monopolies" which is a well understood situation which appears in every freshman-level Economics 101 class, but that only applies to certain industries. For instance, utilities are natural monopolies because it's far more efficient to run one set of wires to every house rather than try to have 10 competing companies all run their own power lines. But most products & services don't fall into this category. I'm not referring to natural monopolies. While I concede many of the cases people would immediately think of in my description of the early internet (Google, Facebook, et al) could readily be classified as natural monopolies, we've seen plenty of consolidation in areas that most economists wouldn't classify as such - Amazon for instance, a bookstore or e-commerce site is not a natural monopoly. And we've seen the same consolidation off the internet everywhere. There are few significant verticals, at this point, that aren't dominated by a handful of giant consolidated players. Independent of how much regulation there is or isn't in that vertical. > Second, "free market" is a specific economic term which means markets which are free from governmental intervention in terms of price controls or subsidies, but are also free from monopolies, cartels or other anti-competitive behavior by any participant. Using the government to break up a monopoly or cartel moves the system towards a "free market". Having zero regulation which allows one or two participants to distort the market moves the system away from a "free market". And this is where economists trip over their own feet and fall face first into the mud of religion. This is a self-referential, recursive definition that allows you to pretend a major consequence of a system is not, in fact, an issue. You realize that you just defined a "free market" to be a market that is free of regulation, but requires regulation to maintain its state as a free market?
- dylan604 4y ago>On one hand, I think that the free market would create payment processors willing to work with the groups rejected by others. These already exist and are sometimes known as "high risk" processors. They charge a lot more for the privilege of accepting payments for what industry has deem high risk transactions due to larger rates of chargebacks. Typical examples are paid subscription to a porn site, but then the card owner claims it was not them that paid for it. CBD/Delta-8/Delta-10/Delta-9 sales are also considered high risk for various reasons with one due to their legality questionable in some states.
- giantg2 4y ago"They charge a lot more for the privilege of accepting payments for what industry has deem high risk transactions due to larger rates of chargebacks." If they're doing lower volume and dealing with higher costs related to chargebacks, then it seems it would make sense they charge more. What is it, like 3% vs 6% or worse?
- arcticfox 4y agoLike 3% vs 12%
- dylan604 4y agoAlso, some charge a steep monthly fee. One that I'm familiar with charges $100/month plus the higher % per transaction. So even if you have $0 in sales for a month, you still pay them $100. So it's not the greater of % per transaction vs monthly fee. It is always monthly fee + % per transaction.
- adrr 4y agoHaving built a neobank. It’s fact that pornography is intertwined with sex trafficking, organized crime, revenge porn and other illegal activities. Regulators crack down on financial institutions if they are caught providing services for illegal activities.
- aliqot 4y agoHSBC wants you to think that but anybody with wikipedia can tell you it's not true in practice. It's not that they don't want your business, it's that the end users in these cause problems. They're happy to keep cartel money, one-to-many is easier than many-to-one, it's simple math.
- _jal 4y agoYeah, and it is a fact that cartel and authoritarian statist money laundering is intertwined with banking. See just about any story about Deutsche in the last decade. I've worked with sex-related sites before. And you're right that there are sleazy people in that industry. But it really isn't hard to distinguish, especially when you can see their payment stream. Without moralist obsessions with sex, nobody would care.
- patrick451 4y agoWhat's your point? Sans morals, nobody would care murder either.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- colpabar 4y agoIf you kill someone I care about, I will want to see you punished. So many people agree with this that we have laws saying you can't kill people or else you'll be punished. But if you pay someone to have sex with them, so what? If both parties consent to everything, then who is harmed? Some people get mad because they think it's immoral, but not everyone.
- Consultant32452 4y agoThe (big) banks cannot fail because the government will bail them out. As such, the banks should be considered a de-facto government entity and be bound by the same limitations on censorship. There is no competition/market.
- kobalsky 4y ago> On one hand, I think that the free market would create payment processors willing to work with the groups rejected by others. how open is the payment network willing to accept a new player when a site like onlyfans with billions of dollars in revenue would rather go down in flames only to be saved by public backlash rather than implementing their own payment processing service? it's obviously not that simple.
- naasking 4y ago> On the other hand, it seems that many financial things are set by international organizations Not organizations, governments. Financial rules set by governments to cut down on money laundering, terrorist funding and other "financial crimes" are why payment processing is rife with liabilities and why Visa and banks have such strict rules. Without these rules banks would happily work with anyone that has money.
- lelanthran 4y ago> "It also establishes a precedent, allowing private companies to set opaque, moralizing, and arbitrary censorship terms without oversight." > Yes, this is done with other things as well. Politics makes strange bedfellows. Complain that twitter or facebook is censoring things and you'll get told that the government should not be able to dictate to private companies who can or cannot be excluded. Allow private companies to exclude a significant chunk of the population, and those same groups will complain of censorship. Both the Right and the Left have a common interest in forcing private companies to not exclude certain people. Too bad that too few people see the value in regulating de-facto monopolies.
- giantg2 4y ago"Both the Right and the Left have a common interest in forcing private companies to not exclude certain people." But they won't come together because it's good if I do it to you, but bad if you do it to me.
- prvc 4y agoThe word "precedent" in that quote seems to be being used in order to deny that this is not already the case in many other contexts! Also strange that one of the examples given of this supposed "censorship" was a pornographer's difficulties in obtaining a loan due to the financial risk brought on, in part, by chargebacks, and not some supposed anti-pornography convictions held by the bankers.
- pasc1878 4y agoYou missed the reason that payment processers set these terms. It is not because they want to. It is because there is a minority who think sex is dirty and only should be done in the family and they will take anyone who is even slightly helping sex workers to court. The only protection public companies would have is there was a law stopping these court actions but no lawmaker is going to do this as the same minority would attack them and the majority would see the company as helping sleaze and what that minority see as sin. Note that any new payment processor would be hit in the same way. The issue is that a minority can persuade the majority of things even if they are untrue or destructive.