5 ms·
If true, this would explain tensions here on HN when discussion of economic issues happens. HN readers are self selected high cognitive ability people.
by bediger4000 4y ago
If true, this would explain tensions here on HN when discussion of economic issues happens. HN readers are self selected high cognitive ability people.
- mjreacher 4y agoWell that's what we would like to think of ourselves.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat's covered by "self-selected."
- mistermann 4y agoSelf-identified seems more fitting?
- nh23423fefe 4y ago
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThis view is actually very narrow-minded, much more than simply having views you aren't able to deftly articulate or defend against a dedicated opponent. It compresses an absolutely huge realm of human experience (believing things???) into a very small one (arguing about them on the internet), and then tries to judo it so the first doesn't matter unless you can ably commit to the second. Tragic reduction of your world here. This is such a content-lite view of intelligence it's embarrassing to even take it seriously. It really comes across that you consider intelligence a virtue and it just isn't. You probably have a lot to learn from "people of average intelligence" about actual virtues like obligation and responsibility, commitment, compassion, understanding, and growth. We aren't lesser than you and I'd take a "average intelligence" person over this sort of smart ass shit as my teammate, business partner, lover, or friend in a second.
- andreilys 4y agoI think they're referring to the NPC programming that people receive through media/authority figures, and only have those views because "my fellow tribe member on Fox News/CNN said so" You can't really blame them though, the average person simply doesn't have the time to be well researched on a given topic, and so are going to default to tribal thinking that when you poke at, falls apart. It has nothing to do with inability to articulate their position, and everything to do with the fact that there simply isn't enough time for most people to become well informed on a given topic.
- abeppu 4y ago> You can't really blame them though, the average person simply doesn't have the time to be well researched on a given topic Sure, we can't all be well researched on most topics. But we can learn to have better BS detectors. We can learn to identify bad arguments. We can learn to question the incentives of people arguing on cable TV. We can learn to be skeptical of claims without evidence, and to understand the kinds of caveats that accompany various kinds of evidence. These can separate the critical thinker who, after watching a TV news segment isn't sure what's true but has some pointed questions, and an uncritical viewer who believes new claims made by whichever talking head they already agreed with.
- redeeman 4y ago> You can't really blame them though, the average person simply doesn't have the time to be well researched on a given topic, and so are going to default to tribal thinking that when you poke at, falls apart. true, but I also cannot expect the average person to be a doctor, but if someone feints in the cinema, and I yell "anyone here a doctor??" I do expect them to not claim to be one if they are not. If you do not know something about a subject, you should not inject yourself in where it matters. And when you want to learn about a subject, you should not be a total sheep that blindly listens to the talking heads on TV, regardless of which channel it is on.
- mistermann 4y agoIs this to say that the proposition has no truth or validity to it, that there are not people who hold extremely confident opinions on certain matters but are literally not able to accurately substantiate their claims in detail in a logically consistent manner given sufficient time?
- paganel 4y ago> Can you really be said to hold a view that you can't even evangelize. Yeah, most definitely, I realise as I get older (I'm in my early 40s now) that life is quite complicated and there's almost no "evangelical"-like truth to it. Especially not when it comes to economics, that's for sure.
- nh23423fefe 4y agoOk, cool view you have there about life that you can't express beyond "its quite complicated".
- paganel 4y agoYes, pure 100% libertarianism results in people dying in the streets because of no medical services, pure 100% communism results in people dying in internment camps. This is if we want to talk about economics, but we can extend that view to lots and lots of other fields. The onus is on the other side, to show that an evangelical "there is only one truth" thing really works.
- nh23423fefe 4y agothanks for providing evidence for my claim that most people's "views" are actually just barren husks without content.
- paganel 4y agoCommunism ended up putting people in internment camps, and I say that as a person that has leaned left more and more these past few years, libertarian-like policies have most likely gotten people killed or, at least, threw them in an unmanageable debt-spiral (like we currently now have in the US), and I say that as a former libertarian (yes, one could say that there's no true "libertarian" health market in the US, and that would be correct, but even the concept of a "health market" is libertarian per se). I honestly don't know what you want me to say that would have more "content" than this.
- bpodgursky 4y agoHN is maybe 1.5 standard deviations above mean, which is a very dangerous place to be.
- deltasevennine 4y agoNo, everyone on HN likes to think they're at least 1.5 std from the mean (when in reality they're below that). Very different from actually being 1.5 std from the mean. This is an even more dangerous place to be.
- bpodgursky 4y ago1.5 std is only 120-125 IQ
- deltasevennine 4y agoMakes sense. Someone on HN is typically average. Everyone likes to think of themselves as slightly more intelligent, but the reality is... most people are average... including the modern programmer. I would say that in the past... the average IQ for programmers was higher.
- antegamisou 4y ago> HN readers are self selected high cognitive ability people. Tech literate maybe, but if we judge from the deplorable quality content of the front page the past 1.5 year... Unless editorialized titles and 2500-word essays on CRUD are what high cognitive ability people are into now! I am aware there are exceptions to this, which is the reason I joined the site, but I've become disappointed over time to see that they are indeed a minority.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]