18 ms·
Open Source PC That Fits in Your Pocket
- recursivedoubts 4y agoone day, I will have my OQO
- tomcam 4y agoA girl can dream, can’t she. Unfortunately, username checks out.
- c54 4y agoI love seeing these projects but can't imagine what in the world I'd do with one of these devices. Small computers that don't benefit from the mobile UX tradeoffs and don't quite have keyboards or screens or a hinge to support putting it down and typing on it. They're cute though. If you had one, what would you be doing with it?
- RL_Quine 4y agoUntil the hardware totally gave out, I used a Sony Vaio P which is of similar size, but had a keyboard usable by a human being. I loved the thing as just a terminal on the go, if I had ever repaired the 3G modem it would have been literally perfect. Sadly the hardware is miserably old now and nobody has many anything like a replacement with a keyboard that doesn’t have its own stress injuries named after it.
- cylinder714 4y agoI saw those at the Sony store at the Metreon in San Francisco. I'm glad it worked well, I couldn't justify the purchase but loved the concept.
- defrost 4y agoI've seen good hardware level network engineers using small form factor portables as isolated "known setup" units for running packet filters, malware scans, diagnostic scripts etc against racked units in situ.
- procarch2019 4y agoI was troubleshooting a very irregular network interruption between two industrial controllers (AB PLC and a DCS). For those who do not work in industrial automation communication between assets is essential and some disruptions can be quite costly depending on the industry/product being made. That can be true of even relatively minimal disruptions. I loaded up an RPi with arch, popped a thumb drive on there and created some startup scripts. Once the RPi booted up it just performed a rolling packet monitor. Once I was alerted about a disruption I went and grabbed the thumb drive. I found a Modbus TCP driver bug. What’s even better is I ended up ‘packaging’ it in an enclosure and was able to utilize it in a lot of scenarios. I’ve been using it over the past 2 years. Edit: in the industrial world equipment like this is not in racks/server rooms. They are usually located in panels that have no external networking (security). When I ‘grabbed’ that means traveling to the site and literally taking the drive.
- defrost 4y ago> Edit: in the industrial world equipment like this is not in racks/server rooms. A rack by any other name . . . :-) TBH I was thinking of not just the trad. IT server room racks but also of cramped radio comms "cupboards" by towers and of production circuit | industrial control access panels / locations in both indoor "warehouse" production and outdoor mineral processing circuits .. Always handy to have a small known general purpose computer with ports, scripts, utilities, etc when you're tracking down the weird bug of the day.
- procarch2019 4y agoI’ve been meaning to get a flipper zero, but I would love to see that device with a standard gig Ethernet port. The flexibility would be amazing. PoE for bonus points. However, for ultimate utility I think the next iteration of my packet scraper will be a dual NIC’d SBC so I don’t have to worry about hubs or ‘managed’ switches with port mirroring.
- guessbest 4y agoWhat would you consider to be a MVPC (Minimum Viable Pocket Computer)?
- em-bee 4y agoa keyboard large enough to type on it with two hands (even if not using all 10 fingers) and a screen no larger than the keyboard. (no touchpad. it takes up way to much space for little gain), 4-8GB of ram and not to much diskpace. (lot's of diskspace takes more effort to back up)
- kragen 4y agoIf the keyboard on this is 7 "inches" wide, that's 14.8 mm per key. I think 14 mm wide would be enough, so this is probably wide enough to type on with two hands. But by the same token, it's probably too big to fit comfortably in most pockets.
- em-bee 4y agothe GPD pocket is 6.5 inch wide, with 16mm per key. and it does fit into some of my pants pockets. but that's actually not a criteria for me. i rather carry it in a shoulder bag or backpack anyways.
- 2III7 4y agoA 6.5+" android smartphone with an external keyboard. My Note 10 Plus does everything I need on the go.
- kragen 4y agoThe picture makes it look like it has a keyboard, a screen, and a hinge to support putting it down and typing on it. My imagined use of such a device is something like this. I board the bus and there's, fortunately, a seat. I sit down, but a full-sized laptop wouldn't fit between my lap and the seat in front of me. I pull out the computer and finish up typing my notes about electrostatically-driven hydrogen–boron fusion, perhaps switching back and forth between Emacs and Jupyter as I do some calculations that go slightly beyond the back of the envelope. Then I switch to an OpenStreetMap viewer to confirm where to transfer to a different bus (though the Pocket Reform evidently doesn't have built-in GPS, I can read a map), and check my address book to make sure I know the address where I'm going. Because the disk is encrypted with a strong passphrase, I know that my address book won't fall into the wrong hands even if the computer gets stolen, unless the thieves have video of me entering the passphrase. I'm arriving early, so when I get off the bus at the transfer point, I stop at a café, sit down at a table inside (out of reach of motorcycle thieves), buy a cappuccino, and bang out a couple of pages of a story I've been thinking about. Probably a first draft I'll totally rewrite, but I have to get through the first draft before I can write something worth reading. For background information for the story, I refer to the copy of Wikipedia in the computer's local copy, using Kiwix. Then a cool idea about cellular automata occurs to me, so I try it out in JS using Emacs and Firefox, then commit it to Git. I can't remember how to draw circles on a <canvas> so I consult a locally stored snapshot of MDN using Zeal. (If that had failed, I'd've used a locally stored snapshot of Stack Overflow using Kiwix.) I pay for my coffee, stick the computer back in my pocket, and continue on to my landlord's house, where I pay him the rent. Then I take another bus to the university; on the bus I use the computer to review the textbook chapter the professor will be teaching today. The desks in the classroom are too small for a full-sized laptop, but the computer fits on one of them neatly. I use it to compute eigenvalues for some of the matrices the professor writes on the board in order to test a hunch I have about them. After class, I'm chatting with another student, and they mention they're interested in learning assembly language. I pull out the computer and open up a web server I wrote in assembly a few years ago; it's small enough that I can scroll through the code in Emacs while holding it in one hand, so we don't need to sit down. On the bus home I use it as a music player, playing through my headphones. At home I charge it and connect to the Wi-Fi in my house and do an incremental backup of the machine to my home server, which is a Raspberry Pi Zero with a USB disk plugged into it. That way, if the Pocket Reform does get stolen, I can restore the full system state onto a new one. The next morning I see that my web server has a problem. I suspect that disabling Markdown on comments will solve the problem, but I want to make sure they don't look too broken before I push the config live. So I test the config change in a "staging server" that's really just a QEMU virtual machine running on the Pocket Reform. It turns out that it doesn't fix the problem. Once I figure out what does, and test it in QEMU, I push the config change live. (I'm testing in QEMU instead of Docker because the server is an amd64 box.) Now I want to go visit a sort of Fab Lab that a friend of mine is setting up in the suburbs. So I consult the bus routes on the computer, stick it in my pocket, and go outside to wait for the bus. Once I'm on the bus, I open up OpenSCAD to put the finishing touches on a mechanical-computing lookup table design I'll try to 3-D print at my destination. It looks wrong, so I run git diff, which shows me that I have a forgotten uncommitted change from six months ago that is fucking it up. git checkout multlut.scad solves the problem, and by the time I get off the bus I have an STL file on my MicroSD card ready for him to slice. While I'm there, I show him a Xyce simulation of a power supply circuit I've been working on, and he shows me that my circuit is too sensitive to noise in a way I hadn't thought to simulate. At night I have a date. We end up talking about oral sex technique, and I mention an instructional video I'd seen that showed me some interesting techniques; later at home I show the relevant part of the video. Throughout all this I never transmitted an IMEI to a cellphone network, and I only ever transmitted a randomized Wi-Fi MAC address, and that only when I was at home. I never sent my data to a data center in the United States, China, or South Korea. I never had to overcome artificial obstacles to installing my own software — or hardware. I was never at risk of not being able to install OpenSCAD because it had been removed from the app store because it hadn't been updated in three years. I never had to deal with any malware, spyware, adware, or antifeatures. None of my files were ever matched against a secret government blacklist of forbidden files. The page numbers I looked at in my textbook were never transmitted to Seattle. I never had to do a CAPTCHA to keep my computations from being aborted. No advertisements interrupted the oral sex video, and because it is stored locally, there's no risk that it will have been deleted from the server because of a DMCA notification. Still, I think it would be better with a camera (with an obvious hardware power switch which activates a camera app when it's turned on) and GPS.
- em-bee 4y agowhen traveling i want something small and portable that does not get in the way, especially when backpacking. sure, you could argue that i should leave electronic devices at home and unhook from this dependency to be connected, but that would remove the ability to back up my photos, or write a diary too. there is a case for the responsible use of electronic devices outdoors. and for that i like that device to be as small as is practically useful. a phone is to small because a touchscreen is just not good for typing. it would take me longer, so i would actually spend more time on the device than otherwise. my first was the transmeta based sony picturebook. since then i have had various other devices of similar size. the largest was probably the OLPC XO. the small but sturdy form means that they pack easily. i just toss it in the bag, not worrying much. with any larger laptop the problem is either weight, or it's so thin that i fear it could break if i don't protect it from things that might push against it. the small form factor helps to reduce the amount of time i like to spend in front of it. so i really just use it for things i need to do when not at home or in the office. the downside is that these devices are actually rather expensive, but for me they were what enabled me to be a digital nomad for a several years.
- NonNefarious 4y agoThat's what I'd imagine too, but thinking it through... the keyboard on this thing is super lame. The lack of a Delete key alone would piss me off if trying to do any real writing. I don't see a "travel" use case that couldn't be served by a MacBook Air (with the Karabiner utility to fix ITS insufferable lack of a Delete key). To me this thing is for very limited technical scenarios, for example as a video signal generator or some kind of analysis or testing device to be used in the field. It might be pretty cool for something like that. Or for mobile hacking.
- vidarh 4y agoThe Macbook Air doesn't fit in my jacket pocket. This thing would, even that thick.
- NonNefarious 4y ago
- pjmlp 4y agoI remember looking forward to getting a Pandora[0], eventually I gave up on what are gimmick devices, most of them only sell a couple of hundreds, are yet another form factor to run MAME, and are gone afterwards just like several 8 and 16 bit devices that hardly anyone remembers. [0] - https://openpandora.org/ https://openpandora.org/
- RockRobotRock 4y agoI agonized over getting one of these when I was a kid. I was completely in love with the idea of having a real PC in my pocket. Now as an adult it just seems silly. of course i never would have expected to be able to do so much with just a phone or tablet
- selfhoster11 4y agoPandora's replacement, Pyra, is Pretty Bloody Expensive (TM), starting at EUR 550 and going up to EUR 750. I think it's a cool device, but it's definitely not worth that much.
- Grumbledour 4y agoEspecially now. When the original pandora came out, the market was different and even after the years it was delayed it was still a great machine for emulation. But now, cheap and semi-open emulation devices exist in the dozens and paying up to 10 times as much just to get linux and a keyboard is not that appealing to many people. If they could do it for maybe <300, I think there would certainly be people considering it, but at that price (and of course the fact that it seems to never get finished) I am not sure they can rally a great community again like they could with the original device. A community wanting such a device would maybe be better of producing a keyboard/gamepad accessory for existing hardware and hacking free software for same. The rockchip based platforms seem like a good target for example.
- RalfWausE 4y agoI have an ancient Atari Portfolio in daily use and because its the same form factor perhaps i can contribute my 2 eurocents: As others already put it, the form factor is great for working on public transportation. No need to somehow wriggle out your laptop but simply slide this mini-laptop from your bag and start working. A small keyboard is something one needs to get accustomed to, but after years now i can sincerely say that i type nearly as fast on the Portfolio as on a regular sized keyboard... and i would assume, that this new computer would have a much better keyboard than the old Portfolio. Ok, now on the topic "what to do with this device": I mainly use the Portfolio for notes during meetings, hacking together a few figures in the spreadsheet app (something that is just plain uggly on an smartphone) and as a knowledge database for my daily work (e.g. MAC-adresses and so on). One thing i have not found in any modern computer is the battery-liftime of the Folio: Nearly a month on three AAAs!
- SamBam 4y agoI love that the comparisons with laptops is that you have to "somehow wriggle" your laptop out of a bag, but a Portfolio can "slide" out of your bag. My laptop slides just fine out of my bag.
- starside 4y agoI wish they made a 17inch open source laptop, even if it was slow. I don't think I could use that thing.
- jogu 4y agoNot 17 inches but their first project was a laptop: https://mntre.com/media/reform_md/2020-05-08-the-much-more-personal-computer.html https://mntre.com/media/reform_md/2020-05-08-the-much-more-p...
- betwixthewires 4y agoMNT makes some pretty cool devices. I follow them pretty closely. This pocket reform is in the R&D stage, the photo in the article is a preliminary render. They're expensive though. The current reform laptop is fantastic but its a thousand dollars thereabouts. The pocket reform will probably be close to that in price, at the very least not comparable in price for the specs, but with open hardware. If that's worth it to you. The good thing I'd they're open hardware, you can download all schematics and fabricate them yourself if you want to. @mntmn@mastodon.social for those of you that want updates from the horse's mouth.
- seba_dos1 4y ago> The good thing I'd they're open hardware, you can download all schematics and fabricate them yourself if you want to. That's true, but since you mention the price, it will cost you much more than simply buying one.
- tjoff 4y agoThat seems quite cheap to me. It could never be about price for specs.
- lambdafourtwo 4y agoThis is cool but phones have fit in my pocket for years. It's all about the form factor if you want a PC. I'm waiting for the PC that's the size of a thumb drive that you just put into any hdmi port. All peripherals connect over bluetooth, and power will have to come from the hdmi port.
- green_on_black 4y ago... an intel compute stick?
- lambdafourtwo 4y agoWhat? This exists? Does it get all power from hdmi?
- happymellon 4y agoNo, they normally require a usb power hooked up.
- 4ggr0 4y agoA small Powerbank could help in that case, if no power socket is available. But generally power sockets aren't far away from HDMI ports, at least in my experience.
- charcircuit 4y ago>I'm waiting for the PC that's the size of a thumb drive that you just put into any hdmi port. Google intel compute stick for one that already exists.
- michaelmrose 4y agoThis exists but is a lot of money for a bad computer. By comparison an intel NUC can actually be a decent computer at 4.6 x 4.41 x 2.01 inches. Why would you actually want this?
- rootw0rm 4y agoFond memories of my Nokia N900, still have it somewhere
- smasher164 4y agoThis is cool, but a 5 hour battery life is kind of a dealbreaker for a device I would be very mobile with. The 11 inch macbook air used to get over 11 hours, and netbooks used to get like at least 4 hours.
- kragen 4y agoCan you put a bigger battery into it?
- vidarh 4y agoEven if you can't, it has 8000mAh total battery capacity there are plenty of 30,000mAh+ battery packs on Amazon. If you can really get 5 hours out of 8000mAh, relying on a battery pack for the instances where you expect there's a chance of spending 5 hours using it somewhere without a charger seems reasonable...
- kragen 4y agoMost of those "30,000 mAh" battery packs on Amazon are actually 8000 mAh, as you can compute by dividing their volume by a trustworthy source of information about lithium-ion battery energy density like https://lygte-info.dk/review/batteries2012/Sanyo%20NCR20700B%204000mAh%20%28Red%29%20UK.html https://lygte-info.dk/review/batteries2012/Sanyo%20NCR20700B.... That aside, in a lot of the situations where I'd like to use a portable computer, it would be very inconvenient, and sometimes dangerous, to have it cabled to an external battery pack.
- vidarh 4y agoThe largest I have is currently is ~20,000 or so, and the weight is in well in line (~450g) and capacity seems to match well with what it's meant to be. One of the 30,000 mAh ones that shows up for me on Amazon even has a picture of it on scales with a big "Note: Bulky and a bit heavy" and showing a weight of 659g for the pack compared to 61.2g for the 4000mAh cells shown on the site you link. I don't doubt there are fakes out there, but so far I've not run into any. But that's besides the point, really which is that you if it works for you - and it sounds like it doesn't for you (but it does for me) - then battery backs solves the capacity issue. Obviously if you can't or won't use battery packs then it won't. For me battery packs is very much preferable to having the device itself be bigger and heavier, because it means I can adjust the bulk I carry with me depending on where I'm going.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- faeriechangling 4y agoHere's a page detailing what the PC actually does. Notably it does have an ethernet jack which I couldn't tell from the pictures which is important given people who plug laptops into racks are going to be among the only people who will buy these. https://mntre.com/media/reform_md/2022-06-20-introducing-mnt-pocket-reform.html https://mntre.com/media/reform_md/2022-06-20-introducing-mnt... This computer has so many memes rolled into into one it's ridiculous, ortholinear, trackball, ultra-modular, FOSS, 7" clamshell.
- napkin 4y agoI don't mean to completely discredit your sentiment. However, I'm making this comment on an MNT Reform. It has served wonderfully as my only laptop for the last year. I'd love to know about equally successful laptops that actually shipped, combining the same set of ideals that were important to me: Open hardware (to a further extent than something like Framework) & tough build quality.
- mintplant 4y agoCan you type with your thumbs while holding the device, or is this the kind of mini-laptop that you have to set down on a table or your lap to type on?
- happymellon 4y agoThe screen is 7 inch, and it has a chunky bezel. I would imagine that you could hold this in your hands and type, but those squared edges and thick body might be uncomfortable.
- lukevp 4y agoReminds me of the OpenPandora, which I still have a first batch of! It was really cool to have at the time but I didn’t end up using it all that much.
- unwind 4y agoAre you me? Jeebz how much I waited for and longed for that machine (I have the wooden box, signed by EvilDragon [1] themselves), and then kind of forgot it in a wardrobe. It's weird, that tendency. :/ Edit: Camelized EvilDragon above. [1]: https://pyra-handheld.com/boards/members/evildragon.1/ https://pyra-handheld.com/boards/members/evildragon.1/
- CheeseWong 4y agoSo why not just install UnixOS on the mobile phone?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- submeta 4y agoDoes it run Emacs?
- ngcc_hk 4y agoJust order a pi4 one small but still large linux handheld. Struggle do not want to play Gpd. This might fit the bill. See how it goes.
- ElCheapo 4y agoCan we stop with this absolute fantasy about PCs that "fit in your pocket"? The medium is the message, the form is the functionality. Smartphones have been "pocketable PCs" for more than a decade already, but are dumbed down because their inputs and outputs are limited. You can't type effectively, your screen is small, your battery is limited. Would you want a command line interface on your Smart TV using only a remote? How about XFCE? Or GNOME? No, for a Smart TV we have purposefully made OSs that are limited in functionality such as Kodi, LibreELEC and others specifically because of the type of inputs and outputs needed. I think the only way we could ever get a portable PC experience on the go is by having AR glasses project a full desktop in front of us and let us control it with an imaginary keyboard and touchpad by somehow analyzing our hand movements on a hard surface in front of us. But that's only if we get to a point where said devices are fast and hold a decent battery, which, with current technology, is impossible.
- stonogo 4y agoMy whole family uses essentially a TV with GNOME running on an attached micropc. We use something like this: https://www.amazon.com/Android-Gimibox-Wireless-Keyboard-Projector/dp/B07WJGSXT8/ https://www.amazon.com/Android-Gimibox-Wireless-Keyboard-Pro... Works like a Wiimote. We don't have to limit functionality, we just launch a web browser and have the streaming services on the bookmark toolbar. None of our visitors have ever had problems operating this system, even ones who have never heard of linux or GNOME or Wiimotes. You just flip the remote over to type text into the search box. When the keyboard side is "up," the motion pointer and the "bottom side" is disabled. Flip the remote and the keyboard is disabled and the motion control resumes. Intuitive as hell, works great. My point is that minor adaptations can lead to surprisingly pleasant functionality. Past failures are not reasons to stop trying new things; they're reasons to try other new things.
- ElCheapo 4y agoYour set up works because you tailored both the hardware and the software to make up for the shortcomings of the devices. Normally a TV remote doesn't have a full fledged keyboard attached to it, so many applications become borderline unusable. What you did is enhance the inputs of your device and this opened up many more possibilities. You also tweaked the software from its ootb configuration to make operations smoother. None of these devices attempt doing something similar. They offer less options than normal computers and their desktop is left unchanged. Lastly, what you wrote actually proves my point. You are not using your linux system to do everything a computer does. Your set of functionalities is limited to media consumption and as such you just had to find a workaround for your use case. Could you browse (or even write) your emails on your TV? Sure, but you'd have to use a heavily customized UI and UX if you don't want people to squint their eyes and take ages to navigate everything. And who's going to write such a program? And what about all the other applications that we expect a complete system to have such as a general purpose web browser, a video player, a file browser, etc.? My whole point is that these "pocketable PCs" might be great for a subset of problems, but they have to be tailored for them. They are terrible general computing devices.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI hate those square-grid-style keyboards. Not sure what they're called but I've had one before in a foldable keyboard. It always felt wrong. I know the current layout was built for mechanical reasons so that typewriter rods wouldn't overlap. But 40 years of muscle memory is not something I want to give up :)
- techdragon 4y agoThe layout is called "Ortholinear", it can be a pain but personally I find handy for lots of things where you don't have that muscle memory like keypads and other accessory input devices. Its frustrating how hard it is to find inexpensive keyboards using the layout, its uncommon so its understandable they cost more. Lately its been a bit of a niche in the customised mechanical keyboard market.
- meltedcapacitor 4y agoNormal staggered layout also matches that the operator's hands are at an angle to the keyboard in a normal position. It's an ergonomic version of the ortholinear layout lol. (Maybe that's less relevant on a tiny device?)
- GekkePrutser 4y agoOh ok I thought it was staggered because the typewriter rods had to go side by side. I don't think Ortholinear is bad as such.. It's just that I don't want to learn a new layout. But on a tiny device it is less relevant, true. Because muscle memory and touch typing doesn't really play a role there.
- tromp 4y agoWhat stops them from reducing the huge bezels and fitting an 8" or even 9" display in there? Is it just that 7" displays are far more common and thus cheaper?
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI think it's because this form factor can be 3D printed; smaller bezels and you need more specialist design and materials that can't easily be reproduced and need to be built in minimum size batches in factories.
- stonogo 4y agoMNT's production runs are not big enough to drive novel display formats. They use off-the-shelf displays. Their other laptop, the Reform, has a list of about four models of LCD that will work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _trampeltier 4y agoReally cool. I have a very light 13" notebook now, but I often think he is to large and also he does bend quite a bit all the time in a full bag. It's sad nobody does something like HP Elite X3 Lap Dock. I really would one, but when it came out Windows Mobile was already shut down, so .. The idea is great, all processing power and storage in the phone, the Lap Dock is just a keyboard and a display, wireless connected. https://www.windowscentral.com/hands-hp-elite-x3-lap-dock https://www.windowscentral.com/hands-hp-elite-x3-lap-dock
- goosedragons 4y agoThere is the nexdock. Doesn't support Miracast but you can use it with Samsung Dex or some other thing.
- _trampeltier 4y agoThat's no contest. It has a wired connection, so no. It need to be small, simple, light and no cable.
- fallous 4y agoIt looks like they've reinvented the Gateway 2000 Handbook.
- Animats 4y agoA current generation cheap subnotebook would be useful, for when you want a complete system, not a Raspberry Pi with wires all over the place. If it actually existed and didn't cost too much, it would be interesting. If it's 3 years out and costs $2500, forget it.
- ezconnect 4y agoI tried this form factor around 2011 during the netbook craze. It's pretty unusable. It was only convenient for Skype call when skype was still the go to video call application. Writing programs on it is unbearable. I am not sure about writers, maybe it's usable for them.
- goombacloud 4y agoLove this modularity of swapping the compute modules!
- Apocryphon 4y agoJust get a Gemini PDA or another retro-smartphone device from Planet Computers.
- thanatos519 4y agoThe Gemini is amazing except for the bit where I am stuck at Debian Stretch using libhybris for the hardware because of all the Android proprietary binary blobs. It's super awesome, and OpenGL ES works great, but it's not following me into the future. My Sony VGN-P720D was similar: amazing hardware with great Linux support out of the box, and ... the same Linux support 5 years later, because the blobs I got the month after I bought it were the last blobs they ever released.
- pabs3 4y agoWhich blobs does it need? The Panfrost work means that ARM Mali GPUs should be supported in mainline Linux/mesa these days. Looks like mainline Linux has Mediatek MT6797 support (but not Gemini support) and mainline mesa Panfrost supports Mali-T880. So potentially doable.
- int_19h 4y agoI own a Cosmo. The keyboard is great. The software is atrocious, and Linux support can be best described as "it exists", last I tried it. From what I heard, Linux on Gemini is even worse, and there are no expectations for things to improve there. On top of it, heavy users have discovered that the build quality isn't great, either - lots of complaints about broken screen cables etc.
- protoman3000 4y agoWhen will I finally live a life where my work iPhone is plugged into a USB4 dock with mouse, display and keyboard and it makes my whole work desktop? M2 is already here, why can't we do this?
- sneak 4y agoHeat dissipation mostly, phones aren’t designed to shed wall powered thermals. You can do this today with an iPad Pro with keyboard cover. Also, pretty much nobody wants this. Most people who use work computers have them provided by the workplace. The workplace does not want the employee phones running the call center apps with customer data, etc. I for one do not want any work data physically present on any personally-owned device.
- JBiserkov 4y ago> Heat dissipation mostly In the dock the phone is sandwiched between 2 cooling fans?
- dijit 4y agoI hear you, but ubiquitous "phone booths" where you can have a quiet call or type up an email with a physical keyboard and large screen would be amazing. Don't let the decline of the telephone system fool you, when phones booths were widely used they were not disgusting toilets that you found in the late 90s-early-00s.
- sneak 4y agoI don’t want to type secrets on a keyboard I don’t own, and I don’t want to display secrets on a display I don’t own. YMMV. I would assume any public keyboard is basically the password equivalent of an ATM skimmer.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoYou could do this on a work provided phone, so the data could be managed the same way they do on a PC. Also, BYOD is still a thing, so there's that. Regarding heat dissipation, you have a point. But I think it depends on the use case, which is the reason why we also have laptops going from paper-thin under-powered models all the way to models requiring a forklift to move around. I think many "office jobs" could be done within the dissipation capabilities of a smartphone. Most of my days are spent answering emails and typing away in a terminal over SSH. My geriatric iPhone 7 could probably handle that without issue.
- encryptluks2 4y agoGod what I would do for a modern, Pixel-based Sidekick phone with the flip around Sidekick 3 design.
- est 4y agoThere are many 7″ or 8″ x86 pocket computers without brands sold in China for about $200, with qwerty keyboards touch screen and everything.
- sien 4y agoThey can be bought on Amazon too. Tibuta Masterpad W100 8.9 inch Unboxing and review : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6RxARPBNZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6RxARPBNZk on Amazon for $US 150 https://www.amazon.com/Tibuta-Masterpad-Computer-1536%C3%972048-Keyboard/dp/B09LS6Y2KT/ https://www.amazon.com/Tibuta-Masterpad-Computer-1536%C3%972...
- uwagar 4y agooh the semicolon not on the same like as jkl is a no-no for me as a programmer.
- itintheory 4y agoHow's the linux support? So many of these bargain laptops are listed as Windows devices. I still remember the days of the 'winmodems' so trusting that these devices can run linux well is a tough sell.
- itintheory 4y agoI've definitely browsed AliExpress in this category many times, but I expect the quality of these devices leaves something to be desired. And I say this as someone who pre-orderd the Popcorn PocketPC, and considering buying a Pinephone Pro with keyboard case.
- akerr 4y agoLooks a lot like the original EeePC. I used one for a couple of years but there was no doubt it was cramped. I still have it and it works. My N900 was fun but didn’t last quite as long before a bit of flex killed the wireless radios. I replaced it with an iPhone 4S and haven’t looked back: I still use open source software every day but running on, or accessed by, (excellent) Apple hardware (the M1 MacBook Air and iPhone 13 mini are the best computers I’ve ever had).
- gitowiec 4y agoI also have Eee netbook. It's so old that it's keyboard stopped working. I bought another keyboard from the same model but changing it didn't help. What do you mean with "flex killed"? Could the same happen to keyboard controller on my piece? Is it possible to fix it with simple soldering new solder? Also I would like to buy this OP mini laptop for my six year daughter... I wonder when it will be ready for production... She might be 8 then. Maybe better Raspberry Pi 400 (but it needs external screen and that is a downturn)? What do you think?
- jakuboboza 4y agoSteam Deck is perfectly fine mini PC that is reasonably portable it is also a decent console. If You will but 20-30 USD dock that has more than 1 output you can plug power, monitor and mouse/keyboard combo. You can go with portable mouse/keyboard and dock/usb-c-hdmi cable to any place and plug it into a hotel TV and be setup on your portable linux machine that can also...game :)
- vladvasiliu 4y agoCould it handle one of those one-wire-to-rule-them-all USB-C docks? I was contemplating this for my gaming needs so I could retire my big-ass desktop. But since I only play at home, and already have the desktop, I figured I wouldn't bother. But I hadn't thought of this use case, so if it could handle it, it would be a game-changer.
- capableweb 4y agoIt does. I got the USB-C dock/hub for PinePhone when I bought the phone, and it works perfectly well for Steam Deck as well. It cost something like $30 and I'm sure it works with other docks/hubs as well, in addition to the official one that will come soon according to Valve.
- jakuboboza 4y agoi have "reinston" dock that is more less noname usb-c to 2 x USB, 2 x USB-c and sd/tf card reader + ofc HDMI plug. So I'm kinda just plugging everything in and surprise it works. My dock is more less a "no name" picked in store to try it out. Also it has option to stream games rendered from your PC so you can play titles like CP2077 on steam deck rendered from your desktop if you feels so.
- tl 4y agoCan it? Yes. Is it perfect? No. Is it (on average) good? YMMV. Things to be weary of: 1. Valve took the same tradeoff Nintendo took with a Switch. As a result, driving higher res displays (4k) works until it fails, badly. The increased processor / memory strain finds lots crashing edge cases. 2. Dock / un-dock has the standard set of headaches, the most annoying which is random pieces of software fixating on hardware that no longer exists when you un-dock (resolution changes, keyboard vs. on-screen, fallback to trackpads from missing mouse, ghost ethernet connections, sound headaches). This is endemic on the games side; random game + its proton shim + SteamOS doesn't like inputs changing. You will occasionally need a full reboot to fix issues. 3. It's a Linux. Torvalds is right then Valve is the best hope of "Linux on the Desktop" but the current frankensystem isn't there yet, and using any ports (or bluetooth) will expose you to a lack of friendliness not found on consoles or even (eww) Windows.
- jdhdosvxjd 4y agothe problem, as with everything, is marketing. everyone here missed the blackberry priv and key2 (not key2-le subversion). they were android flagships with same cpu/memory as the samsung du jour. but with a keyboard that doubled as a touchpad. and no bloatware, pure android. the key2 is only now being left out of security upgrades. absolutely nobody here heard of them. coded on them regularly (keyboard only missed a esc and tab, but easily to work around as it had a ctrl key) I'm sadly typing this on a samsung s-large-number. i hate every second of it and only scroll content. marketing is the intelectual class war we don't recognize.
- dhjdsjdshfh 4y agoTyping on a key2. holding until the last day. The only bad thing is that it was such a comercial failure there's zero postmarketOS support. Nokias were locked down more for necessity of the low hardware. Android and ios are locked down for no reason other than greed. there's zero defensible reason for the smartphone of today to not be an open PC that you can install your opensource OS. and if you utter something like security i would like to ask that you don't interact with me. thank you.
- kratom_sandwich 4y agoLet me add this to my list - Has any of these made it ever into the hands of customers? I believe the only device that actually came out is the Cosmo Communicator (https://www.www3.planetcom.co.uk/cosmo-communicator https://www.www3.planetcom.co.uk/cosmo-communicator) There's also Lisperati1000 - https://www.reddit.com/r/cyberDeck/comments/lbu4di/my_shiny_new_lisperati1000_lisp_programming/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cyberDeck/comments/lbu4di/my_shiny_... Devterm - https://www.clockworkpi.com/devterm https://www.clockworkpi.com/devterm Popcorn Pocket - https://pocket.popcorncomputer.com/ https://pocket.popcorncomputer.com/ Teenyserv - https://expanscape.com/teenyserv/the-teenyserv-prototypes/ https://expanscape.com/teenyserv/the-teenyserv-prototypes/
- heliostatic 4y agoI've got a Devterm, so it has shipped to at least some folks. Took about a year?
- kop316 4y agoWhile this device has yet to be released, their full size laptop, the MNT Reform, is available: https://www.crowdsupply.com/mnt https://www.crowdsupply.com/mnt Personally, the fact that they have released a HW device already gives me a lot more confidence that this will succeed.
- soapdog 4y agoThey larger laptop, MNT Reform, has been shipping for a while. Some friends of mine have it and I've met Lukas and played with a prototype at Fosdem long time ago. It is a real thing and it is a beauty. I'm saving for one.
- Kajayacht 4y agoThere's the OpenPandora (https://www.openpandora.org/ https://www.openpandora.org/) that did make it into hands of customers. If you look around Youtube and such, everyone seemed highly satisfied with it, but as a owner myself, it kinda sucked. By the time it came out, it was underpowered, it never was able to run any decent web browser at an acceptable level. It's focus was gaming and emulation, but even then it wasn't any better than a modded PSP (I would say in terms of software, it was worse). My Pandora had numerous manufacturing defects and the way to resolve it was "post in the user forums" where people would reply "Don't worry about it, it's a purely open-sourced handheld! You could just 3D print a new L button!" And what pissed me off to no end, people would overclock the CPU over 40% to get stuff to run at acceptable speeds, and then in the same breath say that "it's amazing, 10 hour battery!" Not if you overclock the thing. I still get excited when I see these new ultra-portable computers, but then I remember the Pandora and quickly tell myself not to waste my money.
- smallerfish 4y agoIf it were to ship, the mobile data option is great - it could feasibly replace a phone. I've been running my phone with a data plan only, taking calls over voip, for the past 18 months, which has been working fine.
- armitron 4y agoI'll choose my MacBook Air over this every single time. I don't see anything here that doesn't fall under "gimmick".
- wyem 4y agoLooking cute. Wondering how it will be useful though
- salmo 4y agoI keep looking at similar devices. What I really want is a small lap top machine (but not necessarily a clamshell laptop) that I can keep by my couch. My goal is to be able to write software when an idea pops in my head or ssh into my home gear. I just want an xterm w/ vim and a browser to look up docs. I have a old 2012 HP Elite (?) laptop with a permanent powercord (battery died long ago) for this now, but it’s massive and overkill. Out of my nerdiness, I’d like non-intel, but not required. Just something that can run Debian or Arch. I’d love FreeBSD, but never had a good portable experience with it. Has anyone used a device this way and enjoyed it? I guess I’m weird that I want small and ergonomic, but not really “portable” in the traditional sense.
- bittercynic 4y agoAn older xps-13 would be good. Available for under $200. Debian and Arch both install easily and work very well on it, with the exception that you might need to replace the wifi card. With a little tuning you can easily get over 12 hours battery life. The battery is easy to replace. Ex: https://www.ebay.com/itm/295220146891 https://www.ebay.com/itm/295220146891
- cylinder714 4y agoI think somewhere on the Pocket Reform site they describe it as a "sofa PC," more comfortable to use than a regular laptop, more capable than an Android phone running Termux. I had an Averatec N1200, the smallest, lightest netbook made, and it ran OpenBSD without difficulty, so I'd recommend that over FreeBSD. I eventually gave it away because the Atom processor and two gigabytes of RAM and slow SSD became intolerably slow. The keyboard was also very cramped, so while I still LOVE the idea of tiny PCs and netbooks, I'm not sure they can ever be comfortable enough to use.
- uwagar 4y agoi got ben nanonote (fully open source hardware) way back in 2010 or something.
- possiblydrunk 4y agoEarly 2000's (2002?) there was a pocket PDA device that ran linux and had a workable keyboard - the Sharp Zaurus SL-5000D (developer edition). 32 Mb RAM! Had a JVM installed. Got mine at Java One with a Linksys 802.11b Network Card. Fun (at the time) to boot up linux and SSH into my servers. Processor: StrongARM (206 MHz 32-bit SA-1110) Operating System: Linux 2.4 (Embedix) Memory: 32 MB SDRAM, 16 MB Flash ROM, Display: 3.5in 240 x 320 pixel, Color Reflective TFT LCD, 16 bits (65,536 colors) Power: Removable, rechargeable 3.7V Lithium-Ion battery pack, Built-in 3.0V back-up battery, 5.0V AC adapter Communications: USB Docking Station, IrDA infrared port Expansion slot: One CompactFlash Type I / Type II slot, One Secure Digital slot Audio: Stereo headphone jack Size: 2.90 x 5.40 x 0.80in. (74 x 138 x 21mm) Weight: 7.3 oz (206g)
- guestbest 4y agoI had one as well. I even installed gcc on the device. No camera but who cares, right? It didn’t need video conferencing as it could do irc with any number of clients. It even had centerim . It became openzaurus then openembedded and is still alive. Work around to install Wikipedia on an SD card and gutenbrowser make it ver useful except for the 2-3 hour battery life. I think it is because we require heave duty web browsers needing 8gb of ram, we’ll never return to the pda sized computer days
- possiblydrunk 4y agoWow, didn't know it was still alive (in one form or another). I remember getting gcc running and installing busy box. It became something of a challenge to see what you could install and run on this tiny machine.
- ivanjermakov 4y agoWhat are the dimensions? Judging by the image, it is not much shorter than 13" laptop and a lot thicker. Those screen bezels make screen smartphone-sized. What is the purpose of using it? Most X apps won't scale well to that DPI. Can't think of a use-case for it.
- hwbehrens 4y agoAre there any devices that fit the bill of an "anti-laptop"? I despise working on tiny (<27") screens, but I often need to work both from home and from the office. Currently I have a docking station in each location and move a laptop between them. However, I never ever open the laptop or use it on battery power. It seems silly that most of the volume and weight of the device I carry around daily are totally unused, and that most of the tradeoffs it makes are irrelevant to me, but most small desktop machines are either too large or too slow (to meet a price point, presumably?). None that I know of is designed to operate from a single Thunderbolt cable like a docked laptop can. Does such a product exist? I understand that this is a small fraction of a fraction of a use case, and until recently connectivity options weren't really there to support such a device, but I think there is some promise in this idea. The Framework desktop case seems to come the closest so far, but it still doesn't (I think?) address the single-cable connectivity question. There's not too much info about it on the website so I couldn't answer all my questions about it.
- btw0 4y agoMini PC with a portable display is an idea replacement for laptop.
- ozten 4y ago“ChromeBook for your face” VR headsets are coming.
- tristor 4y ago> None that I know of is designed to operate from a single Thunderbolt cable like a docked laptop can. The Mac Mini is basically exactly this, with one exception, which is power. I really wish this existed as well. An M2 Mac Mini that supported being powered over TB with PD, would be perfect for me, because I have multiple work locations that each have monitors that provide 90W of PD power over TB, and I could simply drop it in my bag.
- danbee 4y agoThe Udoo Bolt will happily run entirely off a single USB-C cable. 4K video output, power, and USB.
- MarcScott 4y agoI used to have a VAIO P series laptop - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Vaio_P_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Vaio_P_series It could just about fit in the back pocket of my jeans and had a sim card slot for mobile connectivity, if I remember correctly. It was a really nice little laptop. Not going to be rendering any 3d models on it, but great for basic internet and office work.
- fomine3 4y agoDid it fit on your pocket? There were meme for the PR https://www.engadget.com/2009-01-12-vaio-p-doesnt-have-nothin-on-these-other-awesome-pocket-friend.html https://www.engadget.com/2009-01-12-vaio-p-doesnt-have-nothi...
- dmix 4y agoTheir Amiga graphics card got good reviews: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Cu-LuSB8Ns https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Cu-LuSB8Ns
- account-5 4y agoWhat's the likelihood this will be available outside the US?
- mmargerum 4y agoJesus the pop up ads as you scroll is an automatic host blacklist