10 ms·
Fitbit users will have to sign into Google from 2023
- rvz 4y agoNow you have to thank Google for storing all your personal health data and putting it all behind a Google login.
- elpocko 4y agoThank you, Google. I love you, Google.
- amelius 4y agoLove and hate are emotions that sometimes lie very close together.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoDon't equate money with happiness.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- acheron 4y agoBut it was all right, everything was all right, the struggle was finished. He had won the victory over himself. He loved Big Brother.
- swarnie 4y agoNow? Didn't this advertising company buy fitbit 18 months ago?
- pessimizer 4y agoDemanding audible expressions of appreciation is the most aggressive thing I've heard of in a TOS, but I suppose it was inevitable.
- at_a_remove 4y agoAt least you don't have to do a little dance after drinking a "verification can" of specially-chipped soda.
- throwaway12245 4y agoIs there a fitbit type gadget that let's you USB or bluetooth to a laptop and keep your health data private?
- t_mann 4y agoTurns out time and time again that the most sustainable way to store your personal data (health, financial, notes,...) is in flat files on your harddisk, not some startup's cloud service. Not that that will stop them from collecting, but at least from putting your access behind some walls or disappearing all of a sudden.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoExcept, for the vast majority of people, that is definitely not true. It's actually extremely rare for your average person to get locked out of their Google account (though, of course, it does happen, as chronicled so frequently on HN). It's extremely common for people to lose their hard drive, or have it otherwise damaged by a fall or fire, or just have it crash due to age without a sufficient backup. It order to fix the problems with modern corporate surveillance, we can't keep pretending that storing things in the cloud and using cloud services doesn't have huge benefits. Just telling everyone to only store things in flat files on their local disk just brings up the "old man yells at cloud" meme in my head. What we need are stronger laws. For example, if one company is acquired by another, and that company demands a new login scheme that can link additional data, I think they should need to give you the option of a full refund.
- jjulius 4y agoI agree, but that's one hell of an uphill battle considering the amount of money that would be behind those opposing such laws. Until said laws pass, storing things locally is a valid option for a stopgap despite how cumbersome it might be. Edit: I also have little faith in any legal remedy going far enough. The cat's out of the proverbial bag, too many businesses "depend" on data, and the government certainly enjoys being able to more easily access your data via cloud businesses than having to deal with a different enduser's setup every single time. Not saying we can't make progress, but I'm pessimistic.
- t_mann 4y agoYou're right about the backup situation, but I would still say that even just having your personal data in a flat file backed up with OneDrive - which a lot of users probably have set up without even fully realizing - still beats the app-specific cloud for most purposes (both access- and privacy-wise). Just consider the difference that it makes in the mental model of vendor lock-in. And yes, it may not be that common for people to lose their Google account, but that's really just one failure mode of relying on in-app storage. The provider may decide to suddenly put parts of your data behind a paywall (like Slack just did), or may straight up cease to exist. Even if Microsoft were to do something similar to your OneDrive account, you'd still have your local copy and could change your cloud backup provider with very reasonable effort.
- nabaraz 4y agoI really hope Garmin doesn't get bullied by Apple, and continues to exist. Between Google and Apple, Garmin is a notable competitor, I'd argue Garmin products are superior too.
- y-c-o-m-b 4y agoI want to switch to Garmin because my Fitbit Charge 5 died after 4 months and the replacement they sent me dead after 2 days! I heard Garmin is superior in almost every way, but the only problem is there's countless reports of Garmin having poor sleep tracking; which is a feature I really need with my fitness tracker.
- nabaraz 4y agoI moved from Versa to Fenix, and haven't noticed much difference.
- capableweb 4y agoPoor sleep tracking in what way? I have a Garmin (<$300 one) I mainly got for sleep tracking and haven't noticed any problems with it. It tracks when I go to bed/wake up correctly, and seems me notice nights I sleep less (after drinking alcohol for example) well vs nights I sleep better (done lots of exercise in the day) properly.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> Garmin having poor sleep tracking; which is a feature I really need with my fitness tracker. Needs are required for life. You don't need sleep tracking, you want it.
- ubercow13 4y agoNo, need can be used in various contexts. You could say 'I need to do X in order to meet my personal goal Y.' Or you could say 'I need a product to support Z before I'd consider purchasing it.' GP didn't make it explicit but you can probably assume they were implying one of these contexts, rather than that they would die without that feature.
- kaszanka 4y agoIf you have a supported band (which the Fitbit is not) I highly recommend Gadgetbridge[1], a Free app that respects you, doesn't require online login and never will. [1] https://gadgetbridge.org/ https://gadgetbridge.org/
- 5555624 4y agoIt sounds like time to create a "johndoefitbit@gmail.com" account and use it only for Fitbit.
- sixhobbits 4y agoAnd Google definitely has no tools to link two accounts that are constantly accessed from the same location or IP address so this will definitely provide privacy in spite of using two devices that constantly stream your personal information to Google servers.
- legrande 4y agoAnd risk getting your main account banned for registering multiple Google accounts. Also you will need a whole new phone number for these alternative accounts which can get expensive
- Eleison23 4y agoGoogle's TOS has no objection to users registering multiple Google accounts. I checked this out long ago. In fact, how could they? I currently hold Google Workspaces accounts at my community college and from my employer. In addition to these two, I also have a "main" personal account where I do most of my stuff, including my Android device. Then, I maintain two other separate accounts for volunteer work in various capacities. So I have five accounts in total; in fact I've signed up to Google One and gathered three of them into my "family" group. Google actively encourages people to create as many accounts as we can handle. It's nothing like Facebook, which requires a 1:1 correspondence between humans and personal accounts.
- bob1029 4y agoI use AWS Workmail for this purpose. Every service has its own address and mailbox on my custom domain. No phone numbers or other nonsense required.
- 8organicbits 4y ago
- lnxg33k1 4y agoI bought a Fitbit before it was bought from Google few years ago, and got quite upset with this thing that despite you carefully trying to stay away from buying things that require a meta or Google account, you might end up having to because of acquisitions, so I had an unused Fitbit , fortunately I guess thanks to karma they had a recall for the watch model I had and I got the full money back, but yeah to hell Google, I guess can say that as I don’t even have a Google account
- jsnell 4y agoWhat's the concrete concern here, specifically with regards to migrating the account system? If you're thinking that some mustache-twirling villains are totally lying to customers and regulators about how the data will be used, why do you think using a distinct account system would provide any kind of technical barrier? While if you think that separating the accounts does in fact matter for something, just make a new single-use Google account for just the Fitbit data.
- cush 4y ago"Just" make a new single use Google account. And what, do this for every new product, service and use-case we want to ensure doesn't get joined together? It's so cumbersome to work around today's data-hungry Googlesphere. Google would rather take another decade of yearly $4B fines than build systems that respect our personal information.
- jsnell 4y agoSee, that's exactly what I mean by "concrete". You seem to be saying it's unreasonable to create an account just for the purpose of using a Fitbit. But you've always had to do that. It is literally exactly what a Fitbit account is. For ten years, nobody has thought that it's unreasonable. Like, the only distinction is that now you get to choose whether to create a separate account or reuse the existing one. If you can't actually formulate why the migration of the account system is bad thing, maybe it's actually not?
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoIt is the undisclosed consolidation of information sources that Google holds that scares me. I think most considered Fitbit account a small privacy issue. The Google ecosystem on the other hand is enormous, highly entwined in our lives, extremely intrusive, and information collection & sale is done surreptitiously. I think most, even non technologist feel the negative in this, even if they cannot articulate it.
- 4y ago
- ilikerashers 4y agoFitbit feels a bit like loss leader for a bunch of cloud services already. "Sign up for our premium subscription stuff" is constantly pushed. Meanwhile the charge 5 takes ages to sync just to show metrics and doesn't work offline. It's a cheap tracker that looks good but something is definitely off about the product.
- t_mann 4y agoI once ran a trial comparing two FitBit models (one quite recent at the time) to a medical heart measurement device and manual counting. My conclusion was that FitBit's numbers were pretty much garbage: the manual and medical measurements generally agreed up to 3-4 beats, while the FitBit readings were off by 20 beats and more and fluctuating wildly in a short span of time. Their readings for step numbers might be more accurate, I don't know, but I concluded that the heart rate measurements probably contained more noise than signal.
- cush 4y agoI'm still bitter about Fitbit buying then destroying all of the IP from Pebble. Still the best smart watch ever made.
- sushid 4y agoThat's not quite what happened. Pebble was virtually dead and shopping around for an exit. Fitbit bought Pebble for its IP (i.e. patents) / soft acquihire. No one was going to be making the Pebble 3.
- arcbyte 4y agoAs i recollect it, they had been launching product after product and were in the middle of launching pebble time 2 when they got bought. That's a far cry from "virtually dead"
- sushid 4y agoAgain, that's not quite true. They had barely managed to eke out the Pebble 2 the month prior but had been in distress for quite some time. They had a huge layoff earlier that year as well and were forced to raise a debt funding round sometime that year as well. The market was doing well but the CEO commented about how hard it was for hardware companies to raise funds, especially as hardware companies were getting crushed in the market. The truth is Apple came in and ate everyone lunch. Pebble was effectively dead the moment Apple announced their plans for a smartwatch.
- cush 4y agoIt's exactly what happened. Fitbit bought (true) then destroyed the Pebble IP (true). Whether Pebble was a strong business or not makes no difference. Their tech was incredible and still better than most smart watches on the market today.
- sushid 4y agoPebble's IP was done for. No one wanted to make any more Pebbles including Pebble themself. They were acquihired by Fitbit. It wasn't a case of "we'll continue allowing team X to operate independently bait and switch." At the end of the day there wasn't a robust market for hacker-focused e-ink Android watches.
- voisin 4y agoGoogle did this with Nest, forcing all accounts to move from the Nest app to the Google Home app and change to have a Google email address. Madness.
- cianmm 4y agoI foolishly bought a Nest and three Nest Protects back when Nest were promising to implement HomeKit. Then Google bought them and they just stopped mentioning it. Google continuously doing this means I’ll probably never pay for one of their services.
- nilespotter 4y agoAnyone want to buy a 3 point Nest mesh system I have sitting in a drawer? When Google did this I replaced them with an pfsense router and a couple of UniFi APs.
- legrande 4y agoAnother data-point for the largest data-mining operation ever conducted (Google)
- manishsharan 4y agoIs there an non-cloud ( Desktop based) alternative to Fitbit Premium ? I hate the idea of having such personal and intimate data being accessible to third parties ?
- jxi 4y agoAt least one customer will now never buy a Fitbit again.
- dmitrygr 4y agoFitbit users will become Garmin or Apple users from 2023.
- GnarfGnarf 4y agoI hope Google continues to allow downloading of log files. I wrote an app that charts calories burned (from Fitbit), calories consumed and weight loss (from MyNetDiary dieting app), spO2, sleep, heartbeat, etc.
- xnx 4y agoLonger term, the direction has to be that Fitbit goes away, and -at most- becomes an app that runs on the Google Watch.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lrvick 4y agoI was in charge of data security and privacy at Pebble among other things. I fought hard against data science teams having access to PII. It made me few friends but considering the data could reveal health issues I regarded it as health data even if it technically legally is not at the moment. We were bought by Fitbit which operated with almost complete disdain for any attempt at security or privacy that could slow down operations. Anybody who wanted paintext access to user data seemed to get it without delay. Security and privacy were not among the things that created shareholder value so every issue I discovered was permanently backlogged. It was depressing seeing all the data I fought to hard to protect be absorbed into a machine that would sell it off to the highest bidder, or shrug when it got stolen by a blackhat. I quit 3 months before my golden handcuffs would have kicked in because it felt too unethical to keep working there. Then of course all the data was sold again, this time to Google. No Pebble user ever consented to their health data being sold to Google, but all of this is legal.
- spaceguillotine 4y agoMy Pebble and Time are still missed, charging once a week and the e-ink screen was so damn nice to read
- hobo_mark 4y agoMine still runs a week on one charge, could not find a substitute yet.
- GeneralAntilles 4y agoE-paper, actually, which is a fairly broad umbrella for a lot of reflective LCD displays. E-ink is specifically from E Ink and uses a different display technology (it's what's used in Kindles, etc.). This is probably a lost word-use game, as everybody just says e-ink, but it seems important given the major differences between reflective LCDs and the electrophoretic technology used in ereaders. I had a MetaWatch watch with an e-paper display with silver reflective screen backing and it was, by far, the most comment-generating thing I've ever worn. Still miss it.
- wildrhythms 4y ago
- willjp 4y agoMhm. Anyone trying to buy health insurance? I love the idea of this, I love the convenience of it, but this was always (sadly) going to be a hard pass for me.
- midislack 4y agoThey won't HAVE to, it'll be time to buy a new device by then anyway.
- ls15 4y agoWhat is a more privacy-friendly option to buy in 2022? Are there even privacy-friendly fitness trackers?