7 ms·
This is amazing. It's truly bizarre that 5.1 surround sound, or HDR, or spatial audio, would be proprietary paid formats -- I mean, what if someone told you the
by crazygringo 4y ago
This is amazing. It's truly bizarre that 5.1 surround sound, or HDR, or spatial audio, would be proprietary paid formats -- I mean, what if someone told you there was a license for stereo audio?
And sure it's in Google's self-interest so that they can bring these technologies to YouTube without paying anyone else. But it benefits everybody, so this is really fantastic news for everyone if it's something that takes off.
- sosborn 4y agoPerhaps of interest: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_patent_394325 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_patent_394325
- Bombthecat 4y agoDolby vision is patented. There is already a free version,hdr+ , which samsung supports. But no one is using it.
- BonoboIO 4y agoWhat is exactly patented in Dolby Vision? There has to be some innovation to be patentable. HDR10 and HDR10+ exist.
- jiggawatts 4y agoDolby Vision is poorly documented but I did find a long PDF explaining how it works. It does provide significant value worthy of patent protection. The main thing they did was develop a nonlinear color space designed so that each “bit” of information provides equal value. This way no bits are wasted, making compression more efficient and have fewer artefacts. The color space is also set up so that the “lightness” channel is accurate and brightness can be rescaled without introducing color shifts. They also came up with a way of encoding the HDR brightness range efficiently so that about 12 bits worth of data fits into 10 bits. The format also allows a mode where there is an 8-bit SDR base stream with a 2-bit HDR extension stream. This allows the same file to be decoded as either HDR or SDR by devices with minimal overhead. Last but not least they work with device manufacturers to make optimal mapping tables that squeeze the enormous HDR range into whatever the device can physically show. This is hard because it has to be done in real time to compensate for maximum brightness limits for different sized patches and to compensate for brightness falloff due to overheating. Early model HDR TVs had to have FPGAs in them to do this fast enough!
- suzumer 4y agoWhile Dolby did design the perceptual quantizer gamme (PQ) [1] that almost every HDR device today uses, they waived patenting it [2] when it was standardized in SMPTE 2084 [3]. Everything that is proprietary about Dolby Vision (everything except PQ gamma) is relatively mundane and just dynamic metadata. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perceptual_quantizer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perceptual_quantizer [2] https://f.hubspotusercontent00.net/hubfs/5253154/Dolby%202084%20Patent%20Statement.pdf https://f.hubspotusercontent00.net/hubfs/5253154/Dolby%20208... [3] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7291452 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7291452
- jiggawatts 4y agoPeople assume that some RGB matrix transform and a nonlinear PQ gamma is all Dolby Vision is. In practice it's an entire ecosystem of certifications, professional calibration of panels, efficient encoding formats, etc... To reproduce the end effect of Dolby Vision you'd have to have a team of people liaising with television manufacturers, and makers of production software like DaVinci Resolve. It's not a trivial task that can be done through open source. It's real work that costs money. We can all hope and wish for open standards, but it's a bit like trying to come up with an open architecture for a railway bridge. It'll still take real work to customise it to any particular valley, the local geography, and the specific requirements. Dolby Vision is similar. The mapping from the full signal range to each specific panel is a complicated thing that requires quite a bit of work to determine.
- suzumer 4y agoYou obviously know more about this than I do, but when I watch a a well encoded Blu-ray that doesn't use Dolby Vision like Planet Earth 2, and I compare that to a dolby vision encoded disc, I fail to see a noticeable difference. And when I rip the RPU of a disc that uses dolby vision and look at some of the data [1], I again don't see enough to warrant this being a proprietary system, especially when we have HDR10+. So Dolby may have teams of calibrators and created certifications, at the end of the day I fail to see why this warrants being proprietary. Please let me know what Dolby Vision does better than HDR10+ or regular HDR, because at the end of the day I'm just a hobbyist and want to learn more about this space. [1] https://pastebin.com/m5NfUTbc https://pastebin.com/m5NfUTbc
- zokier 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BrightSide_Technologies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BrightSide_Technologies HDR10 and all the other stuff came along much much later
- izacus 4y agoAnd you can read in this article why - Dolby aggressively made deals with streaming services to push their technology to profit from royalties on end-user devices.
- dopa42365 4y ago>But no one is using it. Aren't both formats just some meta data on top of the same video file? Netflix etc. serve both, depending on what your device supports. Pretty sure that both blurays and "4k TV" channels use HDR10(+) as well. Not like the viewer has to know or care about it (from what I can tell, they're basically identical anyway).
- 52-6F-62 4y agoThere _was_ a license for stereo audio. See: Blumlein and EMI, Fantasound, etc
- crazygringo 4y agoIt made a lot more sense back in the analog days, when figuring out how to encode and decode stereo audio on an LP was non-trivial. But things like 5.1 audio or HDR or spatial audio aren't that much more than adding a bunch of extra channels/bits to a stream, defining relative power levels, and the signal strength follows a curve, and oh there's some positional metadata. The heavy lifting is done by compression algorithms which deserve to be patented because they do genuinely non-obvious stuff. Just like the way Dolby got digital audio onto a filmstrip was similarly clever. But stuff like 5.1 surround sound... it's just channels, man. In the digital world, it seems like it should be awfully easy to design an open standard.
- layer8 4y agoIt’s not just channels. If you want just channels, you can use 5.1 PCM no problem.
- 52-6F-62 4y ago"Seems like", and the reality are often different. That's some of the ingenious nature of these inventions—they seem like they should be obvious and easy. And yet they aren't. Not at first. It took a heavy amount of investment, organization, and talent to get to the point of stereophonic sound alone.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> It took a heavy amount of investment, organization, and talent to get to the point of stereophonic sound alone. Sure, because that adds a ton of new complexity! Going from 2 to 3+ in a digital format does not add complexity.
- bradstewart 4y ago
- SllX 4y agoThey’re paying to use Dolby’s encoding schemes. It’s not the idea of “stereo audio” that’s patent encumbered, it’s some of the encoding schemes that can output stereo audio (much less so these days, patents are expiring and all of MP3’s have). Same with surround audio and spatial audio and HDR: Dolby has an encoding scheme that works well and gets the desired result, is high quality, usually higher quality than the alternatives, and they market it well. I’ll welcome anyone that wants to enter the space that thinks they can do better, but Dolby is good at what they do, and Google often has massive commitment issues for new projects (although notably, not usually when it comes to codecs). I suspect what will happen is YouTube will develop their own HDR and audio codecs, and it’ll just be used on YouTube and almost nowhere else. That’ll be enough to drive client support, but it’ll be one more HDR format in addition to HDR10+ and Dolby Vision, and it’ll be one more set of audio codecs in addition to like the half dozen to a dozen they already decode, and ultimately this will be to increase the quality of YouTube while minimizing their licensing costs. That’s fine.
- kasabali 4y ago> I suspect what will happen is YouTube will develop their own HDR and audio codecs It is stated in the article they're backing HDR10+. Not sure about the audio.
- SllX 4y agoYeah there’s some supposition in the article so I’m not clear if it’s HDR10+ or an extension of it, just that Google wants to do something to break Dolby’s bank and they’ve got a heist crew with something to prove (i.e. Netflix, Samsung, Meta, et al.) and a placeholder name for the audio stuff (“Immersive Audio Container”). The distinction hardly matters since it’ll just be one more format (or set of formats) for manufacturers to support.
- m0RRSIYB0Zq8MgL 4y agoFor audio they are working on something new called Immersive Audio Container https://aomediacodec.github.io/iac/ https://aomediacodec.github.io/iac/
- 4y ago
- EGreg 4y agoYep. Once again, open standards smashing capitalism's rentseeking proprietary schemes helps a wide array of people around the world including new entrants who would have previously been priced out.
- dimitrios1 4y ago> capitalism's rentseeking proprietary schemes Correction: greedy assholes rentseeking proprietary schemes. There is nothing in capitalism that says you must obtain your money through unethical means.
- js8 4y agoThat's lack of understanding of origins of the term "capitalism". Capitalism is typically characterized by (a) free market for labor and (b) private ownership of means of production. Both of these concepts have been considered unethical. The fact that liberals also consider "rent seeking" unethical doesn't change that.
- dimitrios1 4y ago> Both of these concepts have been considered unethical. Considered unethical by who? I wouldn't classify me disagreeing with those who consider those two concepts as unethical as a "lack of understanding"
- js8 4y agoBy many intellectuals and philosophers, like Karl Marx. How do you know you would disagree with their arguments if you didn't even realize such people exist? That's the "lack of understanding" I am talking about. In fact, there are several different explanations why these are unethical. One (Marx's) comes from labor theory of value (which I don't believe in, I think it is self-contradictory, but even classical liberals did believe in, that's why they hated rent seeking). Every ethical argument is based on some ethical principles (like axioms). The question is, do you disagree with the argument (the derivation of the conclusion) or with the principles? I'm tired of this sophistry where people claim "this is not a real capitalism". Why cling to the term then? Capitalism has always been a designation of the actual, real system, not some liberal utopia with no rent seeking. (The actual reason is that you can, somehow hypocritically, acknowledge the flaws of the system, while claiming TINA, anyway.)
- UltraViolence 4y agoAll of this is basically easy to make an alternative implementation of. Just use a slightly different audio codec and rearrange the fields a bit in the format. Probably most important for good uptake is a fancy name. HDR10+ just doesn't sound snazzy enough.
- dylan604 4y agoRight, HDR11 sounds so much better. --But it goes to 11.
- JohnFen 4y ago> what if someone told you there was a license for stereo audio Interestingly enough, stereo was under patent in the 1930s -- so you did need a license then.
- __david__ 4y agoI was involved with digital cinema in the mid 2000s and attended standards meetings. Dolby was constantly trying to push their proprietary format for 5.1 audio into the standard but luckily everyone else at the table pushed back, correctly pointing out that just raw PCM 5.1 audio was perfectly adequate (and didn't require a bunch of licensing fees!). Dolby had to actually innovate (with Atmos) to get anyone to actually listen to them. Though I'm quite disappointed with ATSC 3.0 which appears to have given in to them and used their proprietary audio codec which no one supports yet. I'm extremely skeptical that it provides a tangible benefit over more widely supported formats. Yay, regulatory capture.
- splitstud 4y agoI suppose one man's regulatory capture is balanced by another man's monopolistic behemoth pushing out a competitor that doesn't have an alternate revenue stream.
- phh 4y agoWell French dvb standard is requiring e-ac3, so not all standardizers got the memo... (And it's being used mostly in stereo) Fwiw, Dolby does bring something compared to PCM, which is metadata to dynamically change dynamic range on the final device, allowing higher ranges with perfect home cinema and smaller range when in a noisy environment
- ryandamm 4y agoFor the pedantic record, "regulatory capture" typically refers to a situation where an entity responsible for regulating another entity is controlled or influenced by the body it is meant to regulate. Like if the SEC was influenced by Goldman Sachs, or something, or the FDA was influenced by the pharmaceutical companies it was meant to regulate. Standards bodies are comprised of its member companies, who negotiate (oftentimes quite hard!) with one another over what IP ends up in the standards. They're non-governmental trade organizations (though I suppose with ISO it gets semi-governmental). Disclosure: I work at Dolby but do not have anything to do with standards. I dabbled in standards bodies at a previous startup but am really not qualified to weigh in on any of this, besides the stray pedantry around language.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI believe HDR10+ is open and royalty free. Dolby Vision is not.
- Avamander 4y agoIs there any content though?
- vincentriemer 4y agoIt may be royalty free but it's not truly open — there's an annual administration fee for hardware implementors to get a license (TVs/SOCs): https://hdr10plus.org/license-program/ https://hdr10plus.org/license-program/
- pdntspa 4y agoThank god. Do you know how much of a pain in the ass it is to cleanly sample most modern movies because of this proprietary codec bullshit? The best results come from ripping voiceovers out of the center channel... but busting through encryption and figuring out the right proprietary codec to open the audio is a pain.
- suzumer 4y agoI've found that the easiest way to extract audio data from a Blu-ray movie is to rip the file using MakeMKV and then use FFMPEG to convert the audio data to my codec of choice be it wav, aac, opus, etc. FFMPEG takes care of identifying the right codec to decode.
- pdntspa 4y agoDoes it work with the proprietary stream formats like DTS? I believe I am using some plugin for Audacity for that, but I hate doing the actual sampling in Audacity so it then gets loaded into another editor.
- suzumer 4y agoYes, it works with DTS. Here is the full list of supported codecs: https://www.ffmpeg.org/ffmpeg-all.html#Audio-Codecs https://www.ffmpeg.org/ffmpeg-all.html#Audio-Codecs
- rodgerd 4y ago> This is amazing. Company with online video and advertising monopoly wants to use that monopoly to destroy competitors isn't "amazing", it's "business as usual".
- babypuncher 4y agoYou don't need a license from Dolby to encode or play 5.1 audio unless you are using a format that Dolby owns (like AC-3, TrueHD, etc). Plenty of free and non-Dolby proprietary audio formats support arbitrary numbers of audio channels.
- aesh2Xa1 4y agoFrom the fine article: > Google has a lot of influence on hardware manufacturers
- adolph 4y agoIt may be in someone’s self interest to make anything that any of us do zero cost, at which point we do not have a business model for living (other than some form of the dole contingent on agreeing to whatever conditions put thereupon). To the extent that Dolby creates value and reasonably licenses their development I think the employees of Dolby have a better claim to a fair living than a pure patent troll or an ad farm.
- account42 4y ago> at which point we do not have a business model for living You know we could make it so that living does not require "business model".
- adolph 4y agoI also know that we could put pigs on airplanes. Google is still an ad farm that isn't creating new value for anyone other than Google in this case.
- shmerl 4y agoAll of that doesn't seem anywhere recent. Shouldn't all these patents already expire?
- m463 4y agoYou might want to read the book "Schiit happened" about the Schiit Audio startup We don't see a lot of real innovation from small companies because of proprietary audio and video formats. in schiit's case they do most things via rca audio or usb/pcm + a dac in other cases, there are lots of wired headphones/iem via a 1/4" or 3.5mm audio jack, but basically none via lightning.
- ksimukka 4y agoThe audio format (mono, stereo, 2.1,5.1, etc…) isn’t proprietary. The encoding scheme and codecs are i.e Dolby. However, this is a bit more complicated then what maybe is apparent. The post production sound department for a film will create and mix the sound to a specific format (usually 5.1) and depending on how it will be distributed, Dolby (or other) is used for encoding the distribution. Dolby has been popular because it solves for cases when someone only has stereo or when a theatre doesn’t have a specific capability (Atmos) by mixing down or up the film’s delivery format. It is preferred that audio sources are uncompressed PCM in the WAV format. Most audio in a film is actually mono, but is mixed to a surround format with various effects and processing applied to achieve a desired effect. When the mixing process is complete, it is then rendered to a delivery format which is usually a lossless format and/or a property format. It is worth mentioning that the sound mix for cinema distribution is not the same for digital distribution.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lowdose 4y agoThis is unbundling of all royalty taxes, it is the same for fonts. It’s cheaper to purchase a made-to-order font than pay per use.