19 ms·
Figma: A Random Walk in Palo Alto
- swyx 4y agoAdam writes that his investment criteria are "strong, authentic connection" to the problem, "big enough to generate venture returns", and "someone who is intelligent, trustworthy, and ambitious", and that Dylan was all three. I feel like that papers over just how long it took for Figma to achieve takeoff with regards to revenue (https://twitter.com/DavidSacks/status/1570881311153463296 https://twitter.com/DavidSacks/status/1570881311153463296). must have been a nervous few years in the early days, and the series A/B folks really earned their keep.
- pen2l 4y agoA lot of designers are up in arms over this acquisition and have signaled they'll move on to the next non-adobe alternative, so it raises the interesting question: by way of some anchoring effect, will Penpot or other competitors now be revalued at a much higher amount almost regardless of what their revenue numbers are like?
- alexjurkiewicz 4y agoDevelopers said they would leave GitHub when Microsoft acquired it. Did GitLab get a valuation boost? Maybe a minor one at most. Adobe aren't buying Figma to kill it. It's their future.
- swyx 4y agoyeah lets not rehash this debate, this same back and forth already happened on the announcement thread. we all know adobe aren't the best stewards historically, but intentions are good, yada yada. time will tell.
- gumby 4y ago> Adobe aren't buying Figma to kill it. It's their future. That's for sure. And I can be sure that Adobe knows they are stuck having driven down a wrong road for some time. The big question is: can they revamp? Figma is designed from the ground up to be cloud<-> web, while Adobe's big money spinners have a long legacy of all-on-the-desktop. It's very very hard to retrofit the latter into the former. And they have a huge legacy customer base most of whom are unlikely to want to change. It will be interesting to see how they proceed. Use Figma as an excuse to "eat their own lunch" (instead of, say, porting Lightroom, build from scratch the competitor to Lightroom that someone else could have written?). Or try to retrofit Lightroom? My suspicion is that if they try the retrofit path they will not make it.
- _HMCB_ 4y agoAdobe has been slowly moving to the cloud. Almost imperceptibly. A version of Photoshop lives in the browser. Same for Express. I just think they realize Figma is light years ahead and they want to shorten the gap with an app that fills 80% of their collaborative needs. Then they sprinkle in their font and other technologies they’re good at. Me? I hate browser apps. But that’s just me.
- pen2l 4y agoThey are in a truly capricious position though. I'm a pretty advanced-level Photoshop user and I'm almost fine with Photopea except for the speed and general annoyance of it being a web-app -- if it were a desktop app I'd probably be fine with it. Which is to say, I'd be fine with a $10 product vs. a $1000 one. In the same way that some professional 3d designers I know switched from Maya/c4d to the free Blender and are fine with it (except for the renderer, we still don't have a really good industry-grade GPU-accelerated renderer). Point being that a compelling alternative can be made by a small, focused team in this day and age and offered at a pricepoint that big companies cannot compete with. I fully expect Penpot to take over Figma very soon, AfterEffects will be interesting because really what makes AE what it is is not necessarily AE itself but the killer RedGiant&VideoCopilot plugins so it is equally as vulnerable. There's really no telling where Adobe will be in another 5 years. I would not be surprised if it's 1/10th its current size; in fact I think it is the likely possibility..
- imron 4y ago> Adobe aren't buying Figma to kill it. I'm sure it's not their purpose, however they may end up doing it unwittingly anyway.
- bsder 4y ago> Developers said they would leave GitHub when Microsoft acquired it. Did GitLab get a valuation boost? Maybe a minor one at most. "Developers" may not have moved in much percentage-wise. However, I have noticed quite a few projects moved to GitLab. Projects being on Gitlab forces developers to exist in both places which cracks the "default convenience" monopoly of Github.
- oefrha 4y agoI’m a pretty active open source developer, having a couple reasonably popular projects myself and been a team member of an extremely success one. I’d say maybe one in one hundred projects I’m interested in is on gitlab.com. Last year they stopped allowing anonymous search on hosted issue trackers, and it took me the better part of a year to even notice (I posted https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32252501 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32252501 when I did notice), and I only noticed it on a project that’s developed on GitHub but uses gitlab.com for issue tracking, a choice made back when GitHub’s issue tracker was a lot more primitive. That is to say, I had to search a gitlab.com issue tracker once in a whole year, while I search plenty of open source issue trackers all the time. That’s how irreverent gitlab.com for open source is at least to me. Disclosure: I host a GitLab instance at home.
- bel_marinaio 4y agoGithub did not kill off the free tier
- bsder 4y agoMost overnight successes are 10 years in the making ... The number one commandment of a startup is "stay alive"--everything else is secondary.
- peteforde 4y agoWhat nonsense. 9-10 years to build a successful company is laudable, and along the way there are many metrics which can matter more than net profit. Reinvesting in growth when you're competing with Adobe makes significant sense to me. He went into this with chances that would not look good to any analyst at the start. This is going to have a profoundly different growth curve than your typical Kickstarter startup.
- pas 4y ago"founders should never give up" :o isn't that completely against the lean mindset?
- mradek 4y agoAs a 31yo just barely getting started in my own entrepreneurial journey, I find Dylan to be an inspiration. Everything I hear and read about him is so awesome, and how he really cares about the customers, users, and product. Kudos.
- thghtihadanacct 4y ago
- riddleronroof 4y agoRepeat of what?
- mradek 4y agoI think everything is a “repeat” of something else, but the things that get big usually have something that really differentiates them and blows the competition out of the water. I use figma and fig jam every day. Prior to figma I used sketch and some other apps. They all were missing two key features: ease of use and collaboration. Not needing a mac, and being able to design in the browser with your whole team was a game changer. Throw plug ins into the mix, and a solid community.
- r--man 4y agoThis was such a delighting read for me. Not because it is a success story, but because of the way it talks about the human interactions. Thinking back, it is true that most of my very seemingly random leads came from people who were weakly connected with me and they would be considered equals. Perhaps beyond that point of a weak connection is why SV is different than everywhere else. The author was ready to take a position in a startup out of the basic knowledge of the founder and the general idea. This is practically unheard of where I live. Yes, everyone wants to think it's like that, but in reality they will be asking for a "data room" from a week-old startup. Yet again, you can't blame people because I don't know many intern-to-$20B-Adobe-exit around here... and there goes a cycle
- peter_l_downs 4y ago> Thinking back, it is true that most of my very seemingly random leads came from people who were weakly connected with me and they would be considered equals. For anyone else reading (sounds like the OP might already be aware), you may enjoy "The Strength of Weak Ties" by Mark Granovetter, a legendary paper in the field of network science, which describes exactly this phenomenon. https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~jure/pub/papers/granovetter73ties.pdf https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~jure/pub/papers/granovetter73ties.pd...
- barrenko 4y agoAppreciate it!
- la64710 4y agoOh I promise it is not so simple.
- O__________O 4y agoAppears likely that Dylan’s first funding was likely $100,000 grant from Thiel Fellowship per a comment by Dylan on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11448538 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11448538
- fibonacc 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JakeWesorick 4y agoThis post really shows how much luck/privilege it takes to have a chance at success. Stanford, intern at LinkedIn, being able to just "drop by" in Palo Alto. "Silicon Valley is about People" and it takes a lot of money to get access to those people. The fall of Silicon Valley will be when anyone with the right idea and the ability to build it is able to get funding to actually build it.
- moneywoes 4y agoYep great life lesson. Oh well I guess we need to make our own definition of success
- overeater 4y agoSure your point is a good one in general, but you're combining multiple profiles to create this narrative. Dylan didn't go to Stanford, he went to Brown University. Being an intern, you usually don't have a car, and it's not as easy to get from Sunnyvale (LinkedIn headquarters) to Palo Alto as the story sounds, especially pre-UberX. So the "dropping in" is not like they were living in the same city.
- invalidname 4y agoFor me it would have been a 15 hour flight ;-) I was pitching an Open Source developer tools startup around here at this time. VCs laughed in my face since there's no business model in OSS or in developer tools.
- mannymanman 4y agoLooks like there's a bunch of OSS companies doing well now, with their business model being getting paid for a hosted version of their software. Posthog is a good example.
- invalidname 4y agoThis was around that time. That's my point. In the valley companies like ours got funding for OSS and developer tools at that time (Xamarin, Github, etc.). But in other places it took 5+ years for the dime to drop...
- TedShiller 4y agoThe author’s pat on his own back was about as subtle as a train wreck.
- dimmke 4y agoThe whole post comes off as a humblebrag.
- base698 4y agoHumble?
- xisthesqrtof9 4y agoI was definitely waiting for the him to give himself some kind of an award in the end, or maybe a sound bit of author performing autofelatio?
- achow 4y agoLucidChart was founded around 2008 (couple years before Figma). Their use of WebGL predates Figma's by atleast couple of years, and I remember it was famous enough as a startup to be very visible as a web graphics tool. There must have been other older startups which I'm not aware of. The narrative seems to ignore this. Infact when Figma came around I thought the idea was to combine Sketch (which was truly a pioneer, but limited to only to Mac) and LucidChart kind of web graphics tool to make a platform agnostic 'Sketch'. Great idea - but it was mostly about execution, which was of course was beautifully done.
- ramraj07 4y agoThis is like saying Symbian did everything and more than the iPhone. Technically true, but you definitely miss the point. I’m also not an iPhone fanboy. My phone history includes the 6600, the ngage, ngage-qd, and androids till 2016. Doesn’t mean I can’t appreciate what apple did.
- achow 4y agoHence Apple narrative is around Steve Jobs - great product manager, great marketing person, decisive; company elevating ordinary ('oldish' tech) to extraordinary using power of design,... etc. Apple is not about inventing new tech. Whereas this blog somewhat smells of “History is Written by Victors."
- ajkjk 4y agoApple's narrative, and what Steve Jobs got, was that to get a real hit it's not enough to ship a thing, it has to also be good. Figma did the same thing. Figma is so incredibly better than what it was replacing, it was obvious how successful it would be to anyone who used it.
- achow 4y agoTrue but this argument is non sequitur. Figma as mentioned earlier executed beautifully, no doubt. But the blog narrative is somehow projecting that Figma had vision of WebGL vis-a-vis browser based graphic tools, which I know is not really true and somewhat akin to history is being written by victor. Instead, Dylan & I talked about the transition from Desktop to Web 2.0, and whether now was the right time to bring graphic design to the cloud. John Lilly & I had discussed a hypothesis about this while I was at Greylock, and it was one where I had come to have conviction. The basic premise was that the combination of Web 2.0, Social, and Mobile had finally created the possibility of building truly useful and user-friendly collaborative software in the cloud... This is also disrespectful to the pioneers - nary a word was wasted on people who came before Figma on browser as well as desktop. I wish there was atleast one line dedicated to 'Sketch' software - early version of Figma UI was copy-paste of Sketch one.
- greysphere 4y agoSerious question, what about Figma is unique to a cloud app over a desktop app with cloud features? Does it actually do some computations server side? Clearly the Adobes of the world haven't gone whole hog into online first/collaborative editing (and probably never will due to inertia), but one can imagine someone more nimble doing so without running in a browser. Afaict the uniquely web thing about this product is the lack of install (and to be fair maybe that's a killer feature). Is that it or am I missing something.
- epidemian 4y ago> Serious question, what about Figma is unique to a cloud app over a desktop app with cloud features. There's probably nothing unique about it, but the server/browser model allows anyone on a team to access the Figma project as long as they have a web browser, while a classic client/server model would require a dedicated client software to be installed to access the project. On my last job, we switched from using Abstract for sharing designs between the designers and developers, to using Figma for both designing and sharing between all team members, and the switch was a huge success. Speaking for myself alone, the experience on Abstract was pretty terrible: the native application didn't have a Linux version, and the web client was dog-slow, buggy and limited in features. Figma, on the other hand, being the same web client for everyone, meant a pretty decent experience from the get go, which was a welcome change TBH.
- karaterobot 4y agoYou can run Figma as a desktop app with cloud features. It's a wrapper around the same core as the web app of course. I'm fairly sure of that, though I guess I don't technically know that it's true. "Unique", I don't know. The advantage is that the cost to get people to engage with a design file is so low that it actually happens. It's just a link you click, and you're now looking at the design, or even a clickable prototype of the design. And I'm there, you can see my cursor zipping around, and you can leave a comment, or start a voice chat, and all of a sudden, I'll be damned we're collaborating. If it's a desktop app, and they have to download it, a lot of people just don't do that.
- 4y ago
- ZephyrBlu 4y ago> Regardless, Dylan was brilliant and delight to talk to about almost any topic, and we kept in touch loosely through social media when he went back to school. He ended up interning at Flipboard, a company that happened to be founded by an engineer from Apple who co-taught CS 196P at Stanford with me, their first class on iPhone development. Dylan stayed close to the data science team at LinkedIn, and so we ended up with more than a few reasons to stay connected. I had left LinkedIn to take an EIR role at Greylock, so was just starting to become an active angel investor. This is insane. This reality doesn't exist for >99% of people.
- strikelaserclaw 4y agoFrom reading about Dylan, seems like he came from a middle class background. Of course, where you start off is relative, and you can always go in extreme directions to discount the success of any person ("Oh he grew up in a house with lights, what a privilege etc...)
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoI’m not really commenting on Dylan in particular, moreso the situation. As someone outside the US this sort of thing could never happen.
- rexreed 4y agoThis post is the quintessential post about how success is about being part of the right networks. The cynical part of me calls it the old boys network, the realistic part says that unless you travel in the "right circles" your chances of real success are low. Despite what VCs will tell you about being in the right market, with the right team, and having "traction" and all that, those things only matter (and probably not much) if you aren't in the right network and circles. If you're in the right network, then having the wrong product, wrong market, wrong team, wrong market fit, bad traction, etc. doesn't really matter because those networks will "fix" those problems for you. VC isn't a meritocracy, it's a fairly closed network, and if you can get in you can be successful. For everyone else, success (of the Figma type) is almost near impossible.
- vecter 4y ago> If you're in the right network, then having the wrong product, wrong market, wrong team, wrong market fit, bad traction, etc. doesn't really matter because those networks will "fix" those problems for you. No amount of VC money can fix a bad company that doesn’t solve a burning problem for customers. Conversely, if you do solve a burning problem for a lot customers, getting VCs onboard will be the least of your concerns.
- te_chris 4y agoI think you’re missing the point: being in market is its own privilege
- barry-cotter 4y agoBeing in market is a product of choice or luck. Insofar as it’s good judgment that’s not privilege that’s being better, merit. Luck, winning the lottery of interests, isn’t merit but there’s no interesting sense in which it’s privilege either.
- rexreed 4y agoHaving the right friends in the right networks help you both with market choice and product choice and also provide necessary insights for product-market fit. Not having the right friends or networks means that you have to indeed rely on choice or luck. Having the right network is a significant insight / inside advantage.
- Aeolun 4y agoAs much as it ostensibly is, I just cannot see the ‘acquired by Adobe for 20B’ as a success. At least I’d consider it a failure. If it were ‘Adobe acquired by Figma’ it might be different. But if terrible old behemoths can just buy off all competitors, then where are we going?
- nmfisher 4y agoIt's a success for Figma's founders/investors. It's a failure for everybody else.
- Aeolun 4y agoI dunno, if I set out to build Figma I guess it would be to beat Adobe, not to join them. Maybe the lure of several billion is too much to resist.
- Olphs 4y ago> Maybe the lure of several billion is too much to resist. Well yes seems obvious, unless they already had that kind of money. It's easy to say that from the sidelines, since I assume you haven't turned away several billion of dollars
- Aeolun 4y agoI’m kind of assuming that since they had a 20B company, they were reasonably well compensated (say several million a year). Short of a slightly bigger house, I already have difficulty imagining what I’d use more money for (aside from start another similar company, which seems kind of pointless).
- Infinitesimus 4y agoThere are many interesting ways to spend a billion - funding other founders, investing in under-invested areas globally or in your community, starting a scholarship fund for folks less fortunate, building a big yatch, etc etc. Another good reason to exit is also just to rest, take some time and enjoy the world a bit after being deep in founder mode for so long.
- blobbers 4y ago... so did he get in on the seed round or not?!
- redocecin 4y ago- “On June 25, 2013, Dylan Field, one of my favorite interns from LinkedIn dropped by Wealthfront headquarters in Palo Alto to catch up and get some advice about his new startup, https://figma.com/.” https://figma.com/.” - “The best solution for a problem five years ago may not be the the best solution today, and it very likely won’t be the best solution five years from now. As a result, young engineers approaching problems for the first time can sometimes see opportunities that the most experienced can’t.”
- thimkerbell 4y agoA small tangent piece of writing advice: if you're writing for an audience, anytime you use the name of a startup, include a few words to say what it does. Don't make the reader click away to learn this.
- peteforde 4y agoSome napkin maths: $3.8M seed round a properly structured round usually costs (12-17%) so ~15% of the company that means Dylan raised at a ~$25M valuation $20B is 800x $25M So, for every $10k this self-congratulatory cough gave his former intern after their walk, he just made $8M. Not too shabby, regardless of any emotional context you may project.
- redslazer 4y agoThere would have been dilution at every subsequent round (or additional investments) so that profit per $10,000 is probably 30-50% less than $8mil.
- tempodox 4y ago> This acquisition is just one more step in the fulfillment of a broad vision to elevate design in every organization. This very much remains to be seen. Writing that as though it were a foregone conclusion is disingenuous at best (not to call it hollow marketing drivel, or a comforting lie). The only “fulfillment” that we can assume for now is that Figma's founders made a boatload of money. And maybe that's all the fulfillment you can ever hope for.