5 ms·
> (or Niemann, if concrete evidence against him emerges) This window seems closed though. Carlsen seems to have no evidence. Where else could the evidence come
by nonethewiser 4y ago
> (or Niemann, if concrete evidence against him emerges)
This window seems closed though. Carlsen seems to have no evidence. Where else could the evidence come from? All we have is character attacks. Even if justified, they can't prove that he cheated.
All we know for sure is that Carlsen accused him of cheating with no evidence.
- stouset 4y agoWhat hard evidence—exactly—do you expect Carlsen to be able to produce? Alternatively, imagine anyone in a similar position. What hard evidence can anyone produce in situations such as this? 100% serious question.
- roflyear 4y agoI don't expect him to produce evidence, but I expect him to say more than "I suspect he cheated" If he saw something unusual, like "Hans was messing with his shoe" or "I heard several vibrations coming from Hans during the game" etc.. that would be at least something. It would be something. Magnus has given nothing.
- stouset 4y agoMagnus has produced what he can given the situation and has staked something of extreme personal value—his legendary near-2900 ELO—on it with his move-1 resignation. If he'd heard the guy's damn shoe buzzing he would have insisted on a search.
- roflyear 4y agoBlah. Magnus has given nothing. Could have still insisted he was searched. He didn't. Magnus has anxiety.
- FreakLegion 4y agoFIDE doesn't rate the Champions Chess Tour, but even if it did the format isn't classical, so his quest for 2900 is doubly unaffected.
- stouset 4y agoI appreciate the correction, thank you.
- andrepd 4y agoDoesn't than line of thinking mean that anybody can accuse somebody of cheating when they unexpectedly beat them?
- stouset 4y agoNo, it means that the reality of catching cheaters in chess is fundamentally heuristic if you don't manage to catch them red-handed. This accusation hits many of the heuristic high notes. That doesn't mean he definitively cheated. But to me, with ~15 years of chess under my belt, it does make this accusation credible.
- yesseri 4y agoNiemann have admitted cheating before when playing online, so Carlsen is just not making this up about any random player. There is a history of cheating.
- ddalex 4y agoThere is no smoking gun, but there is a lot of smoke. The ease with which Niemann pulled out of the hand a couple of brilliant moves, without spending too much time thinking about it, on an unusual line, is highly suspicious.
- bnralt 4y agoQuestioning him at the tournament would have at least given Niemann a chance to prove his innocence.
- runarberg 4y agoThat probably would have been even worse of a shit-storm. You think you are rational and will ask good questions, but if you are not a trained journalist, and you haven’t prepared, you will most likely only ask really dumb question that do nothing except cause more drama.
- lupire 4y agoInnocence is never proven, only presumed.
- lmm 4y agoI expect people to hold off the public allegations if they can't prove anything. I could name specific players who I'm pretty sure were cheating in my own game. I've sometimes had a quiet word with a ref and asked them to watch a particular player closely. I've occasionally had a louder word with a ref and asked them to enforce the rules that are in place to make cheating harder. But you can't pull something like this based off of nothing but your own feelings.
- Taek 4y agoI believe you could have an engine look at the historical games of a player and identify the "strength" of each move. How strong (in terms of elo) does a player have to be before they find a certain move? How often do the top players find moves that greatly exceed their own elo? Does Hans find top moves more frequently than his opponents? The challenge with this appoach of course is identifying a players strengths and adjusting for their preparation. Making 20 top engine moves in a row is not odd if both players studied that exact line before the match. What's odd is making 20 top moves in a row on a bizzare line that nobody has ever played before that Magnus specifically prepared because he knew it was unusual (and engine disadvantaged) and unlikely to be in anyone's prep.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoAll this talk of "Carlsen accused him of cheating with no evidence" reminds me of the blowback against some athletes in the 70s and 80s who accused rivals of taking PEDs "with no evidence". Sometimes the evidence of someone doing monstrously better than can be expected by their history is sufficient IMO. I mean, look at this article about swimmer Shirley Babashoff [1], dubbed "Surly Shirley" at the time by the media, for suggesting the East German women were on PEDs in the 70s. Nowadays we look back on those images of the East German women, looking more manly than any dude I've ever seen, and wonder how we considered with a straight face that they weren't on a boatload of drugs. Similarly, it completely baffles me how any sane person can think that Flo Jo wasn't on PEDs in the runup to the 1988 Olympics - her 100m dash record still stands today. I'm not saying Carlsen went about it in the right way, because now Niemann is basically in an indefensible position, but I'm also not willing to quickly dismiss it because Carlsen has "no evidence". 1. https://www.swimmingworldmagazine.com/news/exclusive-shirley-babashoff-breaks-30-year-silence-on-east-germanys-systematic-doping-of-olympians/ https://www.swimmingworldmagazine.com/news/exclusive-shirley...
- pseudo0 4y agoUsain Bolt is another interesting case. Commentators have made a pretty compelling case based on the circumstantial evidence that he was doping, but due to weaknesses in Jamaica's anti-doping program it's likely impossible to prove one way or the other. https://tomnew.medium.com/usain-bolt-lance-armstrong-and-the-duck-test-303b7b891e7e https://tomnew.medium.com/usain-bolt-lance-armstrong-and-the...
- AmericanChopper 4y agoA huge number of (male) athletes across all sports are doping now. Testosterone deficiency is a medical condition, and taking “testosterone replacement therapy” is explicitly allowed by many sports. Even if it’s not allowed, it’s not really possible to robustly test for, because in some forms at least it’s simply increasing the levels of the same hormones that your body is naturally producing. Same goes for human growth hormone. Just take enough to put your levels at a very high, but plausibly natural level and you essentially can’t fail a drug test. It’s only called “testosterone replacement therapy” when it’s prescribed by a doctor btw. Taking exactly the same course of medication in any other circumstances is called “taking steroids”.
- runarberg 4y agoNot quite. There is still a possibility that Niemann will admit cheating. If he actually cheated there may be a time—in years or decades rather then months—that he fills with remorse and admits it (hopefully with a detailed description on how he did it so we can verify). If however he didn’t cheat, we will probably never actually know the truth.
- sva_ 4y agoI don't know much about chess, but it seems like Niemann now has to either maintain his performance in Chess without cheating, or cheat to maintain it if he can't without - in which case he could still be caught.
- John23832 4y agoThat's not true. Both he and Chess.com both say that they have evidence to the extent of Hans' cheating. Both have asked Neimann for the ability to speak freely without threat of libel. Ball is in Han's court.
- kweingar 4y agoThis doesn’t make sense. If they tell the truth, there is no libel, and they don’t need anybody’s permission to speak.
- eyegouging 4y agoApparently this (the idea that telling the truth is necessarily not libelous) is untrue in some jurisdictions? Or perhaps they fear that they are not 100% correct?