12 ms·
Rapid Green Energy Transition Will Likely Result in Trillions of Net Savings
- Bostonian 4y agoCritiqued at https://www.manhattancontrarian.com/blog/2022-9-16-cost-of-the-green-energy-transition-who-you-gonna-believe-me-or-your-lyin-eyes https://www.manhattancontrarian.com/blog/2022-9-16-cost-of-t... . '[H]ere are what I believe to be the main problems with the work: The principal driver of the whole thing is a forecast of rapid and continuous declines in the cost of wind turbines, solar panels and batteries. The assumption is that costs of these things will continue to decline exponentially without limit indefinitely into the future. From the “Results” section: “We know of no empirical evidence supporting floor costs and do not impose them . . . “ Of the three technologies at issue (wind, solar, and batteries), the one I know the most about is batteries. Here is the Way, et al., chart of price history of batteries and the projection they use for the future: ... As to continuing rapid declines in the prices of wind turbines and solar panels, I’ll believe it when I see it. Yes there have been substantial declines to date. But at this point these strike me as mature technologies. The main issues in getting them built and operational are mining and processing huge quantities of metals and minerals, forming the metals and minerals into the devices, transporting the (very large and heavy) devices to their sites, and installing them. How are those things going to get cheaper by any substantial amount, let alone another order of magnitude? The treatment of the energy storage problem in this paper is wholly inadequate, and bordering on the fantastical. The cost fantasies as to short-term storage are discussed above. As to longer term storage, from the Supplemental Information, pages 38-45, it appears that the proposed solution is almost entirely hydrogen, supposedly to be produced by electrolysis from water. (Here, they mostly.call the proposed storage medium “P2X fuels,” somehow implying that it might be something other than hydrogen, much like with New York and its “DEFR” fantasy.). There is currently essentially no existing prototype or demonstration project of this so-called “green hydrogen” anywhere in the world from which realistic cost projections can be derived. (From the 2022 JP Morgan Asset Management Annual Energy Paper, page 39: “Current green hydrogen production is negligible. . . .”). Way, et al., do cite some costs of existing electrolyzers, but I can find no discussion in the paper of the issue that producing hydrogen on a scale sufficient to back up the entire world electricity system is going to require electrolyzing the ocean. And the millions of tons of toxic chlorine gas thereby produced are going to go — where? The problems of dealing with enormous amounts of hydrogen — like explosiveness, embrittlement of pipelines, and the like — are dealt with with a wave of the hand. The creation of a massive green hydrogen infrastructure as the backup for wind and sun hasn’t even been begun by the most fanatical of the green energy crazies like Germany, California or New York. They take one look at the real costs and balk.'
- pydry 4y agoI see his comments section had to explain what pumped hydro was to him.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThat's a very poor critique, as the URL, the title and the first sentence would suggest. Bad even by the low standards of these things generally. edit: Turns out the author runs a climate change denial think tank: https://www.desmog.com/global-warming-policy-foundation/ https://www.desmog.com/global-warming-policy-foundation/ and has been talking nonsense on this topic for over a decade: > During a question and answer period following the debate, a question from the audience nearly left Menton stammering. What plausible alternative explanations, he was asked, account for the obvious warming trend shown in actual temperature measurements since the nineteenth century? Menton’s initial response was ridiculous, consisting of but one word: “Clouds.” After an uncomfortable silence ensued, Menton continued: “Cosmic rays. Nobody knows what’s causing it.” https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/climate-science-on-trial/ https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/climate-science-on-t... further edit: topical bit of info about one of the billionaires anonymously funding this "charity": > Hintze is also chairman of the board of trustees for the Prince's Foundation for Building Community , to which he has donated £683,954 in recent years. In 2009, Hintze received The Prince of Wales Medal for Arts Philanthropy from Prince Charles, who has been a vocal critic of climate sceptics. > In 2010 during a speech at St James' Palace, the prince said climate sceptics were peddling "pseudo science". In a speech at the European Parliament a year ago , the prince said climate sceptics were having a "corrosive effect" on public opinion and were playing a "reckless game of roulette" with the future of the planet. Last December, Hintze replaced Hylton as his charity adviser with Major William Mackinlay, Prince Charles's former equerry. Worth noting that the Hylton fellow mentioned was ousted as part of a political scandal mentioned further up this article: https://web.archive.org/web/20150817181047/http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/mar/27/tory-donor-climate-sceptic-thinktank https://web.archive.org/web/20150817181047/http://www.thegua...
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoOK. But what about the idea that renewable energy costs have no floor?
- bushbaba 4y agoAlso much more consistent and predictable energy prices which will be huge.
- pydry 4y agoOnly for solar/wind/pumped storage/biomass though. Not for nuclear power: >We constructed an additional scenario in which nuclear plays a dominant role in replacing fossil fuels, but this is much more expensive than the other scenarios. For example, using a 1.4% discount rate, the expected NPC is about $25 trillion more than for the No Transition scenario.
- kderbyma 4y agothe cynic in me says that those savings will just become profits for the companies and government through taxes and greed....so savings are relative. Also it seems to be highly dependent on solar mass adoption
- seventytwo 4y agoYou know, collectively, we can do something about that… It’s a political decision in society to allow that added value to be sucked up by those who are already wealthy.
- mistrial9 4y agoyes and no - each day it is game rules plus the ability to negotiate; elected officials come in all flavors
- sheepdestroyer 4y agoIsn't it too late for that now that the power imbalance afforded to Capital owners is so disproportionate? I think that's what transpired from Piketty's "Capital in the Twenty-First Century"
- stormbrew 4y agoHistory is long, and capitalism as we know it is only a couple centuries old (and that's being generous). It's easy to forget that there was a before because it's very common to frame even old economic systems in modern terms, but things changing is the only real constant. There'll be an after too.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoHow do you define capitalism, I’m curious, in this context? What was it 200 years ago that made it different from 400 years ago?
- 4y ago
- qclibre22 4y agoInteresting who funded this study: Institute for New Economic Thinking was founded with an initial pledge of $50 million from businessman and philanthropist George Soros . I'm sure researchers try extra hard to not be influenced by the funders and pursue real science. Let's hope they did in this case.
- burkaman 4y agoIf anyone is curious about the full list of funders: > This work was supported by funding from Partners for a New Economy (R.W. and J.D.F.); Baillie Gifford (J.D.F.); the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no. 730427 (COP21 RIPPLES) (R.W.); and the Oxford Martin School , through the Institute of New Economic Thinking and the Post-Carbon Transition programme ( LDR00530 ) (M.C.I. and P.M.). This research was also funded by the Economics of Energy Innovation and System Transition project ( EEIST ), which is jointly funded through UK Aid by the UK Government Department for Business, Energy, and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) and the Children’s Investment Fund Foundation ( CIFF ) (R.W. and M.C.I.). It would be truly extraordinary if George Soros was able to use his indirect connection to one of eight funders of this study to influence its findings, but I suppose we'll never know for sure.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoInteresting that you plucked George Soros out in particular. Is this /pol/?
- 4y ago
- jasec57322 4y ago
- nynx 4y agoAlright, man
- jasec57322 4y ago
- gnramires 4y agoPlease have a look here: https://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/ https://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/ The evidence is clear and uncontroversial (and has been for decades).
- jasec57322 4y ago
- GlenTheMachine 4y agoThe problem is that the OP, by "just asking questions", is engaging in an enormous time imbalance. It's a standard tactic of skeptics. Ask a simple question. Takes only a minute or two. But the answer turns out to not be so simple, and requires much time in composing an answer. And of course the answer also invokes concepts, terms, models, research, etc that themselves are not simple, and so the questioner asks another round of "simple questions", which take significant time to answer. After a few rounds of this the answerers are exhausted and the questioner proclaims victory in the sense that he/she still has questions, and the answerers "can't" answer them, typically because they have jobs, kids, significant others, and in general a life outside answering skeptic questions. There is a tremendous amount of literature on this in both the popular press and scientific journals. You can google those as easily as we can, and if you were serious about finding the honest answers to your questions that's where you would start.
- 4y ago
- vondur 4y agoCan we really build batteries at the scale needed for this? I’m a bit skeptical.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoWhy? The materials needed for LiFePO4 batteries are very common, and we only need a few dozen large factories and refineries. Compared to the size of the fossil fuel extraction industry, it's tiny. The only question is how quickly we can build up to the scale needed, not if we can.
- brtkdotse 4y agoPhosphorus is essential to growing food and shortages have already begun.
- lukeschlather 4y agoThere's no shortage of phosphorus. As prices go up extraction from human waste becomes profitable and all municipalities just do it. We invest in closed loop systems we stop having to think about energy and agricultural inputs as extractive, there is minimal possibility of "shortage" it's just a closed-loop system that occasionally needs to be topped off a bit.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoYou don't "just do" anything on that scale.
- ncmncm 4y agoBut you do them.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoWe have a shortage of refined Lithium and Phosphate. We have no shortage of the unrefined elements in profitable concentrations.
- tomohawk 4y agoI'm willing to let the EU place their bet on this, and be the 2nd mover instead of the first one. Early bird may get the worm, but the 2nd mouse gets the cheese.
- lnsru 4y agoI am just curious about manufacturing capacity of these green energy gadgets in Western World. When I look at the parts for my solar installation everything is made in Asia. My system is rather simple: 4-6 panels each ~400 Wp and stupid single phase inverter. That battery production isn’t a thing in the West is already well known fact. In my eyes this green energy transition totally depends on factories in Asia. And builds strong dependence since nothing can be made domestically (at least no mainstream solar panels/electronics in Germany).
- kbenson 4y agoBattery production capacity is becoming more decentralized, as countries with large production capabilities stay somewhat stagnant but other countries build factories. China's percentage of world battery production is expected to drop over the next few years while most other countries are expected to increase production capacity.[1] See Tesla's investment in the gigafactory or Panasonic's investment in battery manufacturing in Kansas for examples of this happening. Germany specifically, since you mention it, is expected to surge quite a bit in the global battery market. 1: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1249871/share-of-the-global-lithium-ion-battery-manufacturing-capacity-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1249871/share-of-the-glo... P.S. I suggest opening the statista link in a private tab, I just noticed the second time you visit it you are paywall blocked.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoyeah that and pretty much every computer in the world
- Gare 4y agoBut the machines that make "computers" are designed and produced in Europe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASML_Holding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASML_Holding If you know how to make the tool, you probably know how to make the product.
- prottog 4y agoOnly theoretically. In practice, it takes a lot of know-how unseen by the public to make a product in a manner that is price-competitive against other players in the market. Europe is obviously technologically capable of building chips and assembling functioning laptops that are ready for consumption, since as you pointed out they are capable of making the machines that make the chips; but that's still a long way from saying that they can start churning out Macbook Airs.
- 01100011 4y agoGarbage comment from an uninformed SW engineer: How, in the current economic and geopolitical environment, can they project that production costs will continue to decline? Green tech requires massive amounts of dirty energy to produce. It also has been benefiting from globalization which is now going in reverse. I would add at least 5 years to any timeline given because of the recalibrating global energy and materials supply chains will be undergoing over time. We're probably short of copper. Is anyone figuring out a way to use aluminum as a substitute in many applications? We can work around several of the other critical shortages(nickel, cobalt, not-so-rare rare earths, lithium) in time, either with alternatives or increased extraction, but copper seems like a tough one. There is a lot of wishful thinking or naivete in the political class driving these transitions. I agree that we need to move rapidly to decarbonize but there seems to be a lack of appreciation for the actual work involved in the transition. There is also a parasite-class of folks whispering deceitful tales in the ears of politicians(ahem, hydrogen, ahem) which really only cares about getting their cut. Politicians need to understand you don't just order solar panels and batteries off Amazon. Someone needs to make them, and that someone better be a country you're not in a proxy war or a hot war with. We need to invest in practical measures not just fairy tales that leave us in the dark for a decade or more while we figure out hard lessons.
- joshe 4y agoThe quick answer is that we are not short of any of those materials. We might not be producing enough right now, but there's far more than enough that can be mined or recycled inexpensively. Increased prices will cause more mining and recycling, eventually the price will settle at the cost of production + something for profit. The something for profit is quite small, the coast for low risk capital is ~5% a year. There might be a 5-10 period when profits are high for miners, but eventually the profits will be competed away by new entrants. (Except if you have a mine that produces very cheaply because it is so rich or easy to operate, these people will stay high profit. The most expensive mines will just make back they're capital costs + return). You can see this with fracking which is horribly unprofitable. Hedge funds have lost billions over building fracking wells.
- 4y ago
- darepublic 4y agoI have stood here before, inside the pouring rain (of trillions)
- GlenTheMachine 4y agoOne thing I've not seen a decent discussion of is what industries benefit from enormous amounts of almost free electricity? Other than the manufacturers of wind, solar, etc systems, how does this effect the economy? Obviously that effect is going to be significant, but what exactly does it look like?
- alexvoda 4y agoAluminium production, desalination, and more
- alexvoda 4y agoEventually synthetic fuel will become economically viable.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoEventually is right now. Hydrogen and ammonia electrolyzers are being built by the tens of megawatts as we speak. Presently for chemical synthesis, but use in fuel cells or turbines is not far behind. Simple synthetic hydrocarbons follow soon after that.
- alexvoda 4y agoHydrogen is still cheaper to get from methane. And synthetic hydrocarbons are still expensive. But we are moving towards economic viability. The desired point to get to is to have fossil fuel extraction unprofitable, economically nonviable. At that point even the most ardent deniers of climate change will have to give up fossil fuels or face bankruptcy.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoOnce you include the risk profile any government which is actually governing (I know this is getting rarer) will want a fair bit of synthetic production capacity to reduce the impact of price shocks. The costs of ammonia and urea shortages to a country are much higher than the sticker price when trucking and agriculture depend on them. This strategic capacity investment is sufficient to set off economies of scale which will see the baseline prices start to look less appealing -- even with the current state of massively subsidized fossil fuels. The hard part is getting neoliberal governments to do the thing that is actually the only economically sane option when they've all got massive conflicts of interest.
- FunnyBadger 4y agoComplete BS. Green Energy has radically lower thermodynamic efficiency and energy density than ANY other currently used energy source (especially fossil and nuclear). These two qualities of an energy source have a direct relationship to economic efficiency and utility. Economics and Energy are 1:1 causal - economic growth ONLY occurs with energy growth. Lowering the quality of energy means lowering economic productivity, efficiency and activity. When they say it will result in "trillions of net savings", this is PRECISELY the same as saying that you can increase profits by driving all costs to zero. It's either fraud or ignorance to claim such a thing.
- boxed 4y agoThe thermodynamics and energy density is irrelevant. The external costs of fossil fuels in a scenario without a green transition is so enormous that it can literally crash the current civilization. That means the net savings could also in the worst case scenario be the entire world economy plus all future growth for thousands or even more years.
- tucosan 4y agoNo. Fossil fuels may be more energy dense But they need to be extracted, refined, transported and warehoused. The costs of greenhouse gas emissions through their environmental side effects are not even part of that calculation. In the meantime, a wind turbine keeps generating energy as long a there is wind. We can't deplete wind or ocean waves as a resource. The more we invest in renewable energy, the more efficient per follar speny it becomes.
- samatman 4y agoI downvoted because the first paragraph is dead wrong and needs correcting. Carbon accounting for fossil fuels absolutely includes extraction, refinement, and transportation costs. Saying that it doesn't undermines everything else you say, because this is easily checked.
- pfdietz 4y agoAh, the energy density canard. It's becoming a dog whistle for identifying people who don't know what they're talking about. Energy density doesn't matter; cost does. It's possible to have a high energy density and a high cost -- for example, nuclear fission.
- kkfx 4y agoI'm honestly tired about PR positions written or referring some beancounters ideas of the world, regularly completely detached from the real world. Personally, smelling rodent early enough I've built a new home, airtight as needed/possible, well insulated, with a (still rare these days) heat-pump VMC, other heat-pumps for heating (water-water) and hot sanitary water (air-water), a small p.v. plant with lithium storage enough to being fully autonomous when heating is not needed and partially autonomous in winters months: the result is simple autonomy is not achievable, nor real economy to pay back the huge investment. I mean, I do not invest to earn in money but to guarantee comfort of life in "bad water" expecting unreliability and high services prices, but in monetary terms it's a TOTAL FAIL. Heat pumps can potentially last around 10 years, lithium battery being used very little (daily 15% authorized DOD + eventual blackouts) perhaps the same. Inverters probably can last more, so solar panels, but they'll probably be not much interesting to keep after that amount of time. Long story short ~60k€ for just 10 years of usage. Even with ARTIFICIALLY skyrocketed prices (which is a crime against humanity than in Democracy demand justice, like life-long sentences, outside Democracy demand simple brutal revenge) economically is a total fail. If I add a BEV to the mix is even worse: so far NOTHING is really designed to work on p.v. so even being a WFH worker, so able to recharge a car at home when the Sun shine witch might be most of the time, NO DAMN VEHICLE on sale offer a standard data port to talk to a p.v. invert and get ONLY available power from the Sun like stationary BMS/batteries do (so something we already have at commercial level of evolution), equally almost no vehicle can act as a battery to the home, very few offer a 240V AC inverter with 3kW maximum but NOTHING really integrated nor integrable. Similarly the same happen for hot water where only few systems offer modbus PARTIAL control of the system from a central energy management device witch is normally something home-made since on sale there is again essentially ZERO to really try the self-consumption route. Why such route? Because is the only meaningful choice technically speaking. Yes, you are reading correctly: keeping a national grid stable with big p.v. plants it's simply IMPOSSIBLE until we get superconductive global grid (and I'm not sure if it's possible in that case either). AC national grids are designed to sustain a slowly changing mean load, when the load change fast controlling the grid frequency is a nightmare. That's why the big push to BEV dreaming an surrealist scenario of soooo many connected batteries on wheel that keep regulating the network frequency or offload such tremendous costs to individuals. Those who really think we can run NOW/in a decade the world on renewable can be classified in two categories: dreamers completely outside the real world, not much different than children dreaming Star Trek or CRIMINALS who try a hyper-big scam fully know the outcome. You do not have to believe but to know, so since we are on HN just try to design/outline such renewable economy being honest.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoHow do you make cement and steel?
- pfdietz 4y agoIron ore is reduced with hydrogen. Some carbon needs to be added to make steel from direct reduced iron, but that carbon doesn't need to come from fossil fuels. Cement needs heat, but it doesn't need heat from fossil fuels. And cement will need CO2 capture in any case -- even today, half the CO2 emission from cement is the CO2 released by decomposing limestone, not from combustion.
- cassepipe 4y agoIf you can suffer the french accent, I believe Jean-Marc Jancovici is making some good points about this issue : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s254IPHXgVA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s254IPHXgVA
- engineer_22 4y agoIf you want your model to output a certain result, just make the right assumptions.
- cryptonector 4y agoAccess to power / energy is what wealth is all about today, and has been for over 100 years. However rapidly a "green energy transition" could possibly happen, if it means reducing access to power / energy, then it means a drop in standards of living. In some parts of the world that means more than merely tightening the belt -- it can mean real hunger, while in many others it might mean a return to poverty, though perhaps not hunger. Moreover, people will probably not accept a permanent (or permanent-seeming) reduction in standards of living.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI'm not sold that this would happen. It seems to me the plan in the US is to add green energy, and then slowly replace the dirty energy with more green. I admit I am ignorant of the plans of other nations, but from where I am sitting I don't see any reason to believe there will ever be a reduction in available energy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cryptonector 4y agoWell, that can't be "rapid". TFA is about a "rapid" transition. I'm saying that's just politically infeasible unless you define "rapid" as "as fast as we can without impoverishing people" or unless you define it as "damn the consequences, just do it". That's pretty obviously true. If you take the first alternative, however, you have to consider how long these touted savings will take to materialize and the opportunity cost of the investment needed to get there. For example if you install grid-tied solar panels for your house it will take some number of years for that investment (and upkeep) to pay for itself -- if the lifetime of the installation is 30 years and it pays for itself in 10, it might be worth it, but whether it is worth it will depend not just on the 20 years' worth of savings you'll get, but also on the opportunity cost of the capital needed to fund that solar installation. Opportunity costs are often hard to gauge, so it's easy to con people with analyses that fail to take opportunity costs into account. The opportunity cost of an investment that will yield "trillions" in savings must be substantial because the investment itself must be substantial (if it was free, we'd have done it already, so it must be substantial!).
- ncmncm 4y agoOne of the authors, Doyne Farmer, was among those who invented chaos theory, noted in "Chaos: Making a New Science" by James Gleick, back when (1987, if you can believe it, 35 years ago).
- Proven 4y ago