7 ms·
Obama to eliminate all cap gains taxes for VCs and entrepreneurs
I was just watching Obama live in Ohio and he said he was going to put forward a bill to eliminate all capital gains taxes for anyone investing in startups. This essentially means that entrepreneurs and venture capitalists will pay no taxes at all. This is craziness, what's going on here.
- noodle 18y agoi am not an expert, but i would guess that it would be temporary to stimulate the new business area of the economy.
- davidw 18y agoIt's also "politics"...
- jsmcgd 18y agoSeems fair enough to me. Entrepreneurs and VCs are major wealth creators. It doesn't make too much sense to stifle nascent wealth with blanket taxation rules.
- hugh 18y agoExcept that all taxpayers are wealth creators, and this would just mean screwing the rest of 'em to benefit a small bunch.
- andreyf 18y agoExcept that all taxpayers are wealth creators Not as much as entrepreneurs who deal directly with customers - customers are less forgiving than bosses or PhD advisors. A boss may let you get away with not being productive if you're a nice enough person and trying hard to do your job, but customers want a product for their money.
- kingkongrevenge 18y agoRight, because a corporation that builds a new shipping terminal or rail line does nothing for society.
- joeter 18y agoWell, entrepreneurs are creating additional job opportunities for the economy at large. So if the tax cut creates a more favorable environment for entrepreneurship, there will be more entrepreneurs, and then more jobs should be available. Doesn't seem like the tax payers (who I assume you mean those whose majority of earnings are taxed under income tax rates) are really loosing out when they have more opportunity and a wider job selection.
- josefresco 18y agoNot crazy, and not exactly his idea (but might be a good one) Just like 'McCain's idea' of buying up bad mortgages and re-negotiating new values/payments ... Hillary proposed it months ago. Oh and davidw is right, politics as usual.
- jfarmer 18y agoThis has been a part of Obama's tax plan from the start, FWIW.
- fnazeeri 18y agoThis has been part of his tax plan since at least last year. It is pretty vague however (see section II on page 3 of his tax plan http://www.barackobama.com/pdf/taxes/Factsheet_Tax_Plan_FINAL.pdf http://www.barackobama.com/pdf/taxes/Factsheet_Tax_Plan_FINA...), for example he doesn't define what a "startup" is (e.g. does Bill Gates have to pay tax on his Microsoft stock?). In any case, it's not a new, off-the-cuff, erratic policy proposal.
- hugh 18y agoThat's a shame, because defining a "startup" is the most crucial part of the proposal, and I'm not convinced it can be done sensibly. I'm not sure I approve of the whole idea, but I have to admit it would have good consequences if it were implemented correctly. However, if I could be so bold as to propose Hugh's First Law of Politics, it would be this: The unintended consequences of any policy change are almost always more significant than the intended consequences. And this is almost always doubly so if you're either (a) deploying the military or (b) creating a huge new tax loophole. I foresee two problems. The first is under-defining startups. As others have pointed out by now, it's not that difficult for some rich guy to start a "startup company" in order to handle all his capital-gains producing affairs. Wanna buy an investment property? Better start a company to hold it, so that you can sell it without capital gains tax. Pretty soon you'd have a huge collection of "fake" startups which would probably swamp the real ones. The second possibility is over-defining startups. In order to overcome the problem of fake startups, you define that a "real" startup must have properties X, Y and Z. But some day somebody might start a real startup that's so innovative in its business model that it has X and Z but not Y. Pretty soon you're actually holding back the startup scene by restricting the kinds of startups which people can produce. And at the very least, it's going to create a new administrative burden for startups, who are going to have to spend some time proving to the government that they're real startups and aren't engaging in any unstartuplike activities. Those are the two problems I can think of, off the top of my head. There might be others which I can't think of (but which no doubt will seem obvious in hindsight).
- euccastro 18y agoRe: over-defining startups, For both problems you cite, the worst case scenario comes down to the situation without that law, right? A startup that has X and Z but not Y, will be no worse with the new law than without it. And if the "new administrative burden" wasn't worth it, startups could ignore it and pay their taxes. You may argue that startups that fail to get the tax discount would incur a competitive penalty. I don't think this handicap would be really insurmountable for enough startups that the loss from their failure would outweight the overall gains elsewhere.
- vaksel 18y agoHow is that crazy? Entrepreneurs are the ones that drive America forward. By encouraging investment it will make the country better and may very well rejuvenate the economy.
- opal 18y agoCrazy in that it's a big shift. Crazier if it actually happens. I don't see anyone saying that it's a bad idea though.
- Prrometheus 18y agoYou know what else would rejuvenate the economy? Cutting taxes on all businesses, and not playing favorites. America has the highest corporate tax rate in the OECD. I'm all for startups, I'm all for cutting taxes, but I'm a skeptic of politicians attempts to engineer society through the tax code. At best, it smacks of the old dream of a totalitarian state where an enlightened central director plans society for the good of all. At worst, it provides an incentive for corruption (ok, pig farmers get a tax break but not cow farmers, public school teachers get a tax deduction but not homeschoolers, etc. etc.).
- Retric 18y agoI think our tax rate is more about keeping acountants employed than collecting revenue. There are an insane number of loopholes out there so it becomes a race to see who has the most daring accounting team. I say pick whatever todays average effective tax rate is round it up to the next whole % and destroy all loopholes. That way we can eliminate the economic drag that our stupid tax code produces without reducing revenue. (Ok, this will never happen but I can hope.)
- ConradHex 18y agoHow big a sacrifice is this? In order for capital gains to get taxed there have to be capital gains in the first place. That look like a long shot in the short to medium term.
- anamax 18y ago> I was just watching Obama live in Ohio and he said he was going to put forward a bill to eliminate all capital gains taxes for anyone investing in startups. Remember that the "qualified investor" rules keep most of us out of a lot of startup investments.
- known 18y agoIn Japan, there are two options for paying tax on capital gains. The first, Withholding Tax all proceeds (regardless of profit or loss) at 1.05%. The second method, declaring proceeds as "taxable income" requires individuals to declare 26% of proceeds on their income tax statement. Many traders in Japan use both systems, declaring profits on the Withholding Tax system and losses as taxable income, minimizing the amount of income tax paid. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_gains_tax#Japan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_gains_tax#Japan
- auston 18y agoMy assumption is that this has a cap of $250k per year. I say this because he has repeatedly stated "You will not see an increase in taxes if you make less than $250k per year."
- pxlpshr 18y agoI like Obama and I'm most likely voting for him, but he was on the team (w/ the Clintons) that's partly to blame for this big mess. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ivmL-lXNy64 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ivmL-lXNy64 NINJA loans made me cry. No income, no job or assets = APPROVED!
- jobeirne 18y agoWhy would you still vote for the guy assuming you understand he had a hand in this current mess? That doesn't make any sense to me.
- SwellJoe 18y agoBecause the other option also had a hand in this mess? Damned if you do, Palined if you don't.
- DougBTX 18y agoNot everything is black and white, he could still like him for other reasons, or even just like him more than the other guy.
- pxlpshr 18y agoBecause I believe people learn from their mistakes...
- gnaritas 18y agoBad loans did not create the mess, they are a symptom of the mess. Excess credit caused by some serious deregulation is what created the mess. Once the excess credit was available, banks wanted to leverage it and that started bad loan crap because they can't profit of their newly available leverage if they don't loan it to someone. The dems are not to blame here, mostly the republicans are. The housing market was just a convenient place to dump all the excess credit, had that not been doable the investment banks would have just found some other sector to lend to, problem would still have occurred.
- hugh 18y ago
- abossy 18y agoHow are capital gains relevant to software entrepreneurs? It seems like they are assets that most early-stage companies wouldn't own and thus couldn't profit from.
- fallentimes 18y agoAnyone can issue dividends :).
- dmix 18y agoA healthy capital market (VC/angel) is always good for the high-technology industry. With this type of tax reduction, making investments in startups looks more appealing then other investments, driving more capital to software/biotech/chip makers etc.
- abstractbill 18y agoCapital gains are very relevant to software entrepreneurs. If you're a founder, or an investor, or a fortunate early-employee of a startup, capital gains is the tax you'll be paying on the money you make in the event that your company gets acquired.
- fallentimes 18y agoJust so I understand: So say a fictional company, let's call it "TicketStumbler", were to issue dividends instead of paying salaries (or pays minimal salaries), the investors and founders of this hypothetical company would not have to pay taxes? Or am I missing something?
- bilbo0s 18y agoWe should be careful how we structure this. Consider...Tens of Thousands of out of work financial types along with their lawyers. They start opening law offices and "financial services firms" because entrepreneurs can now operate tax free. Only now we are going back down this road of 'faux wealth creation' that got us here. Now consider Tens of Thousands of out of work real estate agents who start creating 'startups' that hawk foreclosed homes. Or Tens of Thousands of out of work mortgage brokers who start their own businesses slinging mortgages for those foreclosed homes. Are you starting to see the concern I have? Will these firms be considered 'startups', or part of that section of the economy that creates wealth? How should we treat the service economy in general? Are services 'wealth'? What are they backed by? These are very important questions. We should think through this stuff thoroughly prior to enacting policy. Questionable policy is what got us here in the first place. BTW - I love this idea if it can be somehow restricted to people who start a company producing things that other people will pay money for. As opposed to services. This is the definition of wealth creation. EDIT : I see payne92 has hit on a similar concern.
- greendestiny 18y agoApart from the other concerns over this plan, would that kind of restructuring of the labor force into independent operators be so bad? I think labor markets are the least efficient markets around, and I think we'd probably all be better off if they were more flexible.
- payne92 18y agoAs an entrepreneur and investor, I think Obama's proposal solves a "problem" that doesn't really exist. First, long term cap gains tax rates are already quite low (relative to regular income), and I can't think of a single entrepreneurial or investor scenario where I've seen: "gee, if tax rates were lower I'd {invest,start this company}" Second, it will be tough to implement in a loop-hole proof way. Every private equity and hedge fund will be organizing "startup" projects, so they can make take profits tax free. My guess is it will be capped, making it even less of any sort of meaningful incentive. My take: there are other tax areas that need work first, like code simplification and AMT.
- timr 18y agoAnother suggestion: raise the tax, and use it to fund universal health insurance -- something that will encourage entrepreneurs by making their lives easier.
- astine 18y agoIt will certainly give them less incentive to look for a job that provide health-care, but it won't give people any more incentive to engage in startups in particular. You are giving people less incentive to get rich (one big reason to begin a startup) and you are making it more difficult, by taxing them directly. So I don't think universal health coverage will do much for startups. It will mostly help low income and freelance laborers at the expense of the rich and the steadily employed. This might be a good thing, but it won't really help startups all that much.
- timr 18y agoThat's utter nonsense. People don't avoid starting companies because they're afraid of the capital gains tax on their anticipated profits (At least, people with a healthy dose of perspective don't do this). If you're going to pick from the list of reasons that people avoid starting companies, at the top of the list has to be the fact that most are afraid that they'll be unable to take care of themselves and their family during the lean times. Universal health coverage is an obvious step toward alleviating this fear. The abstract, vague notion of someday paying a (rather low) tax on the eventual, theoretical profits from the venture doesn't even come close.
- rajat 18y agoIt's just a favor for the rich (the cynical part of me asks how many VCs give money to Democrats?). Most small startups, computers, software or otherwise, are not suffering from high capital gains taxes. A general corporate tax cut (we have the 2nd highest corporate tax rate in the world), perhaps targeted at small companies, would be a lot more interesting.
- mrkurt 18y agoHealth care's a bigger deterrent to startups than capital gains taxes are.
- calambrac 18y agoHe also has a healthcare plan that's pretty friendly to small businesses and individuals. http://www.barackobama.com/issues/healthcare/ http://www.barackobama.com/issues/healthcare/
- bkmrkr 18y agoWhy can't I just create a hedge fund and call it a startup? Bam no taxes.
- Prrometheus 18y agoPoliticians say things all the time. You must be new at this.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoJust for some background, I'm a libertarian (though not a party member) I'm really skeptical of the tax plans both parties are putting forward. Additionally I'm extra super skeptical of having one party completely in charge of the country, which is where it looks like we are heading. If I understand Obama correctly, investing in startups would be tax-free but as soon as you make 250K per year we're going to zap you with extra taxes? Seems like that would reward investors, which is good, but then stick it to the sole proprietors who make it on their own (bootstrap). So -- good news for one type of startup and bad news for another? Beats me. The tax code is a complete mess, and for one, I'm tired of politicians continuing to tinker with it to engineer society one way or another. It's dumb.
- jdavid 18y agothis can be really great if you are starting a company and it is in pre ipo growth mode, somethimes you have to pay tax on shares that are not sellable.
- lanceweatherby 18y agoMr. Obama's official tax plan states the following: Eliminate capital gains taxes for small businesses, cut corporate taxes for firms that invest and create jobs in the United States, and provide tax credits to reduce the cost of healthcare and to reward investments in innovation. * What you have stated he said is very different, and perhaps he has changed his position. Regardless, I would love to hear Obama explain what he means by eliminating capital gains for startups and small businesses? There is a big diff between eliminating all capital gains taxes on start-ups and small businesses and eliminating all capital gains taxes for individuals that found/invest in start-ups and small businesses. Small businesses and startups have very little capital gains liabilities. Entrepreneurs that start successful companies and those that invest in them have potentially huge capital gains liabilities and the latter by definition reside in the wealth class that Obama wants to tax more. You really think he is proposing that folks like PG, Cuban, Larry, Sergey, and Bill Gates for that matter pay no taxes on their capital gains. I think not. The concept would encourage investment so I like it. But I want the details which have not been forthcoming.
- anamax 18y ago> You really think he is proposing that folks like PG, Cuban, Larry, Sergey, and Bill Gates for that matter pay no taxes on their capital gains. He doesn't have to propose that because it's already law. I don't know about PG, but the estates of the others, which will get the vast majority of what they earned, won't pay taxes when they die. At most they're going to pay capital gains on what they spend while they're alive, and even then there are some tricks. Inheritance tax is optional if your assets are liquid enough and large enough. In short, when Gates and Buffet said that estate taxes should be higher, they were talking about taxing other people. And you thought that they set up those foundations to do good....
- lanceweatherby 18y agoI beg to differ. Estates are currently taxed. I believe to the tune of 45% of the amount over $2 million. As far as capital gains goes, they are due when you sell your capital. In the case of PG this most likely occurred when he sold ViaWeb. Everytime Larry and Sergey sell their GOOG stock they incur captial gains. Obama is generally proposing raising the capital gains tax from 15% to 20% for anyone that earns over $250,000. Any startup founder that has a successful exit should make a heck of a lot more then $250k. By def an angel investor must earn $200k per year or have a net work of more than $1 million. And that is why I want to see the details.
- helveticaman 18y agoFabulous. Kick ass.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- t0pj 18y ago"More likely, you'll just get a lot of people doing things that can be made to look on paper like startups." http://paulgraham.com/inequality.html http://paulgraham.com/inequality.html
- dfranke 18y agoWrong. He said he's going to eliminate capital gains taxes on startups not on startup investors. So if your startup buys stock in other companies and makes a capital gain, it doesn't pay taxes on it. Hear recently of any startup doing such a thing? No, I didn't think so.
- Alex3917 18y ago"That’s why I’ve proposed eliminating all capital gains taxes on investments in small businesses and start-ups. And today, I’m proposing an additional temporary business tax incentive through next year to encourage new investments."
- dfranke 18y agoHmm. That and the PDF version of Obama's position statement suggest your interpretation. Obama's convention speech and the HTML version suggest mine. I wonder if he's even clear on the difference.
- Allocator2008 18y agoSenator Obama has it on the money here I think. Going back to the depression, what was it that really got things moving and finally led to the prosperity of the 1950's? Well, WWII, which stimulated production. The best, perhaps the only, "way out" of a depression is new enterprise. We don't need a war for that of course. We just need new products, new idea, new technologies, which create new jobs and importantly "moves money" again. The problem is money is "frozen", being "hoarded" by scared banks and investors. So giving a tax incentive to entrepreneurs can stimulate the economy by getting start-ups a hand-up, which gets investment money moving, which creates jobs, etc. Socializing banks will not lead to prosperity in the long-run. Free-enterprise will.