5 ms·
States move faster... so fast that a technology company would be constantly chasing 50 different state laws. The Internet is a global entity, and it doesn't st
by jfengel 4y ago
States move faster... so fast that a technology company would be constantly chasing 50 different state laws.
The Internet is a global entity, and it doesn't strike me as being well served by the "laboratory of the states".
Federal legislation is slow, but executive agencies can move faster if they are empowered by legislation to make rules. Congress sets broad principles, and it's not unreasonable that those principles should stay the same for a decade at a time, even in a fast-moving domain like privacy. And while regulatory agencies can be their own pieces of work, it is much easier to deal with one national agency's rules than 50 different ones.
- takeda 4y ago> States move faster... so fast that a technology company would be constantly chasing 50 different state laws. As a person who's data is being sold I would one up it and wish that each county would produce their own regulations. That business is a cancer.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoCounty? I’ll do you one better, locality. Every hamlet the world over with so much as a post office should have their policies.
- 23B1 4y agoI'll do you one better: every individual has total domain over their own data.
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoThat’s Authoritarianism!
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoI appreciate you and your idea.
- seanw444 4y agoAfter seeing how the ATF operates entirely autonomously to nearly eliminate the right to bear arms through increasingly more unnecessarily complex and ridiculous "rules" that make you felon for things that were previously (and should still be) totally legal, I have zero interest in giving executive agencies autonomy to make laws. And it doesn't matter that the rules can be ruled as ineffective by a high court, because it takes ages to get through the whole court process. So in the time that the court took ruling something totally unconstitutional, people's rights are squandered (especially without any democratic consensus to enact it), and the people that enacted and enforced the later-deemed-unconstitutional rulings face zero repercussions. And guess what? They then move on to the next unconstitutional ruling that squanders as many rights as possible for as long as possible.
- klabb3 4y ago> unnecessarily complex and ridiculous "rules" that make you felon for things that were previously (and should still be) totally legal Not going into the US-centric gun debate and assuming that guns are simply tools, isn't it reasonable that gun owners need to monitor the regulations? If you operate heavy machinery or run a chemical lab, I'd expect you to keep a close eye on upcoming legislation and rules. I'd not be surprised if a food truck operator would need to keep track of more rules than gun owners.
- tekknik 4y agoBoth of these examples are enterprises, not something a private citizen does. I would also hesitate to say that you can become a felon overnight with either of these scenarios (remember all of the rights lost, including gun ownership, by being labeled a felon). And a majority of businesses shield themselves such that if they do violate the law it’s the business itself penalized, not the workers. In the case of gun ownership it’s the individual being penalized. To make your example equivalent, imagine if the food truck or some piece of equipment in that truck was suddenly made illegal. And if you’re in possession of it you are now a felon. Yesterday (literally) it was legal and you were not given advanced notice anymore than waking up this morning and receiving notice. If heavy machinery and food industries operated this way there would be much less competition and likely no food trucks at all
- abigail95 4y agoIf fewer jurisdictions = better, then just adopt the GDPR as-is. That seems obviously bad to me, having more jurisdictions to work out what the best laws are seems like a better idea.
- rmatt2000 4y agoI'm somewhat skeptical that giving more power and discretion to federal regulators will result in increasing freedoms for the American people.
- jfengel 4y agoI'm somewhat skeptical that the increasing power of private companies to gather and sell your personal data is increasing freedoms for the American people. So a pragmatic person chooses a solution that maximizes the benefit and mitigates the tradeoffs.