13 ms·
Not a fan of the British crown (why are they exempt from taxes during record high inflation) but who should they return the diamond to - Afghanistan (it was the
by alephnerd 4y ago
Not a fan of the British crown (why are they exempt from taxes during record high inflation) but who should they return the diamond to - Afghanistan (it was the Durranis that looted it from Nader Shah after he looted it from the Mughals), India (Maharaja Ranjit Singh took it as tribute from Shah Shuja after conquering Kashmir from the Durranis), or Pakistan (the Sikh Empire capital was Lahore and the Durrani Empire capital was Peshawar until the last Sikh-Afghan War, thus any claim India or Afghanistan has on either Empire's legacy is also owned by Pakistan, even inspite of Partition or the Durrand Line).
On top of that, if it goes to India - should it be owned by the Central/Federal government, the Punjab government (the state that is the core of the former Sikh Empire), Jammu Kashmir's Government (because of Shah Shuja and Raja Gulab Singh), Delhi Government (the Mughal capital), or Andhra Pradesh Government (the mine is located there). And is it worth putting a logjam into the Free Trade Agreement India and the UK are currently negotating?
If they give it to Pakistan, should it go to the Pakistan Federal Government, Punjab Government (the state that is the core of the former Sikh Empire), AJK Government (because of Shah Shuja and Raja Gulab Singh), or Khyber Pakhtunkwa Government (the state that is the core of the former Sikh Empire and former Durrani Empire)? Is it worth putting British Humanitarian and Military Aid at risk?
If they give it to Afghanistan, is it to the Taliban led government, or the government in exile? Is it worth putting British Aid and potential recognition at risk?
It's a conundrum and an complicated legal question that honestly isn't worth it for any of the countries, all of whom have bigger issues to deal with, also it can be argued that the Sikh Empire handed it to the UK fairly.
- pippy 4y agoAlso would the world be a better place if they gave it back to some third party, so it can be sold to a private collection and be locked in a vault somewhere? Where it is now has a lot of historical and cultural significance. It is currently being admired publicly by thousands of people, sitting on the coffin of Queen Elisabeth.
- blibble 4y agothe Imperial State Crown is the one sitting on HMQs coffin and has the Cullinan II diamond (among many others) the one in the article (containg the Koh-I-Noor) is the Queen Mother's Crown
- OJFord 4y ago> It is currently being admired publicly by thousands of people, sitting on the coffin of Queen Elisabeth. [sic] I think you mistook that photograph in the article or misread the caption - that was Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother's coffin; not Elizabeth II's. The crown 'currently being admired publicly [...]' does not contain the Kohinoor: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_State_Crown https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_State_Crown
- soperj 4y ago> It's a conundrum and an complicated legal question that honestly isn't worth it for any of the countries, all of whom have bigger issues to deal with. Sure, but the crown shouldn't keep it. Give it to a neutral 3rd party until an agreement is in place.
- alephnerd 4y agoWho would the neutral 3rd party be? It would still cause the same argument as above. The United States (Afghanistan would say no), China (India would say no), the Commonwealth (Afghanistan isn't a member), the UN (which Afghan government?), etc.
- Apocryphon 4y agoSri Lanka, they could use the help right now.
- alephnerd 4y agoSri Lanka hasn't recognized the Taliban government and India would also say no due to the China factor.
- Apocryphon 4y agoNo one has yet recognized the Taliban government. Give it to Bangladesh then.
- alephnerd 4y agoPakistan would say no due to strained relations, and state level Indian governments would pressure the federal government to say no due to anti-Bangladeshi sentiment in India (sort of similar to anti-Central American sentiment in the US with an added Islamophobic element or Ethnic element depending on the region) - appearing to vacillate to Bangladesh over what is basically a dumb symbolic issue would piss off voters in very narrow Indian elections.
- Turing_Machine 4y agoIt's like the argument that California should be given back to Mexico, when Mexico itself was a Spanish colonial construct.
- abeppu 4y agohttps://www.mercurynews.com/2022/01/25/california-redwood-forest-returned-to-native-tribal-group/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2022/01/25/california-redwood-fo... Update: To clarify, Turing_Machine likened the suggestion that California be given to Mexico to alephnerd's description of the complex and unclear proper ownership of the Koh-I-Noor. I claim that the situation in California is simpler, at least in some places, because there are native Californians to give stuff back to and multiple tribes are willing to cooperatively take custody and stewardship of the land, as the InterTribal Sinkyone Wilderness Council has. This is in many ways the opposite of Pakistan, India and Afghanistan having competing / mutually incompatible claims.
- alephnerd 4y agoTribal Soverignity is a different story than nation state soverignity. The Federal government has supremacy over Tribal and State Government. Worcester v. Georgia still holds edit: the OP is actually a good example now that he explained it.
- Turing_Machine 4y ago"Give it back to local indigenous groups" is an entirely different thing from "Give it back to Mexico". What is now California was never controlled by what is now Mexico until the Spanish colonizers showed up. The Aztecs (who were themselves brutal colonizers, as it happens) weren't running the show there or anything like that.
- tomcam 4y agoHow far back does one go for indigenous groups? Kennewick Man, in the case of Washington State? How do we figure out which Indian tribe gets how much, of the dozens we know about in California history? Do we discount for those tribes that owned slaves?
- armchairhacker 4y agoIdeally it should be “bought” from the 3 countries and they should receive a sort of donation. AFAIK they need money a lot more than Britain, and tangible food and resources are a lot more useful than a pretty diamond. Though I kind of doubt this will happen…
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> they need money a lot more than Britain, and tangible food and resources are a lot more useful than a pretty diamond This is the comment’s point. The benefits of a trade deal might measure up to the worth of this diamond in minutes.
- alephnerd 4y agoThe diamond is worth only $10-12 billion (edit: at most), which is a decent chunk of money, but only 0.25% of the Indian Federal Government's YEARLY budget or only 10% of the Pakistani Federal Government's YEARLY budget. EDIT: apparently the diamond is worth even less - google fu has failed me yet again
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gw99 4y agoPowder it. Problem solved.
- valarauko 4y agoHere's a solution: regard the diamond as the property and legacy of the people, with the royals holding it as mere stewards. Rather than basing the center of the nation at the location of the royal court, consider a population weighted centroid as the center of the legal holding. So for example, while the former Sikh empire was based at Lahore, much of the western Punjab was sparsely populated till the early 20th century, with the bulk of the empire's population in Eastern Punjab and the non-punjabi segments of present Northern India. As the diamond moved hands, perhaps we can also weigh how long it rested in each region, so a nation (i.e., its people) that held it for a brief while has a commensurate level of claim to its ownership. I think the issue of federal government vs state government - federal government holds it as stewards of the people.
- alephnerd 4y agoBut the owner before the Sikh Empire was the Durrani Empire before which was the Afsharids before which was the Mughals. So is it India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Iran, Georgia, Azerbaijan, Armenia, or Turkmenistan if using the broadest definition of a successor state. And "federal government holds it as stewards of the people" would piss off a subset of voters in both Punjabs, JK, Himachal, Haryana, Delhi, Chandigarh, and KPK - all states that have mixed feelings with their federal government. Elections tend to be very close in multi-party parliamentary systems (both for federal elections and local elections).
- valarauko 4y agoWe know the boundaries of each empire, and can make guesstimates of each population. Weigh each claim by how long they held it, and the population of each historic state at the time, not the modern successor state. So the centroid of "ownership" would move across South Asia over time (I doubt a weighed centroid would ever leave South Asia). Advance the clock, and the centroid would advance from Southeast India to the north over time. Once the clock reaches the point at which the British ransomed it from Duleep Singh, award it the successor state of wherever the centroid is.
- 4y ago
- twblalock 4y agoDavid Frum's new Atlantic article shows a similar situation in Nigeria: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/10/benin-bronzes-nigeria-return-stolen-art/671245/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/10/benin-b... Basically the Nigerian federal government, the state government of Benin, and the descendants of the kings of Benin who originally owned the stolen Benin bronzes all think they should be the ones to whom the bronzes should be returned -- and in the case of the current king, he asserts they are his family's private property. On top of that, there is a long track record of art being stolen from modern-day Nigerian museums and sold to other museums or collectors, and returning the bronzes just for them to be re-stolen does not benefit any of the parties involved.
- UncleMeat 4y agoOkay. But that's surely not a reason why the Brits get to keep it. "This is too hard, let's give up and keep bringing in tourist money to our museums through these artifacts" feels like an awfully convenient excuse.
- zibby8 4y agoPossession is 9/10 of the law.
- MonkeyClub 4y agoThis is along the lines of the other, equally glorious line: "Property is theft, therefore theft is property."
- p_j_w 4y agoYou won't mind if my gang and I steal your TV at gunpoint then?
- karaokeyoga 4y agoI would mind, because possession is nine tenths of the law.
- archduck 4y agoDecree that it be split equally among all invested parties, Judgment of Solomon style. (Though in this case, they may end up having to follow through, i.e. cutting their baby into equal parts.)
- alephnerd 4y agoBut which Afghanistan - the Taliban or the basically nonexistent Government in Exile?
- psychphysic 4y agoThe obvious partial answer is to stop parading it around while that questions considered. Tbh I don't care where the rock is or who owns it. Regarding the crown I just wish investments were transparent on par with sovereign wealth funds (Norway's Global Pension Fund is gold standard imo). Where are they investing, is it ESG? Whats the structure for tax purposes. Etc.
- SnowHill9902 4y agoThat’s a common misconception. Salomon never intended to actually split anything. He could have said “if you don’t reach an agreement I’ll keep the baby myself” and it’d have worked alright since the mother would have cried (loudest).
- pclmulqdq 4y agoAccording to which source? I think the people quoting the "split the baby" story are quoting a bible story which is unambiguous. Most old testament stories are parables that got written down and edited to support the religion, so I wouldn't be surprised if some sort of Judaic parable (or a parable from another culture) said that Solomon had a less violent solution.
- jobs_throwaway 4y agoNot according to the Bible's (translated) telling: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Kings%203%3A16-28&version=CEV https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Kings%203%3... >They argued back and forth in front of Solomon, 23 until finally he said, “Both of you say this live baby is yours. 24 Someone bring me a sword.” >A sword was brought, and Solomon ordered, 25 “Cut the baby in half! That way each of you can have part of him.” >26 “Please don't kill my son,” the baby's mother screamed. “Your Majesty, I love him very much, but give him to her. Just don't kill him.”
- electriclove 4y agoPut it in a museum in India. Yes, it might piss some off, but this idea of keeping the status quo (keeping it with the British) because it is complicated is ridiculous.
- alephnerd 4y agoWhy not Pakistan? Why not Afghanistan?
- golem14 4y agoIf it needs to be given away, maybe to a museum belonging to the United Nations? I'm not sure if there are truly extraterritorial museums, though.
- jjeaff 4y agoNo, the United Nations does not own museums.
- alephnerd 4y agoAlso, I don't think the Taliban government has been recognized in the UN yet, which makes stuff murkier soverignity wise.
- kelseyfrog 4y agowhats this? https://www.ungeneva.org/en/knowledge/museum https://www.ungeneva.org/en/knowledge/museum
- mattclarkdotnet 4y agoA UN museum of escrow might be neat. Here’s all the awesome stuff people are too pigheaded to come to an agreement on, complete with explanations of why.
- cortesoft 4y agoWhat made you pick India, and not Pakistan or Afghanistan?
- Ozzie_osman 4y ago
- Victerius 4y agoNo, it's a legitimate argument. If the British had taken possession of an object from an Indian tribe in California in 1800, who would be entitled to it? The U.S. government? The government of Mexico? The State of California? The Tribes' descendants? Possession is 9/10 of the law.
- Ozzie_osman 4y agoYes, for your hypothetical object, all of those parties would have a more legitimate claim than the British, and so I'd argue that any of them would be a step in the right direction (though more specifically, I'd say the tribes' descendants have the most legitimate claim). By the way, there are many examples of colonizing European countries refusing to return things they took during colonization where that "we don't know who we should give it to" argument is much weaker or non-existent. For example, Egypt has many items that are on display in European (mostly British and French) museums that it has tried to regain where ownership is not that complicated because the item was taken from Egypt by a European without complicated chains that might affect who owns what. Maybe the most famous is the Rosetta Stone, which was found and taken by French troops from Egypt, then given to the British via some treaty, and the British refuse to give it back despite many calls from Egypt. You could say something like "oh well it's unclear whether the British should give it back to the French or the Egyptians"... but I hope you can see how that would be a stretch.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alephnerd 4y agoBut the Khedivate of Egypt has a direct successor state - the Arab Republic of Egypt. The Sikh Empire, Durrani Empire, and Princely state of Kashimr and Jammu do not - this is why tensions are always high between India, Pakistan, and Afghanistan.
- OJFord 4y ago> (why are they exempt from taxes during record high inflation) (Because we pay taxes to the crown, doesn't really make sense for the king to pay tax to his majesty's own revenue and customs, HMRC. That said, there was something in the accension council about continuing to volunteer tax on something or another, and as the Duke of Cornwall he volunteered tax on duchy income. My understanding is that the royal family is a net contributor to state coffers even without (how would you even begin) accounting for all the tourism income.)
- alephnerd 4y agoWhat about revenue generated from Waitrose Duchy Organic and other Crown owned but Private enterprises[0]? Not combative but actually curious, but I'd prefer an actual legal opinion on this, not some online commentator to be honest. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waitrose_Duchy_Organic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waitrose_Duchy_Organic
- OJFord 4y agoWell I'm not qualified to give 'an actual legal opinion', so this is the best I can do: https://www.princeofwales.gov.uk/what-duchy-originals-it-anything-do-duchy-cornwall https://www.princeofwales.gov.uk/what-duchy-originals-it-any... To stray back into 'some online commentator' though, I believe that may be outdated: I think it's now wholly Waitrose, just a brand. (Notice there's no Essentials/Cooks Ingredients organic brand/products - if it's organic it's Duchy Organic.)
- alephnerd 4y agoInteresting. I've also been trying to find if royals other than the now deceased Queen have volunteered to income tax and capital gains tax, but I cannot find clear information on this (which is unsurprisng).
- Symbiote 4y agoThe claim of income from tourism is wrong: https://www.republic.org.uk/tourism https://www.republic.org.uk/tourism (At least if you believe the figures from Visit Britain, the government organization for tourism.)
- sfg 4y agoDoes it have to go to any country? Duleep Singh was the owner, when the British took it. Who is his legal heir?
- throwawaylinux 4y agoThe British crown is the legal owner now, so bringing the law into it doesn't help you. It's not a legal matter it's a moral one, and OP made a very good point about why that's more difficult than you might think.
- mr_toad 4y agoHe had eight children (in exile in England), but none of them had heirs.
- xuki 4y agoSo we do it British style, go up the family tree and find the nearest cousin or whatever.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoYou die without an heir, your property reverts to the state. Looks like the diamond is already with its true owner.
- alfl 4y agoThe Crown pays taxes: https://www.royal.uk/royal-finances-0?ch=5#bio-section-4 https://www.royal.uk/royal-finances-0?ch=5#bio-section-4
- alephnerd 4y agoQueen did which is good! I'm curious whether King Charles will though as he seems to own a fair number of private enterprises, as well as the other royals (I think Prince Harry and Megan Markle announced raising a Series B for their company earlier today for example)
- matthewheath 4y agoYes, King Charles III will pay the same taxes as Queen Elizabeth II did - he agreed to it during the Accession Council meeting. Only the Monarch and income from the Duchy of Cornwall (paid to the Prince of Wales) are exempt from income, capital gains, and inheritance tax. Every other member of the Royal Family are liable to tax, the same as us. They can offset the cost of their official duties against their taxes though.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThere's confusion between Queen, Royal family, and the Crown. The Crown is effectively the state. It's different from the private income and possessions of the Monarch and Royal family.
- b112 4y agoNot a fan of the British crown (why are they exempt from taxes during record high inflation) The rest of your comment scans, but this bit seems weird to me. What does the rate of inflation have to do, with taxation? Some points: - we are no where near record inflation, at least not in the US and Canada, and I presume the UK too. I recall 18% being thrown around in the 80s. - changing tax policy due to inflation seems a weird idea to me. Inflation causes cost of living changes, but also, as a result, wage increases are fought for and won. If anything, inflation needs to see taxation brackets moving upward to be fair! Not more taxation... - look at all consumption tax. Inflation goes up, pricing goes up, so sales tax, gas tax, etc collected increases as a result. I guess I don't get the inflation angle.
- tomcam 4y ago> I recall 18% being thrown around in the 80s. I was there. And I got hit by the 18% they threw
- alephnerd 4y agoBy record high I meant in recent memory - good catch, should have clarified. To your second point, CoL in London is basically LA level. London rents+council tax make rental prices SF level (around $1-2k/month in rent and around $1-2k/month in local property tax, which rentors apparently pay as well) while London median incomes are below poverty line LA or SF levels (around $40,000/year) [0], and inflation around 8-9%, the optics of a high net worth family exempt from Income Tax and Capital Gains tax unless they choose to incure it voluntariliy is very jarring. [0] - https://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/article/average-uk-salary https://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/article/average-uk-salary
- SilasX 4y agoThat makes it sound like a small miracle that 80% of the people there can afford to live there at all.
- alephnerd 4y agoKinda seems like it! I was back there for an industry conference a couple days ago actually and a number of the service staff who were around my age (20s-early 30s) actually asked me about how to immigrate to the US and Canada. Tbf this is anecdotal and I'm sure there are other Brits on this forum who can probably give more information.
- sawyna 4y agoTechnically speaking, we don't really know who owns it. But what we do know is that the British definitely doesn't own it. If somebody stole this from the British today, they have no right to complain!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ignoramous 4y agoI guess you and GP are in agreement. Whoever steals it, owns it.
- JamesBarney 4y agoBritain definitely has the best claim. They were given it in a treaty almost 200 years ago, and are currently in possession of it.
- kinj28 4y agoImagine a thief comes to your house with a gun & a treaty paper. He gives you two options - 1) sign the treaty paper where I leave you harmless but take away all your wealth 2) kill you and your family and take away all your wealth Which option would you choose? Your heir 200 years later would stop their claim on it ? Fair deal?
- bcrosby95 4y agoYou've just described thousands of years of history. Maybe it should be returned to mother earth, that way there would be no violence in the chain of ownership.
- nishs 4y agounironically. yes. we should throw it into the ocean. it’s more fair than the current situation and there seem to be no other plans to rectify the situation in the near future either.
- taneq 4y agoWho would they pay taxes to? Themselves?
- bee_rider 4y agoThe part of the government that provides services to the people.
- rajeshp1986 4y agoThere is an approach to decide the ownership. When India got independence and the Republic of Indian union was formed, the Indian central government got ownership of all the assets of the princely states. There are instruments of ascession signed by each Maharaja stating the transfer of rights for properties and assets. I doubt if anyone has even seen these documents in a while but it could technically be traced and the rights could be deduced.
- alephnerd 4y agoIt's not that cut and dry. First, does it belong to the Sikh Empire or Jammu Kashmir. If it belongs to the Sikh Empire, which Punjab does it belong to? If it belonged to Jammu Kashmir does it belong to AJK or JK? On top of that, if it belonged to JK, did it belong to Kashmir w/ Gulab Singh or Kashmir during the Durrani occupation? If the Durrani Occupation, then which successor of the Durrani state - Afghanistan or Pakistan. The British Raj provinces in the North (Punjab[0], Sindh[1], Pakhtunkwa[2]) was treated differently than the rest of India. We voted for the Unionist Party [3][4] - not Congress or the PML. And if I'm being honest (and much more annoyed at this point) you guys left us for slaughter during Partition - Congress, Jan Sangh, the PML, Jamaat-e-Islami, Akali Dal, etc. While Gandhi was in Bengal, where were the rest of the Indian independence leaders when my Mom's side were forced to leave Jhelum? Where were you guys when the Muslims in my dad's village were forced to leave by the sword and bullet (both Zia-ul-Haq's and Imran Khan's biradari/clan were from villages within 40-50 miles from my dad's ancestral village before they were forced to leave)? Why did we try to assasinate Nehru in the refugee camps? Why did we try to assasinate Jinnah in Karachi? Why didn't you guys arrest demagouges like Tara Singh who helped flame this shitshow? The rest of India left us to rot, and then did the same thing in the 1980s and the 1990s. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punjab_Province_(British_India) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punjab_Province_(British_India... [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sind_Province_(1936%E2%80%931955) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sind_Province_(1936%E2%80%9319... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North-West_Frontier_Province https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North-West_Frontier_Province [3] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unionist_Party_(Punjab) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unionist_Party_(Punjab) [4] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sind_United_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sind_United_Party
- cafed00d 4y agoThose diamonds were mined in Kollur in modern day south India. It should go back to them. And yes, before you harp on it, the land we call America should go back to the Native Americans, the aboriginals of Australia and New Zealand should also get their lands back. Or whoever else has been the subject of conquest. Ultimately, slavery, caste, and colonization are institutions of brutality. Reparations are owed. Britain can never repay the damage colonization caused to India. But it can return the diamond as an admission of guilt. And sure, it’s owed to a bunch of countries. I’m pretty sure India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka can figure out a shared ownership model for the diamond. They seem to get along fine sharing cricket trophies when there’s a draw.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago
- rcstank 4y agoHow do we know which Native Americans to give it back to? The land I sit on has been taken by conquest by many different tribes.
- imgabe 4y agoCivilizations clash. Some win, some lose. Should Gaul go back to the Romans? You would have the Earth remain completely static, and wherever your ancestors happened to evolve into humans that’s where you and your descendants live forever until the end of time? It’s ridiculous. Things change. Move on.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cafed00d 4y agoThat’s a dangerous precedent to set. You’re essentially egging on today’s generation to “clash back”. Colonialism isn’t the same as ancestral predator prey mechanics. Or, that we should reverse every unjust war waged in the world. Some are just blatantly brutal. Simple. We owe it to our species to recognize mistake, apologize and make repairs. Would Britain really say “it’s ridiculous. Things change. Move on” for forcefully castrating Turing simply because he was gay? Oh wait. No. They didn’t actually do that. Some atrocities are just that bad. Things don’t change. It’s ridiculous. Grow a spine!
- kamaal 4y agoNice excuses to not return it back to the last known owners.
- betwixthewires 4y agoThe last known owners aren't sovereigns of a nation anymore. And if they wouldn't give it to the ones before them this entire discussion is a sham.
- kamaal 4y ago>>The last known owners aren't sovereigns of a nation anymore. India is a democracy, people's government. So your argument doesn't stand.
- betwixthewires 4y agoHow does that statement address my point at all?
- drieddust 4y ago
- npinterview 4y agoIt is not very hard, it can go to a museum and can go around the country. After all in a democracy the people are the kings. Personally I would not want it back, because it is just the tip of the iceberg. The church of England (now csi and cni) hold on to 1000s of acres of colonial land across the country. The kohinoor is just a drop in the ocean.
- goto11 4y agoI guess that means if somebody stole the diamond from the crown today, they would get to keep it?
- akvadrako 4y agoWhy not? Especially if they kept it safe in a museum or gave it to one of the other parties that has a claim.
- imgabe 4y agoIf they were powerful enough to prevent the government of the UK from taking it back, they certainly could.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoOf they have bigger muscles than the British then yes. That's how it's always worked.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nextlevelwizard 4y ago>why are they exempt from taxes during record high inflation Because they literally own all (or at least most) of the tourist attractions in the UK. It looks funny how the royal family is paid bunch of money for just existing until you realize they own the land and they have deal with the government where government handles the properties and whatever and pays the royal family for it, but the amount revenue is much much larger
- Symbiote 4y agoThe monarch doesn't own it. It's not well defined, but if anything, the state owns it, with some of the profits from the estate being used to fund the monarch. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crown_Estate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crown_Estate (And the monarch is still exempt from inheritance tax on their private property, e.g. Balmoral.)
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThis is why I'm not a fan of "correcting" history. What happened, happened. You cannot really correct it without breaking something elsewhere. Returning this diamond isn't going to magically erase 200 years of colonial rule.
- morbidious 4y agoBut it's going to give back a sense of pride and belonging to people to see their possession back in their hands
- concordDance 4y agoFomenting nationalism seems like a bad idea.
- morbidious 4y agoSo you have the George Soros mentality https://youtu.be/__ouwLEMaTM?t=212 https://youtu.be/__ouwLEMaTM?t=212
- la64710 4y agoIt’s origin was in India so it should go back to India. Which authority or organization within India takes care of it is their business.
- amriksohata 4y agoLol a typical british divide and rule statement, who is going to take it? Forget that, just give it back to someone neutral then? Punjab is part of India, so India will do. It was taken from a Maharaja whos citizens and their descendants wanted to be part of India
- dmz73 4y agoI think the rule should be: if the entity claiming the item obtained it through conquest originally, they don't get it back. If the item was created or purchased by the entity, they should get it back.