4 ms·
It's not just you. The business model of many tech companies consists of creating digital fiefdoms to lock "their" users into and then selling access to "their"
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
It's not just you. The business model of many tech companies consists of creating digital fiefdoms to lock "their" users into and then selling access to "their" users. They sell access to "their" users to other software developers. They sell access to the attention of "their" users to advertisers.
It's pretty disgusting and dehumanizing.
- sithlord 4y agois that any different than going to Disney World and having coke products shoved in your face?
- matheusmoreira 4y agoOf course. When I go to places like that, it's because I want to consume. When I go to a store, when I open the store app, it's because I want to see products. That's the whole point. In those cases, it's not advertising, it's information. The problem with computers today is you get advertised to no matter what you do. Can't boot goddamn Windows without it finding an excuse to show you stupid Taboola ads. Can't open a simple website without being literally flooded with ads all around the "content". This "content" is just an incidental abstraction, an arbitrary square on the screen that ads mold themselves around like parasites. It doesn't matter what the "content" is, it could be anything that draws in users, the real product is their attention being captured by the ads.
- grey_earthling 4y agoI describe this problem as misaligned purposes. You want to consume plastic stuff; Disney World wants to sell you plastic stuff; a magical time ensues. But you buy Windows because you want a useful OS; whereas Microsoft make Windows as a shop-front for their paid-for services; your purpose and the makers' purpose are misaligned, and you end up frustrated and annoyed that Windows isn't what you want it to be. Similarly, if a website's purpose is to make money (which is fair enough of course), but you're there because you want to read interesting stuff, that's a misaligned purpose and a frustrating time for you. Websites that exist primarily to show off interesting stuff tend not to tax the content-blocker so hard, because the author and audience's purposes are well-aligned. And community-governed OSes/distros tend not to push other services, because the purpose for making them genuinely is to be a useful OS (for their intended niche). My suggestion for what it's worth: choose tools and services where the maker's purpose for making it aligns with your purpose for using it.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> choose tools and services where the maker's purpose for making it aligns with your purpose for using it What if they don't exist anymore? Because not taking advantage of your users by advertising to them means leaving money on the table. Eventually some executive is gonna show up, notice that and demand that it be done because his compensation is directly tied to revenue growth or something.
- grey_earthling 4y agoYep. I'm saying: avoid things that exist primarily to make loads of money. Smaller, looser, less-commercial organisations have fewer or no executives, less concern with making as much money as possible, and (in my opinion) tend to produce less bullshit. This is distinct from producing good-quality work — their output may be unpolished, but it'll generally be sincere, and free of over-commercialised tat.
- Eisenstein 4y agoWhich ISP, phone company, or electrical utility company works like that? They don't, because we have (hopefully) regulated them. There is a point in which a product stops becoming a choice and starts becoming necessary to function. You could argue that operating systems are one of those things. Lets put some ideas together for regulation in these spheres.
- howaboutnope 4y agoAn OS is not a destination, it's a medium if you will. A better comparison would be being blasted with ads no matter where you go.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoYes, because it's trivially easy to avoid going to Disney. To avoid all tech giants, you practically need to opt-out of modern society and become a hermit.
- goosedragons 4y agoI reinstalled Windows 10 on a machine recently and like half the setup process is now ads for other Microsoft services or things related to ads. Do you want Office 365? OneDrive? Xbox Game Pass? Can we use your location for ads? Kind of ridiculous. I don't think there was any the first time I installed Win 10? Maybe just Office 365? I can't wait for Windows 13 when Microsoft has sold installer ads to the highest bidder and I'm asked if I want a case of Mountain Dew during install.
- FearlessNebula 4y agoPlease drink a verification can
- tomcam 4y agoOK that was really really good. Thank you.
- FearlessNebula 4y agoOh I can’t take credit for that, it’s from 4Chan: https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/983286-4chan https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/983286-4chan
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThat's hilarious. It just keeps getting worse. It's like they have no self-awareness or limits.
- Liquix 4y agoThese corporations are not bastions of self-awareness nor moral fortitude. They are machines with the singular goal of making the red line go up. It will continue to get worse as long as people continue buying their products.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago
- javajosh 4y agoIt's healthier to think of business models more like organisms. Animals aren't "good" or "bad" for having a lifecycle that involves parasitism or predation, stealth or deceit, or any number of behaviors, like cannibalism. Life doesn't care how you live, just that you live.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoBusinesses live because society allows them to live. How about we make humane business models a pre-condition for existence? "It exists in nature" is not a solid argument for anything. I've read about insects that coerce their mates into copulation under threat of predation. Yet nobody seriously argues that humans should be allowed to rape because rape exists in nature. Such an obviously sociopathic argument just doesn't fly.
- javajosh 4y agoI argue only that organisms evolve to occupy whatever space is available to them. This true of organisms, it is true of businesses. Both respond to incentives.
- humanizersequel 4y ago> Businesses live because society allows them to live. It is not a one way street from "mores of society" -> "business practices". Large corporations frequently go to extreme lengths attempting to manipulate what society does and does not allow.
- midoridensha 4y ago>"It exists in nature" is not a solid argument for anything. I've read about insects that coerce their mates into copulation under threat of predation. Yet nobody seriously argues that humans should be allowed to rape because rape exists in nature. Such an obviously sociopathic argument just doesn't fly. It's worse than that. Some insects (I think it's mantises) will murder each other after copulation. I'm not sure what the evolutionary advantage there is, but this doesn't seem like something humans should emulate. >How about we make humane business models a pre-condition for existence? No, because too many people don't want this.