24 ms·
More US Employers Are Trapping Workers in a New Form of Indentured Servitude
- Group_B 4y agoOf course the acronym is TRAP. Can't make this stuff up.
- happyopossum 4y agoWell, actually they did - the commonly used name does not include the P, I’ve never seen it that way elsewhere. The author appears to have added that solely to make for a catchy acronym.
- KennyBlanken 4y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=%22Training+Repayment+Agreement+Provisions%22 https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Training+Repayment+Agreem...
- Izkata 4y agoWell of course you're going to find it if you search for it, since we already know it's in this article. Take out the fourth word and not only do you get 3x as many results, they're less clickbaity and google seems to have a much better understanding in its related and suggested searches.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoThe point is that it's not a term invented by the author as the comment I replied to implied (and further, went on to accuse the author of doing it for sensationalism.) I didn't think I actually had to explain that, but I guess I should have expected as much when I got involved in the token "attack the piece's author over terminology and motives instead o of the actual points of the article" thread. Attacking something because it's "clickbait" or for its terminology instead of actually addressing its core positions is intellectual sloth.
- nine_zeros 4y agoAll businesses in America ultimately end up with rent-seeking and bondage.
- metadat 4y agoI think it reflects more the high degree of desperation employers are feeling with staffing -- especially in cases where they can't (or won't) raise wages. All those boomers abruptly quitting en mass during the pandemic really screwed things up for "the plan". It's time to rethink things, and this TRAP approach is rubbish.
- tdeck 4y agoYep, that's where our sympathy should lie here. With the employers /s
- metadat 4y agoNot what I'm saying at all. I'd be happy to string 'em up, they're repeatedly proving to be scum to the human beings who's care and well-being said employers have been entrusted with.
- wahern 4y agoThe relative recency of TRAPs isn't explained by "[a]ll businesses in America ultimately end up with rent-seeking and bondage." You still need a theory to understand why they weren't prevalent before. And within such a theory is where one might begin searching for a remedy, presuming one isn't so cynical that they believe achieving a remedy impossible.
- pessimizer 4y ago> so cynical that they believe achieving a remedy impossible. It's cynical to assume that this assessment is cynical.
- lucas_membrane 4y ago
- prottog 4y agoThe absurdity of the name aside, this is unconscionable on the part of the employers, and it's likely that most employees in this kind of circumstance can tell their employers to stuff it without any adverse consequence. One thing worth keeping in mind for prospective entrants to the workplace: if any employer says you owe them money (for acts other than intentional or gross negligence, which for the most part employees are nevertheless legally not liable, but may feel ethically responsible), then it is no longer an employee-employer relationship. Put another way: if you're not an equity partner in a business or a strictly independent contractor who signed an agreement saying otherwise, you should never have to pay an employer for anything.
- ianai 4y agoHow hard would it be for a random person to fight back successfully though? If it requires hiring a lawyer that might be enough barrier itself. All they have to do is ensure they don’t pay the worker enough to hire a lawyer.
- metadat 4y agoThe companies might find it difficult to actually get legal enforcement against poorly compensated employees. It seems like more of a scare tactic.
- ianai 4y agoTo me, it’s just slavery. Don’t care about any seeming mitigating factors.
- sulcate 4y agoAn entity doesn't need 'legal enforcement' for a supposed debt when they can threaten to or send someone to collections and ruin their credit/drain their time to fighting it, though.
- metadat 4y agoSee sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32906450 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32906450
- makeitdouble 4y ago> Although critics question the legality of TRAPs, a legal analysis published last year found that courts generally uphold the agreements in challenges brought under anti-kickback provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act, the law establishing a federal minimum wage. > In 2000, the study noted, a federal judge in Manhattan nullified one employment agreement in the financial services industry, ruling that the language of the contract “approaches indentured servitude.” The general picture seems to be: this situation is mostly compatible with how the rule makers want it to be, is in no way accidental, and will be upheld upon challenge in most cases. Some people will have the decency to not go with the grain, but they are few, and represent the exception more than the rule.
- Spooky23 4y agoI think these things make sense where intended. My last employer will pay for a graduate education - you’d get a decent MBA or other degree and pay nothing. They’d even give you time off for certain things. In exchange, they wanted a 30 month commitment post graduation. I think that’s fair and very much employee driven. The problem is when you apply this to unskilled labor. “Training” someone at Petsmart in how to wash and trim a Labrador retriever is a basic task and nobody should be on the hook for that.
- alistairSH 4y agoExactly. Pursuing a graduate degree is optional (outside of select professionals - lawyers, doctors, prof engineers). You can attend graduate school outside the scope of employment (on your own dime). The market for graduate programs is competitive. And the degree retains its value beyond the immediate job placement. PetSmart should be required to prove that its training program provides actual, long-term value to the employee if they want to claw back the money spent on training. In my mind, the program would need to result in a legitimate industry certification for that to be true... As is the case for some skilled trades, where you complete an apprenticeship or other training and earn membership in the trade union. Or trucking, railway engineering, or commercial pilots.
- 11thEarlOfMar 4y agoFirst, they are called Training Repayment Agreements. Not sure where 'Provision' was added. Then, there are certain attributes that need to be adhered to before these agreements will hold up. 1. Must be Voluntary. Typically, the training is within the context of a job the employee already has. They are are undergoing training to expand their skills and thereby earn more. 2. Must be portable. Means that once the training is completed, the employee could take the skill and go work somewhere else. 3. The details must be clearly spelled out. 4. Must be legal in the jurisdiction the employee will be working. Training Repayment Agreements are not legal in all locales. [0] [0] https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/spring2022/pages/reimbursement%20for%20training%20expenses.aspx https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/spring2022/pa...
- cratermoon 4y ago"voluntary" doesn't mean much when the employer to worker power differential is so heavily weighted towards the employer. This is or was a thing with H1B visa holders.
- encryptluks2 4y ago> Must be portable. Means that once the training is completed, the employee could take the skill and go work somewhere else. Gets trained in AWS-specific cloud services. Sure, I can port my knowledge to another company as long as they rely on one service provider.
- happyopossum 4y agoThat’s a really bad example if you’re trying to show one that’s not portable - there are literally thousands of jobs at hundreds of companies for people trained in AWS.
- encryptluks2 4y ago> there are literally thousands of jobs at hundreds of companies for people trained in AWS That still relies on one service provider, so no not portable like you'd like to believe.
- rdtwo 4y agoNobody who benefits from the abuse will be punished - that is the way.
- ecshafer 4y agoI saw one of these at a job when I graduated undergrad. I had an over the phone interview with a consulting company, Revature specifically. I can't even remember if I applied to them or not (since I applied to so many). After what was a 10 trivia question type interview they decided to "give me an offer!". It was a contract $50k a year, for two years with a $20k "training fee" that was fully repayable if you leave before 2 years. I obviously declined it because that is a ludicrously low salary for a software developer in the US, and also it was an insane "training fee". So I presume, their business model is desperate people for jobs, "train" them, then keep them in indentured servitude. They also tried to hard sell a job which is obviously gross.
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y agoThis happened to me, too. I could imagine someone without connections, who is desperate, who simply doesn’t know how much software devs could make, who comes from poverty, etc. would be vulnerable.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThat was mostly me at a certain point in my career except I did know how much devs could make. That doesn't make them actually offer you a job at that salary though. I didn't get into anything like this but I took an offer far far below market rate. When you have no connections, no resources, no work history in the field, dependents to support.... Shit $42k was still more than I was making in the career I came from. I took it then and people are still taking that stuff now. They aren't wrong to do so either, but the ones exploiting them in this way are wrong to do it.
- jcbrand 4y agoWhen you have no connections, no resources, no work history in the field Sounds like you took a job at roughly the market rate (for what you're offering), not below market rate. Just because some developers earn a lot, doesn't mean all developers should immediately earn that much or otherwise consider themselves underpaid. Having connections, resources, experience, education etc. makes you more valuable and therefore increases the value of what you're offering. In other words, don't compare apples and oranges just because they're both fruit.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI dont get it. If it's a voluntary exchange then it's definitionally non-exploitative.
- duxup 4y agoBased on the article the amounts owed appear to be at times arbitrary and don’t seem to reflect the cost to the employer/ what work the employee did. I don’t think you can voluntarily / knowledgeably agree to a completely unknown sum.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoWages already dont reflect the value of the work done. Thats how profit is made. So, I'm not seeing much of a difference.
- duxup 4y agoAs described in the article one employee upsold $6k in extra products, but when she quit she was charged the full amount of the training bill. This would seem to indicate these financial punishments/ threats don’t reflect anything the employer is actually losing, and the employee actions potentially have no impact on the cost. Hard to really be informed as to what you are agreeing to when it seems to be an entirely arbitrary outcome.
- marak830 4y agoIf enough employers insist on this, then the standard of employment goes down. Workers rights must be immutable to stop that happening.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIf it's real employers with a reasonable duration, then would it have a significant impact even if it's very widespread?
- andrekandre 4y ago
- duxup 4y agoThey didn’t mention state laws. I find employment laws vary a lot state to state. Are there places this might be prohibited by state law? I ask because I once took a job that involved 6 months of paid, benefits and all, training before you even started work. One guy did up and quit after 6 months, but generally this is how this company did business. It worked… I always wondered why they didn’t have some sort of restriction or rules or something to avoid being taken advantage of. I assumed they didn’t because of some state law.
- bombcar 4y agoZappos does that and pays you to quit iirc. The main idea is that after investing six months you’re not likely to quit, and if you are the type to quit the company would rather learn that than have you tough it out.
- ilaksh 4y agoShould be prison time for business owners who do this. Of course there won't be, because our society is controlled by self-serving, ignorant Malthusians, but in my mind it's very similar to slavery, and there are few crimes that are worse.
- teeray 4y agoYou load sixteen training videos, what do you get, Another day older and deeper in debt…
- mLuby 4y agoI was coding remotely where the sun always shines rebased my co'mmits and I pushed to CI I closed 16 bugs in the comp'ny repo And the scrum master said, "Well, bless my soul"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WorkerBee28474 4y agoI worked for a company that did this in a white collar capacity - FDM. I basically regard them as the scum of the Earth. However, unlike the article, they usually rent out their trainees as consultants to big companies with broken hiring practices. Myself and a lot of other people I know got an impressive name to put on our resumes and spun that into decent careers. So maybe I shouldn't be so harsh.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Mc91 4y agoI work for a Fortune 50 company, more than one software programmer consultant who worked for us had one of these agreements. Of course, they never got any real training. All the ones I knew didn't have their contracts with us re-upped as they were eager but didn't know anything and had been presented as senior programmers when they weren't even associate/junior level programmers.
- c3534l 4y agoI don't think it should be legal to charge employees for training in any form. Either provide it for free, or don't provide it at all. What possible purpose does putting yourself in the middle as both the lender and beneficiary have other than to fascilitate abuse?
- bushbaba 4y agoSo you don't feel that doctors should pay for their education? What about jobs which require paid certifications? But in general I agree. Keep paid education separate from employment. No good can come from conflating the two.
- c3534l 4y agoThat is such a misrepresentation of what I said I think you might have just misread it or something. They should pay for their education with money. If they can't afford medical school, they can take out a loan. That loan shouldn't be a condition of employment payable to your employer. Like I said, either you should get the training yourself or the employer should provide it.
- derbOac 4y agoWhat's interesting is that medical residencies in the US have involved similar controversies as highlighted by the piece that's the focus of this thread. Residents are not allowed to leave their residencies, under threat of being banned from the matching process that's required to enter one. The criticism is this leads to all sorts of abuse from programs, because unhappy residents can't transfer. This is despite the fact residencies are often federally funded, and the residents have already taken out large educational loans for medical school.
- molotovh 4y agoEducation and job training are not the same thing. Education in a field is general knowledge needed to perform in the field regardless of employer. Job training is learning the specific knowledge needed to perform a specific position for a specific employer, including their SOPs, policies, etc.
- Animats 4y agoThis is debt peonage. The trouble is, the US law against peonage was not drafted tightly enough. "The holding of any person to service or labor under the system known as peonage is abolished and forever prohibited in any Territory or State of the United States; and all acts, laws, resolutions, orders, regulations, or usages of any Territory or State, which have heretofore established, maintained, or enforced, or by virtue of which any attempt shall hereafter be made to establish, maintain, or enforce, directly or indirectly, the voluntary or involuntary service or labor of any persons as peons, in liquidation of any debt or obligation, or otherwise, are declared null and void."[1] As you can see, the reference is to "the system known as peonage". So, new, innovative means of accomplishing the same result may or may not be covered. So far, cases involving training repayment agreements do not seem to have taken the peonage route.[2] The PetSmart case in California makes several arguments. One is that PetSmart is illegally operating an unlicensed educational institution. The "California Education Code provides that “a note, instrument, or other evidence of indebtedness relating to payment for an educational program is not enforceable by an institution unless, at the time of execution . . . the institution held an approval to operate.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 94917") There are other specific California labor laws probably being violated here. This case is just starting in San Mateo County Superior Court. Scheduling hearing in November. But that won't help in other states with weaker labor laws. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/1994 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/1994 [2] https://towardsjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/PetSmart-complaint_file-1.pdf https://towardsjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/PetSma...
- bagels 4y agoIt also doesn't help people who can't afford lawyers, or made one of these agreements still not knowing that they are illegal.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoIt's no easy feat actually getting on the phone with a lawyer, like making their phone screen, both messages the call would be recorded, the redirect, not easy.
- quickthrower2 4y agoThey should totally allow this. But... Since this debt is a form of specialized investment, turning the relationship into a business deal, it should be available only to employees that are accredited investors. Gotcha!
- ETH_start 4y agoI see this as a way to give companies an incentive to train workers. Without these kind of provisions, the risk that the employee would leave would eliminate much of the incentive to invest in training. As for the criticisms of indentured servitude - which if we're going to call this that, is a very watered down version - I think they're reflexive and not thoughtful. Today we have something much more coercive than indentured servitude and that's involuntary servitude in the form of income tax law. At least with indentured servitude you choose the servitude and it expires after the ordained time. The danger of indentured servitude is that it is offered by private companies with a profit motive who would be more likely to seek to abuse the very dangerous relationship they enter into with the the counter party, to exploit that party. A government imposing an income tax has no such perverse incentives. So the rejection of indentured servitude in favor of government imposed taxes has some reasonableness behind it, but I think it's ultimately a crude and hasty substitution.
- hnbad 4y agoFunny, you'd think a low supply of qualified workers would be sufficient motivation for big companies to train workers or fund external training programs (giving them ample opportunities to advertise themselves as the obvious choice as a future employer in that career). This is how most civilised countries handle it.
- fzeroracer 4y agoTypically speaking if you're worried about employees leaving the way it's 'supposed' to work in a capitalist society is that said employer pays more, offers more benefits, or improves the work culture. The fact that you pivot immediately into an irrelevant argument against income tax has no bearing on the companies using debt as a way to force employee retention.
- ETH_start 4y agoYes, but competing employers can do exactly what you do, and offer applicants more pay. By foregoing on training, they can free ride off of the training the subject employer paid for. >>The fact that you pivot immediately into an irrelevant argument against income tax has no bearing on the companies using debt as a way to force employee retention. Taxation is in fact how we solve the problem of trading liberty for security in the absence of indentured servitude. To elaborate: people need economic security, and many are willing to submit to tax obligations, or in the past, to indentured servitude, to get it. So it's entirely relevant to the question of whether this kind of training for debt arrangement is consistent with accepted social mores, no matter how much you may want to over-simplify and wrap up the discussion.
- jongjong 4y agoWhen the government hinders competition through unjust regulations and by controlling the money supply to benefit incumbents, what we get is indentured servitude and slavery. The key elements of slavery are poor working conditions, a lack of opportunities and a government which treats one class of people favorably other another class of people (in the modern case, those people who are closely connected to the government receive better treatment over those who are not connected to government due to access to lucrative contracts and favorable regulations).
- jessaustin 4y agoThis is also one of the things driving inflation right now. Since there is so little competition in so many industries, firms can set their prices (and on the other side, set their wages) to whatever they want and consumers have little choice on the matter. We're already past Gilded Age levels of inequality, and the assholes don't see any reason to stop turning the screws. They actually still claim that they're going to control inflation by raising interest rates!
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoYour college didn't do that, saddle you with a mountain of debt and demand repayment even if their education turned out worthless?
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoThat's a pretty weak comparison. From the article: > BreAnn Scally, the lead plaintiff in the class action against PetSmart, told lawmakers about how she was left owing $5,500 to the company for a dog “Grooming Academy” that was initially advertised as free. Registered nurse Cassie Pennings testified about being stuck with $7,500, “more than six months’ rent,” after leaving one hospital job because she was appalled by staffing ratios during the COVID-19 pandemic and didn’t want to be complicit in neglecting patients. College doesn't initially advertise itself to be free and then tack on thousands in fees when you try to leave. Is it overpriced and antiquated in the modern workforce? Sure. Do they create arbitrary fees out of thin air to scare you into continuing to work in an unhealthy environment? Not that I know of.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoOk, so is the issue is false advertisement rather than paid training per se? Sure, let the courts sort that out! But all things being equal, I would rather get paid while being trained and have an option to have its cost waived if I stay on for some time. Of course if training is a scam, again false advertisement. Sadly, plenty of college degrees are also a scam.
- EasyTiger_ 4y agoTwo popups about donating to a website I’ve never heard of, instant close
- travoltaj 4y agoThis thing is pretty common in India for fresh graduates joining big MNCs. They usually have to stay at the company for 1-3 years, and pay a "training amount" if they leave before that.
- taurath 4y agoCompanies will do /anything/ nowadays to keep people from being an employee. Can we please simply take the whole idea of benefits away from employers? The life and health of people shouldn’t be in the hands of some capitalists trying to squeeze every last legal drop of blood from workers while hiding behind the protection of an inaccessible legal system. I have many many friends who are trapped in a cycle of needing to take on contract work for want of a full time position, and they have to juggle their health insurance every time their contract ends. This make seeing day the same doctor or same therapist for even 3 months nearly impossible. Wonder how many people die yearly due to lack of ability to access healthcare while on a legally “not an employee” position - it’s gotta be in the thousands. The worst part is society says this is acceptable loss. It’s ludicrous.
- _8j50 4y agoYou know, I am pretty vocal about worker rights and I have been saddled with debt of over 7K$ for in the job training but I see absolutley no problem with this. Unless there are debtors prisons it just means your credit score is messed for like 7 years (I can function just fine without using credit at all), which means you can't buy a house or a new car when it comes to the essentials but you can live in an apartment and get a used car. I mean, I was told the training cost and that I will have to pay for that cost either by working for them a certain amount of time or if I fail to do that, out of pocket. I knew what I was getting into, as an adult I am responsible for my actions so as much as I want that debt gone and improvey credit score in case I ever need it, it is all my fault, I signed on the dotted line and I was clearly made aware of the consequences. What am I missing here? Honestly asking. I don't care how profitable a company is or if they invented a random number out of thin air, everything costs what people are willing to pay for it. I don't care what people's situation is, adults get treated like one. If that same person was let's say a genral contractor remodelling your bathroom for $5k and abandoned it mid way, he pays for the cost to complete or restor it right? Why would that be different if instead he was employed by the house owner? I just can't reason around this. At the end of the day, there was an agreement and I gave my word on something. I can and probably will avoid the consequences of my going back on my word but isn't it plain dishonesty to claim the deal was unfair? It is even harder to reason around this if I can pay my basic expenses and on top of that earn the equivalent of the training cost (if I bailed out) and if the pay back period has a reasonable (less than two years) limit.
- Thorrez 4y agoIt seems similar to me to non-compete agreements, which are unenforceable in California, but enforceable in many other states. >At the end of the day, there was an agreement and I gave my word on something. Sure, but the anti-TRAPers would say the ideal situation isn't that you can break the agreement, the ideal situation is that the company doesn't require the agreement in the first place.
- _8j50 4y agoI agree with them in principle but unless that is law it is a meaningless sentiment.
- cycomanic 4y agoRyanair is pretty famous for pulling this stuff on mainly young women from poorer parts of Europe, like Romania for working as cabin crew. Essentially they lure them with comparatively high salaries but they have to pay some training fee. The salary doesn't end up that high, because they have to relocate to more expensive areas, they also only get paid for the actual time on the plane, disregarding the prep and checking times and they have to buy the horribly overpriced plane food. So they end up not being able to pay back their training fee. This really should be cracked down on hard.
- johnchristopher 4y agoHow Ryanair is allowed to operate in the EU never ceases to baffle and disgust me.
- Raptor22 4y agoIt's literally initialed TRAP. This is Looney Tunes levels of villainy. C'mon, corporate America, at least put in the effort to make the dystopia believable.
- cvccvroomvroom 4y agoAren't student loans from the Navients and such predators of young adults who get fleeced by universities binging on their wallets the macro economic distributed version of debt peonage? Why can't college be cheaper by like 2-3 orders of magnitude and reign in overspending on buildings and vast bureaucracies of excessive expenditure. I know of a university who has billions in endowment who leveled a $30 million USD donated office complex less than 8 years old to spend another $75 million on parking and another office building. The same university that spent $150 million on software that was never delivered.
- astura 4y agoA close relative of mine who was unemployed was offered a job but they had to sign one of these agreements as a condition of employment and asked for my advice. I advised against taking the job because the salary wasn't great and it's risky to commit an entire year to a job where you have zero idea about the working conditions yet! I was also thinking the employer might have added this clause because they are having retention issues, which is an indication of poor working conditions. The training also kinda sounded like BS and the cost seemed very arbitrary. They decided against that job. They said they'd take the job without the training payback requirement but it was mandatory. The family member was in a position to not take the job because their spouse was making enough money to support their entire family, but not everyone has that luxury. It seems like only the people who are most desperate will take these jobs. It's bananas these "training payback agreements" are becoming common!!!
- lgrebe 4y agoWould this happen in a „purpose-economy“ with steward-ownership? More on the topic in this TedX talk: https://youtu.be/Z2Uy_ODDiZo https://youtu.be/Z2Uy_ODDiZo
- jimnotgym 4y agoIn the UK the Good Law Project faught and won a case against exactly this. Link below https://goodlawproject.org/news/significant-win-capita-ends-use-bonded-labour/ https://goodlawproject.org/news/significant-win-capita-ends-...
- kurupt213 4y agoThat’s an unfortunate acronym. The story kind of writes itself. Charging for training is worse than the unpaid internship.
- deskamess 4y agoVery common in India or at least used to be.
- bronco21016 4y agoThis has been a long standing practice for pilots. Operators would have the pilot sign a training contract requiring either repayment or some number of years of service. The reasoning is most operators will spend $20-30k+ getting a pilot fully certified for their aircraft and operation. I successfully avoided any of those situations but the common knowledge was that you could walk away and tell the prior employer to stuff it. It’s not worth their time and effort to pursue it beyond some threatening phone calls. I’m not a lawyer obviously.
- zzbzq 4y agoThere's a difference if someone is trained in real difficult skills over a long period of time, vs. given standard training to do a minimum wage-tier job for 10 hours by their minimum wage co-workers, and then told it's worth $7,500+ of debt.
- bronco21016 4y agoI don’t disagree. I think my point centers more around the idea that most of these “agreements” can safely be ignored. Again, not a lawyer.
- dudeinjapan 4y agoWhile I'm completely against these TRAP provisions, playing devil's advocate here, most colleges aren't exactly training useful skills these days, so I kind of get why employers would want to charge for actual training.
- pneumatic1 4y agoI was a carpenter in my early 20s and the owner of a company said he was going to sue me for the cost of some very specific training since I quit after only working for him for 9 months. It was pretty valuable training and I definitely used it to get my next job. I said I'd sue him for wages he owed from when he paid everyone non-union rates on a union job site. Also not requiring use of personal vehicles and not reimbursing for mileage. That was the end of it. He was sued for that reason a couple of years later by the local union itself. He just folded the entity and made a new one. I'm sure he is still treating people the same way.
- Karsteski 4y agoIn Ontario, these types of employee contracts are not enforceable[1]. And at least in the case of Canada, I doubt they would actually try to enforce these contracts lest the same conclusion be formally reached in other provinces, destroying these companies' business models. Just a heads up for anyone in Canada that thinks they are trapped under one of these companies. Just leave if you want. [1] https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2021/03/23/temp-agency-billed-young-workers-a-prohibited-30000-fee-for-leaving-their-job-labour-board-rules.html https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2021/03/23/temp-agency-bill...
- Tangurena2 4y agoThis isn't new. I worked at GM when they bought EDS. Chatting with some of the folks who were moved over to EDS (they took over all IT functions as I understood it), they mentioned having to attend "training" every year and if you left within 2 years of that particular training, you were required to repay that training (which was several thousand dollars per year - in the mid 80s). I was outraged, but the guys I talked with seemed to be OK with it.
- danjoredd 4y agoWhat happens if you don't attend the training?
- Tangurena2 4y agoIt was described as mandatory, although you had a choice of which courses you wanted to take. The impression I was left with was that they believed that the company would never fire them (this would have been true for GM, but not for EDS, for whom they now worked). The culture at GM was such that a lot of people were "lifers". The book "The Organization Man" [0] seemed to describe how many people lived/acted. EDS was founded by Ross Perot, who was a very charismatic person [1]. He was also a "love him or hate him - there's no in between" person. I admired his ability to stir up GM and I remember many of his antics that annoyed the pants off of the board at GM [2]. According to Perot, the culture at IBM was also full of "lifers" which led to his founding EDS. 0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Organization_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Organization_Man 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Perot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Perot > Perot joined the Boy Scouts of America and made Eagle Scout in 1942, after 13 months in the program. After 2 years as a scout, I was still a tenderfoot. :) 2 - He annoyed the board so much that they ended up paying him over $100M to go away (his shares were promised to be between $X & $Y, so they payed the difference between market and $X). I thought that he had a chance to make changes at GM and turn the company around. The execs were terribly insulated from reality, but they chose to live in their bubble rather than do the (painful) things that GM needed to do to survive.
- known 4y ago