9 ms·
Ask HN: Where are the interesting conversations?
I have this suspicion that conversations that are deep about touchy issues are nowhere to be found on the internet anymore. Perhaps they have moved to late-night dinners with VCs or yacht rides with rich people? Where are the places to start (and continue) conversations about important issues without self-censoring and walking on eggshells?
- mw888 4y agoSmall communities that do not tolerate thought control.
- kstenerud 4y agoYou do it in person, with people you trust and respect. It's always been this way, even during the heyday of the free internet. People like to look back with rose tinted glasses at the "good old days" of free expression online, but choose to forget that such conversations with strangers inevitably led to misunderstandings and bad faith assumptions, degenerating into smug superiority fests at best or flame wars at worst. I post occasionally on HN because it's a lot better than other places I've posted to in the past (Usenet, Slashdot, Reddit etc), but even this is but a pale shadow of the conversations I have in person over drinks.
- danielvaughn 4y agoAgreed. I think the anonymous nature of the internet dooms important or interesting conversations. I think what has happened is that people cannot filter their conversations by age anymore. This is pretty unique actually - I can’t think of any situation in real life where I’d engage seriously with a teenager. Perhaps family, or maybe if I was a teacher. And yet, any conversation online is guaranteed to have the full range of age groups. Just as a chain is only as strong as it’s weakest link, a conversation can only be as mature as it’s least mature participant. It’s not fair to say that all teenagers are immature, but they are all inexperienced. And what has happened is that online conversations tend to resemble high school gossip, rather than serious discussions of important topics.
- lolinder 4y agoThere were exceptions. There was one forum I was a part of where none of us knew each other in real life and yet we had long, intense, good-faith discussions on touchy topics that stayed meaningful. I think what made it different was that we were a tight-knit group that was invested in our pre-existing relationship: we started as a clan in a very cooperative video game and we had each other's backs every day in-game. The political and religious discussions occurred in our private forum in the off-topic section. So I suspect you're half right: the conversations have to occur with people you trust and respect. But at least in the early 2000s, they didn't have to occur in-person. What matters seems to be not that they be in-person but that they be private and that all involved cherish their relationships with each other. A lot of what happened in the last decade is that people have left the private spaces and moved into public spaces, where such conversations really do become toxic quickly. Even on Facebook with posts set to friends-only, the system encourages adding so many "friends" that it may as well be public. By the time most people get to friend #300, neither of them really cares about the relationship, so meaningful discussion about touchy topics becomes impossible.
- illuminerdy 4y ago> " There was one forum I was a part of where none of us knew each other in real life and yet we had long, intense, good-faith discussions..." I'm curious what happened to that forum?
- kitsunesoba 4y agoEarly 2000s forums were a special place. None I was part of were quite as close-knit as yours sounds, but the general quality of discourse of those I frequented back then was a good deal higher than what’s commonly seen on social media these days. It’s too bad they’ve gone extinct. The few old style forums that are still hanging on do so by way of sheer momentum (huge numbers of posters) or by having become fringe echo chambers and are just as bad or worse than social media.
- imiric 4y agoTo be fair, there was a good decade and a half, maybe two, where Usenet was the place to have deep, meaningful and respectful conversations. Most netiquette conventions were first established there. Then Eternal September happened, binaries and spam flooded the network, and users looking for good discussions moved on. Reddit went through a similar change more rapidly, and even today, despite of the shitposting, bots and Reddit Inc.'s disregard of its userbase, there are niche communities where well-intentioned discussion takes place. There are also even more niche old school forums or IRC communities where people can take refuge from the rest of the internet. But I do agree that HN is still a surprisingly respectful forum. Not necessarily because of Y Combinator's shepherding or a small team of herculean moderators, but because the community is self-moderated. I do think this will change and become more difficult, as more new users join the site. Longtime users have surely noticed the change already. > You do it in person, with people you trust and respect. It's always been this way, even during the heyday of the free internet. Sure, that would be the preferred way. But the reason we communicate online is because it's often easier to find communities of people with similar interests, than doing the same locally. Anonimity also has a positive aspect, in that it makes interaction easier for getting points across, as we don't let our human biases influence the discussion, and the merit of any point is weighed on its own. Discussions in person, especially around hot topics, often devolve into shouting matches and personal insults. Not that online ones don't, but typing text is often enough to assemble our thoughts in a calmer way. OTOH, there's the obvious lack of human connection missing from online and text-only discussions. But then again, once a community is well established, in person meetups can happen. :)
- moistly 4y ago> To be fair, there was a good decade and a half, maybe two, where Usenet was the place to have deep, meaningful and respectful conversations. Most netiquette conventions were first established there. There were BBS-era networks that also had meaningful conversations. The Well (The Whole Earth 'Lectronic Link, ‘85), Citadel networks (‘81), Fidonet (‘83), and many others.
- seydor 4y ago> led to misunderstandings and bad faith assumptions The assumption of bad faith is a recent phenomenon, i remember when the internet did not a priori assume that everyone was speaking in bad faith. I dont think it s rose tinted glasses, it's just that that thing did not scale
- microjim 4y agoTwitter
- jacknews 4y agolol, my kids were schooling me about today's social medias over dinner. The cool gamerz all hang out on discord apparently. Facebook is for parents and other boring old people. Instagram is for narcissists and attention seekers. Etc, etc. And Twitter is for .. pretentious twits.
- socialismisok 4y agoI'm 40 and this is my understanding of social media landscape. Do others not think this is true? I thought we all agreed that Facebook was for boomers, Gen xers, and millennials who are boring a few years back.
- mrwnmonm 4y agoTwitter? Interesting conversations?
- JonathanBeuys 4y agoI sometimes think Twitter could be used for this. But it seems you have to bring your own audience to Twitter. At least that is what I witness. Everyone who got a conversation going over there was a celebrity outside of Twitter already.
- JSavageOne 4y agoThe problem with Twitter is the character limit. Impossible to have a serious in-depth conversation with a 500 character limit.
- tester756 4y agoI'd start with defining what "important issues" are Why? because there's many of them and each of them may attract different groups of people, thus different discussions groups, forums, etc.
- leesec 4y agotwitter and it's many groupchats
- Bakary 4y agoI'm curious why you think this sort of conversation would only happen between wealthy people. The other aspect to consider is that to have deep conversations, you essentially need 95% reading 5% actual discussing because the depth can be pretty high on most topics. To give a practical example: you can have a deep and touchy convo about the place of religion in life, but in all likelihood every argument you will come up with will have already been written about in far more depth elsewhere. By the very nature of the medium and its history you are only going to have the illusion of depth if you only seek to have conversations as you are describing. It would also be a good idea to carefully consider what you consider touchy. Chances are, it's just normal things to think about for your demographic. For instance, HN readers like to talk about controlling the masses, large future trends, and revel in the forbidden aspect of discussing this sort of thing. But in reality, population control and an 'architect' view of their place in the world has been a normal feature of the well-to-do classes for pretty much forever.
- eru 4y ago> To give a practical example: you can have a deep and touchy convo about [some topic], but in all likelihood every argument you will come up with will have already been written about in far more depth elsewhere. You are right about most arguments about most topics that have been accessible for people for at least a few generations. However, it's also surprisingly easy to come up with completely new takes, once you veer off the beaten path a bit.
- Bakary 4y agoThat is true, but at the same time the depth is so high that short of speaking to another Johnny von Neumann you are not likely going to have that original of a conversation when compared to the pre-existing literature out there.
- eru 4y agoI'm not so sure. Many topics are surprisingly 'high dimensional'. So if you go in a slightly different direction, you can quickly rich new territory. Your new thoughts will likely not be as good as John von Neumann's thoughts, of course. Have a loot at eg 'Why Philosophers Should Care About Computational Complexity' https://scottaaronson.blog/?p=735 https://scottaaronson.blog/?p=735 It many novel and good ideas on classic problems. Of course, I'm cheating a bit here by bringing up something by a genius like Scott Aaronson. But my general point is that combining previously disconnected fields can yield new insights or at least new questions. Another example, it's from religion, but hopefully silly enough not to ruffle any feathers: As far as I know Catholic doctrine says that all humans have one soul and free will. Also, ensoulment happens at conception. The problem is identical twins come from the same fertilized egg. Does the fertilized egg start with two souls, or does the soul split later? Normally, whether identical twins happen is sort-of random. But we also have enough technology that for in-vitro-fertilisation a human lab worker can use their own free will to spontaneously decide whether to produce identical twins or triplets long after conception has occurred. Similar issues occur when you clone a human from an adult's cells. (But it's somewhat easier to deny that clones have souls than to deny souls to identical twins.) Honestly, I don't think anyone is losing sleep over this conundrum.
- ohCh6zos 4y agoInteresting conversations online have gone the way of the Dodo Bird. Many platforms need to be advertiser friendly, you need lots of moderation to get onto the app stores, and if somehow an interesting places does spring up eventually one of the big players finds a way to take it down.
- api 4y agoThat’s half the problem. The other half the problem is that if you do manage to create a really open platform it will be destroyed by bad faith actors and trolls. These will drive away the good stuff and turn your platform into some kind of echo chamber or worse a hate and psychosis ridden hole like what the chans became. The bad chases away the good. Deep substantive discourse requires good faith argument not propaganda techniques, straw men, and trolling. It also requires maturity.
- notacoward 4y ago> it will be destroyed by bad faith actors and trolls Popper's paradox of tolerance plays out every day on social media. If you take a strong free-speech no-moderation approach, your forum will sooner or later be destroyed by propagandists and trolls. If you try stronger moderation, you might keep those at bay but you also lose many of the true free thinkers so the creeps still win. Jerks have an innate advantage on the internet, which makes conversations "across the divide" almost impossible; those are best left for RL environments where trust and physical presence can keep those impulses from manifesting. The best one can do online is choose which side of any relevant divide you're going to be on and limit participation to those who share some core beliefs. (Comparisons to women's colleges and HBCUs should come naturally at this point.) Sometimes this allows interesting (if somewhat bland) discussions. Other times it just leads to ever more tightly defined factions - e.g. genuine socialists vs. social democrats - turning on each other. I've been actively involved in online discussions for 40 years, and I was even a moderator on a political forum through millions of posts. I wish that experience had left me with better solutions, but sadly I have to report that it hasn't. "Leave the sensitive stuff to RL" seems to be the only real answer, with "reduce use/prominence of social media" as a corollary.
- 4y ago
- jmmv 4y agoI think this is what Radiopaper (https://radiopaper.com/ https://radiopaper.com/) is what it’s trying to solve. Previously discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31210680 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31210680
- browningstreet 4y agoAre these interesting conversations producing things? Where’s the interesting output? I have my suspicions, but I hate being that cynical…
- bumby 4y agoWhat do you mean by production? This feels a bit like a bias towards productivity-porn. Philosophical discussions may be worthwhile and produce nothing other than an examined life.
- browningstreet 4y agoCertainly anyone can have philosophical questions, but OP pointed to VCs and such, sounded like a question of interesting business/tech conversations. So, yes.. production.
- bumby 4y agoThey also pointed out rich people on yachts. The one common thread was "important issues" not "productivity." Maybe it's just a SV thing where the two get conflated.
- motohagiography 4y agoWe should probably thank the OP for reserving themselves and be grateful that they have not been seduced by their lower urges, where merely giving in to them would cause vaguely illigitimate and shameful outcomes like yacht usage and being sought out for investment advice. ;) Public discourse is a performance. Not that it is fake, but it is the refined product of practice you can't see unless you have practiced it yourself. When you go see an orchestra and wonder why you can't get up on stage and just jam with them, is it censorship, or is being a part of that performance the effect of something that takes a lot of effort to be welcome in? Start your own punk orchestra or get good enough to be welcome in an officially sanctioned one. My conversations have been on signal groups, slack, pints with fraternal bros, meeting people while travelling and motorcycle camping, drinking at family bbqs, are typically with other men, and an less on boats these days. What they all have in common is they have a bar to entry of not being a sad sack. I agree that there are legitimately lame orchestra admission rules on official social media, but think about what being open, funny and welcome really means, and I guarantee you will get invited everywhere.
- VictorPath 4y ago> conversations that are deep about touchy issues are nowhere to be found on the internet anymore. Perhaps they have moved to late-night dinners with VCs or yacht rides with rich people? What are the touchy conversations on yacht rides with rich people - how to avoid the mistakes Jeffrey Epstein made with his private jet private island child sex trafficking operation?
- swayvil 4y agoThere are people willing to entertain strange ideas. A minority. The "strangers". And there is everybody else. The vast majority. The "normies" Everybody talks to everybody on the internet. Therefore every stranger is surrounded by normies. At best the stranger is ignored. At worst he is shouted down. This creates a ubiquitous field of strange idea suppression. One must find a private club. That's hard. There is a weird absence of private clubs on the internet. Or at least they are hard to find. I guess any private club that advertises its existence immediately gets stuffed with normies.
- Bakary 4y agoThe idea of being a "stranger" as opposed to a "normie" is deeply seductive. I've had the tendency to believe it myself, but then I stumble onto some book or argument or discussion that acts as a reminder that it's all a lot more complicated and much has already been written. Do you have any examples of specific ideas that are actually strange and shouted-down? Not to be too cynical, but sometimes what people qualify as strange is just controversial but classic opinions such as "restricting the poor or another group" or stuff relating to IQ, or a "what they don't want you to know about" type deal
- swayvil 4y agoI use the terms merely to distinguish between 2 classes of people. Do you think that this is an unrealistic distinction? Here's an example. Meditation discussion in a context free of conventional models. It's nigh impossible to find such conversation without getting knocked over the head with citations of Buddhist/etc dogma. On the internet anyway. (Also, I said "ignored or shouted down". Not just "shouted down". See, you have chosen to focus on the extreme, easier to refute, case. In fact, twice striving immediately for the refutation.)
- Bakary 4y agoI don't think it's unrealistic, just that we could possibly add more gradations and call it a spectrum, from the normiest of normies that is completely unreceptive to anything out of the ordinary to world-alerting thinkers who went against the grain of their time. My personal hypothesis is that these gradations of normie-to-strange are important in that they point to a range of similar behavior between people of the same gradation that goes beyond just intellectual conformity or non-conformity. Perhaps one issue with binary classification is that makes it easier for us to overrate our own ideas on account of placing ourselves automatically in the "good" half since the barrier to entry then becomes so low (i.e. just don't be a normie and you're done) The meditation example is a great one actually. The only discussions I've seen about it that don't cover the Buddhism-for-Westerners angle have to do with CBT/repackaged stoicism or people who enjoy nootropics/LessWrong/split-toe shoes etc. I did have one unusual conversation once with a person who described to me a sort of self-induced bad trip they got from meditation practice (based on what I could find online, that is a known phenomenon). Regarding that last part, I agree I came on a bit strong there in my post, and it was unwarranted. I did that because of past experience and familiarity with the discursive style.
- carapace 4y agoThe open and largely unspoken secret of the internet is that only the mentally or emotionally unbalanced post here. The ratio of people who use the internet to people who post regularly on the internet is something like 1000:1. Only nutters talk on the internet. > late-night dinners with VCs or yacht rides with rich people Wat? Where are you coming from? > conversations that are deep about touchy issues Everybody does this, all the time. Maybe your friends are too shallow for you? > Where are the places to start (and continue) conversations about important issues without self-censoring and walking on eggshells? Go ahead and have them, right here on Hacker News. If you're "self-censoring and walking on eggshells" and you're NOT just an asshole, then you just need to study rhetoric. It's an ancient art, thousands of years old, there's plenty of material to work with. If you're well-spoken (and your opinions or ideas are not simply odious) then who cares if people get mad at you? It's on them to reply in kind or they're the assholes, eh?
- seydor 4y agoso I didnt even state any issues and am already presumed to have shallow friends, being an asshole, ignorant of rhetoric and not being well-spoken. maybe eggshells was an understatement
- carapace 4y agoI apologize for insulting you, that was not my intention. I have to point out that you're being defensive and taking an uncharitable view of what I said. Your friends may be shallow relative to you, I don't say anything about their absolute level of shallowness/depth. I'm a pretty shallow person myself (once you get away from the minutia of computer programming, and even there there are a lot of people who are much deeper than I am.) Nevertheless, it happens sometimes that you find yourself with a circle of friends that you are no longer satisfied with, maybe that's personal growth, or maybe you're just becoming a cranky old man. I'm just speculating, there's no need to take any of this personally. (I'm using the pronoun "you" in the general sense, not about you seydor specifically, okay?) I never called you an asshole. Without knowing more about you, it's a possibility, but I'm trying to discount that. It's like saying, "You're not a flying purple people eater, so it must be something else" is not calling you a "flying purple people eater", right? As for "ignorant of rhetoric and not being well-spoken" you seem determined to be offended. I'm just trying to help. If you're not an asshole,, if you don't entertain odious opinions, if you have good rhetorical skills and are well-spoken, and you still feel you have to walk on eggshells, then I would say that the problem must be that you're just looking in the wrong places? I.e. you're not going to get good debate on Imgur. In any event, I hope this find you well, and offer it in the spirit of open and civil discussion. Have a good day.
- bobiny 4y agoI believe that deep and interesting conversations need to have stakes. In your example with VCs, stakes would be trying to figure out where the market is going or trying to strike a deal. Latter also works for rich people. In context of modern social media, the main stake is emotional involvement. Which is often a sign of a shallow understanding of a subject. Take reddit conversations on controversial subjects. There would be loud statements with many upvotes and counterpoints with many downvotes. And downvotes discourage debating for regular people. So you are left with homogenous opinions and trolls. I think interesting conversations may happen with individuals that you stumble upon by chance. Easiest way to get lucky is to be involved in some community that fits your interests.
- rdl 4y agoPrivate signal groups, mostly, or in-person conversations.
- taccicardia 4y agonot sure what you're alluding to. you can easily navigate to 4chan and have as many controversial public conversations as you want. or you can make irl friends. or you can see a therapist and confirm that you have an antisocial worldview. many options for you, friend.
- illuminerdy 4y agoInteresting discussions can happen on pretty much any forum/platform. It's not the 'where' that matters, it's the 'who'. It's the people having the conversation. I've had meaningful conversations on Disqus more than once, which normally you would not think would be a place you could have such conversations.
- adventured 4y agoRich people on yachts? I've been having these types of conversations with my brother nearly every day of the week for the past two decades. There are no barriers to what we can discuss. No eggshells needed. He's a rational, intelligent person. I certainly wouldn't put our conversations on Twitter (or Reddit or xyz), who has time or care to deal with explaining to morons/irrational people/mentally ill people/partisans/whatever why their feelings/emotions/politics/opinions aren't the center of the universe - and who cares what strangers and anons think anyway in most circumstances; their opinions, their thoughts, their feedback, it's all overwhelmingly worthless. I have a couple of friends I can do this with as well. They're out there, find them.
- moviewise 4y ago
- shadowfoxx 4y agoI see this question often but I hardly ever see the people asking starting the conversations they wish to see. Build it and they will come... but I have a few questions: 1) What is an interesting conversation even? Seriously. In my experience there's endless 'interesting' conversation happening on the big site aggregates, even if you have to do a little work to do it. Most of it doesn't just happen to you though. 2) Was there ever a time when deep conversations were happening on the internet? Really, truly. I wouldn't consider stumbling on a thread and reading it unique to old internet. 3) Deep and touchy? You're going to have to define Deep. Because, pick your interest. The depth of information to be found and conversations to be had about... picking a random interest of mine - Visual Art. I can go on Youtube or Twitter and see any number of threads about: NFTs and their place in the wider space, same with AI Generated Art. I can find videos on technique that are deep and technical. There's any number of discord servers to join that if you engage in good faith, people will respond in kind. (One trick is to simply ignore folks who make 'derailing' comments. Here's a secret I thought everyone knew: Trolls and the ironic posters want attention, if you don't give it to them they simply go away; Their biggest fear is being boring, use that against them lol) I'd be interested in what examples you have of 'self-censoring' and 'walking on eggshells'. Seriously. Even the most 'Touchy' subjects I can think of, take your pick of culture war nonsense, if you engage earnestly, deeply, intellectually, there's open discussion to be had.
- HKH2 4y ago> Seriously. Even the most 'Touchy' subjects I can think of, take your pick of culture war nonsense, if you engage earnestly, deeply, intellectually, there's open discussion to be had. Not on HN, as far as I've seen. That's okay, because despite what some people say, not everything is political.
- karaterobot 4y agoYour suspicion is probably correct, and in terms of places you can go (online) to have a conversation that is asynchronous, long form, and comparatively private, I think it's all gone off the public-facing internet, at least for many categories of discussion. Slack, Discord, Matrix, probably some other platforms I'm not cool enough to know about. A long, long time ago, I ran a BBS: now I run a Mattermost server. Feels like about the same level of quality to me. The conversations there run the gamut from lower (more vulgar, less mature) to higher (more in-depth, lengthier, more thoughtful, taking place over a longer time frame) than, say, Twitter, Reddit, or HN. It's not hard to set up an invite-only, hosted chat server. It is somewhat harder to convince people to use it, because a lot of people don't want to run another app. If I had to choose today, I would go with a Matrix-based solution rather than Mattermost, but it wasn't available at the time. Most solutions, including Mattermost, lock you in by not letting you export the (full, including DMs) conversation archive, so you have to choose something you want to stick with for a while.
- nathias 4y agobetween interesting and interested people, so mostly between peers working on the same/similar problems
- vfinn 4y agoI have thought along similar lines, and I think one's own abilities determine the places you end up :), meaning that the more one knows, the more likely one will end up in deep conversations with deep thinking people in sites or situations that are buried in the net and/or in life out there. I'm pretty sure I'm excluded from these events :D. edit: but on the other hand, it's quite easy to get in touch with famous and brilliant people if that's what you like, so... if you have something interesting to say, maybe you'll get somewhere that way.
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y ago
- Syonyk 4y agoCampfires or similar events, ideally lubricated with limited amounts of alcohol, possibly a pipe or cigar depending on wind, going late into the night on evenings when nobody has anything in particular early the next morning. In the winter or smoke season, the same thing can be done indoors, but it's better outside, IMO. It's a far wider, more interesting range of discussions at one of those events than I've found on the internet, and I'm trying to figure out ways to have them more frequently as opposed to the once or twice a month that's been standard for the past few years in my social circles. There are some shadows of that in some Signal groups and Matrix rooms on private homeservers, but mostly those are spawning things to discuss next time we get together in person. I don't know anyone who "posts a full range of their thoughts" online anymore, except in fairly well secured private encrypted chat locations, because of just how toxic the whole place has become.
- abnercoimbre 4y agoYou opened my eyes, you're right! As a teenager I was quite open and vulnerable in online forums. Now my meaningful discussions are on Signal or private Matrix homeservers. This is a more common phenomenon than I thought.
- greenthrow 4y agoStep 1 is make friends with intelligent people who don't think the same way you do. If you are really looking for interesting and challenging conversation this is a prerequisite. A stranger doesn't know you and when you inevitably hit a point where they begin to question your motives or your seriousness or how informed you are, they will not give you the benefit of the doubt repeatedly. Eventually a stranger will write you off. But if you have an established friendship with someone, and have a baseline of trust and respect, then you can have those challenging discussions. But make sure you are really open to being wrong. Most people are not. Interesting discussion between people who disagree about important issues never really existed online. As someone who has been online since the 80s, you can take my word. The internet is mostly good at matching up people who agree due to the effect I mentioned above.
- nickdothutton 4y agoIMO, private dinners. For similar reasons I stopped attending conferences and shows because there was no-longer anything of interest that could be discussed there. That and a general decline in SnR. Once upon a time I would even speak at such events, at the invite of analyst firms. No longer. But more often than not I’ll take up an invite to a private dinner if there are interesting participants.
- RivieraKid 4y agoThere's one niche place which has a unique "feel" that I haven't experienced anywhere else - on HN, Reddit or Twitter. It's a blog section on a non-English website about Linux, but the blogs are about anything - current events, niche engineering topics, etc. The discussions are threaded, with no comment voting. It seems like people there have much more distinct and varied personalities compared to HN or Reddit, where comments sometimes seem like written by a single person. The quality has degraded over time though.
- cloudking 4y agoIn the early days these conversations were found on IRC. I think today, Discord is the modern version of IRC.
- Jaruzel 4y agoMy take is, that people don't converse properly anymore. We're too afraid of upsetting some hitherto unidentified minority or having an unpopular opinion that may get us cancelled. Online discourse is certainly not safe anymore, so yes we do self censor, and because of that we get out of the habit of expressing raw thought or trying to challenge the status quo for fear of being reported or banned. It's a real shame. The internet was supposed to be this great opportunity to unify people and help push through a new way of collaboration and debating, yet it's become an albatross around all our necks. Without healthy debate with controversial or opposing opinions we are never exposed to any viewpoints that differ from our own, so we all just end up swimming in our own echo chamber fishbowls, and the field of intellectual thinking just dies. I'd like to wax on further about this, but I'm typing (badly) on my phone which is in itself to blame for the brevity of online conversation.
- dc-programmer 4y agoIs this perception or reality though? Anecdotally, I don’t know a single person who has been “cancelled”. I share non-orthodox ideas in public all the time and in the worst case scenario it causes a few people not to like me. But who cares
- howenterprisey 4y agoThere are plenty of interesting conversations on the Internet, but relatively few happen in large communities, because those prevent many deep conversations from happening just by their nature. ...that wasn't a answer. Here's an answer. Although their flaws are numerous and well-documented, including their often distasteful beliefs, and although their communities have tons of structural ideological bias, you should check out the "rationalist" community. They can be found on various forums. The discussions on touchy issues have largely moved to forums that are smaller but still public, which can be found with a bit of effort. One issue with them, and at least one other community I know of with a lot of the "learn it yourself" mentality, is their relationship with subject-matter expertise and authority. It's bloody exhausting to defend oneself against a bunch of ignoramuses in a debate in a tree-style forum, so there's a lot of weird crap ideas floating around. But, at least it's vaguely what you're looking for.
- kirbys-memeteam 4y ago
- jacknews 4y agoAm I the only one confused by 'interesting' and 'touchy issues'? Is it some kind of code phrase? The author seems to be fishing for places to discuss particular unnamed issues. Do tell!
- JSavageOne 4y agoI'm building a site like HN where the goal is to reward quality contributions, while also allowing one to filter by topic (sort of like how Reddit has subreddits). https://zsync.xyz https://zsync.xyz Definitely a chicken and egg problem to attract users, but I've got some ideas in the works...
- web99 4y agoTwitter is your best bet.